What’s the Matter With Trumpland? By Paul Krugman

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Bhawks
188
Quote:
What’s the Matter With Trumpland?

By Paul Krugman
Opinion Columnist
April 2, 2018

These days almost everyone has the (justified) sense that America is coming apart at the seams. But this isn’t a new story, or just about politics. Things have been falling apart on multiple fronts since the 1970s: Political polarization has marched side by side with economic polarization, as income inequality has soared.

And both political and economic polarization have a strong geographic dimension. On the economic side, some parts of America, mainly big coastal cities, have been getting much richer, but other parts have been left behind.

On the political side, the thriving regions by and large voted for Hillary Clinton, while the lagging regions voted for Donald Trump.


I’m not saying that everything is great in coastal cities: Many people remain economically stranded even within metropolitan areas that look successful in the aggregate. And soaring housing costs, thanks in large part to Nimbyism, are a real and growing problem.

Still, regional economic divergence is real and correlates closely, though not perfectly, with political divergence.

But what’s behind this divergence? What’s the matter with Trumpland?

Regional disparities aren’t a new phenomenon in America. Indeed, before World War II the world’s richest, most productive nation was also a nation with millions of dirt-poor farmers, many of whom didn’t even have electricity or indoor plumbing. But until the 1970s those disparities were rapidly narrowing.

Take, for example, the case of Mississippi, America’s poorest state. In the 1930s, per-capita income in Mississippi was only 30 percent as high as per-capita income in Massachusetts. By the late 1970s, however, that figure was almost 70 percent — and most people probably expected this process of convergence to continue.

But the process went into reverse instead: These days, Mississippi is back down to only about 55 percent of Massachusetts income. To put this in international perspective, Mississippi now is about as poor relative to the coastal states as Sicily is relative to northern Italy.

Mississippi isn’t an isolated case. As a new paper by Austin, Glaeser and Summers documents, regional convergence in per-capita incomes has stopped dead.

And the relative economic decline of lagging regions has been accompanied by growing social problems: a rising share of prime-aged men not working, rising mortality, high levels of opioid consumption.

An aside: One implication of these developments is that William Julius Wilson was right. Wilson famously argued that the social ills of the nonwhite inner-city poor had their origin not in some mysterious flaws of African-American culture but in economic factors — specifically, the disappearance of good blue-collar jobs.

Sure enough, when rural whites faced a similar loss of economic opportunity, they experienced a similar social unraveling.

So what is the matter with Trumpland?

For the most part I’m in agreement with Berkeley’s Enrico Moretti, whose 2012 book, “The New Geography of Jobs,” is must reading for anyone trying to understand the state of America. Moretti argues that structural changes in the economy have favored industries that employ highly educated workers — and that these industries do best in locations where there are already a lot of these workers.

As a result, these regions are experiencing a virtuous circle of growth: Their knowledge-intensive industries prosper, drawing in even more educated workers, which reinforces their advantage.

And at the same time, regions that started with a poorly educated work force are in a downward spiral, both because they’re stuck with the wrong industries and because they’re experiencing what amounts to a brain drain.

While these structural factors are surely the main story, however, I think we have to acknowledge the role of self-destructive politics.


That new Austin et al. paper makes the case for a national policy of aiding lagging regions. But we already have programs that would aid these regions — but which they won’t accept.

Many of the states that have refused to expand Medicaid, even though the federal government would foot the great bulk of the bill — and would create jobs in the process — are also among America’s poorest.

Or consider how some states, like Kansas and Oklahoma — both of which were relatively affluent in the 1970s, but have now fallen far behind — have gone in for radical tax cuts, and ended up savaging their education systems. External forces have put them in a hole, but they’re digging it deeper.

And when it comes to national politics, let’s face it: Trumpland is in effect voting for its own impoverishment. New Deal programs and public investment played a significant role in the great postwar convergence; conservative efforts to downsize government will hurt people all across America, but it will disproportionately hurt the very regions that put the G.O.P. in power.

