K-12 Quagmire: Problems with Sight-Words: By Bruce

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board

Feb 23, 2017 at 1:13 PM 103

K-12 Quagmire:
Problems with Sight-Words:
By Bruce Deitrick Price
February 23, 2017

(The left & teachers unions have been
trying to get rid of phonics for decades.
What might be the deal on that.)

Why do we have millions of children who never become fluent readers? Easy. Our Education Establishment prefers methods that don't work.

Every language is either a sound-language such as English or a picture-language such as Chinese. They are opposites. You cannot mix them without creating mental chaos. But what do you know? Our public schools insist on mixing them together. This is dogma in today's K-12.

Most Americans have heard of "balanced literacy." That's jargon for mixing them together.

Sound-languages are also known as phonetic languages – for example, Latin, German, Italian, and English. Children read these languages by first learning an alphabet, the sounds represented by the letters, and how to blend those sounds. Then they can read a million words. (They see CAT on the page and blend those three letters into one spoken word. Note that the sounds are contained in the printed words.)

Picture-languages are also known as hieroglyphic, ideographic, or sight-languages – for example, Babylonian, ancient Egyptian, and Chinese. There is no alphabet to learn. Instead children memorize whole diagrams or designs one by one. Note that the pronunciation of a word is not in the word, but in your memory. For example, Ω. You can stare at it all day and never figure out how to pronounce it. Picture-languages are very memory-intensive. Historically, they provided literacy for a smart elite.

So we see two different strategies for creating a language. Surely, nobody would be so malevolent as to make children memorize phonetic English words as if they were hieroglyphic symbols. Doing so almost guarantees cognitive schizophrenia (aka dyslexia).

In fact, our Education Establishment is that malevolent. Look-say, introduced in 1931, insisted that all English words must be memorized as graphic wholes. (Children look at the design and say the pronunciation, thus Look-say.)

A famous book came out in 1955 explaining why this approach was a disaster. But here we are, 60 years after Rudolf Flesch and his Why Johnny Can't Read. Most public schools still trick parents into accepting a big chunk of sight-words.

Parents are told that "high-frequency words" cannot be sounded out because they "don't follow any rules." These oddball words must be dealt with by visual memorization. It's this Big Lie that causes the damage.

In a sound-language, words must always be processed left to right. In a picture-language, words can be processed any which way: left to right, right to left, top to bottom, bottom to top, diagonally, etc. That's how everyone looks at faces, cars, pictures, etc. If a child starts to process English words in that random way, the child will never be a fluent reader.

Making children memorize sight-words introduces a permanent kink. Each new word on the page prompts the question: is this a word I read phonetically, or is it one of those sight-words I was supposed to memorize? Answering this question takes extra seconds. And what if you're sure it is a sight-word, but you can't remember the pronunciation? You have to guess.

Sight-words lead to so-called functional illiteracy, with many tens of millions of people swearing they can't read for pleasure.

I was recently engaged in a bizarre conversation. A wealthy family spend more than $25,000 a year to send their son to a private school so that this child can have every advantage in life. But that school (foolishly) uses sight-words to teach reading. This boy, now in the third grade, is a damaged reader who needs tutoring. The surreal part is that the mother could parrot the official lie: "Of course they teach phonics, but there are a lot of high-frequency words that don't obey any rules. So the kids have to memorize those as sight-words. Of course."

I started thinking about a relative who was in elementary school in the 1950s and was kept illiterate until the end of fourth grade. The same technique crippled both boys. Meanwhile, I know a former teacher who believes that our experts are sincerely trying to get better – they just can't get their act together. Please. Would you promote the same destructive method for 70 years if you were sincerely trying to improve literacy?

Sight-words aren't needed or helpful; they should be eliminated. Sight-words are destructive because the brain is asked to do two different steps unpredictably. Simon says: identify sight-word...read phonetically...read phonetically...identify sight-word... Who wouldn't be confused?

The damage to individual children and to the society is massive beyond calculation. All this happens because you mix two things you cannot mix. Suppose you have patients with Type A blood, and you give them a transfusions of Type B blood. You'll kill them.

Let us call this movie The Eternal Darkness of the Sight-Word Scam. Steven Spielberg directs. Jim Carrey shows us the tragicomic world of the functionally illiterate person. The first scene is a 25th high school reunion. Jim Carrey confronts the teacher who made him illiterate. Carrey tries to throw this teacher out a third-floor window. Hilarity ensues.

