Bipartisan Senate Panel Gives Middle Finger to Devin

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

Jul 3, 2018 at 5:45 PM 225

Quote:

Bipartisan Senate Panel Gives Middle Finger to Devin Nunes

A bipartisan report from the Senate Intelligence Committee says intelligence agencies were right to find the Russians interfered in the election to harm Clinton and elect Trump.

Spencer Ackerman

07.03.18 4:27 PM ET

The Republicans on the House Intelligence Committee have said the NSA, CIA, and FBI got it wrong when they assessed that the point of Russia’s 2016 election interference was to harm Hillary Clinton and elect Donald Trump. But now their counterpart in the Senate, in a bipartisan report, said the intelligence agencies got it right.

In April, the House Intelligence Committee Republicans put out an extensive report exonerating Trump from accusations of collusion with Russian President Vladimir Putin, delivering a conclusion that Democrats had come to consider pre-ordained. Democrats quickly distanced themselves from it.

Chief panel Democrat Adam Schiff said at the time that the GOP report suffered from a “raft of misleading conclusions, insinuations, attempts to explain away inconvenient facts, and arguments meant to protect the President and his campaign.”

One of the key findings of the GOP report, led by critical White House ally Devin Nunes of California, was that the three intelligence agencies erred in their assessment of “Putin’s strategic intentions” behind his election interference.

Nunes’ report struck a delicate balance. It conceded that the election interference happened and that most of the intelligence community analysis (ICA) “held up to scrutiny,” but accused the agencies of not meeting their own standards for tradecraft.

“While most of the analysis contained in the ICA held up to scrutiny,” Nunes’ report held, “the committee found that ICA judgments on Putin’s strategic objectives”—that is to say defeating Clinton and electing Trump—“failed to meet most of the analytic standards set forth in the primary guiding document for IC analysis, Intelligence Community Directive (ICD) 203.”

Such shortfalls “undermine confidence,” Nunes’ report continued, but they weren’t listed as problems with the underlying circumstances of the Russian campaign. Nunes and company instead faulted the agencies for not “incorporat[ing] analysis of alternatives” or more fulsomely explaining the differences in confidence levels between the NSA, FBI, and CIA.

The Senate Intelligence Committee, however, reached a much firmer conclusion: The January 2017 intelligence community was right to find the Russians meddled in the election to defeat Clinton and aid Trump.

“The Committee found that the ICA provided a range of all-source reporting to support these assessments,” it found. “A body of reporting,” from classified intelligence to Russian media, “showed that Moscow sought to denigrate Secretary Clinton.”

The ICA finding on Putin’s objectives used similarly cumulative Russian media, similarities between Trump positions and Putin’s interests “and a body of intelligence reporting to support the assessment that Putin and the Russian Government developed a clear preference for Trump.”

Information “obtained subsequent to the publication of the ICA provides further support” for what the CIA called a Russian aspiration “to help President-elect Trump’s election chances when possible,” the Senate panel found.

As for the internal analytic disagreement on Putin’s pro-Trump/anti-Clinton objectives—NSA had “moderate confidence” in it; CIA and FBI had “high confidence”—the committee, chaired by North Carolina Republican Richard Burr, found no evidence of analytic malpractice.

“The analytical disagreement was reasonable, transparent and openly debated among the agencies and analysts, with analysts, managers and agency heads on both sides of the confidence level articulately justifying their positions,” the Senate committee wrote.

Nunes’ office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

“The committee has spent the last 16 months reviewing the sources, tradecraft and analytic work underpinning the Intelligence Community Assessment and sees no reason to dispute the conclusions,” Burr said in a Tuesday statement.

“The committee continues its investigation and I am hopeful that this installment of the committee’s work will soon be followed by additional summaries providing the American people with clarity around Russia’s activities regarding U.S. elections.”

It’s not the first time a high-profile inquiry into the 2016 election has contradicted Nunes’ findings. In February, before Nunes’ report, Mueller indicted the Russian troll farm known as the Internet Research Agency.

Among the claims Mueller made in the indictment: “Defendants’ operations included supporting the presidential campaign of then-candidate Donald J. Trump (“Trump Campaign”) and disparaging Hillary Clinton.”

