I love it when an antivax “study” meant to show how

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (2) Message Board
Bhawks wowhappens28 #9322
181
Quote:
I love it when an antivax “study” meant to show how “dirty” vaccines are backfires so spectacularly

Orac February 2, 2017 396 Comments


Quote:
Let me repeat for emphasis. The investigators think that what they found is that vaccines are contaminated with all sorts of inorganic metals. What they really found is that the amount of inorganic contamination is so low as to be biologically irrelevant. In fact, what they found is that vaccines are incredibly pure products.

https://respectfulinsolence.com/2017/02/02/an...amination/

And I didn’t even get into a very good question that our scaly friend asked: What were the controls? What would you find if you carried out the same analyses on tap water, for instance? It could very well be that syringe used to draw up and deposit the specimen could be the source of the “contamination.” Hell, it could just as easily be the cellulose matrix on which the specimens are deposited for analysis that were responsible for the “contamination.” I’m familiar with those filters, as they are commonly used in molecular biology. They are not ultra-pure. How were they stored? Often filters can pick up dust from the air. Whatever the source of the particles observed, without controls, there’s no way of knowing if the source was the vaccines or not. It could be that vaccines are even more pure than this study shows!

Now, knowing this, go and read the discussion and conclusion of this paper. You will laugh, and you should laugh. The investigators deserve nothing but mockery for this idiocy, such as:


We come across particles with chemical compositions, similar to those found in the vaccines we analyzed, when we study cases of environmental contamination caused by different pollution sources. In most circumstances, the combinations detected are very odd as they have no technical use, cannot be found in any material handbook and look like the result of the random formation occurring, for example, when waste is burnt. In any case, whatever their origin, they should not be present in any injectable medicament, let alone in vaccines, more in particular those meant for infants.

Other forms of so-far unknown contaminations have recently been observed and, in any case, vaccines contain components that could themselves be the cause of adverse effects. It is a well-known fact in toxicology that contaminants exert a mutual, synergic effect, and as the number of contaminants increases, the effects grow less and less predictable. The more so when some substances are unknown.
“
Yes, laugh, because what Gatti and Montanari actually showed is that the level of inorganic contamination in vaccines is minuscule, suggesting that the manufacturing processes used to make them are very, very good at making sure that vaccines are pure, given that none of the vaccines contained more inorganic particles at a concentration higher than 0.15 femtomolar. But also get angry at the deception and cry that there will be parents taken in by this ridiculous paper, as groups like CSMRI spread it far and wide with terrifying language about “contamination.”

Given that the CMSRI’s scientific advisory board includes antivaccine “scientists” like Christopher Shaw, Yehuda Shoenfeld, Richard Deth, Stephanie Seneff, and Vicky Debold, along with some others I’m not familiar with, it’s not at all surprising that CMSRI loves it. It also amuses me to no end that the “scientific board” didn’t see the obvious problems with this paper.

That’s because it’s all about antivaccine fear mongering, not science.

396 Comments


Chris Hickie February 2, 2017 at 7:53 am

A drop of about 20 microliter of vaccine is released from the syringe on a 25-mm-diameter cellulose filter (Millipore, USA), inside a flow cabinet. The filter is then deposited on an Aluminum stub covered with an adhesive carbon disc. The sample is immediately put inside a clean box in order to avoid any contamination…

…except you’ve drawn it up into a syringe and then put it through a filter, both of which were not controlled for in this “analysis”, as you’ve noted.

Looking at the standards for reagent water purity (and I will preface with stating I trained undergrad as a physicist, so things didn’t get much more complicated for me than hydrogen and, rarely helium), there are standards for purity per ASTM D1193-06. Given that the highest level of purity (ASTM Type 1) allows 50 mcg/L of TOC (total organic carbon) and 1 mgc/L each of sodium and chloride (as well as 3 mcg/L of silica), it does sound like vaccines they looked at were, as you note, incredibly pure.

What a worthless journal the “International Journal of Vaccines and Vaccination” must be to have accepted this rot.


Dangerous Bacon February 2, 2017 at 7:58 am

“Looking at the area outside these precipitates but inside the liquid drop, we identified other things:”

I love it when they talk all technical-like.

I nominate this one for Italian Science Paper of the Year.


Eric Lund February 2, 2017 at 9:04 am

I’d be willing to bet that, if somebody were to use the same protocol to analyze homeopathic remedies, they would find similar or higher amounts of “contaminants”. Because as mentioned above, there were no control samples on things like distilled water. And as I’ve mentioned before, there are limits on how pure distilled water can be made.

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Tim Hortons Bets on ELF Cheer for U.S. Holiday Visits

Updated Category News Views 15

Nothing says holiday restaurant marketing quite like putting spaghetti-shaped whipped topping on hot chocolate and trusting a 2003 movie to do the selling. Tim Hortons is rolling out an ELF-inspired menu at participating U.S. locations starting November 18, 2026, pairing the chain with Warner Bros. Consumer Products and mining Buddy the Elf's sugar-fueled world for a...

Continue Reading
MetaComp Targets ASEAN's Cross-Border Payment Snarl

Updated Category News Views 53

ASEAN payment plumbing is still a patchwork, and MetaComp is betting that patchwork has finally become painful enough to fix. The Singapore-based payments firm says its StableX Agentic Network has topped 1,000 members and reaches more than 100,000 users in its first year. That is a respectable early footprint, not a victory lap. Cross-border payments are littered with...

