dw, The Left's Endgame of Gnostic Activism By Jeffrey

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone
151
dw,
The Left's Endgame of Gnostic Activism
By Jeffrey Folks February 18, 2017

< >

With the left's scorched-earth strategy in response to the Trump administration, we have entered a new stage of politics.

Some, including the great German philosopher Eric Voegelin, would point to that strategy as proof that we have entered the end stage of progressive activism. When progressives would rather see the country fail than admit defeat, we are in serious difficulty.

Voegelin, who fled Nazi Germany in 1938, devoted his life to understanding the rise of modern statist culture, a development he saw as part of a larger tendency toward Gnosticism in Western culture. Derived from the name of an early Christian sect who claimed secret knowledge of divine mysteries, Gnosticism is indeed a dangerously "knowing" attitude toward the world.

In its modern emanation, Gnosticism assumes that human agency can perfect society through centralized control and regulation. Its checkered history includes everything from 19th-century social experiments based on the thinking of Charles Fourier and Robert Owen to 20th-century debacles including Hitler's Third Reich and Mao's Great Leap Forward.

Traditional ideas of human fallibility and limitation, a central tenet of all major religions, implied a foundation of humility and thankfulness toward the Creator. Modern Gnostics substituted a boundless confidence in human capabilities, giving rise to a false religion with man, not God, at the center. Not surprisingly, their efforts involved grandiose schemes designed to remake society and even, as they believed, to "transform" human nature through re-education and indoctrination. Lenin, Hitler, Mao, Castro, Kim Il-sung, and Pol Pot come to mind, among many others. A common thread is an arrogant abuse of power and a disdain for the well-being of ordinary people, who were willingly sacrificed on the altar of social engineering.

In Voegelin's mind, progressivism always leads to antidemocratic and tyrannical forms of governance. Voegelin defined totalitarianism as "the existential rule of Gnostic activists," itself "the end form of progressive civilization" (New Science of Politics, Chicago: 1987, page 132). Voegelin understood that the aim of progressivism is always the seizure of absolute and permanent power as the means of social transformation. Progressives view the election of Donald Trump as an anomaly that stands in the way of their rightful control of the political system. No wonder they have responded with violence and obstructionism. When the Senate minority leader vows to block nearly every Trump appointee, sight unseen, we know we have entered a new stage of political division.

One doesn't have to look far to see where Gnosticism is leading us. Voegelin, who was born in Cologne, Germany and lived from 1901 to 1985, witnessed the defeat of Germany in WWI, the ruinous turmoil of the Weimar period, the rise of fascism, and the annihilation of Germany in WWII. He was fortunate enough to have escaped to the U.S., where he taught at several prestigious universities. He lived long enough, however, to witness the resurgence of progressivism in the U.S. under Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon, and Jimmy Carter.

It is not difficult to predict what Voegelin would have thought of the Great Society as defined in Johnson's speech at the University of Michigan on May 22, 1964, in which Johnson declared that the "city of man" is "marching" toward an ever brighter future filled with "new [social] experiments." Of special import to LBJ, along with urban planning and environmentalism, was the nation's classrooms, in which "your children's lives will be shaped" (not at home or at church, but in the classroom). In order to establish the "new world" our ancestors envisioned, Johnson pledged to "assemble the best thought and the broadest knowledge from all over the world to find those answers for America." Johnson's Great Society speech was a call to arms for the young generation of the sixties. "Your generation has been appointed, by history ... to lead America toward a new age," LBJ declared.

Another major document in the history of Gnosticism was Obama's first inaugural speech. Here Obama committed to "the work of remaking America." In a telling phrase, Obama declared that " he question we ask today is not whether our government is too big or too small, but whether it works." In other words, don't concern yourself with government becoming "too big." Obama's version of Gnostic activism preserved the goals of centralized control of education and the environment and added those of global universalism, multiculturalism, and unilateral disarmament.

Many Americans now live in fear of a government they despise. They are right to be fearful and right to despise it. Our federal government as it now exists would have been unimaginable to the Founders, who envisioned a small executive under the personal administration of the president working alongside and constrained by a Congress and judicial branch, each of these constrained by the Constitution. Our federal leviathan is precisely what Washington and Jefferson warned of. With his European experience and vast reading, Professor Voegelin was able to place this phenomenon of government expansion in the context of the broader tendency that he labeled Gnosticism.

