Trump Judge Pushes for Original Meaning of 1st

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
PoemStone OldSaltDawg #30728
390
Trump Judge Pushes for Original Meaning of 1st Amendment

< >

Judge-James-Ho-640x480.jpg

One of President Trump’s new judicial appointments debuted in a big way on Wednesday in a campaign-finance case, showing that the president is serious about keeping his promise on the sort of judges he appoints, and that his vetting system for nominees is working brilliantly. And liberals are throwing a fit.
A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit recently decided Zimmerman v. City of Austin, holding that the city’s individual limit of $350 during an election cycle does not violate the First Amendment right of citizens to participate in politics. The court then denied a petition for rehearing en banc by a 12-2 vote, in which all 14 judges currently on the court would rehear the case.

Judge Jim Ho is one of the dissenting judges, who was confirmed to the Fifth Circuit last December as the record-breaking twelfth appellate judge to confirmed during a president’s first year. His dissent was joined in large part by Judge Edith Jones, revered as an iron-willed conservative judge who had been a finalist for the Supreme Court in 1989.

“The unfortunate trend in modern constitutional law is not only to create rights that appear nowhere in the Constitution, but also to disfavor rights expressly enumerated by our Founders,” Judge Ho began, citing an opinion from Justice Clarence Thomas, the rock-ribbed originalist jurist for whom Ho clerked years ago. “This case reinforces this regrettable pattern.”

Ho continued:

There is no more quintessentially American principle than the right of the people to participate in their own governance. The First Amendment protects the freedom of speech, and that freedom emphatically includes the right to speak about who our elected leaders should not be. This foundational American liberty includes not only the freedom to engage in one’s own political speech, but also the freedom to support like-minded candidates for office.

“The First Amendment therefore protects campaign contributions,” he said, citing Supreme Court precedent.

“Campaign contributions are not personal gifts—they are donations to support and defray the costs of campaign speech,” Ho continues. “Accordingly, the Supreme Court has carefully delimited the narrow circumstances in which the government may permissibly interfere with campaign contributions.”

Campaign contributions in exchange for favors is outright corruption, and is a crime. But, Ho warned, “the risk of quid pro quo corruption must be established by evidence—courts may not accept mere conjectureas adequate to carry a First Amendment burden.”

He quoted Justice Thomas from a case involving $250 contribution limits, where the justice wrote, “I cannot fathom how a $251 contribution could pose a substantial risk of securing a political quid pro quo.”

“The district court should have heeded Justice Thomas’s common-sense observation—particularly because the record is devoid of any evidence to the contrary,” Ho reasoned, looking to Austin’s similarly low contribution limit.

“As any proponent of campaign finance regulation will tell you, a donor with suspect intentions can circumvent campaign contribution limits—and achieve his nefarious goals—simply by making independent expenditures instead,” Ho added, explaining why these contribution limits do not even accomplish their intended goals. “So either the government regulates everything—or there’s no point in regulating any of it.”

The judge on the New Orleans-based appeals court acknowledged that there is a lot of money in modern campaigns. “But if you don’t like big money in politics, then you should oppose big government in our lives,” Ho goes on. “When government grows larger, when regulators pick more and more economic winners and losers, participation in the political process ceases to be merely a citizen’s prerogative—it becomes a human necessity.”

“This is the inevitable result of a government that would be unrecognizable to our Founders,” he concludes, citing as an example NFIB v. Sebelius—the Supreme Court case upholding Obamacare.

The Economist’s Supreme Court correspondent, Steven Mazie, balked at the Obamacare reference, tweeting that Ho’s opinion was “SCOTUSshaming” that implicitly criticized Chief Justice John Roberts, who was the deciding vote in that case.

Far from it, Ho seems to cleverly agree with Roberts on the key point. In NFIB, Roberts rejected the Obama administration’s argument that it had authority under the Constitution’s Commerce Clause to compel people to buy health insurance, writing, “That is not the country the Framers of our Constitution envisioned.”

“The Framers gave Congress the power to regulate commerce, not to compel it, and for over 200 years both our decisions and Congress’s actions have reflected this understanding,” Roberts continued. That legal principle was also declared in a separate opinion by the four dissenting justices in NFIB: Justices Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, and Alito.

In other words, with five justices onboard, it was part of the Supreme Court’s holding in NFIB. Ho was not “shaming” the Supreme Court. Instead, he was citing it as controlling authority over him, and in doing so acted as a faithful subordinate judge on a lower court.

