Quote:Spy vs. President
The nation’s top former intelligence officials come together to issue a stunning rebuke to Trump.
AKA, 'Deep State' tells Trump F You!.![]()
By Fred Kaplan
Aug 17, 2018•12:02 AM
One of two things happened on Thursday, depending on your point of view. Either some of the nation’s top retired military and intelligence officers publicly criticized President Trump in very strong terms—an uncharacteristic act for almost all of them—or the “deep state” is closing in.
The denunciations came in two waves.
Earlier in the day, retired Adm. William McRaven wrote an op-ed for the Washington Post, protesting Trump’s revoking of former CIA Director John Brennan’s security clearance and declaring—as if in an open letter to Trump himself—“I would consider it an honor if you would revoke my security clearance as well, so I can add my name to the list of men and women who have spoken up against your presidency.”
McRaven is a former Navy SEAL and commander of U.S. Special Operations Command who oversaw the raid that killed Osama Bin Laden. By all accounts, he is as apolitical as they come and had not publicly criticized Trump, or any previous president, until now.
The op-ed continued: “Like most Americans, I had hoped that when you became president, you would rise to the occasion and become the leader this great nation needs. … Your leadership, however, has shown little of these qualities. Through your actions”—which he later described as “McCarthy-era tactics”—“you have embarrassed us in the eyes of our children, humiliated us on the world stage and worst of all, divided us as a nation.”
One former senior intelligence official who read the op-ed sent me an email: “Takes my breath away. This is BIG!!!” Another wrote, again on background, that fellow officers—retired and active-duty—will take this as a sign of a major rupture in civil-military relations, brought on by Trump’s blatant disrespect for national security officials and the entire security system,
Then, late on Thursday night, 12 former CIA directors and deputy directors released a similar statement. By coincidence, the statement was written a few hours before McRaven’s op-ed appeared, according to two of the organizers.
The intelligence officials stopped short of asking Trump to revoke their clearances—that idea hadn’t come up in conversation. But like McRaven, they defended Brennan’s integrity and denounced Trump’s action as having “nothing to do with who should and should not hold security clearances—and everything to do with an attempt to stifle free speech.”
The statement went on: “We have never before seen the approval or removal of security clearances used as a political tool, as was done in this case,” adding that “this action is quite clearly a signal to other former and current officials” to stay silent. It noted that some of the signatories agree with Brennan’s long string of critical statements about Trump, while others do not. However, they all agree that decisions on security clearances “should be based on national security concerns and not political views.”
It was a bipartisan statement. Four of the signers served during Republican administrations; six served Democrats; two served presidents from both parties. More to the point, the vast majority of them are not accustomed to making political statements of any sort, much less direct criticisms of a sitting president.
The ex-officials include William Webster, Porter Goss, Gen. Michael Hayden, and John McLaughlin (those who served Republicans); Leon Panetta, Gen. David Petraeus, Gen. James Clapper, Michael Morell, Avril Haines and David Cohen (those who served Democrats); and George Tenet, and Stephen Kappes (who served presidents of both parties).
More significant, seven of the 12—Webster, Goss, Hayden, McLaughlin, Clapper, Morell, and Kappes—were career intelligence officials. One, Petraeus, was a career combat commander. [Update, Aug. 17, 2018, 12:10 a.m.: Just before midnight, a 13th ex-director, Robert Gates—another career CIA official who has served under several presidents of both parties—added his name to the statement. He had been inaccessible, until then.]
One of the signers told me that some who signed the statement did so reluctantly, given the long-standing principle that intelligence and military officers should remain apolitical. However, the consensus was that Trump’s behavior has gone beyond the pale.
No one could recall any precedent for either of the two protests. Trump and White House spokeswoman Sarah Huckabee Sanders have denounced Brennan in vicious terms. Sanders has also, in the last month, threatened to revoke the security clearances held by Hayden and Clapper for critical remarks they have made about Trump. It will be interesting to see if she and Trump decide to go after well-known war heroes like Petraeus and McRaven.
One of the signers told me the statement was circulated to all living ex-directors and deputy directors at noon on Thursday, with a request to reply by 6 that night. The names of four former directors are not on the letter: former President George H.W. Bush, John Deutch, Adm. William Studeman, and James Woolsey. It could not be ascertained, either by me or by one of the organizers, whether they declined to sign the statement or simply hadn’t seen it by the deadline.
