WashPost ‘Fact Checker’ Hides Crime by Illegal

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone
253
WashPost ‘Fact Checker’ Hides Crime by Illegal Immigrants

< >

The Washington Post‘s deputy “Fact Checker” has retreated from his strange claim that President Donald Trump’s comments on illegal-immigrant crime are misleading because crime by the combined population of illegal and legal immigrants is apparently low.
“Fact Checker” Salvador Rizzo wrote March 15 that:

President Trump has a habit of linking undocumented immigrants to grisly crimes when, in fact, most of the available data and research say immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than the U.S.-born population.

Based on that lede, Rizzo ended his column by saying:

This is another example of Trump cherry-picking a few cases to sell a grand — and misleading — narrative about immigrants and crime. Every demographic group has its share of criminals, but the research shows that immigrants commit crimes at a lower rate than the U.S.-born population.

For feeding this misleading narrative, Trump earns Four Pinocchios.

Reader objections forced him to beat a quick retreat. Via Twitter, Rizzo quickly admitted the distinction between legal and illegal immigrants:

Seeing a lot of, “Oh, you’re conflating legal and illegal immigrant crime data!” No nationwide data to support Trump’s claims as to illegal immigration, and most of the research says all immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than the native-born.

Trump's fireside chats are much more ... vivid than FDR's. The latest one on sanctuary cities gets Four Pinocchios. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-chec...ry-cities/

No nationwide data to support Trump's claims as to illegal immigration, and most of the research says all immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than the native-born.https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2018/01/18/trumps-claim-that-immigrants-bring-tremendous-crime-is-still-wrong/ ….

In a January Fact Checker article, the Washington Post author did the same trick of conflating crimes by illegal migrants and crime by legal immigrants to slam Trump’s criticism of crime by illegals — even as he also praised Trump for not conflating the two categories:

When we fact-checked him as a candidate in 2015, Trump spoke of immigrants generally and without distinguishing between legal and unauthorized residents. But in his most recent statements on Dec. 6, the president narrowed it down to “illegal immigrants … bringing with them crime, tremendous amounts of crime.” …

The majority of the research available on this question continues to show that immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than the native-born and that overall crime rates decline in areas where immigrants settle.

After his March column appeared, March, Rizzo responded to questions from Breitbart News by simply denying that he had commingled the two categories of immigrants:

We did not. We accurately restated our finding from the previous fact-check that most research shows crime is lower among legal/illegal immigrants.

But his March “Fact Checker” lede does conflate the population of legal immigrants and of illegal migrants:

President Trump has a habit of linking undocumented immigrants to grisly crimes when, in fact, most of the available data and research say immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than the U.S.-born population.

Rizzo has a second line of defense. He argues that his March “Fact Checker” article is OK because it “focused on violent crimes because that was the subject of the president’s remarks.”

Trump’s remarks did focus on violent crime, but he also began his remarks by talking about all crime by illegals:

Protecting the safety and well-being of American Citizens is my highest duty as President. Yet, lawless sanctuary jurisdictions are nullifying federal law, obstructing immigration enforcement, and releasing thousands of criminal aliens into U.S. communities to prey on innocent victims. It’s absolutely terrible.

Rizzo’s “violent crime” sidestep is hidden in the article, which does not say that the WashPo is excluding analysis of the non-violent legal violations and crime committed by illegals. Those violations and crimes include being in the country illegally, using other people’s Social Security Numbers, or working illegally — often for wages below what Americans need for a decent life.

Rizzo does this violent-crime sidestep multiple times in the March article to help him criticize Trump’s comments about all crime by illegals. Here’s one example:

“California’s leaders are in open defiance of federal law,” Trump said in his weekly address. “They don’t care about crime. They don’t care about death and killings. They don’t care about robberies.”

The president paints a menacing picture, but the bottom line is that there is no evidence any of the seven individuals he mentions committed a violent crime while ICE was searching for them. The White House said their release by local authorities meant “more crimes being committed,” but the information they provided does not bear that out for violent crimes.

Rizzo’s third line of defense is that Trump supposedly is misleading the public because he does not have good data from federal and state authorities to support his statements about crime by illegal immigrants. But there is plenty of evidence in the poor federal data, from common sense and from good data in Arizona that crime by illegals is much higher than crime by native-born Americans.

In Arizona, the state tracked the native or illegal status of criminals as they were jailed. Researcher John Lott used the data to show that illegals committed more than twice as much crime per person as similar-aged native-born Americans, and that legal immigrants have a low crime rate.

