Making the Rust Belt Rustier Paul Krugman JAN. 27,

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

Jan 27, 2017 at 10:52 AM 250

Quote:

Making the Rust Belt Rustier

Paul Krugman JAN. 27, 2017

Ambridge, Pa., a former steel town west of Pittsburgh, was once a Democratic stronghold but supported Donald Trump in November. Credit Hilary Swift for The New York Times

Donald Trump will break most of his campaign promises. Which promises will he keep?

The answer, I suspect, has more to do with psychology than it does with strategy. Mr. Trump is much more enthusiastic about punishing people than he is about helping them.

He may have promised not to cut Social Security and Medicare, or take health insurance away from the tens of millions who gained coverage under Obamacare, but in practice he seems perfectly willing to satisfy his party by destroying the safety net.

On the other hand, he appears serious about his eagerness to reverse America’s 80-year-long commitment to expanding world trade. On Thursday the White House said it was considering a 20 percent tariff on all imports from Mexico; doing so wouldn’t just pull the U.S. out of NAFTA, it would violate all our trading agreements.

Why does he want this? Because he sees international trade the way he sees everything else: as a struggle for dominance, in which you only win at somebody else’s expense.

His Inaugural Address made that perfectly clear: “For many decades we’ve enriched foreign industry at the expense of American industry.” And he sees punitive tariffs as a way to stop foreigners from selling us stuff, and thereby revive the “rusted-out factories scattered like tombstones across the landscape.”

Unfortunately, as just about any economist could tell him — but probably not within his three-minute attention span — it doesn’t work that way.

Even if tariffs lead to a partial reversal of the long decline in manufacturing employment, they won’t add jobs on net, just shift employment around. And they probably won’t even do that: Taken together, the new regime’s policies will probably lead to a faster, not slower, decline in American manufacturing.

How do we know this? We can look at the underlying economic logic, and we can also look at what happened during the Reagan years, which in some ways represent a dress rehearsal for what’s coming.

Now, I’m talking about the reality of Reagan, not the Republicans’ legend, which assigns all blame for the early-1980s recession to Jimmy Carter and all credit for the subsequent recovery to the sainted Ronald. In fact, that whole cycle had almost nothing to do with Reagan policies.

What Reagan did do, however, was blow up the budget deficit with military spending and tax cuts. This drove up interest rates, which drew in foreign capital. The inflow of capital, in turn, led to a stronger dollar, which made U.S. manufacturing uncompetitive. The trade deficit soared — and the long-term decline in the share of manufacturing in overall employment accelerated sharply.

Notably, it was under Reagan that talk of “deindustrialization” and the use of the term “Rust Belt” first became widespread.

It’s also worth pointing out that the Reagan-era manufacturing decline took place despite a significant amount of protectionism, especially a quota on Japanese car exports to America that ended up costing consumers more than $30 billion in today’s prices.

Will we repeat this story? The Trump regime will clearly blow up the deficit, mainly through tax cuts for the rich. (Funny, isn’t it, how all the deficit scolds have gone quiet?)

Yeah 'funny' and .....predictable. I've been right in calling that one repeatedly. LOL!

True, this may not boost spending very much, since the rich will save much of their windfall while the poor and the middle class will face harsh benefits cuts.

Still, interest rates have already risen in anticipation of the borrowing surge, and so has the dollar. So we do seem to be following the Reagan playbook for shrinking manufacturing.

It’s true that Mr. Trump appears ready to practice a much more extreme form of protectionism than Reagan, who avoided outright violations of existing trade deals. This could help some manufacturing industries. But it will also drive the dollar higher, hurting others.

And there’s a further factor to consider: The world economy has gotten a lot more complex over the past three decades. These days, hardly anything is simply “made in America,” or for that matter “made in China”: Manufacturing is a global enterprise, in which cars, planes and so on are assembled from components produced in multiple countries.

What will happen to this enterprise if the United States takes a meat ax to the agreements that govern international trade? There will, inevitably, be huge dislocation: Some U.S. factories and communities will benefit, but others will be hurt, bigly, by the loss of markets, crucial components or both.

Economists talk about the “China shock,” the disruption of some communities by surging Chinese exports in the 2000s. Well, the coming Trump shock will be at least as disruptive.

