Three Reasons Why Bitcoin Is Not Money <

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone
186
Three Reasons Why Bitcoin Is Not Money

< >

202511_5_.png

With the dramatic rise of bitcoin, many are talking about this crypto-currency as the new money of the future.

Such a simplification is understandable, since the matter of money is complex. Not all that glitters is gold. Likewise, what appears to be money often is not.

Bitcoin does nothing to clarify the matter, since it markets itself as a transactional currency that will be one of many digital replacements for the world's tired old legacy currencies – especially the dollar. In addition, merchants accepting bitcoin payments give the impression that it functions as money.

Libertarians love bitcoin since it appears to break away from the bonds of government. Perhaps they exult in thinking that the predictions of economist F.A. Hayek are coming to pass. He advocated competitive currencies and even imagined monetary units like "Hayeks" alongside "Smiths" and "Joneses" jockeying for prominence in a vibrant market economy.

Difference between Money and Currency

The main confusion lies in the distinction between money and currency. In the mind of the public, the two terms are synonymous.

Currency consists of banknotes and government-issued paper bills and coins that serve as media of exchange to facilitate transactions. In the modern economy, this currency, which is the actual physical cash in circulation, accounts for only a small amount of total money supply.

In this sense, bitcoin, acting like virtual cash, can perform functions similar to currencies' as a medium of exchange.

What Makes Something Money

Money is something different. It requires the existence of a lawful monetary authority. In Greek, money is termed numisma (from which comes numismatics), meaning law. Money is a creation of law. Currency becomes money by the action of lawful authority that assures its universal acceptance and takes it as payment for taxes. It acquires credibility through common usage and custom.

Like a stable legal system, every society needs a stable monetary framework. Throughout history, it has always fallen to responsible government, which exists for the common good, to control money and currency supply, prevent counterfeiting, and keep money's value stable.

That is why the American Constitution granted Congress the power to "coin money, regulate the value thereof, and of foreign coin." Milton Friedman notes: "There is probably no other area of economic activity with respect to which government intervention has been so uniformly accepted."

A private medium of exchange that is not accepted universally and lacks stability cannot be considered money.

That is why bitcoin is not money.

A Measure of Value

For something to be money, it must serve three basic functions: a measure of value, a medium of exchange, and a store of wealth. These are the three reasons why bitcoin is not money.

Money is a measure of value that allows people to gauge what something is worth. A money of account serves as a yardstick. Americans look at things and calculate their worth in dollars – the dominant measure of value.

It is important that money be a stable measurement, since one cannot trade or make contracts when the unit wildly fluctuates. A yardstick that is constantly changing is useless in the construction of a house. That is why it has always been the duty of the state to safeguard the political and monetary stability needed to plan for the future. Determining a measure of value is also an attribute of sovereignty, since it involves the very life of the nation and prevents the country from falling into the hands of a shadow government of manipulators.

By its nature, bitcoin does not seek to be a stable measure of value. Its enthusiasts welcomed its speculative rise in value from one to twenty thousand dollars. No one looks at things and thinks in terms of bitcoin because one cannot be sure what the unit is worth at the moment. Bitcoin itself is further expressed in dollars and not in its own units since it has no stable value in the public mind. It is risky to make contracts in bitcoin since its future value is unknowable.

Money as Medium of Exchange

Money must also serve as a medium of exchange that facilitates the buying and selling of goods. The fact that money is universally recognized within a sovereign area makes it desirable, respected, and trusted.

Bitcoin presents itself as a medium of exchange. Using blockchain technology, the crypto-currency claims to process global transactions more efficiently and instantly, especially outside the limitations of borders and other currencies.

However, bitcoin is a limited medium of exchange restricted to those who accept it. It carries no buyer protection mechanisms against fraud and error found in more traditional methods and instruments like credit cards. Indeed, its lack of security and transparency is a major concern that undermines its reliability.

