Trump Is Wimping Out on Trade Paul Krugman APRIL 3,

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board

Apr 3, 2017 at 1:50 PM 225

Quote:

Trump Is Wimping Out on Trade

Paul Krugman APRIL 3, 2017

During the campaign, Donald Trump talked loudly and often about how he was going to renegotiate America’s “horrible trade deals,” bringing back millions of good jobs.

So far, however, nothing has happened. Not only is Trumpist trade policy — Trumptrade? — nowhere to be seen in practice; there isn’t even any indication of what it will involve.

So on Friday the White House scheduled a ceremony in which Mr. Trump would sign two new executive orders on trade. The goal, presumably, was to counteract the growing impression that his bombast on trade was sound and fury signifying nothing.

Unfortunately, the executive orders in question were, to use the technical term, nothingburgers. One called for a report on the causes of the trade deficit; wait, they’re just starting to study the issue? The other addressed some minor issues of tariff collection, and its content apparently duplicated an act President Obama already signed last year.

Not surprisingly, reporters at the event questioned the president, not about trade, but about Michael Flynn and the Russia connection. Mr. Trump then walked out of the room — without signing the orders. (Vice President Mike Pence gathered them up, and the White House claims that they were signed later.)

The fiasco perfectly encapsulated what’s looking more and more like a failed agenda.

Business seems to have decided that Mr. Trump is a paper tiger on trade: The flow of corporate relocations to Mexico, which slowed briefly while C.E.O.s tried to curry favor with the new president, has resumed.

Trade policy by tweet, it appears, has run its course.

Investors seem to have reached the same conclusion: The Mexican peso plunged 16 percent after the election, but since Inauguration Day it has recovered almost all the lost ground.

Oh, and last week a draft proposal for revising the North American Free Trade Agreement circulated around Congress; instead of sweeping changes in what candidate Trump called the “worst trade deal” ever signed, the administration appears to be seeking only modest tweaks.

This surely isn’t what working-class Trump supporters thought they were voting for. So why can Trumpist trade policy be summarized — to quote The Times’s Binyamin Appelbaum — as “talk loudly and carry a small stick”? Let me give two reasons.

First, back when Mr. Trump was railing against trade deals, he had no idea what he was talking about. (I know, you’re shocked to hear that.)

For example, listening to the Tweeter-in-chief, you’d think that Nafta was a big giveaway by the United States, which got nothing in return. In fact, Mexico drastically cut its tariffs on goods imported from the U.S., in return for much smaller cuts on the U.S. side.

Or take Mr. Trump’s repeated claims that China gains a competitive advantage by manipulating its currency. That was true six years ago, but it’s not true now. These days China is actually intervening to keep its currency up, not down.

Talking nonsense about trade didn’t hurt Mr. Trump during the campaign. But now he’s finding out that those grossly unfair trade deals he promised to renegotiate aren’t all that unfair, after all, leaving him with no idea what to do next.

Which brings me to Trumptrade’s second big obstacle: Whatever you think of past trade agreements, trade is now deeply embedded in the economy.

Consider the case of automobiles. At this point it makes little sense to talk about a U.S. auto industry, a Canadian auto industry or a Mexican auto industry. What we have instead is a tightly integrated North American industry, in which vehicles and components crisscross the continent, with almost every finished car containing components from all three nations.

Does it have to be this way? No. Slap on 30 percent tariffs, and after a few years those national industries would separate again. But the transition would be chaotic and painful.

Economists talk, with considerable justification, about the “China shock”: the disruptive effect on jobs and communities of the rapid growth of Chinese exports from the 1990s through 2007.

But reversing globalization now would produce an equally painful “Trump shock,” disrupting jobs and communities all over again — and would also be painful for some of the big corporate interests that, strange to say, have a lot of influence in this supposedly populist regime.

The point is that at a deep level Trumptrade is running into the same wall that caused Trumpcare to crash and burn. Mr. Trump came into office talking big, sure that his predecessors had messed everything up and he — he alone — could do far better. And millions of voters believed him.

But governing America isn’t like reality TV. A few weeks ago Mr. Trump whined, “Nobody knew that health care could be so complicated.” Now, one suspects, he’s saying the same thing about trade policy.

StanC
Texas 3 hours ago

'But governing America isn’t like reality TV. A few weeks ago Mr. Trump whined, “Nobody knew that health care could be so complicated.” Now, one suspects, he’s saying the same thing about trade policy.'

