Ultimate dem-speak-universal: The "Happy Planet Index"

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
PoemStone cashclan #28747
265
Ultimate dem-speak-universal: The "Happy Planet Index"
screwball math. :-(

< >

It is used to compare different countries and is formed by the combination of

(a x b x c) / d.

In this equation,

a = well-being – "how satisfied the residents of each country feel with life overall" (based on a Gallup poll)

b = life expectancy

c = inequalities of outcomes ("the inequalities between people within a country in terms of how long they live, and how happy they feel, based on the distribution in each country's life expectancy and well-being data"

d = ecological footprint ("the average impact that each resident of a country places on the environment, based on data prepared by the Global Footprint Network"

How do the assorted countries come out? Using this index, Costa Rica with a score of 44.7 is number 1; Mexico with a score of 40.7 is number 2; Bangladesh with a score of 38.4 is number 8; Venezuela with a score of 33.6 is 29; and the USA with a score of 20.7 is number 108 – out of 140 countries considered.

Beyond such obvious questions as "Why are so many people from Mexico coming to the USA while almost none are going the other way?," it is instructive to look at the role of the denominator (factor d) in arriving at those numerical index values.

Any country with a very low level of economic activity will have a low value of "ecological footprint." Uninhabited jungle or barren desert scores very low in that category. With a very small number for factor (d), it doesn't make a whole lot of difference what the numbers for (a), (b), and (c) are; the tiny denominator guarantees that the quotient will be large. Hence the large index reported for some truly squalid places.

The underlying reason why the "Happy Planet Index" is so misleading is because it includes division by a number that for some countries gets pretty close to zero.

Global Warming Potential

The second example of this effect is the parameter "Global Warming Potential," which is used to compare the relative strength of assorted greenhouse gases. The misuse of numbers here has led to all sorts of dreadful predictions about the need to do away with trace gases like methane (CH4), N2O, and others.

"Global Warming Potential" was first introduced in the IPCC's second assessment report and later formalized by the IPCC in its Fourth Assessment Report of 2007 (AR-4). It is described in section 2.10.2 of the text by Working Group 1. To grasp what it means, it is first necessary to understand how molecules absorb and re-emit radiation.

Every gas absorbs radiation in certain spectral bands. The more of a gas is present, the more it absorbs. Nitrogen (N2), 77% of the atmosphere, absorbs in the near-UV part of the spectrum, but not in the visible or infrared range. Water vapor (H2O) is a sufficiently strong absorber in the infrared that it causes the greenhouse effect and warms the Earth by over 30˚C, making our planet much more habitable. In places where little water vapor is present, there is less absorption, less greenhouse effect, and it soon gets cold (think of nighttime in the desert).

Once a molecule absorbs a photon, it gains energy and goes into an excited state. Until that energy is lost (via re-radiation or collisions), that molecule won't absorb another photon. A consequence of this is that the total absorption by any gas gradually saturates as the amount of that gas increases. A tiny amount of a gas absorbs very effectively, but if the amount is doubled, the total absorption will be less than twice as much as at first and similarly if doubled again and again. We say the absorption has logarithmic dependence on the concentration of the particular gas. The curve of how total absorption falls off varies according to the exponential function, exp (-X/A), where X is the amount of a gas present (typically expressed in parts per million, ppm), and A is a constant related to the physics of the molecule. Each gas will have a different value, denoted B, C, D, etc. Getting these numbers within ±15% is considered pretty good.

There is so much water vapor in the atmosphere (variable, above 10,000 ppm, or 1% in concentration) that its absorption is completely saturated, so there's not much to discuss. By contrast, the gas CO2 is a steady value of about 400 ppm, and its absorption is about 98% saturated. That coincides with the coefficient A being roughly equivalent to 100 ppm.