Conservatives are cheering. “What a debut!” wrote former Scalia law clerk Ed Whelan, a leader of the Federalist Society. Professor David Bernstein of Scalia Law School at George Mason University agreed, tweeting out the quote about big government in our lives.

Liberals are predictably reacting differently. The ultra-left ThinkProgress condemned Ho’s opinion as “a sweeping assault,” calling it “a doozy.” The far-left People for the American Way issued the headline, “Confirmed Judges, Confirmed Fears: Trump Circuit Judge Shows His Extremism in Money in Politics.”

Try the decaf. Far from vindicating the shocked outrage leftists are claiming, Judge Ho’s opinion is exactly what President Trump promised to deliver through his judicial picks.

White House Counsel Don McGahn, the president’s top White House adviser on judges, explained to CPAC in March that the president wants nominees who will “stand strong in the face of adversity,” and not be swayed by polls or editorials.

That assurance is nothing new. McGahn spoke at the November 2017 annual convention of the Federalist Society, saying that President Trump is determined to keep “nominating and appointing judges who are committed originalists and textualists.”

McGahn added that they wanted a list of nominees who are “kind of too hot for primetime, the kind that would be really hot in the Senate, probably some people who have written a lot.” That is important, McGahn explained, so that, “We can get a really good sense of their views … the kind of people who would make some people nervous.”

That’s exactly what they got in Ho, who has written on the Second Amendment, racial preferences, national security powers, and a host of other issues—including campaign finance, back when he was a law student.

But Ho also has the credentials McGahn told CPAC they look for. A graduate of a Top-10 law school who clerked for Justice Thomas, served in the elite Office of Legal Counsel at the Justice Department, later served as Texas solicitor general, and then become a partner at a global law firm, Ho’s combination of intellect and commitment to originalist interpretation of the Constitution was on full display in his inaugural opinion as a judge on the Fifth Circuit.

The White House also has expert outside advisers like Leonard Leo, who assists McGahn’s team in identifying nominees who combine such capability with a constitutional conservative philosophy. Many of them have pedigrees like Ho’s.

With over a dozen of President Trump’s appellate judges now on the bench, Americans can probably expect more judicial opinions that unapologetically embrace an originalist view of the Constitution—a view that also polls well with the voters. The president is fulfilling his promise and assembled a team that is making it happen.
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Shenzhen's Vision Unveiled: APEC 2026 Promo Debut

Updated Category News Views 509

Shenzhen's Spotlight Moment at APEC 2026 When Shenzhen announced its promotional video for the 2026 APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting, it wasn't just about standard tourism glitz. This was a show of force, a bold step onto the main stage of global politics and economics. The video's launch wasn’t merely an audio-visual delight—it staked a claim in shaping the future...

Continue Reading
Berry Street Integrates AI with What Matters: Human Touch

Updated Category News Views 224

Health Meets AI at Berry Street In recent waves of news, Berry Street has decided to toss MyScribe, a standalone AI service, into its shopping cart and welcomed its brainwave behind it, Dr. Wasif Bokhari, into their corridors. Yep, they’ve snagged both the tech and the mind! It's the kind of move that makes you stop midway through your diner coffee. Here’s Berry...

Continue Reading
YONDELIS: Thai Approval Opens New Sarcoma Treatment Path

Updated Category News Views 115

New Hope for Thai Sarcoma Patients Alright, we’ve got some good news coming out of Thailand, folks. The Thai FDA just greenlit YONDELIS® (trabectedin) for those grappling with advanced soft tissue sarcoma (STS). Now, this isn’t your everyday drug release—it’s a clinical chess move packing potential for patients who’ve run out of other options. December 1st,...

Continue Reading
Hanwha Power Seals Second FSRU Conversion Deal

Updated Category News Views 42

Riding the FSRU Wave with Hanwha Power Alright, we've got Hanwha Power step-dancing onto the LNG stage with its second splash into the FSRU (Floating Storage and Regasification Unit) conversion gig. Partnering up with Energos Infrastructure, these guys are making serious waves in the energy market by transforming what's pretty much a regular ship into a floating gas...

Continue Reading
WHO and RCSI Bahrain Join Forces on Health Initiatives

Updated Category News Views 416

Forging a Healthier Pathway In a world where healthcare challenges rise faster than my blood pressure during a stock market crash, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland (RCSI) – Medical University of Bahrain have inked a deal to tackle these issues head-on. The memorandum of understanding (MoU) signed on November 15, 2026,...

