The ASPCA Pays Price For Bad-Faith Ringling Brothers

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Trending News

The ASPCA Pays Price For Bad-Faith Ringling Brothers Elephant Suit

The ASPCA sued Ringling Brothers, but ended up paying the circus $9.3 million to help cover its legal bills. Paul Alexander reports.

Who hasn’t seen the television commercials for animal groups? With heart-touching music playing behind a montage of sad-looking dogs and cats, an announcer pleads for contributions to “save” the animals. No organization runs more of these highly effective ads than the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. Many contributors agree to donate $18 a month, helping the ASPCA to bring in $111.3 million for the year ending June 2010.

Elephant Walk Circus

Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus's elephants and their handlers march from railcars to the Wells Fargo Center in Philadelphia, Tuesday, Feb. 15, 2011. (Matt Rourke/AP)

As 2012 came to an end, however, what the ASPCA did not advertise was the fact that, on December 26, $9.3 million in contributions did not go to “save” animals but to Feld Entertainment, the family-controlled company that since 1967 has owned Ringling Brothers and Barnum & Bailey Circus, which has been in continuous operation since 1919. In settling its lawsuit against “The Greatest Show on Earth,” the ASPCA was admonished by the judge hearing the case that it should have never been filed in the first place, primarily because the group used a paid plaintiff.

To be sure, there’s big money in animal welfare advocacy. During the same period the ASPCA raked in its haul, the Humane Society of the United States  brought in even more: $131.2 million.  Smaller groups also raised notable amounts: $5.8 million for the Fund for Animals; $2.8 million for the Animal Welfare Institute, and 1.5 million for the Animal Protection Institute.

While these organizations — all tax-exempt 501(c)3s — can vary in size, their goal is the same, says Frankie Trull, a science activist and lobbyist involved in university-based animal research: “These groups believe that animals are not ours to be used to eat or wear — or for entertainment.”

Specifically, the groups believe that when a handler employs chains and a bullhook—a long cane, made of wood or fiberglass, with a sharp, curved metal end—to control an elephant, a pain-free method of guiding elephants that has been in use for decades (think guiding a dog with a leash), he is abusing the animal. But the groups needed an individual with standing to bring suit. That was Tom Rider, a former employee who worked for Ringling Brothers from June 1997 until November 1999, first as a “barn helper” and then as a “barn man,” in the Blue Unit traveling show. (A second traveling show is the Red Unit.) In essence an assistant to an elephant handler, Rider gave food and water to seven Asian elephants—Karen, Nicole, Lutzi, Zina, Mysore, Susan, and Jewell—as well as cleaning up after them.

The original lawsuit was filed on July 11, 2000 by the Performing Animal Welfare Society (PAWS) on behalf of the ASPCA, AWI, FFA, Tom Rider, and three other individuals. In December, PAWS and the three individuals dropped out, leaving Rider, ASPCA, FFA, and AWI. Using the Endangered Species Act, the complaint alleged that Ringling Brothers “takes” its Asian elephants — “take” is a general term for “harming,” “harassing,” or “wounding” — by employing chains and bullhooks on them, which in turn caused Rider to suffer “aesthetic or emotional injury” because he witnessed this behavior after developing a “strong personal attachment” to the elephants. The groups demanded that Ringling Brothers stop “taking” Asian elephants, a protected endangered species; forfeit possession of the elephants it owns (54 at present); and pay the groups’ legal fees.

“If there are no animal models, there will be far fewer medical advances. That’s why Ringling Brothers’ pushback has been so significant.”

In 2005, the Humane Society became involved in the suit when it acquired the assets of the Fund for Animals; the Animal Protection Institute joined the next year. After almost a decade of legal action—motions, appeals, hearing upon hearing, discovery—a non-jury trial took place before United States District Judge Emmet G. Sullivan in the District of Columbia in February and March of 2009.

In the trial, Tom Rider, the star witness for the plaintiffs, proved to be problematic. Even though he referred to the elephants as his “girls” and claimed to have a “personal” and “emotional” attachment to them on par with the one he had for his two daughters and his grandson, he was unable to identify the elephants in videotaped footage.

Moreover, Rider’s own employment record indicated he was not upset by the way elephants are handed in a circus. Before Ringling Brothers, he worked for Clyde Beatty-Cole Brothers Circus, where he used chains and a bullhook in handling elephants. During his two-and-a-half years at Ringling Brothers, he never complained about elephant mistreatment to the media, circus veterinarians, United States Department of Agriculture inspectors, or his supervisor. When Rider did leave Ringling Brothers, it was not because of the elephants but because the Blue Unit’s traveling show ended. Then he traveled to Europe where he handled elephants owned by Richard Chipperfield that were performing in a circus, again using chains and a bullhook.

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

MERSCO’s Holiday Push Tests Backyard Play Demand in 2026

Updated Category News Views 103

A trampoline sale is not exactly a macroeconomic bellwether, but it does expose a useful little corner of holiday spending: parents buying big, awkward, discretionary stuff that has to earn its space in the yard. MERSCO is joining Amazon’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday window from November 19 through November 30, 2026, with discounts reaching 38% on selected products....

Continue Reading
Blast Doubles Athabasca Ground, but Drills Still Matter

Updated Category News Views 0

More ground in Athabasca can wake up a uranium junior fast, and Blast Resources has certainly grabbed investors’ attention with this one. The company has optioned eight additional uranium claims beside its Wales Lake property in northern Saskatchewan, taking its regional footprint from 12,150 hectares across 16 claims to 30,732 hectares across 24 claims. That is more...

