HUGE! Ropes & Gray Provides Insight on Yesterday's Supreme

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Hate Liars
532
HUGE! Ropes & Gray Provides Insight on Yesterday's Supreme Court Ruling which validated the PTAB's authority to rule on Patent eligibility. In October 2017 the PTAB ruled in favor of ALL of SFOR Patents and dismissed all claims against them

Supreme Court Issues Long-Awaited Decisions in Oil States and SAS Institute
April 24, 2018
Practices: Intellectual Property, Patent Trial & Appeal Board (PTAB)
Proceedings
Printer-Friendly Version

On April 24, 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court handed down two decisions that have a significant impact on inter partes review proceedings before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (“PTAB”) of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (“USPTO”). These proceedings review the patentability of patent claims previously issued by the USPTO.

The Court in Oil States Energy Services v. Greene’s Energy Group (decision here) found that these proceedings do not violate Article III or the Seventh Amendment because patents are public rights for purposes of this question. The Court in SAS Institute v. Iancu (decision here) found that the PTAB’s past practice of instituting review of fewer than all challenged claims violated the plain language of 35 U.S.C. § 318(a), which requires the PTAB to decide the patentability of all claims challenged in a petition.

Neither decision was unanimous, reflecting a rare divide among the Court in addressing patent issues. In Oil States, a 7-2 decision, Justice Thomas wrote for the majority; Justice Breyer wrote a concurring opinion joined by Justices Ginsburg and Sotomayor; and Justice Gorsuch wrote a dissent joined by Chief Justice Roberts. In SAS, a 5-4 decision, Justice Gorsuch wrote for the majority; Justice Ginsburg wrote a dissent joined by Justices Breyer, Sotomayor, and Kagan; and Justice Breyer also wrote a dissent joined by Justices Ginsburg and Sotomayor, and Justice Kagan in part.

Oil States: Inter Partes Review Trial Proceedings Are Constitutional Under Article III and the Seventh Amendment
Oil States had been involved in a patent infringement suit against Greene’s Energy Group, who filed an IPR petition challenging claims of the asserted patent. Ultimately, the PTAB held that the claims were unpatentable. Oil States then appealed the decision to the Federal Circuit and eventually to the Supreme Court, arguing in part that the inter partes review proceedings were contrary to Article III and the Seventh Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

At the Supreme Court, Oil States argued that Article III, which vests the “judicial power of the United States” in the courts, prohibits the PTAB—a non-Article III forum—to extinguish private property rights in an adversarial proceeding such as an IPR. Oil States also argued that the Seventh Amendment’s jury trial right prohibits the PTAB from deciding issues of patentability. Despite previously denying several other similar petitions for certiorari, the Supreme Court granted Oil States’ petition, agreeing to review the constitutional questions presented. After several months of briefing, oral argument took place on November 27, 2017. Fifty-seven (57) briefs amicus curiae were filed at the merits stage, showing the intense public interest in the Court’s decision. In addition, the U.S. government also submitted briefing to the Court, in which it argued for the constitutionality of inter partes review, and participated in the oral argument.

Today, after a nearly five-month wait, the Supreme Court issued its decision affirming the Federal Circuit and upholding the constitutionality of IPR proceedings. In writing for the Court, Justice Thomas explained that patents convey a specific type of right—a “public franchise”—and that the reevaluation of the patentability of claims by the USPTO involves an adjudication of public rights. As such, the Court found that IPR's are not an improper exercise of the judicial power under either Article III of the Constitution or a violation of the right to a jury trial under the Seventh Amendment.

The Court’s affirmance of the status quo in Oil States is therefore unlikely to lead to any changes at the PTAB. However, the Court did emphasize the narrowness of its decision, noting that it was not addressing any retroactive issues associated with PTAB proceedings and reaffirming prior holdings are property protected by other provisions of the Constitution, such as the Fifth Amendment. Thus, the door may be open for possible future constitutional challenges.

SAS Institute: Partial Institution of Petitions Is Not Authorized
Although Oil States has garnered more attention than SAS, which was argued the same day, the Court’s decision in SAS will have significant impact on PTAB proceedings going forward. Section 314(a) of Title 35 states that the USPTO Director may not institute review unless the Director determines that “there is a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to at least 1 of the claims challenged in the petition.” If review is instituted, Section 318(a) states that the USPTO Director “shall issue a final written decision with respect to the patentability of any patent claim challenged by the petitioner and any new claim added under section 316(d).” Despite this directive, the PTAB only instituted review and issued a final written decision on a subset of the claims that SAS initially challenged. The Federal Circuit affirmed the PTAB’s practice of so-called “partial institution,” holding that the final written decision need only address the claims under review post-institution. The Supreme Court, however, found that the language of the statute is clear—SAS was entitled to a final written decision addressing all of the claims it has challenged, reversing the Federal Circuit and remanding the case for further proceedings.