At its heart, Gnosticism is driven by a dangerous confidence in the power of humans to control the world in which they live. It is one thing to have created the wonders of modern medicine, the labor-saving technology of the computer, and the advances of modern-day agriculture. It is quite another to pretend that a small, unelected ruling elite, all of them educated at the same universities and sharing the same predilections, should presume to govern by edict and court order.

How will it be with a president who promises to go "much further," as Hillary Clinton did in the recent campaign? Obama's executive actions, as bad as they were, were just the preamble – testing the waters for a full-scale assault. The end form of progressive civilization will not be, as some assume, a nonviolent democratic welfare state. It will be a vast government bureaucracy through which the State, turning its vast powers against the people, will govern all aspects of life.

The vehement reaction of the left to Trump's victory is evidence of how deeply engrained this vision of the future has become among progressives. It is foolish to imagine that, having poisoned half of our population, Gnostic activism will somehow dissipate under a Trump administration that itself betrays more than its share of Gnostic leanings. It is more likely that Gnosticism will continue to metastasize until it largely controls American political life. A full-blown progressive government, of which the Obama administration was a fair taste, would completely abandon constitutional limits in the service of what it deems the "higher purposes" of social equality or some other rationale. The particular rationale is irrelevant – power is what matters to progressives.

At that point, all constitutional liberties will have been lost, and we will subsist at the whim of a progressive elite dedicated to "perfecting" society, as they see it. That end point will constitute, as Voegelin predicted long ago based on his observation of earlier totalitarian movements, "the end form of progressive civilization." At that point, America will endure a catastrophe similar to what every other progressive state has done in the past. As Voegelin noted, "Gnostic politics is self-defeating in so far as its disregard for the structure of reality leads to continuous warfare" (quoted in Enrico Peppe, "Eric Voegelin: Science, Politics, and Gnosticism," The Intellectual Conservative, November 2, 2003). Following the catastrophe, with "the change of generations," Voegelin believed, Gnosticism might at last be abandoned. That was one alternative. The other was "horrible physical destruction" and unpredictable and ominous alterations in the social order.

Gnostic politics leads inevitably to "warfare" of one sort or another. Is not America, now divided into two great factions, already at war? In the end, Gnosticism triggers a debacle, and what follows, as Voegelin understood, is unpredictable. This, I fear, is the tragic path of American life over the next thirty years.



Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Memorial Manor's Five-Star Signal in Long-Term Care

Updated Category News Views 106

Care quality is the only score that matters here A nursing home recognition is not the sort of news anybody should read like a trophy-case press release and then forget by lunch. Families make decisions around long-term care when they are tired, worried, and often dealing with a parent or spouse whose needs have changed fast. In that setting, a facility putting up both a...

Continue Reading
ASUS Brings AI Infrastructure Choices to SC26 Floor

Updated Category News Views 154

Compute buyers are sick of being handed one locked box That is the nerve ASUS is pressing at SC26: enterprises want AI infrastructure that fits the job in front of them, not somebody else's tidy product roadmap. The company is pitching a full-stack “AI Factory” blueprint built across Intel, AMD and NVIDIA hardware, running from rack-scale systems and conventional...

Continue Reading
Avelo Tests Loyalty Math With WeSalute Fare Discounts

Updated Category News Views 81

Airline discounts can look like generosity until the load factor starts talking back. Avelo Airlines has joined WeSalute with fare discounts for active-duty military members, veterans, first responders, nurses, medical professionals, public servants, teachers and eligible family members. It is a sensible move for a young carrier built around smaller airports and lower...

Continue Reading
AES Clears FERC, Nearing Its December 2 Takeover Close

Updated Category News Views 10

One more regulatory gate just swung open for AES, and this deal is finally staring at the finish line instead of wandering through the usual approval swamp. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has issued its final order approving AES's acquisition by a consortium led by Global Infrastructure Partners, part of BlackRock, and EQT Infrastructure VI. The last major...

Continue Reading
Radiate Holdco's Q3 Results: What We Know Now

Updated Category News Views 117

Digging Into Third Quarter Highlights Radiate Holdco, LLC has just thrown its third-quarter financial hat into the ring, stirring up some interest in the world of FLFO secured notes and senior notes. The folks in Princeton, N.J., sure know how to keep things exclusive—this intel is only for those holding their Notes or in the pretty exclusive club of qualified...

