The Israeli Approach to Women in Combat By Jonathan F.

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone john1234 #19081
431

The Israeli Approach to Women in Combat
By Jonathan F. Keiler
February 28, 2017

at-painter.gif

The American military and the Israel Defense Force (IDF) have some things in common and differ in others. One current difference regards the integration of women into combat forces.
Under the Obama administration the American military opened all jobs to female service-members, including combat infantry and commando units. The IDF has not followed suit. Combat infantry and commando units, as well as tank units, continue to remain off-limits to Israeli women, and the Trump administration might find the Israeli experience illuminating if it decides to roll back Obama’s policy.

Both militaries have moved in recent years to integrate women into the fighting forces, and generally have followed comparable paths. For example, female fighter pilots have operated successfully in both militaries for many years, women help crew naval fighting ships, and serve in virtually all combat support functions.

Something the American and Israeli militaries do not share is a concern for border security. In the U.S. this is (with rare exceptions) a civilian function, and while we have problems, they pale compared to Israel’s. Israel is a tiny state with proportionately huge hostile borders, which are mostly a military responsibility. Historically, the IDF has had to divert immense resources just to keep the state’s borders secure from hostile raiders. Involving first line units in this task wears them down and detracts from combat training. As a result the IDF has used reservists, territorial troops, and home guards for this task whenever possible, but there are never quite enough troops.

In 2000, the IDF sought to partially alleviate this problem with the formation of the Caracal battalion, the IDF’s first all-female infantry unit. The creation of the battalion killed several birds with one proverbial stone. It provided additional troops for the border security mission, took pressure off the IDF to integrate women more fully into the ground forces, and provided a long-term practical testing ground for the viability of female infantry. The results are now in. Limited line of communication and security missions yes; full scale combat no.

That is not to say that the Caracal battalion has been a failure. Far from it. In 2009 it was reformed as a mixed gender unit, and since that time three other mixed gender infantry/security battalions have been added. On at least two occasions female troops have successfully engaged in border skirmishes.

Recently, the IDF decided to fully rationalize the process of training and staffing these units based on lessons learned over the years, and one of those lessons is that for all their spirit and willingness to serve, female troops are not capable of functioning as regular combat infantry.

Admitting that women are different allows the IDF to better equip and staff these units to maximize their effectiveness. So for example, mixed gender infantry battalions will no longer carry the FN MAG 7.62 mm machinegun (in U.S. service the M-240.) The weapon and ammo are too heavy for female troops, so instead these units will rely exclusively on the Negev light machinegun (the IDF equivalent of the American SAW.) Likewise, these units will only carry American M-4 carbines, which weigh less than the Israeli Tavor. Female troops also wear special flak jackets and load bearing gear to better accommodate ammo and equipment. These changes are designed largely to reduce the disproportionately large number of stress injuries suffered by female soldiers.

Another disproportionately large cause of attrition is the often harsh and demanding nature of infantry officers. In the IDF many infantry officers emerge from the elite paratroop and Golani brigades and are then distributed around other units. Such officers proved a poor fit for female infantry, and as a result the IDF redesigned its assignment policies to have more sensitive officers lead the mixed gender units.

This is an honest if accommodating policy, which seeks to maximize to contributions of female infantry troops, without pretending that they can do all the things that real combat infantrymen can do. This makes the IDF policy substantially different from the American.

The American military is pretending that women can do the same things men can do and is supposedly not lowering standards to accommodate them. Few really believe that this is the case, and even if it is, it seems hardly worth the disruption that opening combat infantry units to a few extraordinary women might bring. Plus adding a statistically meaningless number of female combat infantry and commandos to the ranks won’t satisfy feminists and culture warriors within and without the military, which means standards will inevitably be lowered.

The IDF policy offers a middle ground that could protect the integrity and quality of the combat infantry while at least partially satisfying feminists and particularly by opening up 11B infantry slots to ambitious female officers, who are the real constituency within the military pushing this issue. While the U.S. does not have the border security problems Israel does (and it is not a military responsibility anyway) we do have line-of-communication and rear area security problems whenever our troops campaign abroad. Military Police have sometimes performed this function and security operations in Panama in 1989 produced the first female officer to lead soldiers in ground combat. In Iraq, tank and artillery crews were sometimes pressed into this role (it’s how former artillery officer and Congressman Allen West came to prominence) without adequate equipment or training, and at the expense of practicing their own critical specialties.

American mixed gender infantry battalions on the IDF model could fulfill this role, provide infantry billets to female troops (and especially officers), and actually meet a military need, rather than twisting the system around for political accommodations. Female troops could be trained and designated 11B with appropriate accommodations and the caveat that they would only serve in the security battalions. They could receive further training, be equipped and armed in accord with functional practicality and need. This would not satisfy everybody, but it would be a more honest and militarily sound solution than the current policy, and one the Trump administration’s new military secretaries should consider.
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

De Beers Puts Namibia's 176-Carat Owishi on Display

Updated Category News Views 149

A 176-carat natural diamond can still make a room stop breathing, even in a trade battered by arguments over lab-grown supply, luxury spending, and what “rare” ought to mean anymore. De Beers Group, working with Grandview Klein Diamond, has unveiled Namibia’s Owishi natural diamond in Washington, DC. That is the hard fact on the table: a large Namibian stone, a U.S....

Continue Reading
Schloss Johannisberg Leads 2026 Global Vineyard List

Updated Category News Views 106

A 1,200-year-old riesling estate just beat the world at being memorable. Schloss Johannisberg in Germany’s Rheingau has taken No. 1 in The 50 Best Vineyards 2026, moving up from No. 2 last year and also claiming Best Vineyard in Europe. For anyone watching the wine business from the outside, this is not really a story about one bottle edging out another. It is a...

