Why Smart People Still Believe Conspiracy Theories By

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board

Nov 19, 2017 at 10:26 AM 125

Quote:

Why Smart People Still Believe Conspiracy Theories

By Jeffrey Kluger

http://time.com/5023383/conspiracy-theories-r...tter-brief

November 14, 2017

Millions of Americans believe in conspiracy theories — including plenty of people who you might expect would be smart enough to know better.

Despite mountains of scientific evidence to the contrary, at least 20% of Americans still believe in a link between vaccines and autism, and at least 37% think global warming is a hoax, according to a 2015 analysis. Even more of us accept the existence of the paranormal: 42% believe in ghosts and 41% in extrasensory perception. And those numbers are stable.

A 2014 study by conspiracy experts Joseph Uscinski of the University of Miami and Joseph Parent of Note Dame University surveyed 100,000 letters sent to the New York Times and the Chicago Tribune from 1890 to 2010 and found that the percentage that argued for one conspiracy theory or another had barely budged over time.

Now, a study published online in the journal Personality and Individual Differences provides new insights into why so many of us believe in things that just aren’t true: In some cases, we simply want to believe.

In the first part of the two-part study, psychologists Thomas Ståhl of the University of Illinois at Chicago and Jan-Willem van Proojien of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam recruited 343 people online and had them complete surveys related to the so-called Importance of Rationality Scale (IRS) and the Morality of Rationality Scale (MRS).

In the IRS test, they were asked to agree on a scale of 1 to 7 with a series of statements such as, “It is important to me personally to be skeptical about claims that are not backed up by evidence.”

For the MRS, the survey included statements like, “Being skeptical about about claims that are not backed up by evidence is a moral virtue.” The people were also asked a number of questions designed to measure their Analytic Cognitive Style (ACS), which basically looks for how much they base conclusions on the presence of facts as opposed to on intuitive leaps.

Finally, the investigators asked the same participants to rate their belief on a 1 to 7 scale in several familiar conspiracy theories — the moon landings were faked, the government had advance warning of the 9/11 attacks — and in broader conspiracy statements such as, “There are secret organizations that greatly influence political decisions.”

Belief in six different paranormal phenomena, including reincarnation and astrology, were measured the same way.

The second study was similar but also sought to correlate belief in conspiracy theories and the paranormal with overall cognitive ability. To determine this, the people answered a number of questions that measured their numeracy — or basic mathematical skills — and their language abilities.

Both studies pointed in more or less the same direction. High scores in cognitive style (the ACS) were associated with low scores in conspiracy or paranormal beliefs, no surprise since those participants rely on hard facts before reaching a conclusion.

But the ACS itself wasn’t enough. People also had to score high in the Importance of Rational Thought (IRS) scale, suggesting that not only did they think rationally, but that they considered that fact an important personal quality. The MRS — the measure of rationality as a moral good — had less impact here.

“A likely explanation,” the researchers wrote, “is that the MRS primarily predicts social judgments and behaviors, but not privately held beliefs.”

In the second study, cognitive ability did seem to play a role in making belief in the paranormal less likely, but only among people who also scored high on analytic style. The second study’s findings regarding conspiracy theories were less conclusive.

What’s most troubling — and a little mystifying — is the fact is that so many people in the studies score high on all of the rational and intellectual metrics and yet nonetheless subscribe to disproven theories.

That’s the case in the real world too, where highly educated people traffic in conspiratorial nonsense that you’d think they’d reject. In these cases, the study concluded, the reason may simply be that they’re invested—emotionally, ideologically—in believing the conspiracies, and they use their considerable cognitive skills to persuade themselves that what’s untrue is actually true.

If you want to believe vaccines are dangerous or that the political party to which you don’t belong is plotting the ruination of America, you’ll build yourself a credible case.

There’s a lesson here for all of us: It’s not enough just to have the ability to think analytically, but the inclination to do so too. A little more cold, rational thought may not only help us free ourselves from the silliness of conspiracies, but open us to new ideas.

