Latest docket entry. Letter from Blank Rome to the Court

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
lovindollars
717
Latest docket entry. Letter from Blank Rome to the Court and all Counsel of Record. Total bitch-slap to the Defense. I love it.

Dear Judge Falk:
We represent Plaintiff, StrikeForce Technologies, Inc. (“StrikeForce”) in the above-captioned cases and write in response to Defendants’ letter dated November 17, 2017, seeking leave to amend their invalidity contentions. StrikeForce opposes Defendants’ request to amend their invalidity contentions because they have failed to meet the requirements of L. Pat. R. 3.7. L. Pat.R. 3.7 requires that Defendants make a timely application and show good cause for the amendment. Defendants have shown neither.
Defendants acknowledge they learned about these two new prior art references shortly after they were served by a defendant (Entrust) in another case, in another court (E.D. Va.). It is not surprising that Defendants’ letter is vague regarding when specifically they learned about these new references—Defendants admitted to StrikeForce they learned about these references in July 2017—four months ago. Ex. 1, Defendants’ November 13, 2017 Email to StrikeForce.

Defendants thus waited four months before seeking to amend their contentions. By Defendants’ own admission, Exhibits D and E to their supplemental contentions are copies of the same charts provided to Defendants by Entrust. Thus, there is no excuse for Defendants to have waited four months before seeking leave to amend. This Court has routinely found a delay of four months to be untimely for the purposes of L. Pat. R. 3.7 and denies those motions. See Antonious v. Nike, Inc., No. 2:11-CV-06327, 2015 WL 6122457, at *4 (D.N.J. Oct. 15, 2015) (“Notwithstanding the fact that the Documents were discovered, or should have been discovered by January 2015, the Trust waited an additional four months to bring its motion to amend. This delay does not amount to timeliness.”); Warner Chilcott Co., LLC v. Mylan Inc., No. 3:13-CV-06560, 2015 WL
3630970, at *8 (D.N.J. June 10, 2015) (finding a delay of 76 days lacked diligence, and further noting that “ he Court would be hard pressed to find such unexplained delay acceptable in any case”); Jazz Pharm., Inc. v. Roxane Labs., Inc., No. 2:10-CV-06108, 2012 WL 3133943 (D.N.J.
July 30, 2012), aff'd, 2013 WL 785067 (D.N.J. Feb. 28, 2013) (denying motion for leave to amend Local Patent Rule disclosures where the defendant located prior art in September and delayed filing its motion until the following February); Horizon Pharma AG v. Watson Labs., Inc.-Florida, No. 1:13-CV-05124, 2015 WL 12850575, at *3 (D.N.J. Feb. 24, 2015) (finding that a six-week delay between discovering the basis for an amendment and moving to amend invalidity contentions was not diligent).1

Defendants also reference the denial of their IPR petitions by the PTAB as somehow justifying their delay in seeking leave to amend. More to the point, Defendants believed that their IPR petitions were going to be granted. And for some reason, Defendants believed they were justified in doing nothing with these new references until some later undefined date. Contrary to
Defendants’ expectations, the PTAB wholly rejected both of Defendants’ IPR petitions. Then, with their invalidity case suddenly in tatters, Defendants sought to assert these additional prior art references. As this Court has already demonstrated, Defendants cannot justify their lack of diligence in seeking to amend their contentions on the filing of an IPR petition. Warner Chilcott Co., 2015 WL 3630970, at *8. In other words, the pending IPR petitions did not excuse Defendants from complying with the Local Patent Rules.2

Tellingly, Defendants do not cite any opinion from the District of New Jersey to support their IPR excuse. Instead, they rely on a single Northern District of California case. See generally Karl Storz Endoscopy-Am., Inc. v. Stryker Corp., No. 14-CV-00876-RS (JSC), 2016 WL 2855260 (N.D. Cal. May 13, 2016). The facts in that case, however, are very different than those in this case. In Karl Storz, the defendant delayed seeking to amend its invalidity contentions until a stay was lifted; a stay that was granted based solely on the filing of an IPR petition. That court, unlike this Court, routinely grants motions to stay based solely on the filing of an IPR petition. Thus, the defendant in that case had a reasonable expectation that its motion to stay would be granted. That is in stark contrast to this Court, which routinely denies motions to stay based merely on the filing of an IPR petition. See Derma Sciences, Inc. v. Manukamed Ltd., No. 3-12-CV-03388, 2013 WL 6096459, *1 (D.N.J. July 18, 2013) (denying defendants’ preinstitution
motion to stay); Straight Path IP Group, Inc., v. Vonage Holdings Corp., et al., No. 2-14-CV-00502 (D.N.J Aug. 28, 2014) (denying pre-institution motion to stay as premature); Medac Pharma, Inc. et al. v. Antares Pharma, Inc. et al., No. 1-14-CV-01498 (D.N.J. July 17, 2014) (denying pre-institution motion to stay with leave to re-file after institution decision is rendered); Depomed Inc. v. Purdue Pharma L.P., No. 3-13-CV-00571, D.I. 84 (D.N.J. July 9, 2014) (denying pre-institution motion to stay as premature); Power Survey, LLC v. Premier Util. Servs., LLC, 124 F. Supp. 3d 338, at 339 (D.N.J. Mar. 18, 2015) (denying pre-institution motion to stay as premature). Thus, unlike the defendant in Karl Storz, the Defendants in this case had
no reasonable expectation that the case would be stayed based solely on their IPR petition. And indeed, the case has not been stayed. In sum, Defendants cannot point to their failed IPR petition as an excuse for their delay in seeking to amend their invalidity contentions.
Defendants also fail to demonstrate they performed a diligent search in the first instance, as required by L. Pat. R. 3.7. The two prior art references Defendants seek to add are not new. The Chapman reference, for example, is fourteen (14) years old and the Ruddle reference is twentyfive (25) years old. Both were within the public domain for decades at the time Defendants
performed their searches. Indeed, even a cursory prior art search using the “Find Prior Art” feature of Google Patents and a few common terms from the asserted patent reveal both of these references near the top of the search results. Ex. 2, Prior Art Search 1; Ex. 3, Prior Art Search 2.