This excursion into the physics of absorption pays off when we look at the mathematics that goes into calculating the "Global Warming Potential" (GWP) of a trace gas. GWP is defined in terms of the ratio of the slopes of the absorption curves for two gases: specifically, the slope for the gas of interest divided by the slope for carbon dioxide. The slope of any curve is the first derivative of that curve. Economists speak of the "marginal" change in a function. For a change of 1 ppm in the concentration, what is the change in the radiative efficiency?

At this point, it is crucial to observe that every other gas is compared to CO2 to determine its GWP value. In other words, whatever GWP value is determined for CO2, that value is reset equal to 1 so that the calculation of GWP for a gas produces a number compared to CO2. The slope of the absorption curve for CO2 becomes the denominator of the calculation to find the GWP of every other gas.

Now let's calculate that denominator. When the absorption function is exp (-X/A), it is a mathematical fact that the first derivative = [-1/A][exp(-X/A)]. In the case of CO2 concentration being 400 ppm, when A = 100 ppm, that slope is [-1/100][exp (-4)] = - 0.000183. That is one mighty flat curve, with an extremely gentle slope that is slightly negative.

Next, examine the gas that's to be compared with CO2, and calculate the numerator.

It bears mentioning that the calculation of GWP also contains a factor related to the atmospheric lifetime of each gas. Here we'll concentrate on the change in absorption due to a small change in concentration. The slope of the absorption curve will be comparatively steep, because that molecule is at low concentration, able to catch all the photons that come its way.

To be numerically specific, consider methane (CH4), with an atmospheric concentration of about Y = 1.7 ppm, or N2O, at concentration Z = 0.3 ppm. Perhaps their numerical coefficients are B ~ 50 or C ~ 150; they won't be terribly far from the value of A for CO2. Taking the first derivative gives [-1/B][exp{-Y/B) ]. Look at this closely: with Y or Z so close to zero, the exponential factor will be approximately 1, so the derivative is just 1/B (or 1/C, etc.). Maybe that number is 1/50 or 1/150 – but it won't be as small as 0.000183, the CO2 slope that appears in the denominator.

In fact, the denominator (the slope of the CO2 curve as it nears saturation) is guaranteed to be a factor of about [exp (-4)] smaller than the numerator 7 – for the very simple reason that there is ~ 400 times as much CO2 present, and its job of absorbing photons is nearly all done.

When a normal-sized numerator is divided by a tiny denominator, the quotient blows up. The GWP for assorted gases come out to very large numbers, like 25 for CH4 and 300 for N2O. The atmospheric lifetime factor swings some of these numbers around still farther: some of the hydrofluorocarbons (trade name Freon) have gigantic GWPs. HFC-134a, used in most auto air conditioners, winds up with GWP above 1,300. The IPCC suggests an error bracket of ±35% on these estimates. However, the reality is that every one of the GWPs calculated is enormously inflated due to division by the extremely small denominator associated with the slope of the CO2 absorption curve.

The calculation of GWP is not so much a warning about other gases, but rather an indictment of CO2, which (at 400 ppm) would not change its absorption perceptibly if CO2 concentration increased or decreased by 1 ppm.

The Feedback Effect of Global Warming

The third example comes from the estimates of the “feedback effect” in computational models of global warming. The term “Climate Sensitivity” expresses how much the temperature will rise if the greenhouse gas CO2 doubles in concentration. A relevant parameter in the calculation is “radiative forcing,” which can be treated either with or without feedback effects associated with water vapor in the atmosphere. Setting aside a lot of details, the “no feedback” case involves a factor L that characterizes the strength of the warming effect of CO2. But with feedback, that factor changes to [ L /(1 – KL)], where K is the sum of assorted feedback terms, such as reflection of radiation from clouds and other physical mechanisms; each of those is assigned a numerical quantity. The value of L tends to be around 0.3. The collected sum of the feedback terms is widely variable and hotly debated, but in the computational models used by the IPCC in prior years, the value of K tended to be about K = 2.8.

