Conservatives Fail the N.F.L.’s Free Speech Test By

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

May 25, 2018 at 8:55 AM 125

Quote:

Conservatives Fail the N.F.L.’s Free Speech Test

By David French

Mr. French is a senior writer at National Review.
May 24, 2018

Members of the San Francisco 49ers kneeled during the national anthem, prior to a game against the Arizona Cardinals in Phoenix, Arizona last year.CreditMichael Zagaris/San Francisco 49ers, via Getty Images

The United States is in the grips of a free-speech paradox. At the same time that the law provides more protection to personal expression than at any time in the nation’s history, large numbers of Americans feel less free to speak. The culprit isn’t government censorship but instead corporate, community and peer intimidation.

Conservatives can recite the names of the publicly shamed from memory. There was Brendan Eich, hounded out of Mozilla for donating to a California ballot initiative that defined marriage as the union of a man and woman. There was James Damore, abruptly terminated from Google after he wrote an essay attributing the company’s difficulty in attracting female software engineers more to biology and free choice than to systemic discrimination. On campus, the list is as long and grows longer every semester.

It is right to decry this culture of intolerance and advocate for civility and engagement instead of boycotts and reprisals. The cure for bad speech is better speech — not censorship. Take that message to the heartland, and conservatives cheer.

Until, that is, Colin Kaepernick chose to kneel. Until, that is, the president demanded that the N.F.L. fire the other players who picked up on his protest after he was essentially banished from the league.

That was when the conservative mob called for heads to roll. Conform or face the consequences.

On Wednesday, the mob won. The N.F.L. announced its anthem rules for 2018, and the message was clear: Respect the flag by standing for the national anthem or stay in the locker room. If you break the rules and kneel, your team can be fined for your behavior.

This isn’t a “middle ground,” as the N.F.L. claims. It’s not a compromise. It’s corporate censorship backed up with a promise of corporate punishment. It’s every bit as oppressive as the campus or corporate attacks on expression that conservatives rightly decry.

But this is different, they say. This isn’t about politics. It’s about the flag.

I agree. It is different. Because it’s about the flag, the censorship is even worse.

One of the most compelling expressions of America’s constitutional values is contained in Justice Robert Jackson’s 1943 majority opinion in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette. At the height of World War II, two sisters, both Jehovah’s Witnesses, challenged the state’s mandate that they salute the flag in school. America was locked in a struggle for its very existence. The outcome was in doubt. National unity was essential.

But even in the darkest days of war, the court wrote liberating words that echo in legal history: “If there is any fixed star in our constitutional constellation, it is that no official, high or petty, can prescribe what shall be orthodox in politics, nationalism, religion, or other matters of opinion or force citizens to confess by word or act their faith therein.”

Make no mistake, I want football players to stand for the anthem. I want them to respect the flag. As a veteran of the war in Iraq, I’ve saluted that flag in foreign lands and deployed with it proudly on my uniform. But as much as I love the flag, I love liberty even more.

The N.F.L. isn’t the government. It has the ability to craft the speech rules its owners want. So does Google. So does Mozilla. So does Yale. American citizens can shame whomever they want to shame.

But what should they do? Should they use their liberty to punish dissent? Or should a free people protect a culture of freedom?

In our polarized times, I’ve adopted a simple standard, a civil liberties corollary to the golden rule: Fight for the rights of others that you would like to exercise yourself. Do you want corporations obliterating speech the state can’t touch? Do you want the price of participation in public debate to include the fear of lost livelihoods?

Then, by all means, support the N.F.L. Cheer Silicon Valley’s terminations. Join the boycotts and shame campaigns. Watch this country’s culture of liberty wither in front of your eyes.

The vice president tweeted news of the N.F.L.’s new policy and called it “#Winning.” He’s dead wrong. It diminishes the marketplace of ideas. It mocks the convictions of his fellow citizens. And it divides in the name of a false, coerced uniformity.

Writing in the Barnette decision, Justice Jackson wisely observed, “As governmental pressure toward unity becomes greater, so strife becomes more bitter as to whose unity it shall be.”

The N.F.L. should let players kneel. If it lets them kneel, it increases immeasurably the chances that when they do rise, they will rise with respect and joy, not fear and resentment. That’s the “winning” America needs.