The fact that these references were so easily identifiable using common search terms appearing in the asserted patent confirms that Defendants did not originally perform a diligent search, otherwise they would have been identified long ago. Thus, Defendants have failed to establish their original search was diligent.

Lastly, Defendants devote much of their argument to the issue of undue prejudice, even inserting it into their arguments regarding their own diligence. But, as this Court has frequently held, the question of undue prejudice is considered only if the party seeking leave to amend has already
met the threshold requirement of diligence under L. Pat. R. 3.7. See, e.g., Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp. v. Sandoz, Inc., No. 3:12-CV-03289, 2014 WL 997532, at *7 (D.N.J. Jan. 6, 2014), aff'd, 2014 WL 1494592 (D.N.J. Apr. 16, 2014) (“If the moving party has not shown its diligence in finding the new information or seeking leave to amend, the court does not even reach the issue of whether the proposed amendment would prejudice the non-moving party.”); AstraZeneca AB v. Dr. Reddy's Labs. Inc., No. 3:11-CV-02317, 2013 WL 1145359, at *3 (D.N.J. Mar. 18, 2013) (“ he Court may only consider prejudice to the non-moving party if the moving party is able to demonstrate diligence.”). Because Defendants fail to meet their burden of showing their initial search was diligent and that their application to amend was timely once they did learn of these references, the Court need not consider undue prejudice to the non-moving party.

For the foregoing reasons, Defendants’ request to amend their invalidity contentions should be denied.

We are available should Your Honor need anything further. Thank you for Your Honor’s
courtesies.

Respectfully submitted,
/s Jonathan M. Korn
Jonathan M. Korn

Zerify Inc (ZRFY) Stock Research Links

ZRFY Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Sasol AGM Resolutions Passed in One Swift Swing

Updated Category News Views 119

Sasol's AGM Delivers Smooth Sailing for Shareholders Can't say I'm surprised, but Sasol's annual general meeting on the 13th of November went off without a hitch—unless, of course, you're one of those folks who just loves fireworks at these gatherings. The entire set of resolutions danced through with a resounding "Aye," making it one heck of a day for anyone banking on...

Continue Reading
AI Pushes Asset Managers Towards New Investment Growth

Updated Category News Views 89

AI: A Double-Edged Sword for Asset Managers Peeled straight from the heart of New York's financial buzz, AI is changing the game for asset and wealth managers. Now, we ain’t talking about some futuristic sci-fi scene, but real-world shifts that are scratching their way into boardrooms. Nearly 80% of firms playing the AI card see a sweet lift in productivity and...

Continue Reading
Fapon's MEDICA 2026 Bid: Game-Changer or Same Old?

Updated Category News Views 147

Fapon's Ambitious Pitch at MEDICA: A Real Deal? MEDICA 2026 sees Fapon stepping up, laden with flashy promises and hardened expertise. Set up in Düsseldorf, these folks are pushing their Local Manufacturing Solutions harder than a door-to-door vacuum seller. The main pitch? Bolstering local IVD production with their comprehensive tech transfer services. How many outfits...

Continue Reading
Surgical Tooth Extraction: When It’s Necessary

Updated Category News Views 24

Unpacking the Complexities of Tooth Extraction Ever wonder why some tooth extractions are a stroll in the park while others dive straight into surgical territory? It's all about positioning, condition, and what's lurking underneath. Thanks to Dr. Yadira Cardona-Rohena of Hamilton Mill Oral & Facial Surgery, we’ve got the lowdown. The Need for Skilled Surgical Techniques...