A good summary. It emphasizes a basic truth regarding Trump's many utterances and tweets that are well illustrated by his comments on health care. During the campaign we were told that we'd see a healthcare-for-all-plan that would be better, cheaper, and that it would be easy to bring about.

The real message, the basic truth, was that Trump had no idea of what he was talking about. And that lack of knowledge continues with respect to nearly every other subject area. How much time has he really spent pouring over the complexities of tax plans or national budgets? As much as tweeting time?

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Temu Joins DBI to Boost Irish Digital Business Growth

You know it's a lively day when Temu, the big fish in the e-commerce pond, decides to dive into Ireland's digital waters by joining forces with Digital Business Ireland (DBI). Yeah, we're talking about more than just a handshake here. If you’re wondering why this matters, keep your ears open to the whispers of opportunity. Temu's addition isn't just a membership; it's a...

Hanwha's Big Bet: Tokenizing Real-World Assets with Chainlink

Hanwha and Chainlink: A Game Changer in Tokenization What do Hanwha Investment & Securities, a heavyweight in Korea's finance scene, and Chainlink, the wizard of onchain finance, think they're up to? They're buddies now, locked and loaded, to tokenize real-world assets (RWAs). They're not just shaking hands; they're aiming to jiggle the global finance bedrock....

JOIA Rose Hall Revives Jamaican Luxury Experience

A New Chapter for Jamaican Luxury If there's one thing that gets the blood pumping, it's a massive overhaul of a decades-old resort, especially one sitting pretty on Montego Bay's golden shores. December 1, 2026, marks the return of JOIA Rose Hall to the hospitality scene—shiny, revamped, and all about delivering an oasis fueled by authentic Jamaican culture. Forget...

Static Media Acquires CarScoops to Boost Auto Reach

Static Media's Latest Move in the Automotive Arena The digital media landscape keeps morphing, and Static Media just decided to crank up the gears a notch by snapping up CarScoops.com. For those with an eye on the automotive field, it's the kind of play that could shift the tides. Static Media, already a heavyweight with brands like Jalopnik and SlashGear under its belt,...

Anguilla: Paradise for Safe, Solo Beach Escapes

A Safe Haven for Solo Adventurers You ever dream of escaping to a place where the world slows down and serenity reigns supreme? Somewhere you can kick back, soak up the sun, listen to the waves, and leave your worries behind? Well, folks, Tranquility Beach Anguilla fits that bill and then some. Why Anguilla Tops the List Let's talk about the accolades Anguilla has raked...

Solink Secures $100M: NYSE Sees Tech and Sports Moves

Folks, it’s a busy day on Wall Street, with Solink leading the charge by landing over a cool $100 million in fresh funding. Let's break this down because when startups pocket nine-digit figures, it's time to pay attention. Solink's Leap Forward Now, what’s Solink doing with all that cash? They're not scrambling for coffee money, that's for sure. Instead, this funding...

Benewake Unveils SR Series LiDAR for Mobile Robots

Wave Goodbye to Bulky Sensors Hot off the Beijing press, Benewake's got something new—the SR Series 360° 3D LiDARs, set to stir up the robotics world. They're compact, power-efficient, and packed with smarts. It seems Benewake is tapping into a juicy market with these little sensors. Sleek Design and Big Promises The SR18 and SR96 models have a lot going for them. The...

AskGamblers Unveils Tool for Casino Complaints

A Fresh Move in the Casino World AskGamblers has made a move that might just change the game for online bettors. They’ve rolled out a new casino complaints dashboard designed to revolutionize how players raise issues with casinos. Sure, the gambling world is no stranger to complaints, and it's about time someone in the sector paid attention to airing dirty laundry in a...

Oxford Bank Reports Strong Q3 Amid Challenges

Digging Into Oxford Bank's Q3 Numbers You ever wonder how a smaller banking outfit yet to become a household name manages to punch above its weight? Let's look at Oxford Bank Corporation's (OTCQX: OXBC) third-quarter antics, where dreams of better margins and loan growth dance, even as operational costs spike. Net Income Climbs Despite Rising Costs The headline here is...

Meritus Health Adopts Sectra's Cloud for Radiology Boost

Meritus' Bold Move into the Cloud Jumping headlong into the tech game, Meritus Health has teamed up with Sectra to harness their One Cloud solution. This isn't just a plug-and-play deal; it's a strategic bet to overhaul how radiology is done. Do you know the kind of back-and-forth it takes to get a diagnostic image these days? Too much, if you ask me. Meritus is going...