FBI Dealt Blow By DC Judge; Must Address Measures Taken To

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Lmcat
151
FBI Dealt Blow By DC Judge; Must Address Measures Taken To Verify Steele Dossier
Sat, 08/18/2018

The FBI has been dealt a major blow after a Washington DC judge ruled that the agency must respond to a FOIA request for documents concerning the bureau's efforts to verify the controversial Steele Dossier, before it was used as the foundation of a FISA surveillance warrant application and subsequent renewals.

US District Court Judge Amit Mehta - who in January sided with the FBI's decision to ignore the FOIA request, said that President Trump's release of two House Intelligence Committee documents (the "Nunes" and "Schiff" memos) changed everything.


Judge Amit Mehta

Considering that the FBI offered Steele $50,000 to verify the Dossier's claims yet never paid him, BuzzFeed has unsuccessfully tried to do the same to defend themselves in a dossier-related lawsuit, and a $50 million Soros-funded investigation to continue the hunt have turned up nothing that we know of - whatever documents the FBI may be forced to cough up regarding their attempts to verify the Dossier could prove highly embarrassing for the agency.

If Mr. Steele could get solid corroboration of his reports, the F.B.I. would pay him $50,000 for his efforts, according to two people familiar with the offer. Ultimately, he was not paid. -NYT

What's more, forcing the FBI to prove they had an empty hand will likely embolden calls to disband the special counsel investigation - as the agency's mercenary and politicized approach to "investigations" will be laid all the more bare for the world to see. Then again, who knows - maybe the FBI verified everything in the dossier and it simply hasn't leaked.

That said, while the FBI will likely be forced to acknowledge the documents thanks to the Thursday ruling, the agency will still be able to try and convince the judge that there are other grounds to withhold the records.

In January, Mehta blessed the FBI's decision not to disclose the existence of any records containing the agency's efforts to verify the dossier - ruling that Trump's tweets about the dossier didn't require the FBI and other intelligence agencies to act on records requests.

"But then the ground shifted," writes Mehta of Trump declassifying the House memos.

"As a result of the Nunes and Schiff Memos, there is now in the public domain meaningful information about how the FBI acquired the Dossier and how the agency used it to investigate Russian meddling."

The DOJ also sought to distinguish between the Steele Dossier and a synopsis of the dossier presented to both Trump and then-President Obama in 2016, however Mehta rejected the attempt, writing "That position defies logic," while also rejecting the government's refusal to even say if the FBI has a copy of that synopsis.

"It remains no longer logical nor plausible for the FBI to maintain that it cannot confirm nor deny the existence of documents," Mehta wrote.

It is simply not plausible to believe that, to whatever extent the FBI has made efforts to verify Steele’s reporting, some portion of that work has not been devoted to allegations that made their way into the synopsis. After all, if the reporting was important enough to brief the President-elect, then surely the FBI thought enough of those key charges to attempt to verify their accuracy. It will be up to the FBI to determine which of the records in its possession relating to the reliability of the Dossier concerns Steele’s reporting as discussed in the synopsis.

“This ruling represents another incremental step in revealing just how much the FBI has been able to verify or discredit the rather personal allegations contained in that synopsis derived from the Steele dossier, ” said Brad Moss, a lawyer pressing the lawsuit for the pro-transparency group, the James Madison Project. “It will be rather ironic if the president’s peripheral actions that resulted in this ruling wind up disclosing that the FBI has been able to corroborate any of the ‘salacious’ allegations.”

In other words, the FBI must show what they did to verify the claims contained within the Nunes and Schiff memos.

Because the case was heard on appeal, the ruling will not take immediate effect, notes Politico, which adds that the appeals court is now likely to remand the case to Mehta, while the FBI is going to try and convince him the records should remain unreleased.

https://www.wnd.com/2018/08/judge-fbi-must-ad...y-dossier/

https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2018-08-18/fbi...le-dossier
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Portillo's Faces Class Action: Investor Losses at Stake

Updated Category News Views 225

Investor Tensions Rise as Portillo's Inc. Lawsuit Unfolds Investment ain't all sunshine and rainbows, and if you've been holding Portillo's Inc. (NASDAQ: PTLO) stocks between September 19, 2023, and May 4, 2026, you might find yourself caught in a storm front. We're talking shareholder class action lawsuit, folks, thanks to some allegedly misguided management moves. This...

Continue Reading
YONDELIS: Thai Approval Opens New Sarcoma Treatment Path

Updated Category News Views 103

New Hope for Thai Sarcoma Patients Alright, we’ve got some good news coming out of Thailand, folks. The Thai FDA just greenlit YONDELIS® (trabectedin) for those grappling with advanced soft tissue sarcoma (STS). Now, this isn’t your everyday drug release—it’s a clinical chess move packing potential for patients who’ve run out of other options. December 1st,...

Continue Reading
Shenzhen's Vision Unveiled: APEC 2026 Promo Debut

Updated Category News Views 466

Shenzhen's Spotlight Moment at APEC 2026 When Shenzhen announced its promotional video for the 2026 APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting, it wasn't just about standard tourism glitz. This was a show of force, a bold step onto the main stage of global politics and economics. The video's launch wasn’t merely an audio-visual delight—it staked a claim in shaping the future...