Continue Reading
Mall of America Strives for World Record This Black Friday

Updated Category News Views 183

History in the Making at Mall of America Yeah, it seems these folks are not just about shopping anymore. The Mall of America is aiming to set the bar high this Black Friday, eyeing a GUINNESS WORLD RECORDS title for the most people holding up the same shopping bag all at once. Imagine a thousand people, synchronized like a flash mob—only with shopping bags instead of...

Continue Reading
TOYO Slips on Earnings Amid Strategic Expansion

Updated Category News Views 155

TOYO's Solar Journey: Ups and Downs If there's one thing riding high on volatility these days, it's solar energy. TOYO Co., Ltd. (Nasdaq: TOYO) spilled the beans on Q3 2026, and oh boy, it's a mixed bag. Revenue Jumps, Yet Profitability Takes a Hit Let's cut to the chase: the third quarter served up a 4.8% dip in revenue year-over-year, landing at $129 million, though it...

Continue Reading
Envision and Tsinghua Propel Climate Innovation at COP31

Updated Category News Views 87

Collaborating for a Greener Future On the bustling stage of COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, Envision Energy and Tsinghua University teamed up with the Global Alliance of Universities on Climate (GAUC) to showcase a bold agenda. Their focus transcends mere dialogue, pushing for actionable climate solutions anchored in technological innovation, academic synergy, and the dynamism...

Continue Reading
Phoenix Contact Achieves Guinness Record in Wiring

Updated Category News Views 160

A Blitz of Wires and Innovation Boy, did Phoenix Contact shake things up in Blomberg. On a crisp November day, a group of fresh-faced first-year students pulled off something astounding—wiring 500 terminal blocks in a jaw-dropping 2 minutes and 20 seconds. This wasn’t just any effort; it was enough to earn them a shiny new Guinness World Record. What they did wasn’t...

Continue Reading
New York Reclaims Bagel Crown at 2026 BagelFest

Updated Category News Views 106

A Bagel Victory at Citi Field Holy schmear! New Yorker's are grinning wide like a bagel with a double helping of cream cheese—Ess-a-Bagel from Manhattan snagged the top honors at the heavily contested 2026 New York BagelFest. Back in its rightful hands, the Bagel Crown stays in the Empire State, and it's a victory for tradition and taste. Celebrating 50 years in the...

Continue Reading
Mars Moves on Cash Tender Offers for Seniors' Notes

Updated Category News Views 52

A Strategic Financial Maneuver or a Casual Gambit? Okay, what’s Mars up to now, you ask? Here we go with this. The behemoth behind some of your favorite snacks and pet indulgences is making waves—not with candy, but with cash. Mars, Incorporated is rolling out tender offers to buy back a substantial chunk of its Senior Notes for $2 billion in cold, hard cash. When a...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

FTI Consulting Welcomes New Leaders to Enhance Transactions Team

Updated Category News Views 162

FTI Consulting Expands Expertise in Transactions Practice FTI Consulting, Inc. has recently announced the addition of two seasoned M&A professionals to its Transactions practice within the Corporate Finance & Restructuring segment. This strategic move aims to enhance their offerings and support clients in managing complex transactions. Introduction of M&A Experts The...

Continue Reading
BetaNXT Recognized as Leader in Wealth Management Innovation

Updated Category News Views 309

BetaNXT Earns Recognition as a Trendsetter in Wealth Management BetaNXT has captured attention in the financial technology landscape, particularly with its groundbreaking DataXChange platform. This innovative solution is designed to enhance modernization and innovation in wealth management, fostering business growth through a connected data ecosystem. Finalist in...

Continue Reading
OysterLink Sees Record Interest in Hospitality Job Searches

Updated Category News Views 124

Surging Demand for Restaurant and Hospitality Positions New analysis indicates that interest in restaurant and hospitality jobs has surged, reaching the highest level seen in five years. This summer's data from OysterLink's platform, combined with nationwide Google Trends, showcases a remarkable uptick in searches and applications, highlighting a strong rebound in the...

Continue Reading
Innovative Lithium Battery Solutions Enhanced by ITU and Huawei

Updated Category News Views 315

Joint Innovations in Lithium Battery Technology At the prestigious Global Digital Power Summit, a collaboration between the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) and Huawei brought significant attention to lithium battery applications for telecom sites. With industry leaders and experts congregating, the dialogue centered around technological advancements aimed at...

Continue Reading
Licel vTEE Continues to Lead in EMVCo TEE Success

Updated Category News Views 130

Licel vTEE Achieves EMVCo Approval Again The groundbreaking virtual trusted execution environment, Licel vTEE, stands out as the only SBMP TEE to receive evaluation and approval from EMVCo. This marks another milestone in the continued recognition of Licel's innovative technology. Unprecedented Recognition for Android Platform Licel's vTEE has received re-evaluation and...

Continue Reading