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Bybit Expands On-Chain Access: Japanese Equity Focus

Bybit's Bold Foray Into Japanese Equities Isn't every trader just itching to talk about Japan these days? Well, Bybit's got your back with its latest maneuvers. The platform is broadening its scope by diving headfirst into Japanese equities with a fresh offering—JPE backed by JX, no less. Bybit's RWA Earn platform isn't sticking to the boring fixed-income strategy...

ALP's Bold NYC Pop-Up: A Gamble or Genius Move?

ALP Swings Big in the Big Apple Here's a move that's about as loud as blaring your TV at midnight — ALP, the nicotine pouch brand that’s been taking quiet corners of rural America by storm, is barging into New York City with a brazen pop-up and a parade of marketing antics. Think of it as taking the Wild West and plunking it down in the urban jungle. They're...

Huawei's 2026 Leap in Gartner Magic Quadrant Recognition

China's Telecom Giant Steps Up Globally Gartner's all about benchmarks and bragging rights in the tech world, and brother, Huawei just grabbed a major piece of that spotlight in 2026. They've snagged a spot in the coveted Leaders Quadrant of the Gartner Magic Quadrant for Infrastructure Platform Consumption Services. Now, why should folks with skin in the game care?...

Hyperscale Data Plans Major Stock Exchange Deal

Hyperscale's Bold Move: Exchange Offer Hits the Market Man, when a company believes its market value is out of whack, you get moves like this. Hyperscale Data, strutting under ticker symbol NYSE:GPUS, is swinging for the fences with an exchange offer, aiming to mop up $50 million worth of its common stock with a sweet deal that’s sure to grab any investor's attention....

New Metrics Aim to Elevate Organ Procurement Performance

Revamping Organ Procurement: A New Approach In the tangled web of healthcare, the organ donation system stands as a lifeline that's often tangled in its metrics. The latest stride by the Association of Organ Procurement Organizations (AOPO) might put some untethered efforts in line. With an announcement on November 9, 2026, the AOPO unveiled three fresh performance...

Smart Cooling Accessory: A Game Changer for AC Units?

New Kid on the Block: The Smart Cooling Game They say the devil's in the details, and this one’s got all the right tweaks. Picture this — a compressor-based air conditioning system beefing up with a savvy accessory that promises to give your condenser coil some extra muscle. That's right, we've got ourselves a new contender in the cooling corner: THE CSC UNIT. It's...

Soluna Schedules Q3 2026 Earnings Call: What To Expect

Soluna's Upcoming Earnings Call: A Crucial Update Here we are again, folks—floating on the edge of another one of Soluna Holdings' earnings calls. Mark November 16, 2026, on your calendar because that's when Soluna's slated to drop its third quarter financials and walk us through the numbers. At 5:00 PM Eastern Time, they're firing up the webcast and phone lines for a...

Small-Town Firm Rises to CNBC's Top 100 Advisors

Defying Odds from a Small Town Let's talk about McKinley Carter Wealth Services snagging a spot on CNBC's 2026 Financial Advisor 100. Being the lone ranger from West Virginia in a sea of over 41,000 advisory firms ain't no small potatoes. That's right, this Wheeling-based firm landed at No. 98, solidifying its place amongst the top independent financial advisors in the...

ASMAX Unleashes Next-Level Motorcycle Comms at EICMA

Transforming the Motorcycle Communication Landscape Motorcycling ain't just about the roaring engines and the rubber on the road. In the world of helmets and handlebars, some bright minds are weaving tech magic at the EICMA 2026 in Milan. ASMAX has rolled out its shiny new RoamX intercom gadget, leaving folks buzzing at Hall 6. What RoamX Brings to the Table This ain't...

Deadline Looms for BETR Investors: Take Action Now

What’s the Fuss About? Alright folks, let’s lay this out simple: Better Home & Finance Holding Company (NASDAQ: BETR) is in hot water. A class action’s been slapped on them, accusing the firm of sugarcoating its business prospects. If you bought BETR shares between March 13, 2026, and May 7, 2026, you might have a dog in this fight. Buckle up, because the stakes are...