Continue Reading
PSEG Long Island Warns Customers on QR Payment Scams

Updated Category News Views 131

Holiday panic is a thief's favorite crowbar, and Long Island households are plainly in the crosshairs. PSEG Long Island used Utility Scam Awareness Day on Nov. 18 to warn customers about impersonators demanding immediate payment under threat of a power shutoff. The central message, “Think Before You Scan,” is not flashy corporate wallpaper. It is practical advice for...

Continue Reading
First US Extends Buyback Clock Through Year-End 2027

Updated Category News Views 188

A buyback extension is not a thunderclap; it is a bank board keeping a useful tool within reach. First US Bancshares has pushed the expiration of its existing repurchase authorization from December 31, 2026, to December 31, 2027. That matters, but investors ought to resist turning a calendar change into a grand earnings prophecy. The company has bought back 2,122,972...

Continue Reading
GE Aerospace Backs Service Members With $100K Gift

Updated Category News Views 190

A six-figure commitment can look tiny beside jet-engine budgets, yet it can matter a great deal when it reaches people navigating the awkward jump from military service into civilian life. GE Aerospace has committed $100,000 to Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University to support transitioning service members. That is the whole heart of this announcement, and frankly, it is...

Continue Reading
Aimbient's OR Timestamp Study Puts Efficiency to Test

Updated Category News Views 160

A camera catching a patient’s arrival on time may sound mundane, but operating rooms are where mundane details can turn into serious money and better operational decisions. Aimbient’s newly corrected announcement points to an independently conducted Stanford Medicine study in JAMA Surgery that tested whether its computer-vision system could document key operating-room...

Continue Reading
Automotive Laminates: Small Market, Real EV Leverage

Updated Category News Views 126

Cabin trim has become a surprisingly serious battleground, and that is the whole point of this automotive laminates story. Nobody buys a vehicle because somebody bragged about a multilayer film behind the door panel. Yet the materials under the fingertips, beneath the carpet, and around the dashboard increasingly decide whether an interior feels cheap, quiet, durable, or...

Continue Reading
Early Therapy After Sports Injuries Deserves Careful Timing

Updated Category News Views 27

A limp can become a bad habit long before an athlete calls it one. That is the plain, useful concern behind Dr. Kali Spoto LaRue's discussion of sports-injury physical therapy for athletes in Fairport and Greater Rochester. The central message is not that every sore muscle needs the same response, nor that anybody should charge back into practice because they had one...

Continue Reading
FAA Funding Gridlock Raises Aviation Reliability Risk

Updated Category News Views 8

Friday’s radar and communications trouble delivered the sort of warning nobody in aviation can shrug off: the machinery behind the flight board is getting old, fragile, and far too dependent on people improvising around it. Thousands of flights were delayed or canceled when air traffic control facilities became unstable, according to the Southwest Airlines Pilots...

Continue Reading
Schloss Johannisberg Leads 2026 Global Vineyard List

Updated Category News Views 135

A 1,200-year-old riesling estate just beat the world at being memorable. Schloss Johannisberg in Germany’s Rheingau has taken No. 1 in The 50 Best Vineyards 2026, moving up from No. 2 last year and also claiming Best Vineyard in Europe. For anyone watching the wine business from the outside, this is not really a story about one bottle edging out another. It is a...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

NN, Inc. Welcomes Tim Erro as Chief Commercial Officer

Updated Category News Views 219

NN, Inc. Welcomes Tim Erro as Chief Commercial Officer NN, Inc. (NASDAQ: NNBR), a leader in high-precision industrial components, has recently appointed Tim Erro as its new Chief Commercial Officer. In this role, Mr. Erro will spearhead NN's global commercial efforts, enhancing the company's strategic initiatives aimed at business growth and development. Under the...

Continue Reading
Horizon Robotics Unveils Innovations in Smart Driving Solutions

Updated Category News Views 321

Horizon Robotics Unveils Innovations at IAA Mobility 2025 Horizon Robotics, a pioneer in smart driving solutions for passenger vehicles, recently demonstrated its cutting-edge technologies at IAA Mobility 2025. This platform not only highlights the company's dedication to smart mobility but also marks a significant step in its global outreach by establishing new...

Continue Reading
Nuvoton Technology Unveils Exciting New Industrial ICs

Updated Category News Views 157

Nuvoton Technology's Innovative BM-ICs for Industrial Applications Nuvoton Technology Corporation Japan (NTCJ) is set to introduce groundbreaking industrial battery monitoring integrated circuits (BM-ICs) designed for 48V batteries. These new products, named "KA49701A" and "KA49702A," are scheduled to enter mass production soon. Enhanced Safety Features in Battery System...

Continue Reading
Celebrate National Coffee Day with Atlas Coffee Club's Free Offer

Updated Category News Views 206

Celebrate National Coffee Day with Atlas Coffee Club Atlas Coffee Club is thrilled to celebrate National Coffee Day with a fantastic offer that every coffee lover is sure to appreciate. From now until October 2, you can snag a complimentary 12-ounce bag of single-origin coffee just by subscribing. All you need to do is cover the shipping fee, and you’re all set! The...

Continue Reading
Crypto Market Dynamics: Bitcoin and XRP Show Potential Gains

Updated Category News Views 264

Bitcoin Approaches Key Resistance Levels Recently, Bitcoin has seen a substantial surge as it has crossed a significant resistance level around $102,000, signifying a bullish sentiment in the market. This progression highlights a critical test as Bitcoin now looks to penetrate a key psychological and technical barrier at $105,000. The macroeconomic backdrop is favorable,...

Continue Reading