CODA: For the sake of illustration and discussion, let's say "&" is pronounced "my," "#" is pronounced "car," "@" is pronounced "is," and "%" is pronounced "fast." So a sentence in this sight-language could look like this: & # @ % and be pronounced "my car is fast." Imagine how difficult and tedious it would be to memorize (with instant recall) even 100 such symbols, never mind thousands. This, in effect, is what millions of children are told to do

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Woodpack Global Unveils Crate Design System: A New Era Begins

Innovating the Wooden Crate Landscape An old industry got a much-needed facelift today, folks. Woodpack Global has rolled out Crate Design System™ (CDS)—a snazzy new tool that's shaking up the wooden crate design landscape. It blows the dust off outdated design methods that have been collecting cobwebs since the '60s. That's right, we’re talking about a significant...

ZEEKR's Shooting Brakes Dominate: Over 400K Sold

ZEEKR's Stellar Performance in a Crowded Market Another month, another bumper crop for ZEEKR's shooting brakes. These beauties aren't just hanging in there; they're leading the pack. In August alone, global deliveries marched past the 10,000 mark for the third month running—a feat not easily achieved in today's saturated automotive landscape. It's no wonder the...

MCatalysis Secures $5M to Disrupt Fuel Cost Dynamics

Funding Fuels Innovation MCatalysis has just secured a hefty $5 million in seed funding to throw down with the big dogs in energy production. This isn't your regular backyard science project; this company is serious about changing the game with a tech-driven approach that could undercut current fuel prices. HL Energy Ventures and Oxford Science Enterprises are backing...

RARE Foundation Rebrands, Focus Still Strong

Unveiling the RARE Foundation's New Identity In the stock market, you ride waves of change, and let me tell you, it ain't just stocks and bonds that change names and faces. Case in point: The EveryLife Foundation for Rare Diseases has spiffed up as the RARE Foundation. New name, new logo, the whole enchilada. This isn't just a cosmetic touch-up, though. It's about...

Job Market Shifts: Adaptation vs. Fairness Dilemma

The Chameleon Effect in Today's Job Market Walk into any open-space office these days, and you'll see faces plastered with composed, work-ready smiles—faces that might not look so familiar outside those walls. The modern workplace has draped its cloak over individual personalities, with the mighty pressure to 'fit in' often forcing a change in how folks present...

Monib Zirvi's Dermatology Excellence Honored in 2026

Trailblazer in Dermatology Recognized Again Fancy yourself a star in dermatology? Well, take notes from Dr. Monib A. Zirvi. The guy just got his due recognition from Marquis Who's Who for his sizable contributions to dermatology and research. For someone who's been at this game for over two decades, Zirvi doesn't just glide by on old merits. He's the real deal, and his...

Aflac's $200M Milestone in Cancer Charity Support

Pioneering Efforts Across Decades Here’s an effort that bucks the usual corporate talk. Aflac, the supplemental insurance giant, isn’t just mumbling about its mission; it's doing the heavy lifting in the fight against childhood cancer and blood disorders. With over $200 million in contributions poured into the cause over more than 30 years, they're putting the capital...

Sandbox VR Expands to Melbourne, Betting on Immersive Fun

Sandbox VR Ventures into Melbourne's Heart Every now and then, a venture takes its ambitions and rolls the dice on a prime location. Sandbox VR is swaggering into Melbourne's bustling Central Business District, fresh out of its success on the Gold Coast. Opening this Melbourne venue on September 14 marks a significant leap in the company's Aussie expansion—a bold nod to...

South Florida Donor Network Honors 52 Heroic Donors

A Heartfelt Tribute to Lifesavers You ever been to a gathering that reminds you how deeply human connections run? That's what happened at The Diplomat Beach Resort in Hollywood. South Florida Donor Network (SFDN) pulled together a ceremony honoring 52 donor heroes whose legacies beat strong through the recipients living thanks to their gifts. An Event Worth Attending...

Cap Juluca: Caribbean Luxury Redefined on Maundays Bay

The Tranquil Call of Maundays Bay Find me dipping my toes in the sands of Maundays Bay come October 10, 2026, and you'll understand why this slice of Anguilla stakes its claim to being the best beach on the globe. Cap Juluca, that crown jewel of Caribbean luxury, swings open its doors once more, promising indulgence framed by turquoise waters and the soft whisper of white...