Facebook's IPO: Thoughts On Momentum, Pricing And Valuation

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Stock Buff

Facebook's IPO: Thoughts On Momentum, Pricing And Valuation (It's Still No Buy)

Guest post written by Aswath Damodaran

Aswath Damodaran is Professor of Finance at the Stern School of Business at New York University.

Aswath Damodaran

Now that the Facebook IPO is behind us, though the hype and the debate about the offering will continue for the weeks to come, it is time to step back and make an assessment of its value as a company, how it was priced and what may have gone awry.

Let’s start with this: yes, Facebook can be valued.

Facebook is a company with tremendous potential, with two key drivers of value: an immense user base and unparalleled information about these users. The question is whether they can convert this potential into profits, and if so, how quickly. In its IPO filing in February, Facebook reported 2011 pre-tax operating profits of $1.8 billion on revenues of $3.7 billion, making it, by far, the largest and most profitable of the social media companies. Here are four key value drivers for Facebook:

  • Revenue growth : Facebook has been on a steep growth path, with revenues growing 150% in 2009 and 88% in 2010, but the drop off in revenue growth from 2010 to 2011 suggests that growth will moderate. If the company can maintain a compounded revenue growth of 40% for the next 5 years, with growth rates scaling down after that towards the growth rate of the economy, the firm will have revenues of $44 billion in ten years, which would put it on the same growth path as Google in its first years as a public company.
  • Operating margins : Facebook’s current operating margin of 45.68% is mind-boggling and likely to decline as revenues get larger. If Facebook is able to maintain a pre-tax margin of 35% (close to Apple’s, and higher than Google’s) as a mature company, it would be pulling off a very difficult feat.
  • Cost of growth : As Facebook’s revenue grows, it will find itself under pressure to pay more for this growth. In fact, its acquisitions of Tagtile , Glancee and especially Instagram (for $1 billion) in the three months since the initial S-1 filing suggest that the company will be aggressive in its pursuit of growth, which is both good news (for those seeking growth) and bad news (for those worried about the cost of that growth).
  • High risk : There is significant risk in the company. In valuing the company,  we use a cost of capital of 11.42%, which would put Facebook in the top quartile of publicly traded U.S. firms in terms of risk.

These inputs yield a value of equity for Facebook of about $70 billion, and a value per share of $29. Assuming a company will grow like Google and have margins like Apple is, by definition, optimistic and this value would be at the upper end of my range. Assuming a more rocky road to scaling up and lower profitability will deliver a value in the $20-$25 range.

Some may disagree with me on my basic assumptions, either viewing them as over optimistic or over pessimistic, but I think a discussion centered on growth, profitability and the cost of growth is not only a healthy one but one that we should be having about all young, growth companies.

I would use this framework to challenge two oft-stated views about these companies: (a) that they cannot be valued today because the future is too uncertain or (b) that they must be worth very little because they don’t have significant earnings today. The first is a cop-out, since not making estimates is not going to make uncertainty go away, and the second will leave you on the sidelines with any young, growth company.

Facebook has been a quasi-public company for a couple of years now, thanks to the rise of the private share market. The company traded in this market fro months before the investment banking syndicate priced it at $38 a share last Thursday. Much as I would like to believe that the pricing of Facebook in the IPO was based upon an assessment of the fundamentals, I am a realist. Much of what passes for valuation on Wall Street and corporate boardrooms is not valuation, but pricing.

Put bluntly, the investment bankers spent the bulk of the last week surveying investors, trying to get a sense of what they would pay, rather than assessing what Facebook was worth.

In hindsight, Facebook was priced right on Friday morning, but valued wrong. That may sound odd, given what the stock has done since, but I think it indicates one of the dangers of pricing stocks. You are trying to play the momentum game, and it is one that can shift on you quickly. I am surprised that it happened so soon after the offering, but the bankers and the company not only overplayed their hands with the extended hype and the hiking up of the offering price, but were undercut by insiders cashing out in the days leading up to it. While I would love to point to the decline in the stock price since the offering as evidence that the market is cognizant of value, I think it is more the consequence of momentum investors, disappointed in their inability to make money from the promised IPO pop, heading for the exits.

While we can debate what Facebook’s value is and whether investment bankers mispriced the stock, there can be no debate on the fact that the corporate governance at the company is abysmal. From the decision to incorporate as a “controlled” corporation to issuing shares to the public with diluted voting rights, the message has been sent that this is Zuckerberg’s company and that stockholders are just capital providers. Here is why we should care: Facebook has a great product but it is not a great company, not yet. To become one, it will have to navigate challenges in scaling up growth, while maintaining profitability and controlling costs. Like all businesses, the top managers will stumble along the way, and unless challenged, will not see the need to adapt.

With its user base, Facebook has the ingredients to generate sizable profits down the road, albeit with substantial risks along the way. At the right price, I would buy the company, notwithstanding the uncertainty about the future.

At the IPO offering price or even at the price at which it is trading at right now, I would not.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/ericsavitz/2012/0...ll-no-buy/

Meta Platforms, Inc. (META) Stock Research Links

META Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Hyster-Yale's $125 Million Convertible Debt Shuffle

Updated Category News Views 86

Forklifts do not make headlines often, but debt terms sure can. Hyster-Yale has proposed a $125 million private offering of convertible senior notes due November 15, 2031, with buyers able to take another $18.75 million if the initial purchasers exercise their option. For NYSE:HY holders, this is not a victory lap or a distress flare by itself. It is a refinancing...

Continue Reading
Hanon's BMW Thermal Win Matters Beyond the Trophy Case Today

Updated Category News Views 152

A 16-Kilogram Box Just Grabbed the Auto Supply Chain’s Attention Hanon Systems did not win these two 2026 PACE honors by polishing up some old hose-and-valve package. Its Highly Integrated Cooling Entity, or HICE, is aimed right at a stubborn electric-vehicle problem: keeping a vehicle’s thermal systems controlled without turning the architecture into a sprawling,...

