Quote:Republicans Are Getting Ready to Repeat Kansas’ Tax Cut Disaster
By Jordan Weissmann
•Nov. 29, 2017, 6:27 PM
In a rational world, Kansas’ notorious experiment with radical business tax cuts, which came to a close this year after a half decade of disaster, would serve as a cautionary tale for the Republicans who are now attempting to pass their own tax bill through Capitol Hill—a historical example to be avoided at all costs.
Instead, they’re on the verge of repeating it, nearly step for step.
At this point, Kansas’ budget nightmares have become a part of public policy lore. In 2012, Gov. Sam Brownback attempted to turn his state into a conservative model for the nation by enacting a series of sweeping tax cuts.
Most importantly, he entirely eliminated taxes on what are known as pass-through businesses—which around that time made up 94 percent of all U.S. firms and accounted for about half of the country’s business profits. Brownback insisted that the move would act “like a shot of adrenaline into the heart of the Kansas economy” and create “tens of thousands of new jobs.”
Pass-throughs are often misleadingly described as “small businesses” in order to justify lightening their tax loads. In reality, they’re simply firms like partnerships or S-corps that aren’t subject to the corporate tax rate.
Instead, they pass profits through to their owners, who pay taxes on them on their personal returns (hence the name). They are often small—your corner bodega or pediatrician’s office is probably a pass-through—but can also be huge. The Trump Organization? Its various tentacles are organized as pass-throughs.
Suffice to say, cutting taxes on these businesses didn’t do Kansas’ economy much good. Instead of a jobs boom, the state found itself slogging through years of unimpressive growth and massive budget deficits as its tax base disappeared, forcing lawmakers to cut spending on public schools, colleges, Medicaid, and more.
The state’s credit rating was humiliatingly downgraded. Eventually, legislators got fed up with the pain, and this year they finally voted to reverse the cuts, with Republicans joining Democrats to override Brownback’s veto.
In April, a group of economists took stock of the Kansas misadventure, using administrative tax data to figure out whether the cuts had done any good at all. In short, the researchers concluded, they had not.
The main effect, it seemed, was that business owners relabeled some of their income as “profits” rather than wages in order to cut their tax bills. Business investment by passthroughs actually seemed to decline slightly.
If states are supposed to be the laboratories of democracy, then Kansas now looks like a blown-out chemistry workshop where some reckless kids got burned in a chemical fire. You would have to be blind to follow in its footsteps.
But that is exactly what Republicans have decided to do. Both the House and Senate versions of the bill include generous cuts to pass-throughs, worth hundreds of billions of dollars over a decade. The House version, which is larger, carves out a special, 25 percent top tax rate for them. The Senate bill allows pass-through owners to deduct up to 17.4 percent of their business profits from their taxes—though lawmakers like Ron Johnson of Wisconsin would like to bump that number up.
One would be hard pressed to exaggerate just how pointless these cuts are from an economic standpoint. Politicians like Johnson argue that if Congress doesn’t reduce taxes on pass-throughs, they will be at a disadvantage compared with big companies that benefit from the 20 percent corporate rate Republicans have planned.
This ignores two key details: First, corporations are typically taxed twice, once on the company level and then when they distribute dividends (which is why they have a higher average tax rate than passthroughs today).
Second, any business that decided it was getting a raw deal on taxes could just choose to convert to a C-corp and get the better rate. “Pass-through businesses have the opportunity to convert to C-corporation form any time they wish by checking a particular box on a particular IRS form,” Scott Greenberg of the conservative Tax Foundation told me, explaining why he thought the pass-through cuts were needless. “I don’t think that these provisions are ultimately justifiable.”
It goes almost without saying, meanwhile, that these cuts will mostly benefit the wealthy. According to one recent study, about 69 percent of income earned by pass-throughs ends up in the hands of members of the top 1 percent.
Unlike Brownback’s tax cuts, the GOP’s current proposals do include some elaborate guard rails meant to prevent the new tax breaks from being abused by people who want to pretend their wages are really business “profit,” as happened in Kansas.
They’re also designed to limit highly paid professionals like lawyers, doctors, and accountants from taking advantage of the lower tax rates, since their “profits” are really more like salary, rather than returns to capital investments.
