Bloomberg-Battery Makers’ Great Hope for Cheap Lithium Faces Talent Crunch
By Jonathan Gilbert
December 27, 2017, 6:00 PM CST Updated on December 28, 2017, 6:30 AM CST
In the global rush to supply the electric-car revolution, lithium hot spot Argentina is grappling with a shortage of talent.
Battery makers are depending on the South American nation’s high-altitude salt flats as a key new supply of the metal, with vast deposits and an investor-friendly government luring prospectors and developers. Under President Mauricio Macri, Argentina has ambitions to become a lithium superpower, supplying as much as 45 percent of the market, up from about 16 percent now.
Projects have faced unpredictable weather and financing struggles. But perhaps the biggest barrier to development is a dearth of skilled workers.
“In Argentina, everyone wants to be a lawyer or a doctor,” said Miguel Angel Persoglia, who has worked on copper and silver projects and now heads the pilot operations at Minera Exar SA, a joint venture between Lithium Americas Corp. and Soc. Quimica & Minera de Chile SA. “There’s no technical personnel” for lithium.
The shortage of local expertise can be seen as a growing pain in a new industry, and one that’s being exacerbated by competition from other sectors, like shale gas, as deregulation under Macri helps jump-start the economy.
Argentina was the world's third-biggest producer in 2016
Up until two years ago, the only company extracting lithium on a commercial scale from Argentine brine was U.S.-based FMC Corp., which began operations in the Dead Man salt flat in 1997. Australia’s Orocobre Ltd. became the country’s second producer in 2015.
The SQM-Lithium Americas venture on the Cauchari-Olaroz salt flats about 13,000 feet (4,000 meters) above sea level in Jujuy province plans to start producing lithium carbonate at an annual rate of 25,000 metric tons in 2019. Dozens of other projects are at earlier stages.
Argentina is looking to take market share from neighboring Chile where would-be producers need authorization from the nuclear energy commission in a throwback to a 1979 decision to declare lithium “strategic.”
Extracting lithium from salty water is cheaper and easier than hard-rock mining. Producers drill for brine, then pump the liquid through giant hoses into turquoise evaporation ponds. What’s left is processed into lithium carbonate, prices of which have tripled in the past three years.
But companies including Orocobre have found the process is trickier than they first thought. The Brisbane, Australia-based company, which operates at Cauchari-Olaroz in partnership with Toyota Tsusho Corp., has cited a lack of engineering expertise as contributing to its failure to hit a production target of more than 15,000 tons for the year through June. With cloudy weather also hindering evaporation and snow storms stopping arrivals of a key imported chemical, output was about 11,900 tons.
“You can’t generate the know-how just like that,” said Cristian Saavedra Lopez, a Chilean who heads Orocobre’s lithium operations in Argentina. The company has been working for about two years with the National University of Jujuy to train both current employees and students who could apply for jobs at the mine, Saavedra Lopez said.
The university, with the support of Conicet, Argentina’s science and technology promotion agency, has set up a research center for improving extraction techniques and developing high-performance rechargeable batteries made with lithium. Notably, the center hired Victoria Flexer, a prominent Argentine chemist who was tempted home after years overseas.
A lithium carbonate mine with capacity of 20,000 tons a year needs an operational staff of about 200, according to Argentina’s Energy and Mining Ministry. With 38 projects in the nation’s lithium pipeline, including Minera Exar, that could mean an arduous headhunt to ensure 7,600 jobs of varying technical levels get filled.
Bespoke Chemistry
In the race to satisfy world lithium appetite that’s set to more than double by 2025, driven by the electric-vehicle boom, Lithium Americas expedited the talent search.
To equip its Minera Exar venture with expertise, the company brought SQM on board in March 2016, giving up a 50 percent equity stake. The partnership also ensured a $285 million investment from China’s Jiangxi Ganfeng Lithium Co. and Thailand’s Bangchak Corp. at a time when it’s proving tough to get financing for Argentine lithium projects.
SQM already produces lithium carbonate at a much bigger mine on the Atacama salt flat over the border in Chile. It has sent 60 seasoned engineers to Minera Exar, according to Lithium Americas.
“It’s an arms race for engineers,” said John Kanellitsas, Lithium Americas’ president, comparing the talent squeeze to the shortage of specialist programmers in Silicon Valley. The problem, according to Kanellitsas, is that generic mining experience is insufficient. “This is not copper or gold,” he said. “Every lithium project is a bespoke chemical plant.”
Monster Reserves
Argentina has the world's third-largest amount of recoverable lithium
For companies further behind the curve, the answer has been to call on experience abroad.
Advantage Lithium Corp., which is digging exploratory wells on the fringes of Minera Exar’s holdings, lured Callum Grant out of retirement last year to lead operations, Chief Executive Officer David Sidoo said. Grant, a Scot, has worked in mining across the Americas for decades.
Advantage plans to publish an estimate of its resource in the first quarter of 2018. Orocobre has a 25 percent stake in the project.
Sidoo and his peers highlight the positives of operating in Argentina, like the asphalt road snaking up to the salt flats that makes transportation easy. But most of all, they say, there’s the goodwill of the Macri government.
If the hurdles to assembling a talented workforce can also be overcome,“this is Argentina’s time,” Sidoo said.
