The lead attorney for SecureAuth/Knobbe Martins who

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
Hate Liars
479
The lead attorney for SecureAuth/Knobbe Martins who submitted the Alice 35/101 in October 2017 wrote the below piece. I wonder what he thinks now based on the Supreme Court's decision that Alice needs to take a back seat to PTAB patent eligibility reviews.

Recent Federal Circuit Decisions Emphasize Effect of Factual Questions on Patent Eligibility
By Jeremy Anapol Knobbe Martins
March 14, 2018

In two recent cases, the Federal Circuit addressed the role of factual questions in resolving patent eligibility under 35 U.S.C. § 101. The first case was Berkheimer v. HP Inc. and the second was Aatrix Software v. Green Shades Software.[1] These cases possibly undercut the holdings of previous cases in which the Federal Circuit routinely affirmed judgments invalidating patent claims under § 101 in the early stages of litigation, when factual questions are typically unresolved.[2]

In Berkheimer, the Federal Circuit reviewed a decision invalidating eight patent claims under § 101 on a motion for summary judgment. The court reiterated the familiar principle that “patent eligibility is ultimately a question of law,” but added that the underlying question of “[w]hether something is well-understood, routine, and conventional to a skilled artisan at the time of the patent is a factual determination.”[3] Turning to the challenged patent, the court identified certain “purported improvements” to computer technology that were described in the specification.[4] The court held that these purported improvements, “to the extent they are captured in the claims, create a factual dispute regarding whether the invention describes well-understood, routine, conventional activities.”[5]

Because four of the eight claims at issue in Berkheimer contained “limitations directed to the arguably unconventional inventive concept described in the specification,” the Federal Circuit found that those claims raised a “genuine issue of material fact making summary judgment inappropriate.”[6] Accordingly, the court vacated the grant of summary judgment on those four claims, but affirmed on the other four claims that did not recite the limitations that were arguably unconventional.

In Aatrix, the Federal Circuit reviewed a decision invalidating six patent claims under § 101 on a motion to dismiss. In the proceedings below, when the district court granted the motion to dismiss, it found that a claim limitation relied on by the patentee failed to satisfy § 101 because it merely described “a ‘well understood’ and ‘routine’ component and function of a computer.”[7] After that dismissal, the patentee moved for reconsideration and moved to amend its complaint.[8] The patentee’s proposed amendments to the complaint explained how the claims allegedly reflected an improvement in computer technology that was neither well-understood nor routine.[9] The district court denied the motion to amend and declined to reconsider its holding on § 101 in view of the amended complaint.[10]

On appeal, the Federal Circuit panel issued a split decision. The majority (Judges Moore and Taranto) emphasized the presence of factual questions, echoing the court’s approach in Berkheimer. Specifically, the majority explained that “the ultimate determination of eligibility under § 101 is a question of law” but “like many legal questions, there can be subsidiary fact questions,” which include the question of “[w]hether the claim elements or the claimed combination are well-understood, routine, conventional.”[11] The majority then found that there were “concrete allegations in the second amended complaint that individual elements and the claimed combination are not well-understood, routine, or conventional activity.” [12] On a motion to dismiss, the district court was required to accept those allegations as true, but it failed to do so.[13] Thus, the majority vacated the dismissal and remanded the case to the district court.

Judge Reyna dissented in part. He argued that the majority opinion attempted to “shoehorn a significant factual component into the Alice § 101 analysis” and “shift the character of the § 101 inquiry from a legal question to a predominantly factual inquiry.”[14] Judge Reyna also argued that, after Aatrix, “a plaintiff facing a § 101 motion may simply amend its complaint to allege extrinsic facts that, once alleged, must be taken as true regardless of its consistency with the intrinsic record.”[15] The majority opinion in Aatrix did not directly address Judge Reyna’s criticism.

The majority stated that patent eligibility can be decided on a motion to dismiss “only when there are no factual allegations that, taken as true, prevent resolving the eligibility question as a matter of law.”[16] But the majority did not state that factual allegations must be taken as true “regardless” of intrinsic evidence (e.g., the patent specification and the claims themselves) as Judge Reyna argued. To the contrary, the majority’s reference to “concrete” allegations may suggest it believed the allegations in Aatrix amounted to more than the type of gamesmanship Judge Reyna feared.