The situation in SAS is not uncommon. Among the 4,000+ decisions instituting review to date, the PTAB has generally instituted review—and subsequently issued final written decisions—only on the particular claims for which the petitioner has shown that there is a reasonable likelihood that it would prevail at institution. While the USPTO has not released specific statistics, and a majority of these decisions have instituted as to all challenged claims, a significant number of these decisions have instituted as to fewer than all challenged claims.

The Court’s decision today raises important questions and issues going forward. For example, the Federal Circuit and the PTAB will need to address the impact of SAS on proceedings already subject to partial institutions, both before and after a final written decision has issued. The PTAB may also adjust the role that institution decisions will play if these decisions cannot narrow the number of claims at issue, because final written decisions must address all challenged claims. For example, rather than issuing detailed institution decisions with substantive analysis regarding all challenged claims, the PTAB may instead choose to issue a simplified notice of institution containing minimal, if any, information useful to the parties. Relatedly, petitioners and patent owners litigating before the PTAB will need to adjust their respective strategies in light of SAS and any changes in the PTAB’s practices. For example, because the issuance of a final written decision as to a claim triggers estoppel provisions under Section 315(e), petitioners will need to assess the impact of SAS if all challenged claims will be subject to a final written decision if the proceeding is instituted regardless of the likelihood of success as to each claim. Conversely, patent owners will likely adjust pre-institution strategies to focus attacks on the broadest claims and abandon prior practices attempting to avoid institution as to fewer than all of the challenged claims.

Short of legislative action or additional regulatory workarounds that attempt to maintain more of the status quo, the decision in SAS will significantly alter practice before the PTAB going forward.

We will continue to monitor further developments regarding the impact of these decisions. If you have any questions about this Alert, please contact Scott McKeown, Gabrielle Higgins, James Davis or Matthew Rizzolo.

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Pepsi Faces Georgia Labor Pressure Ahead of Strike

Updated Category News Views 121

A Pre-Dawn Labor Test Is Brewing in Georgia At 2:30 in the morning, nobody gathers outside a distribution center for the scenery. More than 100 Pepsi-Cola drivers from Atlanta and Lithonia are slated to meet Tuesday, November 24, at the Pepsi Distribution Center in Lithonia, Georgia, with Teamsters General President Sean M. O'Brien joining them. That hour matters. It puts...

Continue Reading
Fluence Investors Face a November 27 Litigation Clock

Updated Category News Views 65

Six calendar squares are all that separate eligible Fluence investors from the November 27, 2026 lead-plaintiff deadline. That is not much time to locate trade confirmations, calculate losses, and decide whether taking a larger role in a securities case makes sense. The lawsuit is not a verdict, and anybody pretending otherwise is selling smoke. But the underlying...

Continue Reading
S&P Global's December 8 Talk Puts Guidance in Focus

Updated Category News Views 71

A 35-minute fireside chat can be a whole lot of nothing, or it can leave a useful breadcrumb trail for shareholders willing to listen closely. S&P Global has put December 8, 2026 on the calendar, when Chief Executive Officer Martina Cheung is scheduled to appear at Goldman Sachs' 2026 Financial Services Conference in New York. Her slot runs from 5:00 p.m. to 5:35 p.m....

Continue Reading
Lymphatic Research Gains Attention Beyond Wellness Claims

Updated Category News Views 94

Ankles leave little clues after a long day: sock grooves, puffiness, that dull heaviness nobody bothers to name. PureHealth Research wants people to look past the usual salt-and-water explanation and consider the lymphatic system, the body’s comparatively unsung network for gathering fluid from tissues and returning it to the bloodstream. Fair enough. This system does...

Continue Reading
ASA’s 2026 Grants Push Dermatology Into New Terrain

Updated Category News Views 104

Thirteen Small Bets With Serious Human Stakes Skin science rarely gets the splashy headlines, yet it touches a staggering number of people and carries some very stubborn unanswered questions. American Skin Association’s 2026 grant class puts 13 awards across skin cancer and dermatologic disease, with a noticeable willingness to follow newer clinical terrain rather than...

