Department of Education A Brief and Appalling History

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone cashclan #18339
127

Department of Education
A Brief and Appalling History
By Michael S. Goldstein
February 14, 2017



Congratulations to Secretary DeVos.

She will now roll up her sleeves and work to ensure that our children receive the education they deserve, and not the education they have been receiving for a long, long time. We know that she wants to begin by devolving a good portion of the responsibility for education from the federal bureaucracy to the states.

As noted by E. Jeffrey Ludwig in American Thinker on February 9, 2017, "Federalism in the area of education with its restored respect for state authority is the key to change and progress." But this will just be a start, not the end. It is time to resuscitate the Constitution of the United States vis-à-vis the responsibility for education.

There has never been a constitutional basis for any federal control over education in the states. National government control of education is a constitutional travesty, a regulatory nightmare, a burden on the states' and the people's budgets, and a burden on the state and local education systems and institutions over which it has made itself the overseer. Secretary DeVos is the right person to work toward the goal of removing the federal government from the educational process.

Mr. Ludwig states that the trend of federal control over education, with its attendant uniformity, was perceived as early as 1926. In fact, federal control, with many of its attendant problems, and the clear fact of its unconstitutionality, was perceived by members of Congress 50 years earlier.

Federal imposition into education in the states began just after the Civil War. At the behest of the National Association of State and City School Superintendents, Congress created the first national office of education in 1866. What the superintendents said they wanted was a bill that would:

1. Secure greater uniformity and accuracy in school statistics.

2. Bring together the results of school systems in order to determine their comparative value.

3. Assemble the different methods of school instruction and management for distribution.

4. Collect and diffuse information generated by school districts respecting state school laws, teacher qualifications, modes of heating and ventilation, and other subjects.

5. Help communities in the organization of their school systems.

6. Encourage education as a valuable object and shield of civil liberty.

The superintendents' group specifically stated that they wanted this national support "without [the federal government] being invested with any official control of the school authorities therein."

There was neither mention of nor desire to utilize the federal treasury to fund any educational programs. There was no hint by the superintendents that the federal office of education would do anything other than collect statistics. In short, the department was to be an educational statistical service located in Washington, D.C.

But that's not what the superintendents got.

The 1866 bill stated, in part:

There shall be established, at the City of Washington, a Department of Education for the purpose of collecting such statistics and facts as shall show the condition and progress of education in the several States and Territories, and of diffusing such information respecting the organization and management of schools and school systems and methods of teaching as shall aid the people of the United States in the establishment and maintenance of efficient school systems, and otherwise promote the cause of education throughout the country.

The bill also provided that the Commissioner report to Congress annually "the results of his investigations and labors, together with a statement of such facts and recommendations as will in his judgment subserve the purpose for which this department is established."

This national bill was the camel's nose poking under the edge of the federal tent, and over the next 100 years, the camel came all the way in. Though the initial educational sphere of action was small, the bill requested that Congress assert jurisdiction over the sphere of education itself, even though the Congress had absolutely no constitutional authority to do so.

In 1866, Congressman Andrew J. Rogers, a Democrat representing New Jersey's 4th Congressional District, spoke eloquently against the bill to establish a federal Department of Education. Mr. Rogers declared that the bill:

... proposes to put under the supervision of a bureau established at Washington all the schools and educational institutions of the different States of the Union by collecting such facts and statistics as will warrant them by amendments hereafter to the law now attempted to be passed, to control and regulate the educational system of the whole country.

Rep. Rogers correctly noted that the bill was open on the question of future control but that it clearly asserted federal jurisdiction over education. This opened the door, he stated, for control, either directly or indirectly, through funding or other means, at any time in the future when conditions proved that expediency should again be made the rule of constitutional construction. To assert that the degree of federal jurisdiction was small and limited to statistics in no way impaired the jurisdictional claim, for once jurisdiction was established, government could assert complete sovereignty within that sphere at any time.