Notice that as L tends toward 1/3 and K goes to 3, the denominator goes to zero. For the particular case of L = 0.3 and K = 2.8, the denominator is 0.16 and the “feedback factor” becomes 6.25. It was that small denominator and consequent exaggerated feedback factor that increased the estimate of “Climate Sensitivity” from under 1 oC in the no-feedback case to alarmingly large estimates of temperature change. Some newspapers spoke of “11 oF increases in global temperatures.” Nobody paid attention to the numerical details.

In more recent years, the study of various positive and negative contributions to feedback improved, and the value of the sum K dropped to about 1, reducing the feedback factor to about 1.4. The value of the "Climate Sensitivity" estimated 30 years ago in the "Charney Report" was 3˚C ± 1.5˚C. Today, the IPCC gingerly speaks of projected Climate Sensitivity being "near the lower end of the range." That sobering revision can be traced to the change from a tiny denominator to a normal denominator.

The take-home lesson in all of this is to beware of tiny denominators. Any numerical factor that is cranked out is increasingly meaningless as the denominator shrinks.

When some parameter (such as "Climate Sensitivity" or "Global Warming Potential" or "Happy Planet Index" has built into it a small denominator, don't believe it. Such parameters have no meaning or purpose other than generating alarm and headlines.



Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Chicago Auto Show: Run & Explore Indoors This February

Updated Category News Views 81

Nobody’s thinking about running laps when they walk into a colossal auto show, but the Chicago Auto Show isn't letting the pedal ease off the gas. Swing by on February 14, folks, for something not typically seen on the floors of McCormick Place. Run participants have got one hour to log as many miles as they can on the 2.4-mile loop right inside the show. Why a Running...

Continue Reading
Lennar Faces Legal Heat Over Alleged Misleading Statements

Updated Category News Views 107

Rumbling Legal Drama with Lennar Corporation Every trader knows the uneasy feeling when a stock you're eyeing takes a surprising nosedive on some legal muck coming out of the woodwork. Well, it's Lennar Corporation's turn in the spotlight for all the wrong reasons. They're getting slapped with a class action lawsuit by investors claiming the company pulled a fast one...

Continue Reading
Kansai Powers Up US Grid with Bold Investment Move

Updated Category News Views 99

Betting Big on Battery Storage Let's unpack this big move by Kansai Electric. Anytime a major player like Kansai steps out of its home turf, folks better pay attention. Looks like Kansai's gotten cozy with Elevate and ArcLight, nabbing a minority stake in Prospect Power. This ain't your average widget factory—it's a beefy 150MW/600MWh battery energy storage facility in...

Continue Reading
BETR's Legal Tangle: A Deeper Dive into Investor Turmoil

Updated Category News Views 86

BETR's Shaky Ground: When Promises Fall Short In the rough-and-tumble world of finance, there's little room for empty promises. Better Home & Finance Holding Company (NASDAQ: BETR) might have to learn that the hard way. Investors who snagged shares between March 13 and August 6, 2026, are now clutching their heads as they watch their investments nosedive. When companies...

Continue Reading
Daymond John's Four-Center Bet on Longevity Game

Updated Category News Views 95

A Shark's Dive into Longevity Here you go—Daymond John, the face of FUBU and a household name from Shark Tank, is not just talking about living longer; he's putting his wallet where his words are. John is jumping into the longevity game with both feet, joining Ultimate Longevity Center's (ULC) latest venture. We're talking about four new centers across California,...

Continue Reading
Surgical Tooth Extraction: When It’s Necessary

Updated Category News Views 98

Unpacking the Complexities of Tooth Extraction Ever wonder why some tooth extractions are a stroll in the park while others dive straight into surgical territory? It's all about positioning, condition, and what's lurking underneath. Thanks to Dr. Yadira Cardona-Rohena of Hamilton Mill Oral & Facial Surgery, we’ve got the lowdown. The Need for Skilled Surgical Techniques...

