Interesting Read...... Fed. Circ. Finds Another Alice

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (2) Message Board
CyberC
491
Interesting Read......


Fed. Circ. Finds Another Alice Ruling Came Too Soon
Share us on: By Ryan Davis

Law360 (February 14, 2018, 7:22 PM EST) -- The Federal Circuit faulted a lower court Wednesday for invalidating data manipulation patents as abstract ideas on a motion to dismiss, the second time in days the court has held that a judge too quickly found that patents failed the U.S. Supreme Court’s Alice test.

As it did in a different case on Feb. 8, the Federal Circuit ruled that there were factual disputes about whether two Aatrix Software Inc. patents claim patent-ineligible subject matter, so Judge Harvey E. Schlesinger of the Middle District of Florida was wrong to dismiss the company’s suit against Green Shades Software Inc.

The appeals court held 2-1 that in addition to incorrectly finding that every claim of the two patents covered only the abstract idea of collecting and organizing data, the judge also should not have denied Aatrix’s motion to file an amended complaint the company said would show that the patents contained something more than conventional activities and were thus not abstract.

"These allegations, if accepted as true, contradict the district court’s conclusion that the claimed combination was conventional or routine," the Federal Circuit said. "Therefore, it was an abuse of discretion for the district court to deny leave to amend."

The ruling follows the same reasoning in last week’s Berkheimer v. HP Inc. decision, in which the appeals court said a judge wrongly granted summary judgment finding a patent ran afoul of the high court’s Alice holding that abstract ideas implemented on a computer are not patent-eligible under Section 101 of the Patent Act.

The Berkheimer ruling was the first time the appeals court expressly held that evaluating the validity of patents under Alice involves factual questions about whether a patent contains inventive components that make it patent-eligible. According to experts, that could make it much tougher for an accused infringer to invalidate patents under Alice early in a case.

The high court held that patents are invalid if they cover abstract ideas and do not transform them into something more than "well understood, routine and conventional activities previously known to the industry." The Federal Circuit has now twice emphasized that what is routine and conventional is a factual issue that often cannot be decided on summary judgment or motions to dismiss.

The court said Wednesday that the allegations in Aatrix’s 55-page amended complaint, which is 50 pages longer than its initial complaint, “suggest that the claimed invention is directed to an improvement in the computer technology itself and not directed to generic components performing conventional activities.”

The case began in February 2015, when Aatrix, a North Dakota-based company that makes accounting software, filed suit alleging that Florida-based Green Shades' Tax Filing Center software infringed its patents. The case was dismissed just over a year later.

Both the Berkheimer and Aatrix decisions were written by Judge Kimberly Moore and joined by Judge Richard Taranto. While the Berkhimer decision was unanimous, with Judge Kara Farnandez Stoll also on the panel, Judge Jimmie Reyna wrote a strong dissent in the Aatrix case saying he disagreed with "the majority's broad statements on the role of factual evidence" in the patent-eligibility analysis.

"Our precedent is clear that the Section 101 inquiry is a legal question," he said. "In a manner contrary to that standard, the majority opinion attempts to shoehorn a significant factual component into the Alice Section 101 analysis."

Making patent-eligibility a factual inquiry opens the door to "the introduction of an inexhaustible array of extrinsic evidence, such as prior art, publications, other patents and expert opinion," which "would turn the utility of the [motion to dismiss] procedure on its head," he said.

"This contradicts our case law that patent ineligibility under Section 101 is a question of law, and that it can be appropriately decided on a motion to dismiss," he said.

John Lunseth of Briggs & Morgan PA, an attorney for Aatrix, said the majority's holding "is a breath of fresh air in the law as applied following the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Alice."

"The courts were, in too many cases, simply picking up and reading the patent, and with no or very limited factual information, deciding a particular software patent was patent-ineligible," he said. "We are gratified to see that there is a trend to return to the very long-standing law that ... dismissal is not appropriate where there are material issues of fact."

