Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB's Decision Sealing Mitchell

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
News Desk 2018
52
Federal Circuit Affirms PTAB's Decision Sealing Mitchell Victory in Audatex Patent Lawsuit

SAN DIEGO, CA--(Marketwired - Aug 9, 2017) - Mitchell International, a leading provider of technology, connectivity and information solutions to the Property & Casualty (P&C)  claims and Collision Repair industries, has announced that the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the Patent Trial and Appeal Board's (PTAB) February 2016 decision invalidating all three patents in Audatex North America Inc.'s patent infringement lawsuit asserted against Mitchell, agreeing that the Audatex patents are abstract and not inventive.

Audatex, a unit of Solera Holdings, Inc., sued Mitchell in February 2012 alleging that Mitchell's WorkCenter software infringed three Audatex patents. The Audatex patents detailed a business process for using the internet to process insurance claims including total loss valuations. Before the PTAB, Mitchell asserted that the Audatex patents simply use well-known technology to generate valuation reports for damaged cars, and are not directed to improving a computer's functionality.

In February 2016, the PTAB sided with Mitchell and invalidated all three Audatex patents as abstract under the U.S. Supreme Court's Alice Corp. decision, in which the high court ruled that abstract ideas implemented using a computer are not patent eligible. The PTAB also decided each of the claims in all three Audatex patents were both anticipated and obvious.

Audatex appealed portions of the PTAB's decision to the Federal Circuit. After receiving briefing and hearing oral arguments, on July 27, the Federal Circuit affirmed the PTAB's invalidation of all three Audatex patents. In its written decision, the Federal Circuit fully backed Mitchell's arguments and rejected all of the appeal issues raised by Audatex. "The proposed claims recite nothing more than the collection of information to generate a valuation report for a damaged vehicle with the aid of well-known technology," the opinion reads. "They embody an abstract idea that merely uses a computer and generic components as tools to collect these data and generate reports."

"To see the Federal Circuit affirm the PTAB's decisions so quickly after oral argument is welcome news for Mitchell," said Stephanie Kroon, Senior Vice President, General Counsel and Secretary at Mitchell. "We believed from early in the case that Audatex's claims against Mitchell had no merit and the Federal Circuit has confirmed our position. This decision is a complete victory for Mitchell."

For further collision repair and property casualty industry updates and perspectives, follow Mitchell on Twitter @Mitchell_Intl , @MitchellClaims , @MitchellRepair ,  @MitchellPBM and LinkedIn .

About Mitchell International Headquartered in San Diego, California, Mitchell International, Inc. delivers smart technology solutions that simplify and accelerate claims handling and repair processes, driving more accurate, consistent and cost-effective resolutions. Mitchell integrates deep industry expertise into its workflow solutions, providing unparalleled access to data, advanced analytics and decision support tools. Mitchell's comprehensive solution portfolio and robust SaaS infrastructure connect its customers in ways that enable tens of millions of electronic transactions to be processed each month for more than 300 insurance companies, over 30,000 collision repair facilities and countless other Property & Casualty industry supply partners across the Americas and Europe. For more information, please visit www.mitchell.com .

Contact: Brianna Bruinsma LEWIS PR for Mitchell 619-677-2700 Mitchell@teamlewis.com

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Teamsters Ratify Contract, Averting Waste Strike

Updated Category News Views 117

Big Win for Teamsters Local 350 You ever seen a strike averted by sheer willpower and unity? That’s what's happened here with the workers at South San Francisco Scavenger Company. These folks—drivers, mechanics, sorters, and utility workers—all banded together under the Teamsters Local 350 and showed management what's what by securing a contract they deserve. We're...

Continue Reading
Duolingo Faces Class Action: Key Investor Steps

Updated Category News Views 162

Navigating Turbulent Times with Duolingo Holy moly, the dumpster fire that is the Duolingo (NASDAQ:DUOL) legal saga just got hotter. If you snagged yourself some shares between May 2, 2025, and February 26, 2026, you'd better sit down and grab some antacids—because the nauseating roller coaster is far from over. Robbins LLP is rounding up the troops for a class action,...

Continue Reading
Apani Adds Kelsun Assets to Its Natural Fiber Platform

Updated Category News Views 29

A materials deal with more chemistry than chest-thumping Seaweed and cotton have landed under one roof, which is a lot more interesting than another apparel brand slapping a green label on ordinary fabric. Apani said November 17 it acquired the assets of Keel Labs, bringing Keel's seaweed-based Kelsun fiber alongside Apani's enhanced cotton-cellulose filament technology....

Continue Reading
PawnMate Boosts Inventory Efficiency for Pawnshops

Updated Category News Views 213

RFID Technology: Breathing New Life into Pawnshops Let's get things rolling with the cold, hard truth that pawnshops aren't exactly what most folks expect when it comes to cutting-edge technology. But times are a-changin', and PawnMate’s RFID Inventory Module is the latest twist in this industry storyline. It's like swapping out a rusty toolbox for a brand-new set of...