Here is the complete text of the ex-intelligence leaders’ statement:
August 16, 2018
STATEMENT FROM FORMER SENIOR INTELLIGENCE OFFICIALS
As former senior intelligence officials, we feel compelled to respond in the wake of the ill-considered and unprecedented remarks and actions by the White House regarding the removal of John Brennan’s security clearances. We know John to be an enormously talented, capable, and patriotic individual who devoted his adult life to the service of this nation. Insinuations and allegations of wrongdoing on the part of Brennan while in office are baseless.
Since leaving government service John has chosen to speak out sharply regarding what he sees as threats to our national security. Some of the undersigned have done so as well. Others among us have elected to take a different course and be more circumspect in our public pronouncements.
Regardless, we all agree that the president’s action regarding John Brennan and the threats of similar action against other former officials has nothing to do with who should and should not hold security clearances – and everything to do with an attempt to stifle free speech.
You don’t have to agree with what John Brennan says (and, again, not all of us do) to agree with his right to say it, subject to his obligation to protect classified information. We have never before seen the approval or removal of security clearances used as a political tool, as was done in this case.
Beyond that, this action is quite clearly a signal to other former and current officials. As individuals who have cherished and helped preserve the right of Americans to free speech – even when that right has been used to criticize us – that signal is inappropriate and deeply regrettable. Decisions on security clearances should be based on national security concerns and not political views.
William H. Webster, former Director of Central Intelligence (1987-1991)
George J. Tenet, former Director of Central Intelligence (1997-2004)
Porter J. Goss, former Director of Central Intelligence, (2005-2006)
General Michael V. Hayden, USAF, Ret., former Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (2006-2009)
Leon E. Panetta, former Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (2009-2011)
General David H. Petraeus, USA, Ret., former Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (2011-2012)
James R. Clapper, former Director of National Intelligence (2010-2017)
John E. McLaughlin, former Deputy Director of Central Intelligence (2000-2004)
Stephen R. Kappes, former Deputy Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (2006-2010)
Michael J. Morell, former Deputy Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (2010-2013)
Avril Haines, former Deputy Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (2013-2015)
David S. Cohen, former Deputy Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (2015-2017)
Spy vs. President The nation’s top former
Top 10 Most Recent News Articles
Yunnan Tin’s AI Materials Push Has Real Operating Teeth
Tin rarely gets the spotlight until the machinery behind modern computing starts demanding more of it. Yunnan Tin Group is making the sensible case that this unglamorous metal can matter a great deal in semiconductors, artificial intelligence infrastructure and new-energy hardware. There is plenty of corporate ambition wrapped around that case, naturally, but a few...
Continue Reading
Jeff Stern Turns Travel Photography Into Full Attention
A cancelled photography conference in March 2020 sent Jeff Stern toward the American Southwest, and that detour eventually became A Change of Scenery. Frankly, that origin has more grit than the usual polished creative-origin tale. While much of the world had stopped moving, Stern went alone, stood at White Pocket beneath a cobalt sky, and began reconsidering what he...
Continue Reading
IAS Marks 42 Years Amid Germany Religious Freedom Win
Bagpipes, country roads and a gathering from six continents made this far more than a routine anniversary reception. The International Association of Scientologists marked its 42nd anniversary at Saint Hill in East Grinstead, England, with thousands of Scientologists and guests arriving as autumn settled over West Sussex. That sort of turnout is a visible statement of...
Continue Reading
AIM Academy Accreditation Signals a Broader Quality Push
Early-childhood education does not hand out many clean, easily comparable scorecards, which is precisely why AIM Academy’s new Cognia recognition deserves a closer look. The Alabama provider has earned Cognia Initial Accreditation, while its Pike Road center received Accreditation with Merit after its Initial Accreditation Review. That is not a revenue event, not a...
Continue Reading
Vision Marine's Cash Cleanup Meets a Hard Reality Ahead
A boat dealer slashing debt by $27.5 million deserves a nod, even when the rest of the ledger still makes your eyebrows climb. Vision Marine Technologies turned fiscal 2026 into a working-capital cleanup job: inventory came down hard, floor-plan financing nearly vanished, and operating cash flow finally turned positive. For NASDAQ:VMAR, that is real progress. It is not,...