Continue Reading
Cardio Partners Hits a Million Milestone with Red Cross

Updated Category News Views 39

One Million Trained, One Million Prepared Ah, a million sounds like just another number, doesn't it? But when someone's life hangs in the balance, those are a million folks ready to jump in and act. Cardio Partners has hit this mighty milestone in CPR, AED, and First Aid training, gaining a pat on the back from none other than the American Red Cross. It's a testament,...

Continue Reading
DHL Leverages Robust Growth in Resilient Supply Chains

Updated Category News Views 136

Supply Chain Resilience: A Strategic Game Changer Market volatility's got its teeth in the game, and everyone in logistics knows it. DHL Supply Chain isn't just sitting back; they're riding the wave of change, snagging a 12% revenue bump in 2026. It's not your typical headline growth, either. More like the kind of growth that gets logistics gurus eyeing those contract...

Continue Reading
Inventor Launches Handy Solution for Kids' Car Sickness

Updated Category News Views 29

A Fresh Take on an Age-Old Problem Just when you thought the universe had thrown all it could at beleaguered parents, here comes a nifty little accessory tackling those dreaded uphill battles with kids and car rides. Some bright spark from Middleburgh, New York, sick of scrubbing car seats and clothing every other road trip, came up with a clever little invention named...

Continue Reading
Choate's Expands to New Mid-South Markets

Updated Category News Views 85

Family Traditions Drive Choate's Growth Back in the day, you might've thought the family-run businesses were a dying breed, right? Not in the case of Choate's Air Conditioning, Heating, Plumbing & Electrical. These folks aren't just holding the fort; they're storming new territories across the Mid-South like they've got something to prove—or maybe just something to...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Disney Steers Focus Towards Asia's Streaming Landscape Success

Updated Category News Views 192

Disney Enters the Competitive Asian Streaming Market Walt Disney Co (NYSE: DIS) is strategically positioning itself to dominate in the vibrant Asian streaming market. The company's latest initiative involves a significant investment in original Japanese anime, alongside the expansion of its Korean superhero franchise. With this bold move, Disney aims to establish a strong...

Continue Reading
MSSA and GSMA Unite to Expand Mobile Satellite Services

Updated Category News Views 81

Strategic Alliance of MSSA and GSMA The Mobile Satellite Services Association (MSSA) has announced an exciting new partnership with the GSMA, a leading global organization dedicated to mobile operators and the broader mobile ecosystem. This synergy aims to elevate mobile technology to new heights and transform the landscape of mobile satellite communications. Advancing...

Continue Reading
Celebrating Pioneers: 2025 XCEL Summit for Men Highlights Heroes

Updated Category News Views 259

Honoring Leadership at the 2025 XCEL Summit for Men Black Enterprise is excited to showcase the remarkable individuals receiving the prestigious XCEL Awards at the much-anticipated XCEL Summit for Men. This year's celebration promises to be a hallmark event, scheduled for mid-October at the Hyatt Regency Grand Cypress in Orlando. Attendees can expect a magnificent...

Continue Reading
Innovative Trial Launches to Combat Pediatric Leukemia Worldwide

Updated Category News Views 259

Revolutionizing Pediatric Leukemia Treatment The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society (LLS) has embarked on an extraordinary journey with the launch of the PedAL (Pediatric Acute Leukemia) Master Clinical Trial, a trailblazing effort that marks the world's first-ever global trial focused on menin inhibitors for treating pediatric leukemia. This initiative is part of LLS's broader...

Continue Reading
Aflac Partners with Workday to Enhance Employee Benefits Experience

Updated Category News Views 196

Aflac's Collaboration with Workday for Enhanced Wellness Solutions Aflac, a prominent provider of supplemental insurance in the U.S., has entered into a partnership with Workday Wellness aimed at revolutionizing employee benefit offerings. This strategic relationship empowers employers to provide a more personalized experience for their workforce, ultimately aimed at...

Continue Reading