The truth is that doing something about America’s growing regional divide would be hard even with smart policies. The divide will only get worse under the policies we’re actually likely to get.


Kagetora
New York5h ago
Times Pick

The problem in Trump land is twofold. First, some genius decided that it was a good idea to offshore a large portion of US manufacturing, and the people left jobless were told that they needed to upgrade their educational and skill levels.

Some did But this is easier said than done - there are only so many engineers and designers needed in any field, and some people are simply not capable.

The other problem is just ignorance. These people's sense of victimization provides them with an identity and with an opportunity to blame their ills on someone else, i.e. minorities and foreigners.

Hence Trump becomes their imagined savior. But frankly a lot of us are tired of the never ending rationalizations as to why any of these people continually vote against their self-interests by electing people like Trump.

The truth is that if they are gullible enough to believe anything that comes out of Donald Trumps mouth, then they deserve to be in the situation they are in.

Joan In California
California4h ago

Can't believe there's still room at the commentary inn, but anyway, we seem to be reliving the age of the robber barons. One of you(se) op-ed folks needs to print the famous " Let Us Prey" steel engraving by Thomas Nast. Then all should write a column to illustrate the illustration. That's where we are.

It is truly remarkable that one of the least lovable presidents, LBJ, did through his long congressional career the most for those poor states and folks through rural electrification and other programs, and as president the most for old folks with Medicare.

It also is pitiful and pitiable that our president is promoting policies that undo so much and that congressional Republicans are so fearful of riling the 35-40% alias Trump supporters by voting in the funding and laws that will help them. To continue supporting laws and programs that will keep the poor down and out is sooo 19th century.



Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

DEFSEC Tackles Nasdaq Bid Price Hurdle with Share Move

Updated Category News Views 63

Navigating Bid Price Deficiency Issues Well, it seems DEFSEC Technologies Inc. found themselves in a tricky spot last week. A nasty gram from Nasdaq’s Listing Qualifications Department pointing out that DEFSEC's shares had dipped below that $1.00 per share requirement for too long—a full 30 business days. Now, don't panic just yet. This isn't about the shares getting...

Continue Reading
RBI Prices $1 Billion of Secured Notes Due 2031, 2036

Updated Category News Views 222

A billion dollars of fresh paper just landed on Restaurant Brands International’s balance-sheet doorstep, and this one deserves more than the usual sleepy glance at a financing release. RBI has priced $500 million of 6.00% senior secured notes due 2031 and another $500 million of 6.40% senior secured notes due 2036. The expected closing date is November 24, 2026,...

Continue Reading
Midea's Cooling Systems Take Center Stage at DCW ME

Updated Category News Views 64

AI Surge Demands Cooler Solutions Alright, who'd guess that data centers would feel the heat—literally—like a welder's furnace in Abu Dhabi? As AI demand burns hotter across the Middle East, data centers are sweating it out against 50°C-plus temperatures. We're talking about some serious pressure on traditional cooling methods that just can’t cut it anymore....

Continue Reading
Bona's 2027 Floorcast Finds Wood and Trust Still Win

Updated Category News Views 202

Floors are turning into a long-game purchase again Gray flooring may be limping toward the exit, but the more important signal in Bona's 2027 Floorcast is that homeowners are thinking less like bargain hunters and more like custodians of an expensive asset. That is a useful read for anybody watching the home-improvement and maintenance landscape. People do not replace a...

Continue Reading
Floating Solar Gets a Serious Test in Central New York

Updated Category News Views 86

A flooded quarry pit outside Cortlandville is getting a second career, and that is more interesting than another solar announcement draped across empty acreage. Third Pillar Power has started construction on Crown City Solar at Suit-Kote Corporation's active Polkville Crushed Stone Facility, pairing a working mine, asphalt plant, and storage terminal with what the...

Continue Reading
Visa Direct Tests Stablecoin Prefunding in Asia-Pacific

Updated Category News Views 41

Cross-border payouts have always had an ugly little problem: money can move digitally in theory, then sit around waiting for banks to wake up in practice. Triple-A’s new collaboration with Visa Direct aims straight at that nuisance in Asia-Pacific, allowing eligible clients to use stablecoins to prefund cross-border payouts while the recipient still gets local currency....