Continue Reading
Philadelphia Firm Targets 100 Toys for Children This Holiday

Updated Category News Views 90

A hundred unopened toys can look modest on paper, yet that is exactly why this Philadelphia effort lands differently than the usual chest-thumping corporate charity chatter. van der Veen, Hartshorn & Levin has set a clear holiday target: collect 100 new, unwrapped toys for children in the Philadelphia area through the U.S. Marine Corps Reserve Toys for Tots program. No...

Continue Reading
CSMI Boosts CT's Cybersecurity for Defense Sector

Updated Category News Views 132

Paving the Way for Cybersecurity Excellence Out in chilly Connecticut, CSMI made a mark. The State's Office of Manufacturing picked them to join the advisory council for the Defense CyberSecure Program (CT-DCP). It ain’t just a pat on the back; it's a big deal for the region's defense and aerospace manufacturing gang. Connecticut's got its eyes set on beefing up its...

Continue Reading
Greenberg Traurig Cheers Clients' 69th GRAMMY® Nods

Updated Category News Views 101

A Momentous Occasion for Greenberg Traurig's Entertainment Clients Oh, the glamour and glitz of the music world! There's nothing quite like the GRAMMY® Awards to stir up a blend of excitement, ego, and anxiety in the industry. This time around, the lawyers over at Greenberg Traurig are beaming with pride as their clients scoop up nominations for the 69th Annual GRAMMY®...

Continue Reading
AR Cards in Casino Gaming: A High-Stakes Revolution

Updated Category News Views 138

A New Breed of Casino Experience Walk into a casino today, and you might just enter a whole new reality. No, this isn’t a cheesy magician’s trick or a glitzy PR stunt—this is the real deal brought to you by augmented reality (AR) trading cards. Imagine the slots you love wrapped in a sci-fi movie where characters leap out, tap you on the shoulder, and call you by...

Continue Reading
Wall Street Gains Hold Amid Volatility Drop

Updated Category News Views 66

A Week of Gains and Regulatory Moves Right out of the gate, it’s been a decent stretch for Wall Street. Weekly gains kept the party going, even as traders navigated the usual hurdles. Stocks finished the week with a solid performance—all the heavy hitters like Dow, S&P 500, Nasdaq, and Russell 2000 ended on a high note, waltzing uphill past where many imagined...

Continue Reading
Lennar Faces Securities Fraud Lawsuit: Investor Insights

Updated Category News Views 208

Investors in Lennar: Navigating the Legal Storm Hold onto your hats, folks. Lennar Corporation (NYSE: LEN) is up against it with a brand-spanking-new securities fraud lawsuit helmed by Schall, Brown & Schwartz LLP (SBS). This isn't just a couple of investors grumbling over cocktails; it’s a full-blown class action that’s waving the legal banner under the Securities...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Soka Gakkai International's Commitment to Peace and Dialogue

Updated Category News Views 482

Soka Gakkai International Empowers Dialogue at Peace Forum Recently, Soka Gakkai International (SGI) announced its participation in a significant event dedicated to peace and dialogue. This forum will take place following a prestigious Nobel Peace Prize ceremony where the Association of Hibakusha will receive accolades for their enduring advocacy for world peace. A Forum...

Continue Reading
Harnessing AI for Effortless Image and Video Creation with Sisi

Updated Category News Views 369

Revolutionizing Visual Content Creation with AI In an age where digital visuals play a crucial role in communication, Fotor stands out as a pioneer in enhancing creativity with technological prowess. The company has recently introduced the Fotor AI Agent, affectionately known as Sisi, an innovative AI-powered assistant geared to simplify the process of creating images and...

Continue Reading
China Hour Expands Chinese Media Footprint in Africa

Updated Category News Views 51

An Ambitious Cross-Continental Media Play The airwaves are getting a new twist. This time, it's a blend of cultures, as China Hour makes an entrance in South Africa. That's right, folks—Jiangsu Broadcasting Corporation (JSBC) has set up camp alongside the South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC), pushing a big media wave across the continent. If you've been...

Continue Reading
BlockFills Enhances Liquidity for Institutional Traders in Crypto

Updated Category News Views 209

BlockFills Partners with CoinDesk Indices for Enhanced Market Liquidity BlockFills, a prominent player in the digital assets sector, is making strides to improve liquidity in the cryptocurrency market. Its recent collaboration with CoinDesk Indices aims to establish an institutional-grade options market, particularly targeting the CoinDesk 20 Index. This initiative is...

Continue Reading
Understanding the Recent Options Trends with Airbnb (NASDAQ: ABNB)

Updated Category News Views 101

Airbnb's Options Activity Explained Investors are eyeing Airbnb (NASDAQ: ABNB) with a fair amount of skepticism lately. Notably, there has been a noteworthy increase in bearish options activity, a trend that could indicate potential shifts in market dynamics that traders should not take lightly. Our observations reveal significant insights into how savvy players are...

Continue Reading