To clarify the potential impact of Aatrix, it is helpful to compare that decision with Berkheimer because both judges who joined the majority in Aatrix also joined the unanimous decision in Berkheimer. As explained above, Berkeimer vacated summary judgment on four out of eight claims, but affirmed summary judgment on the other four claims. The court invalidated the latter claims despite several factual assertions that the patentee raised in an effort to show eligibility.

First, the patentee asserted that the claims were rooted in technology because they recited a “parsing” limitation.[17] However, the court rejected this assertion by relying on the patentee’s admission that “parsers had existed for years prior to his patent.”[18] Second, the patentee asserted that the claims improved computer functionality by eliminating redundancy in an unconventional manner.[19] Addressing this assertion, the court noted that the four claims it held invalid did not recite any limitations that required eliminating redundancy.[20] Because that allegedly unconventional feature was not recited in the claims themselves, it could not provide the inventive concept necessary to satisfy § 101.[21]

Berkheimer shows that despite the Federal Circuit’s recent emphasis on factual questions, it continues to view some of those questions as insufficient to prevent claims from being held invalid as a matter of law. Indeed, Berkheimer warns that “not every § 101 determination contains genuine disputes over the underlying facts material to the § 101 inquiry.”[22] This warning is consistent with the Supreme Court’s decision in Alice. In that case, the Court affirmed summary judgment of invalidity on four patents and concluded that various computer-related claim limitations were “purely conventional” and therefore non-inventive.[23] The Court reached this conclusion without explicitly referring to any evidence or factual findings.[24]

Although fact finding may not be necessary to every § 101 decision, patentees litigating § 101 should identify any concrete or genuine questions of fact that might affect the § 101 inquiry in their cases specifically, and consider raising those questions in their pleadings and evidentiary submissions. Conversely, accused infringers should be prepared to explain why any questions of fact raised by the patentee cannot affect the outcome of the § 101 analysis in their cases because they are not “concrete” or “genuine.” For further discussion of factual questions that may be material under § 101, see the section on “Pitfalls for Eligibility Evidence” in our prior article: Will Courts Consider Evidence of Patent Eligibility? [25].

[1] Berkheimer v. HP Inc., No. 2017-1437 (Fed. Cir. Feb. 8, 2018); Aatrix Software, Inc. v. Green Shades Software, Inc., No 2017-1452 (Fed. Cir. Feb. 14, 2018).

[2] See, e.g., Cleveland Clinic Found. v. True Health Diagnostics LLC, 859 F.3d. 1352, 1360 (Fed. Cir. 2017) (The Federal Circuit has “repeatedly affirmed § 101 rejections at the motion to dismiss stage, before claim construction or significant discovery has commenced.”).

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

University of Phoenix Poll Gets a Useful Reality Check

Updated Category News Views 108

Good Numbers, With the Usual Fine Print Employer approval is the kind of evidence career-focused schools desperately need, and University of Phoenix just put up a pretty loud batch of it. Among managers who directly supervise its graduates, 94% said the university understands employer needs, while 92% said its programs align with workforce demands. Those are stout...

Continue Reading
Tampa General's Food Bet Earns a 2026 Innovation Award

Updated Category News Views 78

Hospital meals have long been the punchline nobody bothered to fix, which is why Tampa General Hospital's latest recognition deserves a closer look. The not-for-profit academic health system was named the 2026 Inno Pick by the Tampa Bay Business Journal for its Food as Medicine initiative, its fifth straight year landing among the publication's Inno Award honorees. Awards...

Continue Reading
Alibaba Lawsuit Deadline Puts Disclosure Risk in Focus

Updated Category News Views 159

A calendar deadline is doing more work than any earnings headline for Alibaba shareholders this week. A securities class action notice says investors who bought or acquired Alibaba Group Holding Limited securities between May 23, 2024 and November 11, 2026 may seek appointment as lead plaintiff by January 19, 2027. That is a procedural milestone, not a verdict, and...

Continue Reading
Cottage Grove Tests Holiday Demand Across Lake Norman

Updated Category News Views 125

Flour and foot traffic make a pretty honest little scoreboard. Cottage Grove Bakery is putting itself in front of Lake Norman shoppers twice on Saturday, November 21, while also taking Thanksgiving orders and laying groundwork for 2027 workplace and school visits. This is not a public-company earnings story, and nobody should pretend a tray of scones is a quarterly...

Continue Reading
Domino's Probe Puts Franchise Disclosure Under Lens

Updated Category News Views 110

A franchisee's shuttered stores can turn cheerful unit-growth talk into a nasty accounting of credibility, and that is the uncomfortable territory Domino's now occupies. Kahn Swick & Foti has opened an investigation into whether Domino's officers and directors breached fiduciary duties or violated state or federal law. That is not a finding of misconduct. It is a legal...