Joseph Bain of Shutts & Bowen LLP, an attorney for Green Shades, said the ruling is only procedural and did not address the merits, adding that the company believes it will prevail when the case returns to district court.

"Now that we know crystal-clear what Aatrix thinks the inventive concepts are, we will be able to show that they are routine and conventional on remand," he said.

Matthew Rizzolo of Ropes & Gray LLP, who is not involved in the case but follows the Federal Circuit's eligibility rulings, said Judge Reyna’s dissent and the potential of the rulings to impact a large number of cases make it likely the court will be asked to review this issue en banc.

“This decision combined with Berkheimer, if they hold, constitute a pretty high bar for 101 challenges at the outset of cases,” he said.

He noted that the new difficulties accused infringers will face in quickly getting patents invalidated under Alice in court could prompt more of them to make Section 101 challenges using the America Invents Act’s covered business method review program if their motions to dismiss are denied.

The patents-in-suit are U.S. Patent Numbers 7,171,615 and 8,984,393.

Judges Kimberly Moore, Richard Taranto and Jimmie Reyna sat on the panel for the Federal Circuit.

Aatrix is represented John Lunseth II of Briggs & Morgan PA.

Green Shades is represented by Joseph Bain and Harold Gillis of Shutts & Bowen LLP.

The case is Aatrix Software Inc. v. Green Shades Software Inc., case number 2017-1452, in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.

--Editing by Aaron Pelc.
0 Comments

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Peñoles Locks In Solar Storage for Northern Mine Loads

Updated Category News Views 33

A mine never sleeps, which is why the battery matters more than the solar-panel headline. Peñoles has signed a 20-year power-supply agreement with Atlas Renewable Energy for a Coahuila project combining 269 MWp of solar generation with battery storage. The project is slated to begin operating in the first half of 2029 and is expected to provide roughly 550 GWh a year to...

Continue Reading
Tonum and Euvita Link Supplements to Personalized Care

Updated Category News Views 14

Muscle loss has become the awkward footnote in the GLP-1 weight-loss boom, and Tonum Health is trying to put that concern nearer the center of the care conversation. Its newly announced partnership with euvita health places Tonum's supplements and functional nutrition products inside a physician-led platform built around biomarker testing, hormone and peptide therapy,...

Continue Reading
Blue Diamond's $1 Billion Brand Meets Farm Realities

Updated Category News Views 76

A Ten-Cent Signal Carries Real Weight A ten-cent edge over the industry benchmark may not excite the cocktail-party crowd, but almond growers notice every penny when fertilizer, power and pest control keep gnawing at the farm gate. Blue Diamond Growers says it delivered payments roughly 10 cents above the benchmark in its latest year, alongside net profit that came in...

Continue Reading
Italian Wine Faces U.S. Slump and New Market Openings

Updated Category News Views 110

American demand has put a cork in the easy story, and Italian wine producers cannot pretend otherwise. In the first nine months of 2026, U.S. imports of Italian wine dropped 18.4% by value. That is painful because the United States remains Italy's largest destination market by value, not some side shelf that can be ignored until conditions improve. Still, the broader U.S....

Continue Reading
Dario’s Second Women’s Health Win Tests Expansion Case

Updated Category News Views 71

Midlife care just became the newest proving ground for DarioHealth’s sales pitch. The company says The Minnesota Star Tribune has expanded its existing relationship to include Dario Women™, a program for employees navigating perimenopause and menopause. Eligible employees are expected to gain access in January 2027. For NASDAQ:DRIO, this is not some grand revenue...

Continue Reading
Hone Health’s $228M Bet on Data-Led Longevity Care

Updated Category News Views 172

Longevity medicine just got a very large check and an even larger assignment. Hone Health says it has raised $228 million to push physician-led care beyond its roots in hormone optimization, and the split of that financing matters more than the celebrity names attached to it. Only $28 million is described as Series A equity; the other $200 million comes as growth...