Continue Reading
Happiest Minds Extends Absa Banking Platform Reach

Updated Category News Views 34

Mauritius just handed Happiest Minds a useful, if modest, banking-tech scorecard. On November 19, 2026, the company said its cloud-native Arttha platform had been deployed to support selected capabilities within Spark by Absa, a digital banking and lifestyle app from Absa Bank (Mauritius). This is not the sort of announcement that lets anybody pencil in a giant revenue...

Continue Reading
Pressure Injury Care Needs More Than Awareness Alone

Updated Category News Views 52

Wet skin does not care how polished the awareness campaign looks. That is the uncomfortable truth sitting underneath Worldwide Pressure Injury Prevention Day, the annual observance held on the third Thursday of November. Pressure injuries remain a stubborn problem across healthcare facilities and home care settings because prevention is not one tidy action; it is a chain...

Continue Reading
SAGA's Radar Assays Tighten the Trapper North Case

Updated Category News Views 210

Rock that keeps showing up where the model says it should is the sort of boring news a junior miner desperately needs. SAGA Metals has put out fresh assay results from Radar’s Trapper North area, and the useful part is not merely a loud grade in one hole. It is the apparent persistence of thick titanium-vanadium-iron oxide mineralization across tighter-spaced drilling....

Continue Reading
Norfolk Southern's 200-Year Campaign Meets a Hard Market

Updated Category News Views 118

Two centuries of railroad history can stir the blood, but it does not move a single carload by itself. Norfolk Southern has opened its 200-year railroading celebration with the GeneratioNS campaign, a three-locomotive NS 200 commemorative series, and plans for public events across its network. For a railroad with deep roots and very modern operational pressures, this is...

Continue Reading
Highway 99 Truck Death Puts Safety Records in Focus

Updated Category News Views 97

A stopped car on a highway shoulder is supposed to be a bad day, not a death sentence. Yet on November 5, 2026, a person helping a relative with a disabled vehicle was killed on northbound Highway 99 in Elk Grove after a commercial tractor-trailer allegedly drifted onto the shoulder, hit both stationary vehicles, and overturned. Northbound lanes were closed for hours. A...

Continue Reading
Blue Diamond's $1 Billion Brand Meets Farm Realities

Updated Category News Views 118

A Ten-Cent Signal Carries Real Weight A ten-cent edge over the industry benchmark may not excite the cocktail-party crowd, but almond growers notice every penny when fertilizer, power and pest control keep gnawing at the farm gate. Blue Diamond Growers says it delivered payments roughly 10 cents above the benchmark in its latest year, alongside net profit that came in...

Continue Reading
Linq's $90M Bet on the Infrastructure Behind AI Agents

Updated Category News Views 193

Ninety million dollars just landed on the least glamorous part of the AI-agent rush: the pipes. Linq, the San Francisco private company, announced the round on November 18, 2026, led by Andreessen Horowitz, with returning backing from TQ Ventures, Mucker Capital and Abstract, plus new money from Anthos and Left Lane Capital. Ben Horowitz is joining the board. That is a...

Continue Reading
Health In Tech Gets a Real Distribution Test in 2027

Updated Category News Views 67

A 100,000-employee funnel is the sort of number that makes a small InsurTech investor sit up, then reach for the fine print. Health In Tech has brought a national third-party administrator onto its eDIYBS platform, giving the company access to a TPA serving more than 650 employers in over 40 states, with more than 100,000 covered employees as of May 2026. That is...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Aramore: Recognized as a Leader in Wellness Innovation

Updated Category News Views 276

Aramore Wins Prestigious Award for Innovation in Wellness A significant milestone in the beauty and wellness sector has been marked by Aramore's recent recognition as the "Best Breakthrough Wellness Startup" in the 2025 Glossy Awards. This honor underlines the company’s groundbreaking scientific approach to skin care and health enhancement, setting a new standard for...

Continue Reading
GAPVelocity AI: Pioneering Hybrid Approach to Legacy Modernization

Updated Category News Views 244

Transforming Legacy Modernization with GAPVelocity AI Industry-First Combination of Deterministic and Generative AI Delivers 75% Faster Modernization with Enterprise-Grade Security and Predictability Growth Acceleration Partners (GAP), a prominent consulting and technology services provider, has unveiled a revolutionary hybrid AI platform known as GAPVelocity AI. This...

Continue Reading
Singapore AI Week: A Gathering of Global AI Innovators

Updated Category News Views 311

Singapore AI Week: An Unforgettable Celebration Singapore AI Week is set to be a remarkable event, bringing together over 100 activities within 10 distinctive Community Hubs. This vibrant festival will feature an array of offerings, from Mixmag's creative-tech stage to the engaging student programs guided by the National Youth Council and Wavesparks. This event aims to...

Continue Reading
Cove Capital Hits Milestone: Debt-Free DST Success

Updated Category News Views 61

Unpacking Cove Capital's Latest Triumph Let’s dive right into this one. Cove Capital Investments isn’t playing around with their recent accomplishment. They’ve gone ahead and fully subscribed their latest playground for investors, the Ponder Small Bay Industrial 101 Delaware Statutory Trust. What makes this interesting is not just the $18.6 million in equity they...

Continue Reading
ZIM Integrated Shipping Services: A New Chapter Ahead

Updated Category News Views 252

ZIM Integrated Shipping Services Shares Are Making Headlines ZIM Integrated Shipping Services Ltd. (NYSE: ZIM) is in the spotlight as shares have seen fluctuations recently, especially after a dip of 1.13% in after-hours trading, closing at $19.29. Strategic Acquisition Proposal Under Review The board of ZIM is currently engaged in a comprehensive strategic review...

Continue Reading