The Shift: From Liberal-Conservative to

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone
132

The Shift: From Liberal-Conservative to Globalist-Nationalist
By Taylor Lewis
March 5, 2017

Last July, with Donald Trump on the verge of sealing up the Republican Party's presidential nomination, Ross Douthat authored a column in the New York Times about the new political battlefield. "[P]erhaps we should speak no more of left and right, liberals and conservatives," the token trad wrote. "From now on the great political battles will be fought between nationalists and internationalists, nativists and globalists."

Douthat's sentiment was echoed at the recent CPAC gathering, where President Trump's chief strategist, Steven Bannon, explained the difference between economic populists like himself and the jet-setting Davos crowd. "[W]e're a nation with an economy," he preached to the crowd. "Not an economy just in some global marketplace with open borders, but we are a nation with a culture and a reason for being."

It's true that we in the West are undergoing a political reorganization. The past two years have seen an explosion of nationalist political parties and personalities. The terms "liberal" and "conservative," in the popular context, are beginning to lose relevance. What's replacing them isn't so much party difference, but class.

The lines of separation between the elites and provincials has never been clearer. On big, nation-defining issues – trade agreements, wars, transnational partnerships, necessary credentials for high office – the divide cuts evenly. Those moneyed, cloistered, and comfortable welcome globalization and all its attendant benefits. Those who aren't so well off don't.

But class separation doesn't get to the heart of the difference between one end of the widening gulf and the other. The nationalist-globalist frame stems from something different, something more epistemological.

Politics really comes down to a value judgement: how does society best organize its collective life?

For nationalists, love of country, its inhabitants, and its unique character guides law-making. Government is formed solely for the benefit of citizens. High-minded psalms to the brotherhood of man have little place in policy.

The globalists are devoted to the biggest community on Earth: worldwide humanity. To the globally minded activist, there is no difference between the man next door and the man in a hut in Cambodia. Each is due equal consideration when it comes to the law.

In his recent New York Times column, David Brooks hits on this difference by singing a dirge to the enlightened universalism he sees as the cornerstone of the West. "The Enlightenment included thinkers like John Locke and Immanuel Kant who argued that people should stop deferring blindly to authority for how to live," he explains. But the anti-enlightenment movements of today "don't think truth is to be found through skeptical inquiry and debate."

Who are these intellect-eschewing dunderheads? Donald Trump, of course. But also Nigel Farage and Brexit backers, Marine Le Pen of France, Geert Wilders of the Netherlands, and Viktor Orbán of Hungary. Each has cultivated popular support by appealing not to passionless debate, but to deep love of country and, more pointedly, familiarity.

These decidedly anti-intellectual voters act based not on cool reasoning. They go the polls not to impose their abstract philosophy on the world. They protect what is theirs, what is close, what they identify with.

To contrast this limited view of life with the liberal is to compare soil with sky. Wide open and infinite, the sky is spaceless. It doesn't shift and sift like dirt through your fingers. It can't be seen and felt like solid earth.

The nationalist is necessarily parochial, attached to his specific time and place. The globalist takes the opposite approach. Not starting from below but above, he takes an all-encompassing view of mankind and sets to reshape the world in its image. The leftist global crusader is a firm believer in what Michael Brendan Dougherty calls "the idea of eternal human progress and moral arcs bending across the universe."

The idea of unstoppable progression demands much from its acolytes. Do national borders impede immigrants looking for a better life? Then all barriers must be eliminated. Do some people prefer those who share their faith, culture, skin color, and history to those who don't? Then they must be made to take a more universal view toward man and be shamed for their bigotry. Does the preservation of national wealth deprive poorer countries of prosperity? Then wealth must be redistributed, be it in the form of trade, military occupation, or direct financial transfer.

On and on the reduction goes until all human distinctions are replaced by the universal, homogeneous, and thus bland and uninteresting man. When the liberal-globalist achieves this sterile paradise, he'll be left with mannequins for men, able to recite facile tropes about joyful togetherness. This "thin view of man," to use the words of Polish philosopher Ryszard Legutko, can be an anti-civilizing force if left unchecked.

What is the contra to thin humanity? Thick, obviously. And what does thick entail? It means an acceptance of complexity, of the infinitudes of thought and emotion within every individual. "Across a room," writes Ted McAllister, "a conservative might spy a sack of rapidly degenerating amino acids, but rather than thinking of the elements that make up the body he sees, he wonders about this creature's past, its network of relationships, its relationship with books."

Here's where the paradox sets in: while the nationalist-conservative takes a simple approach to living, his narrow vision accepts the inner complexity of the individual. He doesn't purport to have a theory for how all should be governed. Rather, the good he sees is best for his family, his community, his country. Going any farther impedes on the right of another nation-dweller to determine his future path.

The political clash before the West has its basis in distance. How far a man is willing to go to impose his will usually determines his political allegiance. For those who would stop at their country's defined border, the influence is growing. How far it grows will be determined by those who think of their persuasive power as limitless.


Article
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Cambrian Turns Dairy Wastewater Into Long-Term Gas

Updated Category News Views 87

A Wisconsin dairy plant just traded lagoon duty for a 20-year service arrangement, and that is more consequential than the usual shiny renewable-gas headline. Cambrian Innovation says it has commissioned and is operating a wastewater treatment and resource recovery system that handles roughly 280,000 gallons a day. That works out to about 102 million gallons annually, a...

Continue Reading
CloudBackend's €6.6M Test: Can Vibe Code Become SaaS?

Updated Category News Views 272

A prototype is cheap theatre; keeping it alive after customers arrive is where the bill lands. CloudBackend has raised €6.6 million to attack that unglamorous, absolutely vital stretch between an AI-made app and an actual software business. The round is led by Carl-Henric Svanberg's family office, while existing backer M2 Asset Management increased its stake. That is a...