Continue Reading
IDEAYA's IDE101: A New Front in Cancer Battle

Updated Category News Views 212

IDEAYA's Bold Move in Precision Medicine IDEAYA Biosciences, no stranger to the frontlines of cancer treatment, is gunning for a breakthrough with their latest pick, IDE101. They're jumping into the ring with a potential first-in-class inhibitor targeting CDKN2A-deficiency—a notorious player in the solid tumor game. They're not just mixing things up for the sake of it;...

Continue Reading
Hanwha Power Seals Second FSRU Conversion Deal

Updated Category News Views 0

Riding the FSRU Wave with Hanwha Power Alright, we've got Hanwha Power step-dancing onto the LNG stage with its second splash into the FSRU (Floating Storage and Regasification Unit) conversion gig. Partnering up with Energos Infrastructure, these guys are making serious waves in the energy market by transforming what's pretty much a regular ship into a floating gas...

Continue Reading
Innovent's Big Leap: Targeting European Lung Cancer Market

Updated Category News Views 0

Innovent's Regulatory Milestone in Europe They say every underdog has its day, and for Innovent Biologics, that time just might be now. Receiving a positive opinion from the Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use (CHMP) is no small potatoes. Especially when we're talking lung cancer—a notorious heavyweight in the cancer world. The Finer Details of Zybrivo’s...

Continue Reading
D-Wave Quantum Hit with Securities Fraud Lawsuit

Updated Category News Views 349

A Legal Quagmire for D-Wave Quantum Investors Securities fraud lawsuits are like light in a dark alley—you need them when the truth's been stashed out of sight, but they illuminate the dirty and damp parts of investment strategies nobody wants to talk about. Right now, D-Wave Quantum Inc. is smack dab in the middle of such litigious action. If you had the misfortune of...

Continue Reading
Championing Change: USTA Mid-Atlantic Gala's Impact

Updated Category News Views 277

A Night to Remember: USTA Mid-Atlantic's Gala Who would've thought tennis could wield such transformative power? This ain't your average sport gala. Last Saturday, a crowd of over 300 gathered at the Ritz-Carlton Tysons Corner for the USTA Mid-Atlantic Foundation's 2026 Tennis Creates Gala. Hosted by the formidable Malika Andrews, this event wasn't just a fancy...

Continue Reading
JOYEE N01 Debuts Globally with First 2,000 Deliveries

Updated Category News Views 284

JOYYE N01 Breaks into the Global Market Now, here we go, folks—a Chinese car with ambitions bigger than the Sahara. On October 28, the JOYEE N01 rolled off the assembly line and into the international scene with a lot of fanfare at FAW's Yancheng Branch. Mark my words, this isn't just another model trying to strut into the global auto arena. This event delivered the...

Continue Reading
Kayla Harrison Dominates UFC 334, Earns Big Win

Updated Category News Views 42

Kicking off UFC 334 with a bang, Kayla Harrison didn't just step into the Octagon—she bulldozed her way through Amanda Nunes to retain her Women's Bantamweight Championship. This showdown didn't just electrify New York's Madison Square Garden, it shook the entire MMA landscape. Harrison, the face of Monster Energy's athlete roster, wasn't content with just defending her...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Geotab's Vision for Addressing Youth Unemployment Through Internships

Updated Category News Views 169

Geotab's Commitment to Future Workforce Development As Geotab Inc. celebrates its remarkable 25th anniversary, the company is taking bold steps to enhance internship opportunities for young graduates entering an increasingly competitive job market. With youth unemployment rates rising in North America, organizations like Geotab are not only addressing a pressing social...

Continue Reading
Joaquín de Valenzuela Joins nCino as EMEA Managing Director

Updated Category News Views 90

Joaquín de Valenzuela Takes the Helm at nCino for EMEA nCino, Inc. (NASDAQ: NCNO), a leader in intelligent banking solutions, is proud to announce the appointment of Joaquín de Valenzuela as the Managing Director for the EMEA region. This significant hire underscores the company's dedication to bolstering its growth trajectory and expanding its influence across the...

Continue Reading
Aya Gold & Silver Unveils Stunning Silver Drilling Results

Updated Category News Views 123

Aya Gold & Silver Reports New Silver Drilling Success Aya Gold & Silver Inc. (TSX: AYA; OTCQX: AYASF) is excited to share outstanding silver drill results from its ongoing exploration at the Zgounder Silver Mine. The results not only highlight high-quality silver finds but also identify several promising new targets in the Zgounder Regional area. Drilling Highlights and...

Continue Reading
Nvidia's Deep Roots in China's Tech Landscape Drive AI Success

Updated Category News Views 278

Nvidia's Deep Roots in China's Tech Landscape Drive AI Success Nvidia Corp. CEO Jensen Huang recently highlighted the significant impact of China’s technology ecosystem on Nvidia’s growth during a keynote address at a major university event. His reflections underline a robust relationship spanning over 25 years, which has been pivotal in shaping Nvidia into a leading...

Continue Reading
Aalberts N.V. Achieves Strategic Growth Despite Market Challenges

Updated Category News Views 314

Aalberts N.V. Reports First Quarter Results In the latest financial report, Aalberts N.V. showcased its first quarter outcomes, revealing revenues of EUR 778.3 million. This figure marks a 3.3% decline in organic revenue compared to the same period last year, pointing to ongoing challenges within the market. Operational Performance and Margin Insights The company's EBITA...

Continue Reading