Kunstler: Not So Happy Motoring By James Howard

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
SaltyMutt
633
Kunstler: Not So Happy Motoring

By James Howard Kunstler
March 30, 2018

It hasn’t been a great month for America’s electric car fantasy. Elon Musk’s Tesla company — the symbolic beating heart of the fantasy — is whirling around the drain with its share price plummeting 22 percent, its bonds downgraded by Moody’s to junk status, a failure to produce its “affordable” ($36,000 — Ha!) Model 3 at commercial scale, a massive recall of earlier S Model sedans for a steering defect, and the spectacular fiery crash in Silicon Valley last week of an X model that may have been operating in automatic mode (the authorities can’t determine that based on what’s left), and which killed the driver.

Oh, and an experimental self-driving Uber car (Volvo brand) ran over and killed a lady crossing the street with her bicycle in Tempe, Arizona, two weeks ago. Don’t blame Elon for that.

There’s a lot to like about electric cars, of course, if, say, you’re a Google executive floating through life in a techno-narcissism bubble, or a Hollywood actor with wooly grandiose notions of saving the planet while simultaneously signaling your wealth and your “green” virtue cred. Teslas supposedly handle beautifully, ride very quietly, have great low-end power, and decent range of over 200 miles. The engine has something like twenty moving parts, is very long-lasting, and is easy to repair or change out if necessary.

Are they actually “green and clean?” Bwaahaaaaa….! Are you kidding? First, there’s the energy embedded in producing the car: mining and smelting the ores, manufacturing the plastics, running the assembly line, etc. That embedded energy amounts to about 22 percent of the energy consumed by the car over a ten-year lifetime. Then there’s the cost of actually powering the car day-by-day. The electricity around the USA is produced mostly by burning coal, natural gas, or by nuclear fission, all of which produce harmful emissions or byproducts. But the illusion that the power just comes out of a plug in the wall (for just pennies a day!) is a powerful one for the credulous public. The cherry-on-top is the fantasy that before much longer all that electric power will come from “renewables,” solar and wind, and we can leave the whole fossil fuel mess behind us. We say that to ourselves as a sort of prayer, and it has exactly that value.

There are at least a couple of other holes in story, big-picture wise. One is that electric mass motoring — switching out the whole liquid fuel fleet for an all-electric fleet — won’t pencil out economically. We probably started the project forty years too late to even be able to test it at scale, because economic events are now moving so quickly in the direction of global austerity that the putative middle-class customer base for electric cars will barely exist in the near future. Americans especially nowadays are so financially stressed that they can’t qualify for car loans — and that is mainly how cars are bought in this land. The industry has strained mightily to bend the rules so that these days it’s even possible to get a seven-year loan for a used car whose collateral value will dissipate long before the loan is paid back. Hard to see how they can take that much further.

The usual answer for that is that you won’t need to own a car because the nation will be served by self-driving electric Uber-style cars-on-demand, which will supposedly require far fewer cars in all. That really doesn’t answer some big questions, such as: how might commuting work in our big metroplex cities? Even if you posit multiple occupancy vehicles, it still represents a whole lot of car trips. Oh, you say, everybody will just work from home. Really? I don’t think so — though I wouldn’t rule out an end to corporate organization of work as we’ve known it, and if that happens, we will be a nation of farmers and artisans again, that is, a World Made By Hand. Also consider, if the car companies only need to make and sell a fraction of the vehicles they sell now, the whole industry will collapse.

Another hole in the story is the universal assumption that the USA must remain a land of mandatory car dependency, hostage to the fiasco of our suburban infrastructure. I understand why we’re attached to it. We spent most of the 20th century building all that shit, and squandered most our wealth on it. It’s comfortably familiar, even if it’s actually a miserable environment for everyday life. But none of those monetary and psychological investments negate the fact that suburbia has outlived its limited and rather perverse usefulness.

We’re so far from having any intelligent public debate about these issues that the events now spooling out will completely blindside the nation.

Support this website by visiting Jim’s Patreon Page! https://tinyurl.com/ycozs4rm

http://kunstler.com/clusterfuck-nation/not-happy-motoring/
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Avelo Tests Loyalty Math With WeSalute Fare Discounts

Updated Category News Views 237

Airline discounts can look like generosity until the load factor starts talking back. Avelo Airlines has joined WeSalute with fare discounts for active-duty military members, veterans, first responders, nurses, medical professionals, public servants, teachers and eligible family members. It is a sensible move for a young carrier built around smaller airports and lower...

Continue Reading
ZTO's Pricing Muscle Shows Up in Third-Quarter Results

Updated Category News Views 136

Ten billion parcels can hide plenty of ugly economics, but ZTO's third quarter does not look like a volume-at-any-cost stunt. The company moved 10.241 billion parcels, up 7.0% from a year earlier, and says that outpaced the industry by 4.1 percentage points. More importantly, revenue climbed 21.0% to RMB14.36 billion while adjusted net income reached RMB2.57 billion. That...

Continue Reading
GALLS Honors Service With Lexington Hall of Fame Wall

Updated Category News Views 86

A headquarters wall can say more about a company than another polished mission statement ever will. On November 17, 2026, GALLS® unveiled the National Law Enforcement Officer Hall of Fame Wall at its Lexington, Kentucky, corporate headquarters, displaying portraits of every past inductee into the National Law Enforcement Officer Hall of Fame. Recognition, made permanent...