Continue Reading
Mindstream’s Jordan AI Campus Faces Its First Real Test
Jordan’s AI ambitions just got attached to a very large gas meter. Mindstream Energy has unveiled a plan for an AI-ready data-center campus at Al-Risha in Mafraq Governorate, built around dedicated natural-gas generation rather than a conventional dependence on the utility grid. The headline number is 400 megawatts of eventual capacity. The number that matters first is...
Continue Reading
Corner Bakery Bets on Holiday Catering Convenience
A $50 carrot on a $350 catering tab tells you exactly where Corner Bakery sees the holiday battlefield: not in one lonely cookie sale, but in the larger group order that can make a restaurant’s day. The chain is pushing holiday catering through November and December, pairing that discount with bakery trays, meals for groups and a promise to handle delivery setup. It is...
Continue Reading
A. O. Smith's Sustainability Scorecard Has Real Teeth
Numbers finally showed up wearing work boots in A. O. Smith’s latest sustainability report. The company says it beat every one of its three environmental targets, and the gaps were not the sort of rounding-error victories corporate communications teams love to polish until they shine. For investors following NYSE:AOS, that deserves a look—not a standing ovation, but a...
Continue Reading
Colon Cleanse Advice Deserves a Careful Read First
Wellness copy can sound harmless right up until it blurs comfort guidance with health guidance. HelloNation’s feature on what to expect after a colon cleanse, drawing on Suzanne Childre of Gentle Wellness Center in Santa Monica, lays out a fairly familiar recovery script: drink water, rest, eat lightly, expect some bowel changes, and do not panic over a little fatigue....
Continue Reading
Dubai's 2028 Fire Congress Puts Global Safety Tech on Stage
Fire engines, wildfires, dense towers, and AI are all colliding in Dubai's next big public-safety moment. The World Fire Congress has handed its 2028 host role to Dubai, making this the first time the biennial gathering of global fire and emergency-service leaders will land in the Middle East. That is not a quarterly earnings event, and nobody ought to pretend it is....
Continue ReadingTop 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles
BMC Helix Ranks High in Enterprise Service Management Report
BMC Helix Excels in Enterprise Service Management Evaluation BMC Helix has recently received top marks in an evaluation of enterprise service management (ESM) solutions, achieving the highest possible scores in 17 different criteria. These criteria include important metrics like vision, roadmap, innovation, egg-tion AI development, and orchestration, partner ecosystem,...
Continue Reading
Inspire's International ETF Celebrates Five-Year Success
Inspire's International ETF Celebrates Five Years of Growth Inspire's biblically responsible international ETF, known under the ticker symbol NYSE: WWJD, has reached an impressive milestone by marking its fifth anniversary. Notably, this fund has not only celebrated its existence but has also outperformed its benchmark, the S&P International 700. A Strong Performance in a...
Continue Reading
Maximize Earnings with ZA Miner: Your Passive Income Solution
Earning Passive Income with ZA Miner The cryptocurrency market can often seem daunting due to its notorious volatility. However, there's a silver lining for those looking to dip their toes into this digital realm without direct investment in cryptocurrencies. Enter ZA Miner, a platform designed to harness the power of crypto mining to generate significant daily earnings,...
Continue Reading
Empowering Women in Racing: Porsche and Iron Dames Unite
A New Era for Women in Motorsports The collaboration between Porsche Motorsport and Iron Dames is a groundbreaking partnership that emphasizes the importance of diversity and opportunities in the racing world. Launched with the inspiring mantra, “Porsche X Iron Dames – because every dream matters,” this partnership is set to take off during the Asian Le Mans Series,...
Continue Reading
Safehold Inc. Plans Earnings Call for Third Quarter Results
Safehold Inc. Announces Earnings Release and Call Safehold Inc. (NYSE: SAFE) has shared important news for its investors regarding its financial performance. The company will unveil its earnings for the third quarter of 2024 following the market's closing on a specified date. This is an anticipated event for stakeholders keen to assess the firm’s financial health and...
Continue Reading