Continue Reading
My Home Delivery's Bold Move in Big & Bulky Sector

Updated Category News Views 177

Redefining Big & Bulky Deliveries with AI Let me tell you, the logistics world isn't for the timid, and My Home Delivery (MHD) is swinging for the fences with their latest tech platform. These folks are rolling out an AI-driven system that promises to turn the bulky goods market on its head. Imagine moving your brand new fridge or that king-size bed across town without...

Continue Reading
Snowhawk Enters Telarus as Digital Demand Gets Serious

Updated Category News Views 84

Telarus just pulled another serious capital partner into the room, and that matters more than the usual law-firm victory lap. Snowhawk Partners has invested in the technology services distributor alongside Columbia Capital, which remains a long-standing partner. Nobody disclosed a valuation, ownership percentage, financing mix, or closing date. Annoying? Sure. But the...

Continue Reading
PSEG Declares $0.67 Fourth-Quarter 2026 Cash Dividend

Updated Category News Views 94

A 67-cent utility dividend rarely sets the tape on fire, and that is precisely the point. Public Service Enterprise Group declared a regular fourth-quarter 2026 common-stock dividend of $0.67 per share, payable on or before December 31 to shareholders of record on December 10. For owners of NYSE:PEG, this is the sort of announcement that belongs in the “steady as she...

Continue Reading
Labcorp's Brazil Trial Push Has Promise and Plenty to Prove

Updated Category News Views 93

Brazilian clinical-trial kit deliveries may soon spend less time tangled in international shipping. That is the practical heart of Labcorp's newly announced collaboration with Grupo Fleury, and frankly, practical is plenty good in this business. Labcorp plans to begin assembling clinical-trial kits locally in Brazil in early 2027, then add laboratory operations by the end...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Hormel Foods Welcomes Debbra Schoneman to Board of Directors

Updated Category News Views 77

Debbra Schoneman Joins Hormel Foods Board of Directors Hormel Foods Corporation (NYSE: HRL), a leader in the global branded food sector, is excited to announce the election of Debbra Schoneman to its Board of Directors. This pivotal decision aligns with the company's ongoing dedication to excellence and innovative leadership. Debbra Schoneman's Background Jim Snee, the...

Continue Reading
Superorganism Secures $25.9M for Biodiversity Ventures

Updated Category News Views 182

Superorganism Secures $25.9M for Biodiversity Ventures Nature and technology fund backed by leading investors aims to redefine how capital advances biodiversity Superorganism, a pioneering venture capital firm focusing on technology solutions for biodiversity, recently announced the successful closure of its debut fund, garnering commitments amounting to $25.9 million....

Continue Reading
Teamsters Local 838 Welcomes First Student Workers in Missouri

Updated Category News Views 174

Teamsters Local 838 Welcomes First Student Workers In a significant development for school transportation workers, more than 100 bus drivers and monitors at First Student in Missouri have united under Teamsters Local 838. This successful vote marks a substantial step in expanding Teamster representation within the school transportation sector, ensuring these workers have...

Continue Reading
Exploring Promising Tech Innovators: Beyond the Giants

Updated Category News Views 121

Understanding the Tech Landscape The technology sector has captured the spotlight as one of the leading areas of growth in recent times. Yet, within this vast landscape, not all players enjoy the same level of success. Many people automatically think of established giants when they hear "tech"—companies often dubbed as the Magnificent Seven, including major players such...

Continue Reading
Highland Copper Innovates with New Drilling and Flotation Tech

Updated Category News Views 112

Highland Copper's New Drilling Program for Metallurgy Highland Copper Company Inc. is taking an exciting step forward with a new drilling program aimed at exploring and optimizing its mining operations. This initiative demonstrates Highland Copper's dedication to utilizing innovative and sustainable mining methods, significantly enhancing its project economics. Focusing...

Continue Reading