But it’s not clear how sturdy those guard rails actually are. And as long as there’s significant tax savings to be had by getting the special pass-through rate, chances are business owners will try to find a way.
Already, tax experts have mentioned to me how law offices could try splitting themselves into multiple firms to get the break, or how people could abuse the carve-outs for passive investors in the House bill.
And the savings from those shenanigans really could be quite large. As Tax Policy Center co-director William Gale pointed out in a blog post, business owners in Kansas were spared a 4.9 percent income tax thanks to Brownback’s cuts. The new pass-through rates Republicans are contemplating could save business owners roughly 7 to 15 points.
Ultimately, though, the most important problem with the Kansas cuts wasn’t that rich guys started playing accounting games to take advantage of them. According to the study in April, only about 8 percent of the state’s revenue losses were due to that kind of income shifting.
The issue was far more fundamental than that. The state simply handed out a massive tax cut to business owners which yielded no economic gains to speak of. Republicans are on track to repeat that self-destructive trick, nationwide.
Worst of all, just like in Kansas, these needless tax breaks for the rich could lead to excruciating budget cuts. Under Congress’s Paygo rules, the tax bill’s deficits will result in large automatic spending cuts to programs including Medicare or Social Services Block Grants, unless the Senate can get 60 votes to prevent them.
Meanwhile, Republicans are now talking about adding an automatic trigger that will cut spending even further if their tax plans don’t generate heroic amounts of economic growth and revenues falls. We could very well be looking at tax cuts for the Trump family paid for by spending cuts on your grandmother’s health care.
Of course, many Republicans would see spending cuts as a feature, not a bug, of their plan. And if slashing taxes on construction companies and midsized manufacturers doesn’t lead to booming economic growth, it may not matter, either.
Republicans have repeatedly admitted that they need to pass this tax plan in order to appease their donors. And pass-through owners are especially powerful interest group whose demands can’t be ignored. After all, rich car dealers give a lot of money to political campaigns. Those guys want their tax cut, too. And so the whole country is doomed to repeat Kansas’ mistake.
Republicans Are Getting Ready to Repeat Kansas’ Tax Cut
Top 10 Most Recent News Articles
AdMaven's Mave AI: Revolutionizing Campaign Management
Taking the Tedious Out of Advertising You've got to love it when technology actually makes life easier, rather than more complicated. AdMaven's latest fancy toy, the AI assistant Mave, is promising just that. It's designed to take the heavy lifting off advertisers' shoulders, especially the day-to-day grind of tweaking ad settings and monitoring performance. If you've...
Continue Reading
Loyalty Programs Cut $1500 Annually for Consumers
Loyalty Programs: An Essential Tool for Households In a world where every dollar counts, retail loyalty programs have become more than just a marketing strategy—they're lifelines for American households scraping through each month. According to fresh research by the Retail Industry Leaders Association (RILA) and conducted by market research leader Circana, these...
Continue Reading
Midea's R290 Tech: Real Green Cooling Revolution?
A Fresh Breeze in Sustainable Cooling In the middle of Kigali’s innovation oasis, Midea RAC stood out at MOP38, the 38th Meeting of the Parties to the Montreal Protocol, flexing its sustainable tech muscles. We're talking about their R290 air conditioning technology—a natural refrigerant with zero ozone footprint and a global warming potential of a mere three. This is...
Continue Reading
ROBOTERA Debuts XHAND 1 Pro-U in NVIDIA Demo
ROBOTERA Steps Up with XHAND 1 Pro-U Move over, traditional robotics; ROBOTERA is here to shake things up with their latest marvel, the XHAND 1 Pro-U. This futuristic gadget isn't just making waves at the Conference on Robot Learning (CoRL) where Jim Fan of NVIDIA spotlighted it in his GR00T 2 demo, it's setting a new bar for robotic dexterity. Hand in Glove with Human...
Continue Reading
DarioHealth's New Research Tackles Healthcare Cost Estimation
Unpacking Dario's Bold Surgical Strike at ISPOR Europe Alright, folks, DarioHealth is shaking up the stage with their new methodology that could very well carve a new path in how we size up digital healthcare savings. Presented at ISPOR Europe 2026, Dario's tactic bypasses the sluggish wait on medical claims data, instead offering an evidence-driven peek at potential...