Continue Reading
A Faded Sign Is a Quiet Leak in Storefront Demand Today

Updated Category News Views 95

Sunlight does not care what the marketing budget said. A storefront can have a decent product, a clean interior and a capable crew, then lose the first impression before anyone reaches the door because its sign looks tired. That is the plainspoken point behind FASTSIGNS' latest guidance on outdoor sign lifespan. This is not glamorous stuff, but it is operationally...

Continue Reading
A €18 Million Mecca Chandelier Tests Austrian Craft

Updated Category News Views 103

Scale Is Easy to Boast About, Delivery Is Not A 34.1-metre chandelier hanging in Mecca is the sort of job that makes ordinary project talk sound downright silly. Lights of Vienna says it designed, built, tested, shipped and installed this monster for the Grand Mosque's Shamiya area, with a contract value of roughly €18 million. That is a serious piece of work for a...

Continue Reading
Sinopec’s Algerian Outreach Reveals a Patient Long Game

Updated Category News Views 20

Soft Power Does Not Run a Refinery, but It Matters A short video contest in Algiers will not move an oilfield schedule or settle a hydrocarbons negotiation. That is precisely why this Sinopec-backed event deserves a sober look rather than a chest-thumping one. On Nov. 15, Sinopec Group and the Chinese Embassy in Algeria co-hosted the final of their second youth cultural...

Continue Reading
Linkind's Best Buy Push Tests Smart Outdoor Demand

Updated Category News Views 62

Holiday lights have quietly become a year-round hardware category, and Linkind wants a louder seat at the table. The smart-lighting brand says three outdoor products have been in Best Buy stores across the United States since October 17, 2026: permanent exterior lights, decorative string lights, and solar pathway lights. That is a real distribution step, not some grand...

Continue Reading
Sunbit’s 2027 Loan Push Meets an NVIDIA-Fueled Tape

Updated Category News Views 0

Credit Is About to Enter Sunbit’s Growth Story Sunbit has spent years building a point-of-sale fintech footprint, and the numbers it cited on November 18 make the next step harder to dismiss as mere marketing fluff. The company says it has topped 400,000 activated cardholders and 50,000 merchants, while expecting more than $440 million in fiscal 2026 sales on greater...

Continue Reading
Nellie's 50% Booking Jump Reveals a Quieter Luxury

Updated Category News Views 6

Silicon Valley’s rich are apparently tired of performing wealth for strangers, and frankly, that tracks. Nellie’s 2027 forecast says its mostly tech-money clientele is moving past the old trophy case of private jets, famous resort towns, and suites priced like small houses. The prize now is privacy, a clean schedule, and somebody competent fixing the ugly little...

Continue Reading
Hanon's BMW Thermal Win Matters Beyond the Trophy Case Today

Updated Category News Views 96

A 16-Kilogram Box Just Grabbed the Auto Supply Chain’s Attention Hanon Systems did not win these two 2026 PACE honors by polishing up some old hose-and-valve package. Its Highly Integrated Cooling Entity, or HICE, is aimed right at a stubborn electric-vehicle problem: keeping a vehicle’s thermal systems controlled without turning the architecture into a sprawling,...

Continue Reading
LG Channels UAE Push Tests the Free Streaming Model

Updated Category News Views 42

A television's idle screen is turning into contested real estate in the UAE. LG Channels is adding programming from Rakuten TV, Stingray and Red Bull TV to its free, ad-supported service, and that matters for more than somebody hunting a movie after dinner. This is a practical push to make webOS-powered screens more useful, more frequently used and, eventually, more...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Desreta Jackson's New Show: A Journey of Healing and Legacy

Updated Category News Views 551

Desreta Jackson Unveils Groundbreaking Show This Fall Desreta Jackson, who captivated audiences through her memorable role as young Celie in Steven Spielberg's acclaimed film The Color Purple, is set to make her return to the limelight with the launch of The Desreta Jackson Show this fall. Produced by Desicon Pictures, the show seeks to ignite meaningful conversations...

Continue Reading
Clarios Unveils Ambitious Initiative to Transform U.S. Manufacturing

Updated Category News Views 354

Clarios Set to Revolutionize U.S. Manufacturing Landscape Clarios is embarking on an exciting journey to bolster American manufacturing, with plans to establish a cutting-edge technology campus focusing on advanced supercapacitor systems production. This initiative is part of a comprehensive $6 billion investment strategy aimed at strengthening domestic supply chains....

Continue Reading
Franchise Equity Partners Expands with Strategic Valvoline Deal

Updated Category News Views 274

Franchise Equity Partners Forms Strategic Partnership with Valvoline Franchise Equity Partners (FEP) is thrilled to announce a new strategic partnership with Valvoline Inc. This collaboration marks a significant milestone as FEP plans to acquire 38 Valvoline company-owned stores. The stores, located in various regions of Texas, will be transitioning to a newly established...

Continue Reading
New Found Gold Announces Successful Financing Round Closing

Updated Category News Views 183

Recent Financing Success of New Found Gold New Found Gold Corp. (TSXV: NFG) (NYSE-A: NFGC) is excited to share the successful closing of its second and final tranche in the bought deal financing, securing a remarkable C$63 million to advance its projects. This milestone marks a significant achievement for the Company, facilitating crucial developments in the exploration...

Continue Reading
Joby Aviation Surpasses Expectations in Q3 Financials

Updated Category News Views 194

Joby Aviation's Remarkable Growth in Q3 Joby Aviation, Inc. (NYSE: JOBY) has recently experienced a substantial surge in stock value, reflecting investor confidence following the release of its third-quarter earnings report. This report highlighted significant movements, particularly as it beat estimates on revenue, even though it faced a mixed assessment regarding its...

Continue Reading