How Trump Would Corrupt the Pulpit By STEVEN WALDMAN

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

Feb 3, 2017 at 2:21 AM 163

Quote:

How Trump Would Corrupt the Pulpit

By STEVEN WALDMAN FEB. 2, 2017

President Trump just reiterated his campaign promise to “get rid of and totally destroy” the law prohibiting churches and other nonprofit tax-exempt institutions from endorsing political candidates.

This change would be horrible for politics — and even worse for religion.

The law, known as the Johnson Amendment, was written by Lyndon B. Johnson, then a senator from Texas, in 1954. It prohibits tax-exempt churches from endorsing political candidates. Mr. Trump on Thursday said repealing the rule would “allow our representatives of faith to speak freely and without fear of retribution,” adding, “Freedom of religion is a sacred right, but it is under serious threat.”

Let’s start by clearing up two misunderstandings. The rule does not prevent churches — or other charities — from speaking freely. Religious leaders and churches have been weighing in on political issues for as long as there have been pulpits.

The Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, Jeremiah Wright and thousands of clergymen on any given weekend have been energetic advocates of political or social causes.

The rule does not even prohibit clergymen from endorsing a candidate. Rather, it says that if a religious leader endorses a candidate, then his church cannot receive the significant benefit of tax exemption, and that people cannot, therefore, make a tax-deductible contribution to that church.

Eliminating the endorsement rule would mean that your tax dollars would now indirectly subsidize a church’s support for a particular political candidate. For instance, conservative taxpayers would indirectly support the Rev. Al Sharpton if he decided to endorse a candidate — or the local mosque that wanted to endorse a candidate. And progressives would indirectly support churches that endorse candidates who are opposed to same-sex marriage.

The conservatives clamoring for this change should think hard: They don’t like their tax dollars going to support groups that perform abortions. Do they really want to pay for churches that push pro-choice candidates? They fear and distrust Islam. Do they really want their hard-earned money to back the preferred political candidates of the local Islamic center?

And those, kiddies, wannabe theocrats and free range authoritarians, are known as unintended consequences.

We're all getting a crash course in them due to an inability of the Trumpmeister and his advisors to simply ask the question, 'and then what?'.

In addition, this would likely create a huge new loophole in the campaign finance system. The donations we make to political candidates are not now tax-deductible. But if this provision is repealed, you could make a tax-deductible contribution to a church (or other charity) that is campaigning for a political candidate.

Houses of worship and other charities could become unregulated vessels for campaign contributions, which taxpayers would then have to partly underwrite because they were deductible. It would be a disaster for our political system, already reeking of corruption.

It also would be a disaster for religion.

Political fixers will try to funnel money through houses of worship. The temptations for clergy members would be intense. Yes, let’s fix the day care center in the basement! All we have to do is endorse that well-meaning candidate and organize a volunteer brigade for him on Election Day.

It may be that the Internal Revenue Service could clarify its current rules to make it easier for churches to navigate, but the harm of a repeal would far outweigh the benefits.

When churches move from being independent vehicles for political causes and become arms of political parties, they lose their prophetic voice.

Worse, they lose their spiritual credibility. As a state legislator in Virginia, James Madison made the case that subsidizing religious organizations undermines religion.

Arguing against a plan to provide subsidies to churches in Virginia, Madison said efforts to help religion would backfire, as faith that is purely pursued was more powerful. Taxpayer-subsidized religion would become corrupt, lazy and unpersuasive — and worse, he said, “an offense against God, not against man.”

Amen to that.

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/02/opinion/ho...n&_r=0

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Truss Financial Tackles Home Equity Closing Delays

Truss Financial Group's Bold Move Against Closing Delays In real estate, time is money. Even the most casual market observer could tell you delays can slice through a deal like a hot knife through butter. That's the headache home equity borrowers face, blindsided by closing delays that sneak up on them without warning. An Industry Bottleneck Finally Addressed Enter Truss...

ROKFORM’s Signal Card: A Wallet Tracker for All

The Gadget You Didn't Know You Needed Ever feel that momentary panic when your wallet seems to have vanished into thin air? ROKFORM's fresh offering, the Signal Card, tackles that heart-stopping moment head-on. They've taken the mundane act of misplacing your wallet and transformed it with their sleek, credit-card-sized tracker. This baby pairs seamlessly with Apple Find...

Charter Next Generation Unveils Gen 2 MDO-PE Films

Peering Into CNG's Latest Innovation Charter Next Generation (CNG) just threw down a hefty gauntlet with its launch of next-gen machine-direction-oriented polyethylene (MDO-PE) solutions. They're pushing the envelope on what recycle-ready packaging can do, folks. Let's not mince words—other players in the field better have their game faces on. This ain't just another...

Cala Launches Game-Changer Wearable for Tremor Relief

Breaking New Ground in Neuromodulation Medical tech's on a roll, and Cala Health just hopped on the fast track with their latest launch—the Cala kIQ Plus System. This bad boy is aiming to offer relief for those grappling with hand tremors, thanks to its FDA clearance and a host of new features. It's the first of its kind, combining multiple therapy modes with an...

Community Banks Missing $106B Lending Opportunity?

A Missed Opportunity for Community Banks It's a classic tale: community banks sleepwalking while big players snatch up low-hanging fruit right in their own backyards. According to the latest report by Cornerstone Advisors, commissioned by Teslar Software, these banks are essentially leaving $106 billion on the table when it comes to consumer lending. That's not just chump...

NYSE Texas Redefines the U.S. Capital Markets Landscape

NYSE Texas: Carving a Niche The notion of 'Y'all Street' might seem like a gimmick, but NYSE Texas is pushing a serious agenda with its newly released white paper, 'NYSE Texas and the Reshaping of U.S. Capital Markets.' This is no small feat. Texas is already housing 235 NYSE-listed companies, boasting a colossal combined worth of $4.8 trillion. With 130 of these firms...

Dentistry.One Achieves HITRUST i1, Boosts Cybertrust

HITRUST i1 Certification: The Gold Standard in Security For a world increasingly reliant on digital infrastructure, cybersecurity certification is no longer just a badge of honor; it's a cornerstone of trust. Dentistry.One nailed this down by bagging that coveted HITRUST i1 certification. When folks talk about securing data, HITRUST might as well be speaking gospel. We're...

Purina Institute Highlights Nutritional Science at WSAVA 2026

A Global Stage for Pet Nutrition Science The folks over at the Purina Institute are back in the spotlight as they gear up to throw their weight behind the 51st World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) Congress in Warsaw, Poland. Set for October 13-15, 2026, this isn’t just another event—they're bringing some serious clout with their 'Food for Thought'...

IWP and VYRE Unveil 'The Plug' for VBNGtv Content

Bringing Capital and Content Under One Roof There's something in the air as Itibari-Waynne & Partners (IWP) team up with the VYRE Network to crank out a fresh slate of content for VYRE Business News Global (VBNGtv). This partnership ain't just another splash in the buzzy world of digital media; it's like merging Wall Street with Hollywood. IWP, prepping to go full...

Northern Jet Names Veteran Matthew Harris as CEO

Fresh Leadership at Northern Jet Well, if you didn’t see this coming, you’ve been snoozing on the tarmac. Northern Jet, no stranger to the skies after three decades, just roped in Matthew Harris as their new CEO from October 2, 2026. They're pulling in this hotshot with more than 25 years riding the turbulence of private aviation. And listen to this: his marching...