By Jonathan Gilbert
December 27, 2017, 6:00 PM CST Updated on December 28, 2017, 6:30 AM CST
In the global rush to supply the electric-car revolution, lithium hot spot Argentina is grappling with a shortage of talent.
Battery makers are depending on the South American nation’s high-altitude salt flats as a key new supply of the metal, with vast deposits and an investor-friendly government luring prospectors and developers. Under President Mauricio Macri, Argentina has ambitions to become a lithium superpower, supplying as much as 45 percent of the market, up from about 16 percent now.
Projects have faced unpredictable weather and financing struggles. But perhaps the biggest barrier to development is a dearth of skilled workers.
“In Argentina, everyone wants to be a lawyer or a doctor,” said Miguel Angel Persoglia, who has worked on copper and silver projects and now heads the pilot operations at Minera Exar SA, a joint venture between Lithium Americas Corp. and Soc. Quimica & Minera de Chile SA. “There’s no technical personnel” for lithium.
The shortage of local expertise can be seen as a growing pain in a new industry, and one that’s being exacerbated by competition from other sectors, like shale gas, as deregulation under Macri helps jump-start the economy.
Argentina was the world's third-biggest producer in 2016
Up until two years ago, the only company extracting lithium on a commercial scale from Argentine brine was U.S.-based FMC Corp., which began operations in the Dead Man salt flat in 1997. Australia’s Orocobre Ltd. became the country’s second producer in 2015.
The SQM-Lithium Americas venture on the Cauchari-Olaroz salt flats about 13,000 feet (4,000 meters) above sea level in Jujuy province plans to start producing lithium carbonate at an annual rate of 25,000 metric tons in 2019. Dozens of other projects are at earlier stages.
Argentina is looking to take market share from neighboring Chile where would-be producers need authorization from the nuclear energy commission in a throwback to a 1979 decision to declare lithium “strategic.”
Extracting lithium from salty water is cheaper and easier than hard-rock mining. Producers drill for brine, then pump the liquid through giant hoses into turquoise evaporation ponds. What’s left is processed into lithium carbonate, prices of which have tripled in the past three years.
But companies including Orocobre have found the process is trickier than they first thought. The Brisbane, Australia-based company, which operates at Cauchari-Olaroz in partnership with Toyota Tsusho Corp., has cited a lack of engineering expertise as contributing to its failure to hit a production target of more than 15,000 tons for the year through June. With cloudy weather also hindering evaporation and snow storms stopping arrivals of a key imported chemical, output was about 11,900 tons.
“You can’t generate the know-how just like that,” said Cristian Saavedra Lopez, a Chilean who heads Orocobre’s lithium operations in Argentina. The company has been working for about two years with the National University of Jujuy to train both current employees and students who could apply for jobs at the mine, Saavedra Lopez said.
The university, with the support of Conicet, Argentina’s science and technology promotion agency, has set up a research center for improving extraction techniques and developing high-performance rechargeable batteries made with lithium. Notably, the center hired Victoria Flexer, a prominent Argentine chemist who was tempted home after years overseas.
A lithium carbonate mine with capacity of 20,000 tons a year needs an operational staff of about 200, according to Argentina’s Energy and Mining Ministry. With 38 projects in the nation’s lithium pipeline, including Minera Exar, that could mean an arduous headhunt to ensure 7,600 jobs of varying technical levels get filled.
Bespoke Chemistry
In the race to satisfy world lithium appetite that’s set to more than double by 2025, driven by the electric-vehicle boom, Lithium Americas expedited the talent search.
To equip its Minera Exar venture with expertise, the company brought SQM on board in March 2016, giving up a 50 percent equity stake. The partnership also ensured a $285 million investment from China’s Jiangxi Ganfeng Lithium Co. and Thailand’s Bangchak Corp. at a time when it’s proving tough to get financing for Argentine lithium projects.
SQM already produces lithium carbonate at a much bigger mine on the Atacama salt flat over the border in Chile. It has sent 60 seasoned engineers to Minera Exar, according to Lithium Americas.
“It’s an arms race for engineers,” said John Kanellitsas, Lithium Americas’ president, comparing the talent squeeze to the shortage of specialist programmers in Silicon Valley. The problem, according to Kanellitsas, is that generic mining experience is insufficient. “This is not copper or gold,” he said. “Every lithium project is a bespoke chemical plant.”
Monster Reserves
Argentina has the world's third-largest amount of recoverable lithium
For companies further behind the curve, the answer has been to call on experience abroad.
Advantage Lithium Corp., which is digging exploratory wells on the fringes of Minera Exar’s holdings, lured Callum Grant out of retirement last year to lead operations, Chief Executive Officer David Sidoo said. Grant, a Scot, has worked in mining across the Americas for decades.
Advantage plans to publish an estimate of its resource in the first quarter of 2018. Orocobre has a 25 percent stake in the project.
Sidoo and his peers highlight the positives of operating in Argentina, like the asphalt road snaking up to the salt flats that makes transportation easy. But most of all, they say, there’s the goodwill of the Macri government.
If the hurdles to assembling a talented workforce can also be overcome,“this is Argentina’s time,” Sidoo said.