A Store of Wealth

The final function of money is what Aristotle calls "a store of wealth." It involves money's ability to preserve value over time and therefore ensure the stability of trade. In this sense, most experts will admit that bitcoin is a store of wealth. However, because of its volatility, it behaves more like a commodity than a currency. Indeed, since bitcoins have no real existence beyond the algorithms that create them, they represent an unreal and precarious store of wealth.

Given its extraordinary rise, bitcoin is better called a risky investment. It is hardly the calm financial yardstick and medium needed to make an economy prosper.

This is yet another reason why bitcoin is not money.

The Drive to "Monetize" Bitcoin

The drive to "monetize" bitcoin and other digital currencies is dangerous. The bitcoin phenomenon represents those who long to break free from legacy currencies that have provided some measure of stability and expressed the sovereignty of nations. They yearn for an economy of frenetic intemperance, in which everything must be instant and effortless. It is an economy detached from reality and responsibility, from which they might create their own abstract economic worlds.

Much like political ideologues who forced their ideal systems upon others, the new economic ideologues do the same. Their economic musings are dangerous, since they tend to force reality to conform to their global fantasies of a free-flowing abstract currency that sidesteps national sovereignty and links all nations and peoples.

German sociologist Georg Simmel, who wrote about the philosophy of money, once defined money as the value of things without the things. Perhaps bitcoin might be defined as the value of nothing without something.

It is certainly not money.





Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

IP Lawyer Chris Henry Returns to Latham: A Game Changer

Updated Category News Views 106

Welcome Home, Chris Henry! Folks, here's a headline that's making waves in the IP litigation water: Chris Henry has returned to Latham & Watkins, taking his place as a heavyweight partner in their Boston office. Now, if you're not deeply entangled in the world of high-stakes intellectual property (IP) disputes, you might shrug. But for tech companies embroiled in patent...

Continue Reading
MatterSeek Platform Revolutionizing Materials R&D Worldwide

Updated Category News Views 156

Innovating the R&D Landscape with MatterSeek In the ever-changing realm of materials research and development, Yuyao Technology's latest innovation, MatterSeek, is a game changer. It's a slick launch, folks, redefining how we look at the R&D landscape through its AI-driven abilities. This ain't just another pie-in-the-sky platform; it's an actual workhorse designed to...

Continue Reading
DEFSEC Completes 9-to-1 Share Consolidation

Updated Category News Views 79

DEFSEC Technologies Tightens the Belt So, DEFSEC Technologies just pulled off something that'll kick up dust among investors. A 9-to-1 share consolidation—now that's no small fry. For those riding the NASDAQ or the TSX Venture with a tight grip on their DEFSEC shares, it's strictly business today. Post-consolidation, DEFSEC's common shares are set to trade under the...

Continue Reading
Ross Pools Joins Forces with Florida Panthers in 2026

Updated Category News Views 56

An Unlikely Team-Up: Pools and Hockey Well, here's one for the books: a South Florida pool company hitching its wagon to an NHL team. Ross Pools, the folks who’ve been carving out backyard oases in the sizzling Florida sun for over two decades, are now officially aligned with the Florida Panthers. Yeah, the same Panthers that snatched the Stanley Cup not once but twice...

Continue Reading
Xiong'an New Area: People's Priorities Reshape Living Spaces

Updated Category News Views 89

Building a City for the People This here is about prioritizing people over skylines. Xiong'an New Area in Hebei Province is shaping up to be more than just a place on the map; it's an experiment in redefining urban living. Skyscrapers and traffic jams? Not on this menu. Instead, nature paves a graceful dance floor between mid-rise residences. Forget your bustling city...

Continue Reading
Dar Global Expands Jeddah Portfolio with $267M Project

Updated Category News Views 221

Dar Global's Big Jeddah Move: A $267M Bet Alright, let's dive into what Dar Global's been up to in Saudi Arabia. They've just announced a whopping SAR 1 billion development project in Jeddah, bringing an international luxury brand to the city with an exclusive co-branded residential concept. Now that's something to chew on for any investor eyeing the Middle East's real...

