Quote:The Troubling Reason the Electoral College Exists
Akhil Reed Amar
Updated: Nov 10, 2016 7:19 PM Central | Originally published: Nov 08, 2016
Although the Philadelphia framers did not anticipate the rise of a system of national presidential parties, the 12th Amendment—proposed in 1803 and ratified a year later— was framed with such a party system in mind, in the aftermath of the election of 1800-01.
http://time.com/4558510/electoral-college-history-slavery/
In that election, two rudimentary presidential parties—Federalists led by John Adams and Republicans led by Thomas Jefferson—took shape and squared off. Jefferson ultimately prevailed, but only after an extended crisis triggered by several glitches in the Framers’ electoral machinery.
In particular, Republican electors had no formal way to designate that they wanted Jefferson for president and Aaron Burr for vice president rather than vice versa. Some politicians then tried to exploit the resulting confusion.
Enter the 12th Amendment, which allowed each party to designate one candidate for president and a separate candidate for vice president. The amendment’s modifications of the electoral process transformed the Framers’ framework, enabling future presidential elections to be openly populist and partisan affairs featuring two competing tickets.
It is the 12th Amendment’s Electoral College system, not the Philadelphia Framers’, that remains in place today. If the general citizenry’s lack of knowledge had been the real reason for the Electoral College, this problem was largely solved by 1800. So why wasn’t the entire Electoral College contraption scrapped at that point?
Standard civics-class accounts of the Electoral College rarely mention the real demon dooming direct national election in 1787 and 1803: slavery.
At the Philadelphia convention, the visionary Pennsylvanian James Wilson proposed direct national election of the president. But the savvy Virginian James Madison responded that such a system would prove unacceptable to the South: “The right of suffrage was much more diffusive [i.e., extensive] in the Northern than the Southern States; and the latter could have no influence in the election on the score of Negroes.”
In other words, in a direct election system, the North would outnumber the South, whose many slaves (more than half a million in all) of course could not vote.
But the Electoral College—a prototype of which Madison proposed in this same speech—instead let each southern state count its slaves, albeit with a two-fifths discount, in computing its share of the overall count.
Virginia emerged as the big winner—the California of the Founding era—with 12 out of a total of 91 electoral votes allocated by the Philadelphia Constitution, more than a quarter of the 46 needed to win an election in the first round.
After the 1800 census, Wilson’s free state of Pennsylvania had 10% more free persons than Virginia, but got 20% fewer electoral votes. Perversely, the more slaves Virginia (or any other slave state) bought or bred, the more electoral votes it would receive. Were a slave state to free any blacks who then moved North, the state could actually lose electoral votes.
If the system’s pro-slavery tilt was not overwhelmingly obvious when the Constitution was ratified, it quickly became so. For 32 of the Constitution’s first 36 years, a white slaveholding Virginian occupied the presidency.
Southerner Thomas Jefferson, for example, won the election of 1800-01 against Northerner John Adams in a race where the slavery-skew of the electoral college was the decisive margin of victory: without the extra electoral college votes generated by slavery, the mostly southern states that supported Jefferson would not have sufficed to give him a majority.
As pointed observers remarked at the time, Thomas Jefferson metaphorically rode into the executive mansion on the backs of slaves.
The 1796 contest between Adams and Jefferson had featured an even sharper division between northern states and southern states.
Thus, at the time the Twelfth Amendment tinkered with the Electoral College system rather than tossing it, the system’s pro-slavery bias was hardly a secret. Indeed, in the floor debate over the amendment in late 1803, Massachusetts Congressman Samuel Thatcher complained that “The representation of slaves adds thirteen members to this House in the present Congress, and eighteen Electors of President and Vice President at the next election.”
But Thatcher’s complaint went un-redressed. Once again, the North caved to the South by refusing to insist on direct national election.
In light of this more complete (if less flattering) account of the electoral college in the late 18th and early 19th century, Americans should ask themselves whether we want to maintain this odd—dare I say peculiar?—institution in the 21st century.
Your take on the matter is incomplete, inaccurate and
Top 10 Most Recent News Articles
Fluence Investors Face a November 27 Litigation Clock
Six calendar squares are all that separate eligible Fluence investors from the November 27, 2026 lead-plaintiff deadline. That is not much time to locate trade confirmations, calculate losses, and decide whether taking a larger role in a securities case makes sense. The lawsuit is not a verdict, and anybody pretending otherwise is selling smoke. But the underlying...
Continue Reading
Tigerlily Brings HIV Information to Women’s Health
A stubborn information gap is exactly where Tigerlily Foundation is planting its flag. The nonprofit’s new national HIV education and awareness campaign, THE POWER OF U, expands work that began in breast cancer advocacy into another area where women need clear facts, trusted voices, and room to speak without being shamed for needing answers. This is not a story that...
Continue Reading
Persistent Dry Eye Symptoms Call for a Closer Look
Eyes can turn into a stubborn little nuisance long before people realize something more complicated is going on. A bottle of artificial tears is easy to grab, cheap enough, and often perfectly sensible for a rough day of screens, wind, reading, or air conditioning. But Dr. Harlan Snyder’s point is the one worth sitting with: when dryness keeps barging back despite...