When expediency is the rule of constitutional construction, we will have a "living Constitution" rather than the actual Constitution we swear to protect and defend. The battle to prevent this is being fought today, particularly in the arena of judicial appointments. Rep. Rogers saw it coming.

Rep. Rogers also focused on the enormousness of the expense of the project and its open-ended nature, and the natural right of parents to educate their children. He reiterated:

[N]o man can find anywhere in the letter or spirit of the Constitution one word that will authorize the Congress of the United States to establish an Education Bureau. If Congress has the right to establish an Educational Bureau ... for the purpose of collecting statistics and controlling the schools of the country, then by the same parity of reason, a fortiori, Congress has the right to establish a bureau to supervise the education of all the children that are to be found in ... this country. You will not stop at simply establishing a bureau for the purpose of paying officers to collect and diffuse statistics in reference to education.

Rep. Rogers correctly observed that power with respect to education was not to be found among those powers enumerated to Congress in the Constitution.

Looking at the Department of Education today, who can say that Rep. Rogers, Democrat of New Jersey, was wrong in 1866? In 2014, the DoE budget was $67.3 billion, proposed to rise to $68.6 billion in 2015. The bureaucratic state's camel, with all its attendant federal employees, is indeed thriving inside the national government tent, and American taxpayers are paying the fees to feed it. Secretary DeVos should put Rep. Rogers's comments on the wall of her office and be inspired by them daily.
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Lake Ridge Sets $0.68 Dividend as 2026 Payouts Rise

Updated Category News Views 128

A community bank raising its cash return is not fireworks, but it gets my attention faster than another glossy growth slogan. Lake Ridge Bancorp has declared a fourth-quarter 2026 dividend of $0.68 per share, payable December 16 to shareholders of record on November 30. That is a plain, useful announcement from OTCQX:LRBI, and plain is often underrated when you are...

Continue Reading
Automotive Laminates: Small Market, Real EV Leverage

Updated Category News Views 126

Cabin trim has become a surprisingly serious battleground, and that is the whole point of this automotive laminates story. Nobody buys a vehicle because somebody bragged about a multilayer film behind the door panel. Yet the materials under the fingertips, beneath the carpet, and around the dashboard increasingly decide whether an interior feels cheap, quiet, durable, or...

Continue Reading
LNG’s Coming Glut Could Gut Global Trading Profits

Updated Category News Views 55

A five-year LNG surplus is the sort of forecast that makes people nod politely today and panic much too late. Bain & Company is putting a hard edge on that risk: the global trading profit pool could slide from an estimated $20 billion in 2026 to roughly $5.5 billion a year during a 2030–34 glut, then potentially tip below zero once cancellation costs bite. That is not a...

Continue Reading
MIND Takes Its Copilot Security Bet Across Microsoft 365

Updated Category News Views 92

Copilot’s promise gets a lot less charming the minute confidential files start wandering around unchecked. That is the knot MIND is trying to untie with its expanded, generally available integrations across Microsoft Copilot, Microsoft 365, Purview, Teams, SharePoint, OneDrive, Edge and Exchange. The Seattle data-loss-prevention company announced the collaboration on...

Continue Reading
Shenzhen Three-Way Summit Puts Stability to the Test

Updated Category News Views 7

Three nuclear powers sharing a room in Shenzhen is the sort of headline that makes every risk desk sit upright, even when the paperwork remains thin. CGTN reports that Chinese President Xi Jinping, Russian President Vladimir Putin and U.S. President Donald Trump met on November 19, 2026, in an unprecedented trilateral summit and issued a Declaration toward Peace. That is...

Continue Reading
Full Truck Alliance Profits Surge as Revenue Slows

Updated Category News Views 38

A freight platform just delivered the kind of earnings math that makes investors sit up: sales barely jogged, while profit took off running. Full Truck Alliance’s third-quarter report is plainly strong on the surface, with net income up 49.0% year over year to RMB1.37 billion. Still, this is not a clean, uncomplicated growth story. The quality of the margin jump...

