Quote:Trump created a budget with such an egregious error he would fail an economics course
• Trump's budget contains an egregious logical error.
• This is a mistake no serious business person would make.
• Trump's personal failings are now not just center stage but whole stage.
Larry Summers
Tuesday, 23 May 2017 | 1:26 PM ETCNBC.com
OMB Director: We didn't close any of the tax gap Tuesday, 23 May 2017 | 11:26 AM ET | 02:51
Details of President Trump's first budget have now been released. Much can and will be said about the dire social consequences about what is in it and the ludicrously optimistic economic assumptions it embodies.
My observation is that there appears to be a logical error of the kind that would justify failing a student in an introductory economics course.
Apparently, the budget forecasts that US growth will rise to 3.0 percent because of the Administration's policies-largely its tax cuts and perhaps also its regulatory policies. Fair enough if you believe in tooth-fairies and ludicrous supply-side economics.
Then the Administration asserts that it will propose revenue neutral tax cuts with the revenue neutrality coming in part because the tax cuts stimulate growth! This is an elementary double count. You can't use the growth benefits of tax cuts once to justify an optimistic baseline and then again to claim that the tax cuts do not cost revenue. At least you cannot do so in a world of logic.
The Trump team prides itself on its business background. This error is akin to buying a company assuming that you can make investments that will raise profits, but then, in calculating the increased profits, counting the higher revenues while failing to account for the fact that the investments would actually cost some money to make.
The revenue generated by the investments might exceed their cost (though the same is almost never true of tax cuts), but that doesn't change the fact that the investment has a cost that must be included in the accounting.
This is a mistake no serious business person would make. It appears to be the most egregious accounting error in a presidential budget in the nearly 40 years I have been tracking them.
Who knew what when? I have no doubt that there are civil servants in OMB, Treasury and CEA who do know better than this mistake. Were they cowed, ignored or shut out?
How could the Secretary of Treasury, Director of OMB and Director of the NEC allow such an elementary error? I hope the press will ferret all this out.
The President's personal failings are now not just center stage but whole stage. They should not blind us to the manifest failures of his economic team.
Whether it is Secretary Mnuchin's absurd claims about tax cuts not favoring the rich, Secretary Ross's claim that the small squib of a deal negotiated last week with China was the greatest trade result with China in history, NEC Director Cohn's ludicrous estimate of the costs of Dodd Frank, or today's budget, the Trump administration has not yet made a significant economic pronouncement that meets a minimal standard of competence and honesty.
Commentary by Larry Summers, the former Treasury Secretary and currently the Charles W. Eliot University Professor and President Emeritus at Harvard University.
Trump created a budget with such an egregious error he
Top 10 Most Recent News Articles
Mynd.ai Alters ADS Ratio Affecting Share Dynamics
Analyzing Mynd.ai's ADS Ratio Tweak When Mynd.ai decides to shake things up with the American Depositary Shares (ADS) ratio, it's like they're throwing a curveball straight at Wall Street. Listen up, this isn't just a deck shuffle—it's a fundamental tweak that could play a big role in the stock’s perceived value. Starting December 7, 2027, one ADS will leap from...
Continue Reading
Preventing Dental Issues in Kids: Valuable Tips Shared
Pediatric Dental Challenges Under the Microscope When it comes to kids and dental health, we're talking about the fundamentals—the kind that sticks around and makes a difference in their future pearly whites. None of that flashy tech gizmo stuff, just straight-on strategies for resilient chompers. Cavities, gum irritation, early tooth alignment—these are the everyday...
Continue Reading
J&J's New Study: Sjögren’s Solution Insight Sparks Debate
Patient-Centric Take on Sjögren's Disease Johnson & Johnson has dropped fresh Phase 2 results on nipocalimab, reminding everyone they're at the helm of reshaping treatments for Sjögren's disease (SjD). A condition leaving about four million folks craving better days, in multiple ways, shines a light on what's gripping patients the hardest. It's hard not to sit up and...
Continue Reading
IRTC Faces Investigation: Shares Plunge Amid Uncertainty
Securities Trouble on the Horizon: IRTC Takes a Hit Wake up and adjust your seat, folks—iRhythm Technologies (NASDAQ:IRTC) is in the spotlight, and it ain't pretty. Shares nosedived over 30% in a single morning, stirring up quite the murky waters for shareholders. The trigger? A less-than-stellar third-quarter report. The Numbers Don't Lie—Or Do They? Management...