Continue Reading
Princess Cruises Launches New Era at Celebration Key

Updated Category News Views 185

Never thought I'd see the day when a cruise ship docking would stir such excitement, but here we are. The Star Princess has made its grand debut at Celebration Key, the latest jewel in Princess Cruises' crown. And they're going all out with Bahamian flair—something about a Junkanoo band and beach art that would make even the crustiest sailor crack a smile. Inaugural Fun...

Continue Reading
Championing Change: USTA Mid-Atlantic Gala's Impact

Updated Category News Views 309

A Night to Remember: USTA Mid-Atlantic's Gala Who would've thought tennis could wield such transformative power? This ain't your average sport gala. Last Saturday, a crowd of over 300 gathered at the Ritz-Carlton Tysons Corner for the USTA Mid-Atlantic Foundation's 2026 Tennis Creates Gala. Hosted by the formidable Malika Andrews, this event wasn't just a fancy...

Continue Reading
Kayla Harrison Dominates UFC 334, Earns Big Win

Updated Category News Views 59

Kicking off UFC 334 with a bang, Kayla Harrison didn't just step into the Octagon—she bulldozed her way through Amanda Nunes to retain her Women's Bantamweight Championship. This showdown didn't just electrify New York's Madison Square Garden, it shook the entire MMA landscape. Harrison, the face of Monster Energy's athlete roster, wasn't content with just defending her...

Continue Reading
CVS Study: GLP-1 Drugs Effective But Costly

Updated Category News Views 139

Can GLP-1s Deliver Value at Their Current Price? Alright, folks, here's a real-world gut check from CVS Health. They crunched some numbers using Aetna's anonymized claims data, and the results are eye-opening. These GLP-1s are showing promising health outcomes—lower hospital visits, better clinical results, yada yada. But when it comes to savings, they ain't quite...

Continue Reading
Beef 'O' Brady's Expands Into Tuscaloosa Market

Updated Category News Views 279

A New Player in Town: Beef 'O' Brady's Lands in Tuscaloosa Listen up, sports fans and pub grub lovers of Tuscaloosa! Beef 'O' Brady's just kicked down the doors and expanded its reach, opening a location smack on McFarland Boulevard. The place threw open its doors on October 26 and is set to make waves in the local scene, driven by the dedicated hands of Mitul Patel and...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Exploring the Growth of the Radiation Hardened Electronics Sector

Updated Category News Views 124

Radiation Hardened Electronics Market Size & Insights Austin - The Radiation Hardened Electronics market has been drawing significant attention as it evolves rapidly. It was valued at USD 1.60 billion recently and is projected to reach USD 2.35 billion within a few years, indicating noteworthy growth driven by an impressive CAGR of 4.45% between 2024 and 2032. Factors...

Continue Reading
Understanding the Growing Investment Trends in Philip Morris

Updated Category News Views 249

Investment Trends Surrounding Philip Morris International Investors with significant capital are taking a positive stance toward Philip Morris International (NYSE: PM), a situation that is essential for market watchers to note. Today, significant activity in options trading has come to light, indicating substantial interest from major players. While the identities of...

Continue Reading
Alibaba Enhances Cross-Border Trade with New AI Features

Updated Category News Views 294

Alibaba's Commitment to AI Development Alibaba Group Holding Limited (NYSE: BABA) is making significant strides in the artificial intelligence (AI) sector. The company is introducing innovative AI tools across its global marketplaces and mobile applications, aiming to enhance the efficiency of cross-border trade while providing users with more intuitive shopping...

Continue Reading
Apache Software Foundation Elevates New Software Projects

Updated Category News Views 219

Apache Software Foundation Welcomes New Projects The Apache Software Foundation (ASF), a passionate hub for open-source software, has officially recognized Apache DevLake and Apache Grails as its latest Top-Level Projects (TLPs). This milestone marks a significant achievement for both projects, unveiling new opportunities in the software development landscape. Introducing...

Continue Reading
How Strategic Finance Consulting Prepares Companies for Growth

Updated Category Business Views 67

Growth rarely strains one area at a time. It pulls on hiring, pricing, inventory, and payment timing all at once, while leaders still need clear signals from the numbers. Reports that worked during an earlier stage can start missing key risks. Companies preparing for expansion benefit from stronger financial judgment, steadier planning, and a clearer view of what daily...

Continue Reading