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Lincoln's Legal Tangle: Stock Plunge Sparks Lawsuit

Lincoln Educational's Troubles Unravel You think you've seen it all, then boom—Lincoln Educational Services hit the skids with their stock diving close to 25% back in August 2026. This ain't your usual small hiccup; we’re talking a lawsuit filed and investors eyeing action as miserly as a broker when the market tumbles. News like this? It shakes the rafters of any...

Network Brainiacs Expands Footprint into Maryland Market

Network Brainiacs Steps into Maryland Territory If you're in the tech services game, expansion stories are the bread and butter of this business. Network Brainiacs, a seasoned veteran in the managed IT and cybersecurity sectors, has taken their first big step into Maryland by acquiring Computer Enhancement Systems (CES), a notable player in the field, as of September 1,...

LAZ Parking and indiGOtech's Bold EV Charging Move

EV Chargers: The Future Parked Closer? I've been around the block more times than a cabbie in Manhattan rush hour, and let me tell you, when it comes to EVs, folks are still playing catch-up. But here's a kicker—LAZ Parking and indiGOtech have decided they're not gonna wait around. This joint venture of theirs aims to sock some sense into the old condo complex parking...

DARPA Pumps $10.7M into RxMP's Hemorrhage Control Drug

RxMP Therapeutics Lands a DARPA Deal Would you look at that—RxMP Therapeutics just got handed a load of cash thanks to some good old government backing. Up to $10.7 million from DARPA is no chump change. It's like finding a lifeboat right when you're treading water out there in the big bad sea. This award under the RAPIID program is set to move the needle for RxMP’s...

PrecisePK Celebrates 40 Years of Revolution in Dosing

Forty Years of Changing the Game There’s something to be said for sticking around in an industry for four decades. PrecisePK, a name that's become synonymous with precision dosing, has been revolutionizing how pharmacists do their jobs since 1985. This isn’t just a company resting on its laurels; it’s at the forefront of technological integration in healthcare....

PetroCal Drives Dual Mandate for Orlando Car Wash

PetroCal's Double Play in the Real Estate Game When you've been in this game as long as I have, you learn to keep an eye on players who can juggle multiple roles. And that's exactly what PetroCal Associates has pulled off with the Tommy's Express Car Wash project in Orlando. This isn't just another carwash setup, folks. We're talking about integrating into Unicorp...

Hyliion Faces Legal Whirlwind After Stock Tumbles 19.3%

Battered by Allegations: Hyliion in Legal Crosshairs Here's a hot mess Hyliion's found itself in. Amidst allegations of deception, the stock has dropped a hefty 19.3%. For anyone keeping tabs on this one, the legal eagles over at The Law Offices of Frank R. Cruz have swooped in, announcing a class action that's got all the trimmings of your classic securities mess. The...

Kat Florence Hotels Offers Unique $20K Wine Tastings

Luxury Retreat Offering Free Rare Wine Tastings The world of high-end hospitality just got a bit more intoxicating, literally. As of October 20, guests at the Elora luxury retreat, part of the Kat Florence Hotels portfolio, can indulge in some of the most coveted wines on the planet—gratis. That's right, wine aficionados can thank Kat Florence's latest extravagant...

Industrial Defender Boosts OT Cybersecurity Capabilities

OT Cybersecurity Takes a Step Forward So today, it’s all about this new roll-out by Industrial Defender. Just another tool shedding light in those dim corners of network security for critical infrastructure operators. Honestly, these folks have been at this for quite some time—talking 20 years uphill and still pushing. From Anomalies to Action Their latest magic?...

AST SpaceMobile Faces Investor Turbulence Amid Concerns

AST SpaceMobile's Unsteady Ground Let's dig into the wild ride AST SpaceMobile (NASDAQ: ASTS) has found itself on. These folks have been taking punches from every direction, from Wall Street's bean counters to hostile market winds. It all started when Scotiabank slapped them with a 'Sell' rating on January 6, 2026, pointing fingers at their faltering position against...