Continue Reading
Cottage Grove Tests Holiday Demand Across Lake Norman

Updated Category News Views 125

Flour and foot traffic make a pretty honest little scoreboard. Cottage Grove Bakery is putting itself in front of Lake Norman shoppers twice on Saturday, November 21, while also taking Thanksgiving orders and laying groundwork for 2027 workplace and school visits. This is not a public-company earnings story, and nobody should pretend a tray of scones is a quarterly...

Continue Reading
DISA Backs Nursing Education With OADN Foundation Push

Updated Category News Views 79

A nursing workforce does not appear by magic when hospitals need it most; somebody has to help students, instructors, and programs survive the long haul before that first shift. DISA's newly announced partnership with the Organization for Associate Degree Nursing and the OADN Foundation is aimed squarely at that unglamorous, essential stretch of the pipeline. For a sector...

Continue Reading
Allooloo's 100M Calls Test Capital Markets AI Data

Updated Category News Views 160

Forty-one point nine thousand issuers is a lot of financial clutter to keep straight, and Allooloo says its machines are getting called on to do precisely that at industrial scale. The Vancouver-based company reported on November 20 that its capital-markets data products now receive 100 million AI-agent calls a month—roughly 3.4 million daily, or 39 per second. That is...

Continue Reading
Greenberg Traurig Adds Privacy Muscle in Denver Office

Updated Category News Views 162

Privacy work used to be the legal department's back-room plumbing; now it can jam an entire product launch. That is why Greenberg Traurig's decision to bring Amber Mednick in as of counsel in Denver deserves more attention than the usual law-firm hiring blurb. This is not a splashy deal, and nobody should pretend one lateral hire rewrites the competitive map. Still, it is...

Continue Reading
Kinross Lawsuit Puts Round Mountain Claims Under Fire

Updated Category News Views 85

A mine can swallow a rosy forecast faster than any spreadsheet admits. That is the ugly center of the proposed securities class action involving Kinross Gold: not merely that production guidance came down, but the allegation that investors were sold too much confidence before the operational reality at Round Mountain Phase S surfaced. NYSE:KGC dropped from $27.62 on...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

GLS and APES Join Forces in Semiconductor Packaging Venture

Updated Category News Views 203

Opportunities and Risks in the Semiconductor Landscape Alright, let’s get into it. Great Lakes Semiconductor (GLS) teaming up with Advanced Printed Electronic Solutions (APES) sounds like a match made in tech heaven, but it also raises some eyebrows. Personally, I’ve been around the block enough to recognize that in this line of business, one misstep can feel like a...

Continue Reading
Renaissance Acquires Ansel Health, Enhancing Insurance Solutions

Updated Category News Views 176

Renaissance's Strategic Acquisition of Ansel Health Renaissance Life & Health Insurance Company of America has recently acquired Ansel Health, a transformative technology company in the supplemental health insurance domain. Innovating Health Insurance Solutions This acquisition not only enhances Renaissance's service portfolio but also promises to lead the way in...

Continue Reading
High-Trend International Group's Revenue Soars with New Strategies

Updated Category News Views 199

High-Trend International Group Sees Massive Revenue Growth High-Trend International Group (NASDAQ: HTCO), a prominent name in ocean technology, has shared its impressive financial results. The Company has achieved a remarkable surge in revenue, marking a pivotal moment in its business journey. Understanding the latest financial summary showcases how effective new...

Continue Reading
Innovative Device Enhances At-Home Medical Exam Experience

Updated Category News Views 391

Revolutionizing Self-Exams with Innovative Design In today's fast-paced world, health awareness is more crucial than ever. Individuals often seek ways to monitor their health conveniently from the comfort of their home. Recognizing this need, an inventive mind has developed a unique device aimed at simplifying personal health examinations. The MEDICAL EXAM WAIST BAND...

Continue Reading
Navitas Unveils Groundbreaking Power Supply for AI Data Centers

Updated Category News Views 86

Navitas Semiconductor Makes Waves in AI Power Supply Solutions Navitas Semiconductor, a trailblazer in power semiconductor technology, is set to impress at the upcoming power electronics conference in China. Their latest innovation, the world's first 8.5 kW AI data center power supply, integrates leading-edge gallium nitride (GaN) and silicon carbide (SiC) technologies....

Continue Reading