Continue Reading
Floating Solar Gets a Serious Test in Central New York

Updated Category News Views 86

A flooded quarry pit outside Cortlandville is getting a second career, and that is more interesting than another solar announcement draped across empty acreage. Third Pillar Power has started construction on Crown City Solar at Suit-Kote Corporation's active Polkville Crushed Stone Facility, pairing a working mine, asphalt plant, and storage terminal with what the...

Continue Reading
Exiger's CEO Honored for Military Support Excellence

Updated Category News Views 58

Recognizing Civilian and Military Leadership When you hear "recognition in the military sector," it isn't just a pat on the back. It's a whole parade of brass hats and high-flyers giving their nods. So, November 10th wasn't just any regular day—Brandon Daniels, CEO of Exiger, gets a shiny, prestigious Five-Star Award for his "extraordinary support" of our military...

Continue Reading
Sola's 11-Step Push Makes Salon Ownership Less Blind

Updated Category News Views 115

A pristine studio does not pay rent by itself. That is the uncomfortable little truth sitting underneath Sola Salons’ new 11-step roadmap for beauty professionals considering salon-suite ownership. The company is telling stylists, estheticians, nail technicians, massage therapists, and other independent operators to treat the move from commission work to ownership like...

Continue Reading
STORMER LAT Targets Sewer Crews' Costly Access Delays

Updated Category News Views 32

A buried cleanout can turn a simple sewer inspection into a scheduling circus. That unglamorous headache is exactly where FIBERSCOPE is aiming its new STORMER LAT Lateral Launch Camera System, announced November 17, 2026. This is not some flashy consumer gadget hunting for attention; it is field equipment built around a painfully ordinary municipal problem: crews often...

Continue Reading
Voltage Energy's Microgrid Launches at RE+ 2026

Updated Category News Views 147

Voltage Energy Unveils New Power Systems In the swirling chaos of energy innovation, Voltage Energy is trying to carve its path at the heart of RE+ 2026. Out in Las Vegas, amidst the buzz of renewable energy tech, they introduced their Microgrid System (MGS) along with two new electrical balance of system (EBOS) products—the Load Break Disconnect Box (LBD) and Combiner...

Continue Reading
Stand Out For Good Makes a Bold Michigan Avenue Bet

Updated Category News Views 183

A six-floor retail commitment lands with a thud Stand Out For Good is taking on roughly 51,079 square feet at 669 North Michigan Avenue, and nobody should mistake that for a casual expansion. Six levels on Chicago's Magnificent Mile is a proper declaration of intent, especially in a retail district that has endured plenty of empty-window handwringing and big-brand churn....

Continue Reading
Medical School Rejections Carry a Steep Price Tag Too

Updated Category News Views 107

A rejection letter can turn into a remarkably expensive piece of paper. BeMo Academic Consulting's new Medical School Admissions Trends Report argues that the damage from missing medical-school admission goes far beyond bruised confidence: applicants can spend thousands chasing another cycle, lose time entering practice, and, if they never get in, forgo what the report...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Coway's Inverter Dehumidifier 23L Triumphs at Global Design Awards

Updated Category News Views 208

Inverter Dehumidifier 23L Wins Recognition at Good Design Awards - The Inverter Dehumidifier 23L gains accolades for its compact design and user-friendly features at the Good Design Awards 2025. - This recent achievement cements Coway's status as a leading player in global design, recognized by all four major awards this year. Coway's Prestigious Award Recognition Hosted...

Continue Reading
Veru's Enobosarm & Semaglutide: A New Era in Weight Loss Safety

Updated Category News Views 314

Positive Safety Profile from Veru's Clinical Study Veru Inc. (NASDAQ: VERU), a trailblazer in biopharmaceuticals, recently revealed exciting topline safety results from its Phase 2b QUALITY clinical study. This trial examined the combination of enobosarm and semaglutide, uncovering significant advantages in safety and efficacy compared to semaglutide alone. Understanding...

Continue Reading
How a $1000 Investment in REV Group Can Grow Over Time

Updated Category News Views 180

Understanding REV Group's Market Performance REV Group (NYSE: REVG) has demonstrated impressive performance in the stock market over the past five years. This company has not only outperformed the broader market, but it has done so by a remarkable 29.45% on an annualized basis, resulting in an average annual return of 42.83%. With a market capitalization reaching...

Continue Reading
Castellum's GTMR Achieves Key CMMI Level 3 Milestone

Updated Category News Views 172

Castellum's GTMR Achieves Key CMMI Level 3 Milestone Castellum, Inc. (NYSE-American: CTM) has exciting news to share, as it announces its subsidiary, Global Technology and Management Resources, Inc. (GTMR), has achieved a significant milestone by obtaining a Level 3 appraisal under ISACA’s Capability Maturity Model Integration (CMMI). This recognition highlights GTMR's...

Continue Reading
Discovering Nature Close Up: The MicroCam X1 Launch

Updated Category News Views 162

Introducing the MicroCam X1 by Littpopo Littpopo, an innovative brand dedicated to exploration technology, has launched the MicroCam X1, a remarkable pocket microscope camera now live on a crowdfunding platform. This unique device combines a powerful 400X microscope with a 4K camera, making it an essential tool for educators, content creators, families, and adventurers...

Continue Reading