Donald Trump's Pants on Fire claim about the estate tax,

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

Nov 21, 2017 at 9:57 PM 273

Quote:

Donald Trump's Pants on Fire claim about the estate tax, small businesses and farms

By Louis Jacobson on Thursday, September 28th, 2017 at 11:54 a.m.

During a speech in Indianapolis launching his proposal for tax overhaul legislation, President Donald Trump said that one element of the plan -- elimination of the estate tax -- would lift a burden on many family businesses and farms.

"To protect millions of small businesses and the American farmer, we are finally ending the crushing, the horrible, the unfair estate tax, or as it is often referred to, the death tax," Trump said in his Sept. 27 speech.

He continued, "That means, especially for all of you with small businesses that are really tremendous businesses, you’ll be able to leave them to your family, and your family won’t have to run out and do a fire sale to try and get the money to pay the tax. ... The farmers in particular are affected.

They have wonderful farms, but they can't pay the tax, so they have to sell the farm. … So that death tax is a disaster for this country and a disaster for so many small businesses and farmers."

We’ve addressed the question of how many small businesses and farmers pay the estate tax in previous fact-checks, but Trump’s assertion that eliminating the estate tax would "protect millions of small businesses and the American farmer" goes well beyond what we’ve heard before.

And the data doesn’t support it.

The estate tax comes into play when someone dies and their estate is large enough to qualify for the tax.

The estate tax was first established in 1916 to offset a decline in tariff revenue caused by the first World War, according to the Congressional Budget Office. Congress has tinkered with it many times throughout the years.

In 2017, estates worth less than $5.49 million are exempt from the tax, according to the Urban Institute-Brookings Institution Tax Policy Center. Above $5.49 million, the estate is generally taxed at 40 percent. However, family-owned farms and closely-held businesses may be able to pay less or pay in low-interest installments.

So how many estates are affected by the tax? Not many, and the people who pay it are usually among the country’s richest families.

For 2017, the Tax Policy Center estimated, based on past tax data and modeling, that 11,310 individuals will have estates big enough to file an estate tax return. "After allowing for deductions and credits, 5,460 estates will owe tax," the center concluded. "Over two-thirds of these taxable estates will come from the top 10 percent of income earners and close to one-fourth will come from the top 1 percent alone."

The top 10 percent of income earners would pay 88 percent of estate tax revenues, the center found, while the richest 0.1 percent could pay 27 percent.

How about small businesses and farms? The center projected that only about 80 small farms and closely held businesses would pay any estate tax in 2017.

That would amount to about 1 percent of all payers of the estate tax that year. And the estate tax revenue from small businesses and farms, the center said, would amount to fifteen-hundredths of 1 percent of the total paid under the estate tax in 2017.

So, getting rid of the estate tax would hardly "protect millions of small businesses and the American farmer," as Trump put it.

Trump's claim doesn't hold up even if you account for small businesses and farms that would potentially benefit from elimination down the road. The number from the Tax Policy Center (80) only refers to the number of small businesses and farms that would have to pay the tax this year.

Multiplying the amount of small business and farm-based estate taxpayers who are living today by deaths over the next 70 years would still just result in 5,600 small businesses or farms potentially relieved of the tax — vastly smaller than Trump’s "millions."

Our ruling

Trump said that ending the estate tax would "protect millions of small businesses and the American farmer."

That’s a ridiculously high estimate. Only 5,460 estates even pay the tax each year, according to a credible estimate, and of those, about 80 represented small businesses or farms. We rate the statement Pants on Fire.

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/state...te-tax-sm/

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Volkswagen Leasing's MXN 2.5B Move Through Bolsa

Reading the Fine Print in VW Leasing's Latest Move Let's get right into the weeds: Volkswagen Leasing's cranking out MXN 2.5 billion in long-term debt certificates. This maneuver ain't happening in a vacuum—it's powered by the intricate levers behind Greenberg Traurig's sharp legal mind. This isn't just another financial transaction; it's a strategically framed...

Jackson Hewitt Aims to Recruit 15,000 Seasonal Staff

Revving Up for Tax Season: Jackson Hewitt's Hiring Push When tax season looms, the hustle can't be understated, and Jackson Hewitt is cranking it up by hunting for 15,000 new recruits to tackle this annual financial circus. Starting October 26, this hiring fest is open season across the nation, pulling out all the stops to bolster its workforce. But what does this mean...

Kat Florence Hotels Offers Unique $20K Wine Tastings

Luxury Retreat Offering Free Rare Wine Tastings The world of high-end hospitality just got a bit more intoxicating, literally. As of October 20, guests at the Elora luxury retreat, part of the Kat Florence Hotels portfolio, can indulge in some of the most coveted wines on the planet—gratis. That's right, wine aficionados can thank Kat Florence's latest extravagant...

King City Gardens Debuts Third Dispensary in Cincinnati

Every corner of Cincinnati’s cannabis scene just got a little busier with King City Gardens opening up shop in Colerain Township. This move marks their third Garden Dispensary in Greater Cincinnati. It’s not just about adding another location, though. It’s King City’s way of cementing their local roots deeper into the city’s soil, rolling out a mix of...

Norwegian Bella™: A New Era in Luxury Cruising

Setting Sail with Norwegian Bella™ in 2028 When you hear about another cruise ship hitting the water, eye rolls might come naturally. But Norwegian Cruise Line's latest announcement adds a few twists worth noting. Today, the big news is that the Norwegian Bella™, the freshest face in NCL's innovative Prima Class, is now open for bookings. This beauty will start its...

Prosecco DOC Chef Residency Debriefs on Inaugural Year

A Fusion of Flavors: The Residency Recap Alright, listen up. The Prosecco DOC Chef Residency has wrapped its initial bash in Italy, where it played culinary matchmaker with talents from Brazil, South Korea, Canada, and the UK. Picture some top-notch chefs crossing borders and tweaking recipes with that unique Italian spark of Prosecco DOC. It wasn't just some ballroom...

NCD Debuts Tool for Medicare Advantage Dental Plans

NCD Takes a Stab at Simplifying Medicare Advantage Dental Plans Alright, let's cut through the clutter and get to what's what. NCD has rolled out a new tool for Medicare Advantage plans, specifically targeting the dental benefits part. This isn't just a fancy gadget, but a real tool built from CMS data to provide some clarity in the chaotic world of health plans. We've...

Freight Rebound Sparks Strategic M&A Opportunities

Is the Freight Recovery Here to Stay? Just when you thought trucking might have run out of gas, we're hitting a sharp turn back into growth town. For those of you dropping equity crumbs every which way but loose in the last few years, this freight lull has been brutal—like the hangover from hell. But Brown Gibbons Lang & Company’s fresh report now hints at a brighter...

ARPwave Therapy: A Game Changer For Patient Recovery

New Insights in Recovery with ARPwave Therapy Getting stuck in a rehab rut is not uncommon. That's where ARPwave therapy steps in, taking an innovative approach to healing by focusing on the nervous system's role in recovery. Props to Jeff Kessler from Maximum Health Physical Therapy for shedding light on this game-changing method during an insightful piece in...

Laredo Oil Eyes Big Gains in Argentina's Oil Play

Argentina's Oil Play: Laredo Oil's Bold Venture Talk about shooting for the stars. Laredo Oil's second tête-à-tête with Santa Cruz Province's big wigs highlights their itch to rejuvenate Argentina's tired oil fields. For folks who know the nitty-gritty of oil, we're talking about the Golfo San Jorge Basin, a place where old dogs might learn new tricks thanks to that...