In January, Rizzo tried to dismiss Lott’s Arizona report by saying it is unique and yet also an “outlier” among other reports. Rizzo downplayed the Arizona report, he told Breitbart News, because the pro-migration Cato Institute “has called [the report’s] methodology into question.”

The Cato Institute declared:

According to Lott, the data allowed [Lott] to identify “whether they [the prisoners] are illegal or legal residents.” This is where Lott made his small error: The dataset does not allow him or anybody else to identify illegal immigrants …

Lott erroneously assumed that the third category, called “non-US citizen and deportable,” only counted illegal immigrants. That is not true, non-US citizen and deportable immigrants are not all illegal immigrants.

Lott’s Crime Prevention Research Center responded to Cato in February:

This is wrong. The category “non-US citizen, deportable” only includes illegal immigrants. We followed the guidance given to us on how to separate these groups out as given to us by the Arizona County Attorneys’ Association, particularly Bill Montgomery, who represented the association and is the DA for Maricopa County, which has about 60% of Arizona’s population. He told us that a pre-sentencing report is used to determine citizenship.

Fourthly, Rizzo’s “Four Pinocchios” claim implies that the president — and the public — should wait for perfect data before making any conclusions about crime by illegals.

But this is a political demand for progressive rule by experts or judges because it denies Americans the right to make a reasonable and conditional judgment — outside the courtroom, amid imperfect information — that young male migrants from some of the most violent countries on Earth should be viewed as more violent than Americans.

A 2013 report by the United Nations showed the murder rates in the largest cities of the migrants’ home countries;

So Rizzo is throwing “Four Pinocchios” at Trump’s comments about crime by illegals — even though Rizzo is improperly conflating crimes by illegals and legals, hiding many non-violent crimes committed by illegals, dodging Lott’s data, and issuing a fatwa on common sense. Why is Rizzo trying to do all of this under the supposed authority of a mere Washington Post “Fact Checker”?

When asked by Breitbart News “Do you wish to minimize barriers against the movement of foreign people into the United States?” Rizzo replied, “The Fact Checker takes no position on the matter.” Americans’ common sense says otherwise.
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Terminus Ballet: A Decade of Defying Dance Norms

Updated Category News Views 135

A Dance Company's Journey of Transformation An anniversary represents more than just a celebration; it's a reminder of the road traveled. On Jan. 30, 2027, Terminus Modern Ballet Theatre will mark its 10th anniversary, encapsulating a decade of defiance against the staid conventions binding classical ballet. This isn't just about pirouettes and pliés—it's dance with a...

Continue Reading
Bacterial Breakthrough in Cancer Therapy: Game Changer?

Updated Category News Views 35

Blurring Lines Between Bugs and Biotech Well, wouldn't you know it, the eggheads over at Jeonbuk National University in South Korea are at it again, pushing the boundaries of what these little bacterial buggers can do. This time, they’ve had a crack at cancer therapy, using engineered Salmonella to pack a double punch against breast cancer in mice. Now, if that ain't...

Continue Reading
Lennar Faces Securities Fraud Lawsuit: Investor Insights

Updated Category News Views 20

Investors in Lennar: Navigating the Legal Storm Hold onto your hats, folks. Lennar Corporation (NYSE: LEN) is up against it with a brand-spanking-new securities fraud lawsuit helmed by Schall, Brown & Schwartz LLP (SBS). This isn't just a couple of investors grumbling over cocktails; it’s a full-blown class action that’s waving the legal banner under the Securities...

Continue Reading
Nauticus Robotics Dive into Defense & UAE Moves

Updated Category News Views 78

Charting New Waters: Defense and UAE Focus Looking at Nauticus Robotics lately, it feels like they're finally getting the hang of balancing their defense play and UAE expansions. This quarter they're coming out swinging, dropping some fine numbers mixed with a slew of strategic moves that got me thinking twice about their place in the subsea robotics world. Financial...

Continue Reading
Tenax Therapeutics Facing Class Action: DEC 28 Deadline

Updated Category News Views 70

Legal Storm Over Tenax Therapeutics Just what the doctor didn't order—legal headaches for Tenax Therapeutics, Inc. (NASDAQ:TENX). Yup, folks, buckle up because we're diving into another class action mudslinging match that’s setting the markets wagging. Berger Montague's law trebuchet is aimed squarely at Tenax and every investor should know the target’s outline....