Continue Reading
Allooloo's 100M Calls Test Capital Markets AI Data
Forty-one point nine thousand issuers is a lot of financial clutter to keep straight, and Allooloo says its machines are getting called on to do precisely that at industrial scale. The Vancouver-based company reported on November 20 that its capital-markets data products now receive 100 million AI-agent calls a month—roughly 3.4 million daily, or 39 per second. That is...
Continue Reading
Fraud0-FouAnalytics Takes Aim at Legacy Ad Verification
Digital ad measurement has spent years grading its own homework, and that little arrangement may finally be getting some daylight. fraud0 and FouAnalytics say their expanded partnership will give advertisers impression-level visibility into where ads actually rendered, whether apparent humans engaged with them, and where wasted Google Ads spend might be recoverable. The...
Continue Reading
Oatly’s $4.13 Tender Offer Is a Legal Detour, Not a Sale
A $4.13 cash offer trading against a $7.17 close is the sort of thing that makes investors squint hard, and Verlinvest is practically waving a flag telling them why. This is not a conventional attempt to buy Oatly Group AB. It is a technical tender offer built to satisfy Swedish takeover rules while Verlinvest buys out its joint-venture partner’s interest in Oatly’s...
Continue Reading
Classic Chevrolet Gives $1.145M to 13 Local Groups
A Thanksgiving Check With Some Real Weight More than a million dollars changing hands before lunch is not the usual holiday fluff, and Classic Chevrolet's planned $1,145,040 donation deserves more than a quick nod. On Tuesday, November 24, at 11 a.m. CST, the Grapevine dealership says it will distribute that sum among 13 nonprofit organizations and charitable programs...
Continue Reading
Kyverna Probe Reopens IPO Disclosure Questions for Investors
Clinical-trial caveats have a nasty habit of becoming shareholder headaches years later. Kyverna Therapeutics is back in that uncomfortable zone after Kahn Swick & Foti said it has opened an investigation into whether the company’s officers and directors breached fiduciary duties or otherwise violated state or federal law. For holders of KYTX, this is not a verdict and...
Continue Reading
California Rideshare Data Exposes an Insurance Gap
Three California counties carried an outsized share of rideshare traffic, and the insurance fine print is where this story gets uncomfortable. A review by Mendez & Sanchez says Los Angeles, San Francisco, and San Diego counties accounted for nearly two-thirds of statewide rideshare trips between September 2019 and August 2020. That is an old snapshot, sure, but it points...
Continue Reading
Six LIFE Photographers Bring History Into Florida Focus
Seventy photographs can make a pretty loud argument when the historical record has been this lopsided. The Ashley Gibson Barnett Museum of Art at Florida Southern College has brought LIFE: Six Women Photographers to Lakeland, and it deserves more than the usual polite nod given to a traveling museum show. Open since November 14, 2026, and running through March 7, 2027,...
Continue ReadingTop 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles
Digital Utilities Ventures Pioneers Sustainable Farming in Africa
Transforming Agriculture with Easy FEN™ Technology Digital Utilities Ventures (DUTV) is making significant strides in sustainable agriculture with its Easy FEN™ modular units. Recently, the company secured a contract worth $3.4 million to deploy these innovative systems, targeting the challenges faced by farming communities in Africa. Sustainable Solutions Addressing...
Continue Reading
Prosafe SE Signs Contract with Ithaca Energy for Safe Caledonia
Prosafe SE Secures Major Contract with Ithaca Energy Prosafe SE has recently finalized a significant contract with Ithaca Energy (UK) Limited regarding the operations of the Safe Caledonia. This agreement comes after a Letter of Intent was issued on July 5, 2024, marking a key step in their partnership and commitment to delivering essential accommodation support. The...
Continue Reading
Robert Half Acknowledged for Corporate Responsibility Excellence
Recognizing Robert Half's Corporate Responsibility Achievements Global talent solutions and consulting giant Robert Half (NYSE: RHI) has recently received notable recognition from Newsweek, being named as one of America’s Most Responsible Companies for the year 2026. This award is a significant endorsement that highlights corporations that prioritize corporate social...
Continue Reading
Boeing's Job Cuts: Navigating Challenges in the Aerospace Sector
Boeing's Significant Workforce Reductions Boeing has made headlines recently with its decision to cut approximately 2,200 jobs. This substantial reduction affects workers in various divisions, particularly in Washington. The downsizing comes as part of a larger strategy to trim about 17,000 positions as the aerospace company faces prolonged financial and operational...
Continue Reading
Exploring the Innovations of Horizon3.ai in Cybersecurity
Introduction to Horizon3.ai's Autonomous Security Horizon3.ai has emerged as a pioneering force in the field of autonomous cybersecurity solutions, significantly shaping the landscape for security teams across the globe. The company, recognized for its innovative NodeZero Autonomous Security Platform, is dedicated to improving cyber resilience and enhancing the...
Continue Reading