Continue Reading
Encore Boston Harbor Workers Triumph After 62-Day Strike
Labor Standoff at Encore Boston Harbor Ends After a stormy 62 days on the picket lines, around 1,300 workers at Encore Boston Harbor finally find themselves back at their posts, carrying with them the spoils of hard-fought victory. This isn't just a paper contract; it's a banner for worker solidarity. These aren't your run-of-the-mill stock flips, folks; this fight was...
Continue Reading
Kestrel Group Faces Financial Hit Despite Revenue Growth
Kestrel's Financial Rollercoaster Continues Here's the deal with Kestrel Group, folks. They just dropped their Q3 2026 financials, and it's a mixed bag. The top line's looking solid with total revenues hitting $4.8 million, riding high on a 203% jump in Program Services fee income. But dig a little deeper, and there's a $16.4 million net loss staring us in the face....
Continue Reading
Pigeon Unveils Green Innovations at CIIE 2026
An International Celebration: Cultural Connections at CIIE Babies have a way of bringing the world together. Every culture has its own quirks and traditions, but the love for a newborn is common ground. Pigeon gets that, and they're putting it on full display at the China International Import Expo (CIIE) in Shanghai. It's their fourth run at this rodeo, and they’re not...
Continue Reading
UP Fintech Faces Class Action: Key Investor Impacts
UP Fintech's Tumultuous Ride Ever watch a stock tumble and think, "Here we go again?" That's UP Fintech Holding Limited (NASDAQ:TIGR) right now. It's staring down the barrel of a securities fraud class action lawsuit, and trust me, it's messier than yesterday's lunch special. The stock's already gone through the wringer, dropping a hefty 25.34% after some nasty news from...
Continue Reading
JOYEE N01 Kicks Off Global Launch with African Orders
A New Chapter for JOYEE N01 There's a moment in every company's life when it either steps boldly into the future or stumbles back into obscurity. For FAW Bestune, October 28, 2026, was one of those defining moments. On this day, they launched global mass production of the JOYEE N01 in Yancheng, China. And boy, did they pull out all the stops—you don't see this kind of...
Continue Reading
Paris Baguette Pioneers Drive-Thru in Oklahoma
Tapping The Unseen Potential In Bakery Cafes Every so often a business move comes along that makes you sit up and say, "Why the hell haven't they done this before?" Paris Baguette has finally cracked that code, rolling out its first-ever drive-thru in Moore, Oklahoma. Now, imagine yourself zipping through for a croissant without leaving the comfort of your car seat. Makes...
Continue ReadingTop 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles
Future Innovations in Cartoning Machines Market from 2025 Onwards
Understanding the Growth of Cartoning Machines Market As we navigate through the evolving landscape of packaging automation, the cartoning machines market demonstrates a noteworthy trajectory, poised to escalate significantly in the coming years. Currently valued at approximately USD 8.72 billion, research forecasts this market to rise to USD 13.58 billion by 2034. This...
Continue Reading
Summary of Annual Meeting Results for NB Private Equity Partners
Overview of the Annual General Meeting Results The Annual General Meeting (AGM) for NB Private Equity Partners Limited has recently concluded, bringing forth significant updates. During the meeting, held for the Class A Shareholders, every resolution on the agenda was passed without any changes, highlighting a unified direction for the company. The resolutions included a...
Continue Reading
AltaPointe Health's iPad Initiative to Combat 911 Misuse
Innovative iPad Pilot Program by AltaPointe Health AltaPointe Health has taken a remarkable step in refining how behavioral health crises are managed. In collaboration with MyCare Technologies, local police, and fire-rescue services, they have launched a new pilot program that focuses on reducing non-emergency 911 calls. This initiative is aimed specifically at improving...
Continue Reading
EBLM Urges Action Following Verdict in Daniel Penny Case
EBLM Supports the Jury's Verdict Every Black Life Matters (EBLM) expresses its support for the jury's not guilty verdict regarding Daniel Penny, emphasizing the importance of protecting others during crises. EBLM believes that rather than punishing individuals for taking action in dangerous situations, the focus should be on addressing the deeper systemic issues that...
Continue Reading
Eden's Innovative Hormone Therapy Made Accessible via Telehealth
Eden Expands Its Telehealth Services for Female Hormone Therapy Eden has recently launched an innovative telehealth offering that provides women with unprecedented access to hormone replacement therapy (HRT) options. With this development, eligible individuals can consult with licensed healthcare providers across most states in the U.S. to discuss treatment for hormonal...
Continue Reading