And the biggest losers, as with health care, will be white working-class voters who were foolish enough to believe that Donald Trump was on their side.

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Conquering Dental Anxiety: Tips for a Calm Visit

Breaking the Fear of the Dentist's Chair There's no sugar-coating it—hitting the dental chair can feel like gearing up for a bout in the boxing ring, especially if anxiety's already taken root. But listen, it doesn't have to be that way, and that's where HelloNation's recent feature steps in. Dr. Adriane Lippian and Dr. Jim Lippian, dentists hailing from Texarkana,...

TCL Powers Senegal's Youth Olympics with Solar Display

Innovative Display Tech Lands in Senegal Cutting through the noise of corporate clutter, TCL just made a move in Senegal that's got layers deeper than a PR stunt. They’ve handed over an ultra-low-power display system to the Université Amadou Mahtar Mbow (UAM) in Dakar, which is also moonlighting as the Youth Olympic Village for the 2026 Games. This isn't just any...

Sonnenfeld, Curtis Shine in Honor of the Reiners' Legacy

Barry Sonnenfeld Takes Center Stage The spotlight is set for a different kind of blockbuster event—not on the silver screen this time, but under the starlit glamour of Beverly Hills. That's right, folks, Barry Sonnenfeld, the DGA and Emmy award-laden filmmaker we all know and love, will be the maestro hosting the Children's Institute's (CII) Cape & Gown Gala on November...

PRTH Shareholder Concerns Amid Merger Investigation

Behind Closed Doors: PRTH's Merger Drama Unfolds The market's got its share of tricky maneuvers and right now, Priority Technology Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ:PRTH) is under the magnifying glass. Levi & Korsinsky, LLP has kicked off an investigation into the nitty-gritty of PRTH's acquisition by its largest shareholder—none other than their own Chairman and CEO, Thomas C....

Springbrook's AI Push: Transforming Local Governance

Revolutionizing Government Tech with AI Springbrook Software is positioning itself as a frontrunner in modernizing government tech, unveiling a suite of AI-driven innovations under its Cirrus ERP platform. During their recent conference, Activate 2026, held in Orlando, the commitment to transforming how local governments operate was clear. With new tools like AI Invoicing...

SAMILBIO Gambles on 'Chaeyun' Launch With November Events

Can SAMILBIO's New Products Make a Splash? In a world where skincare is more competitive than a hot dog stand outside a vegan festival, here comes SAMILBIO with their latest offerings. Launching a whitening cream and an acne-fighting gel under the 'Chaeyun' brand, this company isn't just sticking to digital—it's diving into face-to-face consumer interaction. I mean,...

Richmond Mutual's Q3 2026: A Merger's Mixed Impact

Third Quarter Reflections: Big Changes, Mixed Results Alright, Richmond Mutual Bancorporation just dropped their third quarter results for 2026 and let's just say, it's got more layers than an onion. Richmond's the parent of First Bank Midwest, and their latest numbers tell a tale of a merger aftermath with Farmers Bancorp. They've pulled off a balance sheet expansion,...

Main Street Merger Faces Scrutiny: What It Means for Shareholders

Under the Radar, but Not for Long Ah, mergers—those grand gestures in corporate America that promise growth, synergy, and shareholder value. But not every deal is a head-turner; some fly under the radar until someone grabs the magnifying glass. And that's exactly what's happening with Main Street Financial Services Corp.'s (OTC: MSWV) proposed merger with First...

NIDS Aims Global with CES 2027, Boosts Sensor Supply

Pushing Boundaries at CES 2027 Kicking into high gear, NIDS Co., Ltd. is eyeing the CES 2027 stage like it's their personal gold rush. Already a heavyweight in environmental sensors, the company is all set to seize fresh international opportunities and expand their B2B supply footprint worldwide. Already Turning Heads Founded back in 2000, NIDS ain't new to the sensor...

NABEP's Strategic Push: 41 Rigs to Bolster Output

On The Ground: NABEP's Expanding Venezuelan Presence Think of oil production as a high-stakes poker game where each drill and rig is a well-placed bet. North American Blue Energy Partners (NABEP) is going all in on Venezuela, boosting their rig fleet and pushing production capacity to new heights. Set your sights on November when NABEP's in-country fleet will hit 41 rigs...