Continue Reading
Replit Bets on Trusted Creators to Sell AI Agents at Work

Updated Category News Views 127

Forty-five creators may sound like a marketing footnote, but Replit is aiming at a real enterprise bottleneck: people do not buy grand AI slogans; they buy proof that a messy internal problem can actually get fixed. Its newly launched Replit & Co. program puts business and technology creators in front of that problem, with product access, demonstrations and direct contact...

Continue Reading
A Quanzhou Table Offers China Beyond the Headlines

Updated Category News Views 35

Steam rising from a Quanzhou table can carry more weight than another polished speech about cultural exchange. That is the sensible instinct behind Home Banquets with Master Chefs, the CCTV-4 series using regional meals to explore geography, customs and memory. It is not trying to explain China through a pile of statistics or a museum-label summary. It starts where people...

Continue Reading
Youdao Sets December AGM With No Vote on the Table

Updated Category News Views 87

A shareholder meeting without a vote is more temperature check than showdown, and that is exactly what Youdao has scheduled for December 17, 2026. The company will gather shareholders from 3:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m. Beijing time at its Beijing office, but it has made one point painfully clear: no proposal will be submitted for shareholder approval. For holders of NYSE: DAO,...

Continue Reading
Live Nation Tests Creator Content With Morgan Jay Series

Updated Category News Views 21

A comedian turning crowd work into songs is hardly a boardroom event, but this one has a useful wrinkle: Live Nation Studios put financing behind it. Morgan Jay and Austin-based agency Hello Party launched Music Therapy with Morgan Jay on YouTube on November 18, with Kam Patterson opening the season. The show pairs Jay and celebrity guests for loose conversation,...

Continue Reading
GE Aerospace Backs Service Members With $100K Gift

Updated Category News Views 82

A six-figure commitment can look tiny beside jet-engine budgets, yet it can matter a great deal when it reaches people navigating the awkward jump from military service into civilian life. GE Aerospace has committed $100,000 to Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University to support transitioning service members. That is the whole heart of this announcement, and frankly, it is...

Continue Reading
CHN Energy's Indonesia Record Deserves a Hard Look

Updated Category News Views 56

Twenty years of boots sinking into swamp mud tells a sturdier story than a polished anniversary slogan. CHN Energy says it entered Indonesia's energy market two decades ago and has since built an operating presence around reliable electricity, local training and community work. In a country scattered across thousands of islands, dependable power is not some decorative...

Continue Reading
Institutions Spread AI Bets as 2027 Risks Mount Higher

Updated Category News Views 35

Money managers are not fleeing the party; they are checking the fire exits. Natixis Investment Managers surveyed 515 institutions overseeing $42.7 trillion, and their 2027 posture is pretty plain: keep taking risk, just stop pretending every risk is the same. Inflation, rates, government debt, geopolitical fracture and an AI spending boom are all tugging at portfolios at...

Continue Reading
Nellie's 50% Booking Jump Reveals a Quieter Luxury

Updated Category News Views 161

Silicon Valley’s rich are apparently tired of performing wealth for strangers, and frankly, that tracks. Nellie’s 2027 forecast says its mostly tech-money clientele is moving past the old trophy case of private jets, famous resort towns, and suites priced like small houses. The prize now is privacy, a clean schedule, and somebody competent fixing the ugly little...

Continue Reading
on>

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Virtusa Partners with Wiley to Drive Technological Change

Updated Category News Views 234

Virtusa Partners with Wiley to Drive Technological Change Virtusa Corporation, recognized globally for its leadership in digital business strategy and AI-driven platform engineering, has entered into an exciting partnership with Wiley, a key player in authoritative content and research intelligence. This collaboration aims to foster Wiley's technology transformation over...

Continue Reading
AZZ Inc. Declares Q2 2025 Dividend of $0.17 per Share

Updated Category News Views 67

AZZ Inc. Declares Dividend for the Second Quarter of 2025 AZZ Inc. (NYSE: AZZ), recognized for its leadership in hot-dip galvanizing and coil coating services, has recently notified its shareholders about a significant financial decision. The Board of Directors has approved a second quarter cash dividend amounting to $0.17 per share. This dividend will be allocated to all...

Continue Reading
Tampa General Hospital's Ambulatory Centers Achieve Top Rankings

Updated Category News Views 233

Tampa General Hospital's Ambulatory Centers Recognized The TGH Outpatient Center and TGH Surgery Center at Morsani have earned a prestigious spot among the top five ambulatory surgery centers in the state. Tampa General Hospital (TGH) proudly announces this recognition from a leading publication for the fourth consecutive year. Achievements in Ambulatory Surgery According...

Continue Reading
Norsk Hydro's Resilience Amid Market Challenges: A Detailed Overview

Updated Category News Views 218

Norsk Hydro's Recent Financial Performance Norsk Hydro reported significant financial results for the third quarter, with an adjusted EBITDA of NOK 5,996 million. This showcases a reduction from the NOK 7,367 million recorded in the same period last year, largely attributed to decreased alumina prices and robust NOK dynamics. However, these challenges were mitigated by...

Continue Reading
Top Aerospace and Defense Contractors Shaping the Future

Updated Category News Views 2184

Aerospace and Defense: A Key Industry The aerospace and defense sector is crucial for national security as well as a significant player in the stock market. With the U.S. leading the globe in defense spending, the largest contractors are poised for expansion amid global tensions. Here’s a breakdown of the top 10 largest U.S. defense contractors based on revenue,...

Continue Reading