Continue Reading
Graphic Packaging Shakes Up Leadership and Supply Chain

Updated Category News Views 29

New Leadership Takes the Helm at Graphic Packaging What do you do when you want to streamline an operation that spans continents? Well, if you're Graphic Packaging Holding Company (NYSE: GPK), you bring in fresh leadership to serenade the chaos into a well-oiled machine. Starting December 1, 2026, D. Keith Hamilton will be sinking his teeth into North America Mills &...

Continue Reading
Akeso's Gumokimab Wins NMPA Approval for AS Treatment

Updated Category News Views 194

Gumokimab Approved: A New Dawn in AS Treatment Yeah, the biotech world shifts gears today as Akeso's gumokimab received the green light from China's National Medical Products Administration (NMPA). This approval for treating ankylosing spondylitis, or AS, isn't just another checkbox for Akeso; it's a game-changer in tackling this chronic inflammatory disease. Why should...

Continue Reading
Sasol AGM Resolutions Passed in One Swift Swing

Updated Category News Views 119

Sasol's AGM Delivers Smooth Sailing for Shareholders Can't say I'm surprised, but Sasol's annual general meeting on the 13th of November went off without a hitch—unless, of course, you're one of those folks who just loves fireworks at these gatherings. The entire set of resolutions danced through with a resounding "Aye," making it one heck of a day for anyone banking on...

Continue Reading
ROBOTERA Debuts XHAND 1 Pro-U in NVIDIA Demo

Updated Category News Views 117

ROBOTERA Steps Up with XHAND 1 Pro-U Move over, traditional robotics; ROBOTERA is here to shake things up with their latest marvel, the XHAND 1 Pro-U. This futuristic gadget isn't just making waves at the Conference on Robot Learning (CoRL) where Jim Fan of NVIDIA spotlighted it in his GR00T 2 demo, it's setting a new bar for robotic dexterity. Hand in Glove with Human...

Continue Reading
Saint Luis Rey Launches Exclusive Palatinos Vitola

Updated Category News Views 59

New Beginnings for the Saint Luis Rey Brand You think you've seen it all in the cigar world, but then comes a debut like this that lights a fire under the lush tradition of Cuba. Enter Saint Luis Rey's new Palatinos vitola, a blend wrapped in the mystique of exclusivity for La Casa del Habano and Habanos Specialists. Whether you're a seasoned connoisseur or just dipping...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Navigating the Rising Tide of AI-Driven Cyber Threats

Updated Category News Views 118

The Evolving Landscape of Cyber Threats In today's world, artificial intelligence is rapidly changing the nature of cyber threats. Recent studies reveal that a significant number of companies have encountered AI-driven cyberattacks, highlighting a critical gap in their defense strategies. Despite this alarming trend, many organizations are yet to fully embrace AI in their...

Continue Reading
Insight into the Bullish Movements Surrounding DPZ Stock

Updated Category News Views 58

Understanding the Options Dynamics for Domino's Pizza Investors are expressing a clear bullish sentiment towards Domino's Pizza as evident from the recent options market activities. Analyzing the options history for Domino's Pizza (DPZ), we found a total of 10 significant trades. These trades reveal that approximately 50% of traders leaned towards bullish strategies while...

Continue Reading
PDD Holdings Faces Legal Challenges Over Securities Violations

Updated Category News Views 230

PDD Holdings Faces Legal Challenges Over Securities Violations PDD Holdings, Inc. is currently facing a major class action lawsuit. This legal action stems from accusations that the company misled investors about potential compromises to its applications, raising serious concerns about user privacy, particularly regarding unauthorized access to private messages. Details...

Continue Reading
Significant Shareholder Announcement for Kenmare Resources

Updated Category News Views 98

Major Holdings Notification for Kenmare Resources Plc Understanding the dynamics of major shareholdings is essential for investors and stakeholders alike. Kenmare Resources Plc has recently updated the market regarding key holdings that affect its share structure. The notification process is transparent, with clear communication ensuring that all relevant details are...

Continue Reading
Exploring High-Yield Dividend Stocks for Income Investors

Updated Category News Views 65

Dive into Dividend Investing Dividend investing is often overlooked, especially in an era dominated by the latest advancements in technology and artificial intelligence. While the allure of tech growth may be tempting, savvy investors understand the enduring value of reliable income-generating stocks. The world of dividend stocks is vast, and their potential for...

Continue Reading