Continue Reading
Cardio Partners Hits a Million Milestone with Red Cross

Updated Category News Views 16

One Million Trained, One Million Prepared Ah, a million sounds like just another number, doesn't it? But when someone's life hangs in the balance, those are a million folks ready to jump in and act. Cardio Partners has hit this mighty milestone in CPR, AED, and First Aid training, gaining a pat on the back from none other than the American Red Cross. It's a testament,...

Continue Reading
Crocs to Present at Key Industry Conferences

Updated Category News Views 85

Crocs Set to Step into the Spotlight Alright, if there's one thing about Crocs, Inc. (NASDAQ: CROX) that never fails to surprise, it's how they constantly keep everyone on their toes. The iconic casual footwear brand with its whimsical, love-it-or-hate-it reputation is strapping in for not one but two hefty conferences. They've circled November 19 and December 1, 2026, on...

Continue Reading
Caladan Partners with Anchorage for Stronger Trading

Updated Category News Views 88

Caladan and Anchorage Unite for Asset Growth Man, partnerships might just be the secret sauce we never know we need until it’s on our plate. It's a fresh day in digital trading, and Caladan just shook things up by teaming up with Anchorage Digital, bolstering their trading and settlement capabilities to satisfy the big players. If there's one thing that's hot as a...

Continue Reading
Atomera Preps for Key Craig-Hallum Conference

Updated Category News Views 85

Unpacking the NYC Gathering Alight, let's comb through the moving parts here. Atomera Inc., ticker NASDAQ: ATOM for those eyeing the dance of numbers, is all set to step into the limelight at the 17th Annual Craig-Hallum Alpha Select Conference on November 17, 2026. This shindig isn't just another date on the calendar; it's a strategic haunt where Atomera will rub...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Disney Steers Focus Towards Asia's Streaming Landscape Success

Updated Category News Views 192

Disney Enters the Competitive Asian Streaming Market Walt Disney Co (NYSE: DIS) is strategically positioning itself to dominate in the vibrant Asian streaming market. The company's latest initiative involves a significant investment in original Japanese anime, alongside the expansion of its Korean superhero franchise. With this bold move, Disney aims to establish a strong...

Continue Reading
MSSA and GSMA Unite to Expand Mobile Satellite Services

Updated Category News Views 81

Strategic Alliance of MSSA and GSMA The Mobile Satellite Services Association (MSSA) has announced an exciting new partnership with the GSMA, a leading global organization dedicated to mobile operators and the broader mobile ecosystem. This synergy aims to elevate mobile technology to new heights and transform the landscape of mobile satellite communications. Advancing...

Continue Reading
Celebrating Pioneers: 2025 XCEL Summit for Men Highlights Heroes

Updated Category News Views 259

Honoring Leadership at the 2025 XCEL Summit for Men Black Enterprise is excited to showcase the remarkable individuals receiving the prestigious XCEL Awards at the much-anticipated XCEL Summit for Men. This year's celebration promises to be a hallmark event, scheduled for mid-October at the Hyatt Regency Grand Cypress in Orlando. Attendees can expect a magnificent...

Continue Reading
Innovative Trial Launches to Combat Pediatric Leukemia Worldwide

Updated Category News Views 259

Revolutionizing Pediatric Leukemia Treatment The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society (LLS) has embarked on an extraordinary journey with the launch of the PedAL (Pediatric Acute Leukemia) Master Clinical Trial, a trailblazing effort that marks the world's first-ever global trial focused on menin inhibitors for treating pediatric leukemia. This initiative is part of LLS's broader...

Continue Reading
Aflac Partners with Workday to Enhance Employee Benefits Experience

Updated Category News Views 196

Aflac's Collaboration with Workday for Enhanced Wellness Solutions Aflac, a prominent provider of supplemental insurance in the U.S., has entered into a partnership with Workday Wellness aimed at revolutionizing employee benefit offerings. This strategic relationship empowers employers to provide a more personalized experience for their workforce, ultimately aimed at...

Continue Reading