Continue Reading
Payoneer Gets OCC Nod, but the Finish Line Is Ahead

Updated Category News Views 121

Federal bank paperwork is not usually thrilling, yet Payoneer just found a potentially meaningful lever for its cross-border payments machine. The company received preliminary conditional approval from the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency to form PAYO Digital Bank, a national trust bank intended to support stablecoin services. That is a real regulatory milestone...

Continue Reading
ASA’s 2026 Grants Push Dermatology Into New Terrain

Updated Category News Views 104

Thirteen Small Bets With Serious Human Stakes Skin science rarely gets the splashy headlines, yet it touches a staggering number of people and carries some very stubborn unanswered questions. American Skin Association’s 2026 grant class puts 13 awards across skin cancer and dermatologic disease, with a noticeable willingness to follow newer clinical terrain rather than...

Continue Reading
Surf City Seasons Put Vacation Rental Timing in Focus

Updated Category News Views 42

Summer’s Calendar Does the Talking School bells, not seagulls, appear to set the pace for Surf City’s rental market. Chris Rackley’s seasonal guide makes a pretty grounded point: the “best” time to visit Surf City, North Carolina, is not some universal magic week on a postcard. It depends on whether a traveler needs peak beach weather, wants elbow room, or...

Continue Reading
TEN Holdings Raises $1.0 Million as Dilution Looms

Updated Category News Views 66

A Small Raise With a Loud Message Nothing says “we need room to breathe” quite like selling 1,492,500 new shares for $0.67 apiece. TEN Holdings closed a roughly $1.0 million gross equity offering on November 20, 2026, and investors in NASDAQ:XHLD ought to look at this for what it is: a modest cash infusion that comes with immediate dilution. The company gets capital;...

Continue Reading
Tessera Delisting Leaves HLSQ in a Tougher Market Ahead

Updated Category News Views 116

November delivered a nasty little truth serum for Tessera Defense and Homeland Security: exchange status is not a cosmetic detail when the stock’s selling price has collapsed. On November 10, NYSE Regulation suspended trading in the company’s common shares on NYSE American and began delisting proceedings. By November 17, Tessera had a chance to request review by the...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Major Settlement Proposed for TD Mutual Fund Class Action Cases

Updated Category News Views 65

Understanding the TD Mutual Fund Class Action Settlement If you have ever held units of a TD Mutual Fund through a discount broker, you may be part of a significant class action settlement that has recently come to light. TD Asset Management Inc. has agreed to a settlement amounting to C$70.25 million aimed at resolving claims on behalf of individuals who have held units...

Continue Reading
The No-Nonsense Breakdown on Church & Dwight Co. Stocks

Updated Category News Views 192

Church & Dwight Co: The Lay of the Land Let’s be real. Church & Dwight Co Inc. (NYSE:CHD) is on the radar, trading at about $103.08, and it just popped a neat 1.46%. However, look a little deeper, and you see it’s been a rocky ride over the past year with a drop of 5.41%. Basically, it’s like gearing up for a race—only to find out you’re running on a rocky...

Continue Reading
Experience the Excitement of Jaialdi at Fairfield Inn & Suites

Updated Category News Views 256

Welcoming Guests to the Jaialdi Festival Fairfield Inn & Suites Boise West is thrilled to welcome visitors for the upcoming Jaialdi Festival, an extraordinary event that celebrates Basque culture and tradition. This festival is held once every five years and is expected to gather attendees from around the globe to participate in the festivities. The hotel, operated by...

Continue Reading
Viridien's Successful Senior Secured Notes Offering Explained

Updated Category News Views 137

Success in Senior Secured Notes Offering Today marked a significant achievement for Viridien S.A. as the company announced the successful pricing of its offering of US$450 million 10% senior secured notes and €475 million 8.5% senior secured notes, both maturing in 2030. This offering signals a strong confidence in Viridien's financial strategy and operational...

Continue Reading
Legal Insights: Investors of Ready Capital Corporation (RC) Act Now

Updated Category News Views 133

Understanding the Situation with Ready Capital Corporation (RC) As an investor in Ready Capital Corporation, it's essential to stay informed about recent developments regarding the company, especially if you've faced any financial losses. Currently, there's an important deadline approaching that could affect shareholders significantly. Key Dates and Details for Investors...

Continue Reading