Continue Reading
Sola's 11-Step Push Makes Salon Ownership Less Blind

Updated Category News Views 97

A pristine studio does not pay rent by itself. That is the uncomfortable little truth sitting underneath Sola Salons’ new 11-step roadmap for beauty professionals considering salon-suite ownership. The company is telling stylists, estheticians, nail technicians, massage therapists, and other independent operators to treat the move from commission work to ownership like...

Continue Reading
Abacus Global Faces Scrutiny Over Accounting Practices

Updated Category News Views 0

Storm Clouds Gather over Abacus Global Management If it ain't one thing, it's another—at least that's what folks holding the bag with Abacus Global (ABX) are thinking right now. News of a pending investigation has dropped like a lead balloon, and the air is thick with scrutiny over their financial dealings. We're jawing about related-party transactions now under the...

Continue Reading
Labcorp's Brazil Trial Push Has Promise and Plenty to Prove

Updated Category News Views 24

Brazilian clinical-trial kit deliveries may soon spend less time tangled in international shipping. That is the practical heart of Labcorp's newly announced collaboration with Grupo Fleury, and frankly, practical is plenty good in this business. Labcorp plans to begin assembling clinical-trial kits locally in Brazil in early 2027, then add laboratory operations by the end...

Continue Reading
A Faded Sign Is a Quiet Leak in Storefront Demand Today

Updated Category News Views 31

Sunlight does not care what the marketing budget said. A storefront can have a decent product, a clean interior and a capable crew, then lose the first impression before anyone reaches the door because its sign looks tired. That is the plainspoken point behind FASTSIGNS' latest guidance on outdoor sign lifespan. This is not glamorous stuff, but it is operationally...

Continue Reading
Unishippers Climbs 18 Slots on 32.4% Sales Growth Run

Updated Category News Views 50

Thirty new franchise units can move the needle fast Unishippers did not inch its way up the Franchise Times Top 400; it put up a number that deserves a hard look. Sales rose 32.4% in 2025, the company added 30 franchise units, and the result was an 18-place jump to No. 81 on the 2026 ranking. In the shipping category, it was named the sales-growth leader. For a business...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

The Exclusion of XRP from Trump's Crypto Reserve Explained

Updated Category News Views 679

Understanding the Strategic Crypto Reserve Exclusion The cryptocurrency world was recently shaken when President Donald Trump issued an executive order that left notable omissions. Among these was XRP, a digital asset that Ripple and its supporters had hoped to see included in a U.S. sovereign crypto reserve. The Ripple Effects of Trump's Order After investing heavily in...

Continue Reading
UKG Stands Out as a Top Leader in Workforce Management Solutions

Updated Category News Views 168

UKG Secures Top Spot in Workforce Management UKG, a leading provider in HR, payroll, workforce management, and cultural solutions, has recently earned recognition for its exceptional contributions to the workforce management field. The company has been named a Leader in the NelsonHall New World Workforce Management 2024 evaluation, showcasing its strong performance across...

Continue Reading
Zillow Unveils Innovative AI Virtual Staging for Listings

Updated Category News Views 283

Zillow Introduces AI-Powered Virtual Staging In an exciting development for real estate, Zillow has recently launched an innovative feature known as Virtual Staging. This tool harnesses the power of artificial intelligence to enhance how listings are showcased, making the home-buying experience even more engaging for potential buyers. Creating a Visual Experience for Home...

Continue Reading
Balchem Corporation: Innovating Health and Nutrition Solutions

Updated Category News Views 296

Balchem Corporation's Upcoming Conference Presentation Balchem Corporation, a prominent global manufacturer known for its specialty ingredients aimed at health and nutrition markets, is set to make a significant presentation at an upcoming virtual conference. The CJS Securities New Ideas for the New Year Virtual Conference will feature notable company figures, including...

Continue Reading
Projected Growth of Cottonseed Oilseed Processing Market

Updated Category News Views 85

Overview of Cottonseed Oilseed Processing Market Growth The cottonseed oilseed processing market is experiencing significant growth, projected to reach $7.7 billion within a decade, showcasing a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 6.8%. The increasing demand for vegetable oils, primarily for their versatility and cost-effectiveness, plays a crucial role in this market's...

Continue Reading