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

RYBREVANT's Promising Results in HNSCC Treatment

Impressive Outcomes for RYBREVANT FASPRO in Head and Neck Cancer Tucked away in the endless cycle of drug trials, a glimmer of hope shines through with new data on RYBREVANT FASPRO in treating head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC). This science talk might not rattle the ticker tape directly on NYSE:JNJ, but it has all the makings of a game-changer in the oncology...

Ping An's Bold Green Moves Ahead of APEC 2026

By Owen Jenkins Updated Oct 25, 2026 Category News Views 148

Ping An's Pitch for Green: Talking the Talk and Walking the Walk? Well, here's something cooking in Shenzhen at the Ping An Finance Center—an international seminar championing green development initiatives. It's all buzz around Ping An Insurance (HKEX: 2318; SSE: 601318) flexing its green muscle, orchestrating conversations right before APEC 2026. Talk about timing....

Sac-TMT's Phase III Success Shifts Lung Cancer Paradigm

A New Era in Lung Cancer Treatment? Sac-TMT, the novel antibody-drug conjugate (ADC), just might be shaking up the non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) treatment landscape, and boy, is it making waves. Just when you think you’ve seen it all, here comes sacituzumab tirumotecan (sac-TMT), offering a glimmer of hope for patients whose treatment options have dwindled after...

Innovent's IBI3001 Shows Promise in Phase 1 Trials

Pioneering Path with IBI3001 at ESMO 2026 Navigating through the crowded landscape of oncology trials, Innovent Biologics recently rolled out some riveting Phase 1 clinical data for their new darling, IBI3001. Top brass from Innovent took to the European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) Congress stage to lay bare their findings. Obviously, when you're presenting a...

CapCut's Role in AI-Assisted Small Biz Marketing

In today's fast-paced digital world, small businesses lament the constant hustle to stay relevant online. This juggling act with limited resources often makes effective marketing feel like a high-wire circus performance. Enter AI tools, promising to lighten the load, and CapCut stands out as a game-changer. AI Tools Revolutionizing Small Business Marketing Amid growing...

Love Business Group Helps SMEs Navigate Broadband Choices

Understanding Broadband Needs for UK SMEs When you're knee-deep in running a small biz in the UK, sorting out your broadband needs can feel like sifting through a thousand-piece puzzle. Enter Love Business Group, getting a nod of recognition for being the SME knight in shining armor. Aimed at businesses of all sizes, they've been pegged by Expert Consumers for helping...

Survivors Secure $800M Settlement with NY Archdiocese

Massive Settlement: A Long-Awaited Justice Here's a different kind of news that's hitting like a thunderbolt. Over 1,300 survivors of abuse have finally struck a landmark deal with the Archdiocese of New York. Not only are the numbers staggering, but the relief for these individuals is palpable. We're talking about more than $800 million on the table here. That's some...

Fluence Energy Hits Legal Snag: Investors Called to Act

Fluence Energy Faces a Securities Fraud Challenge It's like watching a slow-motion train wreck. Fluence Energy, Inc. (NASDAQ: FLNC) now finds itself in the crosshairs of a securities fraud class action lawsuit. Apparently, someone was playing fast and loose with the truth concerning their financial guidance. The period in question stretches from November 24, 2025, to...

Kelun-Biotech's Sacituzumab Tirumotecan Shows Promise in NSCLC

Kelun-Biotech's Recent Breakthrough Grab your coffee, and let's chat about something that might just change the lung cancer treatment game: Kelun-Biotech's sacituzumab tirumotecan, or sac-TMT, showing some serious promise in a Phase III trial. With numbers that could make any investor sit up a little straighter, this study has turned heads at the European Society for...

DIRECTV Bags New NHL Deals: Stakes for Sports Fans

NHL Fans, Strap in: DIRECTV Expands Its Lineup In a world where keeping up with your favorite team gets tougher each day, DIRECTV just lobbed a puck right into the net with their latest play. They've snagged a multi-year deal with the NHL for the Carolina Hurricanes, Columbus Blue Jackets, Minnesota Wild, and St. Louis Blues networks. It's a game changer, folks. If you...