Continue Reading
Historic China-Russia-US Summit Aims for Global Stability

Updated Category News Views 91

The Weight of History in Shenzhen When the big players decide to talk face-to-face, it's more than just a photo op. This week in Shenzhen, the leaders of China, Russia, and the United States are doing just that. And let me tell you, it's the kind of gathering that can either stabilize the gears of global politics or grease the wheels of tension. This chinwag isn't just...

Continue Reading
Health In Tech Brings a Tech Veteran Onto Its Board

Updated Category News Views 89

Board appointments rarely make the cash register ring, but they can tell you where management thinks the next bruises are coming from. Health In Tech has added Tim Cortes as an independent director, put him in charge of the Compensation Committee, and placed him on both the Audit and Nominating and Corporate Governance Committees. For an AI-enabled insurance technology...

Continue Reading
Subaru's 650-Car Anniversary Bet Is Delightfully Small

Updated Category News Views 18

Gold brake calipers may sound like a fussy correction, yet that little detail tells you exactly who Subaru is trying to please. The company has revised its announcement for the 2027 WRX tS GD25 and BRZ tS ZC15, clarifying the anniversary-model names and changing the WRX description from red-painted to gold-painted Brembo calipers. Nobody should confuse a corrected paint...

Continue Reading
Vector Adds Mesa Division 10 Veteran for Arizona Growth

Updated Category News Views 61

A toilet-partition deal rarely raises eyebrows, but this one has the sturdy logic investors ought to notice. Vector Building Products has acquired Mesa-based Partitions & Accessories Co., a Division 10 specialist that has served Arizona contractors since 1978. It is not glamorous work. It is, however, the sort of necessary, specification-driven business that gets embedded...

Continue Reading
OCEG Faces China's Demographic Test After 40 Years

Updated Category News Views 44

A school group that once opened 35 kindergartens in a year is admitting the old playbook has run its course. That is the real message behind Oriental Cambridge Education Group's 40th-anniversary talk, not the balloons and ceremonial language. OCEG operates more than 170 institutions across 39 Chinese cities, and its chairman, Yu Yue, says the next chapter will be judged...

Continue Reading
Finzly Welcomes Paul Finch to Drive BankOS Growth

Updated Category News Views 162

Finzly's Strategic Move to Boost Innovation Alright, folks, it seems Finzly means business. They just roped in Paul Finch, the brains who gave us Zelle during his stint as CEO over at Early Warning Services. This guy's been around the block with a couple of the biggest names in banking, and if his past headlines are any indicator, he's got the knack for shaking things up...

Continue Reading
Snowrise Targets the Blind Spots in CPG Sales Data

Updated Category News Views 64

A sales total can look healthy while the floorboards are quietly rotting underneath it. That is the uncomfortable CPG problem Snowrise is aiming at: brands know what moved last quarter, but often cannot identify which stores, channels, communities, or promotions actually created the result. Plenty of management teams still steer by topline revenue, net distribution gains,...

Continue Reading
Redseer's $5M Bet on Faster MENA Decision Intelligence

Updated Category News Views 87

Speed has become the expensive commodity in Middle Eastern commerce, and Redseer is putting roughly $5 million behind the idea that executives will pay to get it. Its newly launched Benchmarks MENA 2.0 platform combines proprietary market data with strategic advisory across nine MENA markets. That sounds like another corporate dashboard pitch until you consider the target...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Uptown Cheapskate and Kid to Kid Shaping the Resale Future

Updated Category News Views 413

Innovating the Resale Landscape with Uptown Cheapskate and Kid to Kid BaseCamp Franchising is witnessing a remarkable transformation in the retail sector through its brands, Uptown Cheapskate and Kid to Kid. With over 260 stores across various U.S. states and additional international locations, these brands are redefining thrift shopping by merging the thrill of the hunt...

Continue Reading
Midea's Indoor Hybrid Heat Pump Revolutionizes Home Heating

Updated Category News Views 348

Midea’s Innovative CirQHP Indoor Hybrid Heat Pump Midea, a well-known leader in the HVAC industry, has unveiled its latest creation: the CirQHP Indoor Hybrid heat pump. This cutting-edge system has been honored with the Innovative Heating Technology Gold Award at an international exhibition. The CirQHP Indoor Hybrid allows homeowners to enjoy a modern heating solution...

Continue Reading
Exploring NYC's Future Guaranteed Income Program for Residents

Updated Category News Views 168

New York City’s Guaranteed Income Initiative New York City is embarking on a transformative journey to introduce a guaranteed income program aimed at helping those in need. Planned for 2026, this program will distribute $15,800 annually to residents who are facing economic hardships. It's an innovative approach to addressing poverty and housing insecurity within the...

Continue Reading
Investigating Potential Shareholder Dilemmas for TXNM, STRR, PVBC

Updated Category News Views 145

Understanding Shareholder Rights and Legal Investigations In the evolving landscape of corporate mergers and acquisitions, shareholder rights play a crucial role. Many companies are involved in significant transactions that raise questions for their shareholders. Today, we explore multiple companies undergoing scrutiny due to potential violations related to shareholder...

Continue Reading
Legal Battle Unfolds as U.S. Steel and Nippon Steel Challenge Biden

Updated Category News Views 215

U.S. Steel and Nippon Steel Challenge Government Actions United States Steel Corp (NYSE: X) and Nippon Steel Corp have taken significant legal steps against the Biden administration after the President's decision to block their ambitious $14.9 billion merger. This action by the government has raised questions about the motivations behind the blockade. The Legal Actions...

Continue Reading