Continue Reading
MIND Takes Its Copilot Security Bet Across Microsoft 365

Updated Category News Views 59

Copilot’s promise gets a lot less charming the minute confidential files start wandering around unchecked. That is the knot MIND is trying to untie with its expanded, generally available integrations across Microsoft Copilot, Microsoft 365, Purview, Teams, SharePoint, OneDrive, Edge and Exchange. The Seattle data-loss-prevention company announced the collaboration on...

Continue Reading
Devicie Broadens Browser Security Across Device Fleets

Updated Category News Views 23

Browsers have quietly become the front door, side door, and occasionally the busted basement window of corporate security. Devicie’s newly expanded Edge for Business Reporting Connector tackles that uncomfortable reality by pulling browser security events from Windows, macOS, iOS, and Android into the same console customers use to oversee Microsoft Intune environments....

Continue Reading
Another Nine's A9OS Puts Software at Center of Golf

Updated Category News Views 63

A golf simulator chain is trying to turn the boring plumbing into its sharpest club. Another Nine’s A9OS is not merely a booking widget dressed up for a franchise brochure; it is meant to run the whole 24/7 operation, from payments and door access to cameras, simulator support and guest help. That ambition deserves attention because this is exactly where a staff-free...

Continue Reading
SteriLance Aims for Smoother Pricks with NanoSense Move

Updated Category News Views 92

Revamping the Lancing Game Out there in Suzhou, SteriLance Medical is steering clear of just chasing meter accuracy—do enough folks even care about glorified electronics?—they're zeroing in on the needle part of the blood glucose test, the part that pricks your finger every damn day. Yep, this new initiative is inviting blood glucose monitoring (BGM) brands to embrace...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Gamma Communications Celebrated for UCaaS Competitive Strategy

Updated Category News Views 342

Gamma Communications Receives Frost & Sullivan Recognition Gamma Communications has received prestigious recognition from Frost & Sullivan with the 2024 Competitive Strategy Leadership Award in the European unified communications as a service (UCaaS) industry. This award highlights the company’s exceptional strategy execution, innovative approaches, and impressive...

Continue Reading
ConocoPhillips Reports Strong Q3 2025 Results and Outlook

Updated Category News Views 232

ConocoPhillips Delivers Strong Third Quarter Performance ConocoPhillips (NYSE: COP) has once again demonstrated its robust operational capacity, reporting impressive financial results for the third quarter. Beginning with consistent execution across its production portfolio, the company's recent performance has exceeded market expectations, showcasing a continued...

Continue Reading
Electrosurgery Generators Market Set to Surge by $3.3 Billion

Updated Category News Views 125

Electrosurgery Generators Market Overview The global electrosurgery generators market is on an impressive growth trajectory, projected to reach USD 3,359.2 million by 2035. As healthcare evolves, this market is driven by innovations and a rising preference for minimally invasive procedures. The surge in outpatient surgical centers and advancements in electrosurgical...

Continue Reading
Explore the Versatile Applications of INNOVERA™ at Lineapelle Milan

Updated Category News Views 322

Discover INNOVERA™ at Lineapelle Milan 2026 Modern Meadow, a pioneer in bio-design, is set to showcase their groundbreaking material, INNOVERA™, at the highly anticipated Lineapelle Milan 2026. This prominent international leather fair will provide a platform for the company to illustrate the dynamic capabilities of INNOVERA™ across various industries. A Revolution...

Continue Reading
Harnessing AI for Enhanced Military Logistics Efficiency

Updated Category News Views 174

Virtualitics Secures Phase II Contract with AFGSC Virtualitics has recently been awarded a significant contract with the U.S. Air Force Global Strike Command (AFGSC). This Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) Phase II contract aims to optimize logistics using artificial intelligence (AI) for Readiness Spares Package (RSP) mobilization. This initiative is crucial to...

Continue Reading