Continue Reading
Alliance for Women in Media Champions Change in 2026
A Celebration of Trailblazing Women in Media If there's one thing I've learned about strong leadership, it's that you can't fake authenticity. Today, we're tipping our hats to some genuine trailblazers. The Alliance for Women in Media (AWM) held its annual Gracies Leadership Awards, celebrating the achievements and vision of seven remarkable women. Honoring the...
Continue Reading
Lennar Faces Legal Heat Over Alleged Misleading Statements
Rumbling Legal Drama with Lennar Corporation Every trader knows the uneasy feeling when a stock you're eyeing takes a surprising nosedive on some legal muck coming out of the woodwork. Well, it's Lennar Corporation's turn in the spotlight for all the wrong reasons. They're getting slapped with a class action lawsuit by investors claiming the company pulled a fast one...
Continue Reading
Caladan Partners with Anchorage for Stronger Trading
Caladan and Anchorage Unite for Asset Growth Man, partnerships might just be the secret sauce we never know we need until it’s on our plate. It's a fresh day in digital trading, and Caladan just shook things up by teaming up with Anchorage Digital, bolstering their trading and settlement capabilities to satisfy the big players. If there's one thing that's hot as a...
Continue Reading
Thunes Boosts Bhutan Remittances with Instant Payments
Thunes' Network Expands to Bhutan: A Game Changer I'll say one thing clear—Thunes isn't messing around. They've just opened the gates for real-time payouts to Bhutan, and it's going to be a game-changer for those living abroad who want to send money back home. Look, for years, Non-Resident Bhutanese have been diving into hoops just to get their bucks across borders....
Continue Reading
Dr. Obeng Joins WellcomeMD with Special Offer for Patients
New Beginnings in Concierge Medicine In late October, WellcomeMD opened its doors to Dr. Paa-Kofi Obeng—an arrival greeted with considerable anticipation in Richmond's medical scene. This isn't just any run-of-the-mill staff addition; Dr. Obeng brings with him over a decade of experience from places like the Veterans Administration Medical Center. He's armed with a...
Continue ReadingTop 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles
Celebrating Consumer Trust: The Most Trusted Brands of 2026
Consumer Trust at the Core of Shopping Decisions In an ever-competitive marketplace, consumers face an overwhelming array of choices, making decisions increasingly challenging. Fortunately, trust acts as a guiding beacon for shoppers, allowing them to confidently narrow down their options when making purchases. According to the BrandSpark American Trust Study, a...
Continue Reading
Saudi AI Hackathon 2025: Empowering Student Innovators
Saudi AI & Edge Computing Hackathon 2025 Fosters Innovation In a remarkable showcase of talent and creativity, the Saudi AI & Edge Computing Hackathon 2025 took center stage, emphasizing the synergy between academia and the tech industry. Hosted by Prince Sultan University and backed by MemryX, this hackathon highlighted the exceptional capabilities of students from...
Continue Reading
Meta Implements AI Hiring Freeze Amid Talent Competition
Meta Platforms Inc. Takes a Step Back in AI Hiring Meta Platforms Inc. (NASDAQ: META) has recently instituted a hiring freeze in its artificial intelligence division. This decision follows months of aggressive recruitment, during which the company significantly boosted its talent pool with substantial compensation offers. The freeze is aimed at regulating the hiring...
Continue Reading
Lady Gaga's Heartfelt Cover of 'Won't You Be My Neighbor?' in Super Bowl Teaser
Lady Gaga Celebrates Community with New Cover In a touching tribute to the spirit of neighborliness, Lady Gaga has graced the world with her cover of "Won't You Be My Neighbor?". This initiative is part of a larger campaign that dives deep into themes of home, community, and belonging. Behind the Scenes of the Teaser Fans can catch exclusive behind-the-scenes footage...
Continue Reading
Palo Alto Networks Plummets: Guidance Cut or Market Misread?
Palo Alto Networks took a nosedive, with shares down over 7% premarket, sitting at $151.69—a shocker for traders who were banking on bullish momentum. The cybersecurity giant's fiscal second-quarter report dropped Tuesday, revealing a mixed bag that left investors scrambling to recalibrate expectations. While the top line reported $2.59 billion in revenue—just edging...
Continue Reading