Continue Reading
Cadence Marks $2.7 Million for St. Jude Family Care

Updated Category News Views 172

Small Wheels, Serious Purpose Tiny tricycles, flour-dusted bake-sale tables, and family pledges have pushed Cadence Education’s St. Jude partnership to $2.7 million since 2018. That number is not a flashy balance-sheet item, nor should anybody try to dress it up as one. It is the accumulated result of school communities showing up year after year, and in a sector built...

Continue Reading
Subaru's 650-Car Anniversary Bet Is Delightfully Small

Updated Category News Views 112

Gold brake calipers may sound like a fussy correction, yet that little detail tells you exactly who Subaru is trying to please. The company has revised its announcement for the 2027 WRX tS GD25 and BRZ tS ZC15, clarifying the anniversary-model names and changing the WRX description from red-painted to gold-painted Brembo calipers. Nobody should confuse a corrected paint...

Continue Reading
AIC Hotel Group's 11 Awards Test Resort Market Reach

Updated Category News Views 42

Eleven Trophies, Four Properties, One Useful Signal Hospitality awards can be a lot of polished brass and very little cash flow, but this batch is substantial enough to deserve a hard look. AIC Hotel Group collected 11 honors spanning Condé Nast Traveler's 2026 Readers' Choice Awards, Travel Weekly's 2026 Magellan Awards, and Good Housekeeping's 2027 Travel Awards. The...

Continue Reading
ROBOTERA Puts Humanoid Robots Into Logistics Night Work

Updated Category News Views 36

Midnight warehouse work is where a humanoid robot has to quit posing and earn its keep. ROBOTERA arrived at the 2026 APEC CEO Summit with a useful answer to the usual shiny-robot nonsense: it says its machines are already working in logistics centers, handling parcel induction and taking on repetitive, physically demanding shifts that people understandably do not line up...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Innovative Gene Therapy Presentation from MeiraGTx at Neuroscience Event

Updated Category News Views 256

MeiraGTx Unveils Promising Research on MC4R Genetic Deficiency MeiraGTx Holdings plc, a pioneering clinical-stage genetic medicine company, has recently made headlines by announcing its participation in a significant neuroscience event. This presentation highlights advancements in treating severe pediatric obesity resulting from MC4R genetic deficiency. The poster...

Continue Reading
Navigating Legal Rights for Shareholders of Flywire Corporation

Updated Category News Views 149

Understanding the Class Action Lawsuit for Flywire Corporation Investors Investors holding shares of Flywire Corporation, referred to as the "Company," should be aware of an ongoing class action lawsuit concerning allegations of securities fraud. The lawsuit aims to ensure that those adversely affected by the Company's actions between specified dates can pursue their...

Continue Reading
LOGISTEC Launches Enhanced Cargo Handling at Baltimore Terminal

Updated Category News Views 235

LOGISTEC Enhances Cargo Handling at Baltimore Terminal LOGISTEC, a prominent North American provider specializing in marine and logistics services, is announcing a significant enhancement to its cargo handling capabilities at its terminal in Baltimore. This advancement comes as LOGISTEC, formerly known as BalTerm, aims to integrate its operations under a unified branding...

Continue Reading
Daversa Partners: Celebrating Recognition as a Top Employer

Updated Category News Views 306

Daversa Partners Recognized as One of the Best Employers Daversa Partners is proud to announce that its Miami office has achieved recognition as one of South Florida’s Best Places to Work for 2025. This significant honor highlights the firm’s unwavering commitment to fostering a workplace culture that champions teamwork and innovation. A Culture of Teamwork and...

Continue Reading
Weaker Jobs Data Sparks Dollar Decline, Rate Cut Hopes

Updated Category Economy Views 648

U.S. Dollar Hits Four-Month Low Amid Weak Jobs Report Friday brought a four-month low in the value of the U.S. dollar. This came after a rather dismal July job report. Employers created just 114,000 new positions according to the report. This far less than the anticipated rise of 175,000. Rising from 4.1%, the unemployment rate also hit 4.3%. These numbers begged...

Continue Reading