The Peaceful Transfer of Power -- and Its Enemies

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone getmoreshares #16738
151
The Peaceful Transfer of Power -- and Its Enemies



We mouth the formulaic words but reflect too little on the political miracle that is the peaceful transfer of power.

The enormous authority entrusted to the president shifts from someone who leaves office voluntarily, without a bullet fired, to another who assumes office by oft-repeated constitutional procedures. These powers quietly transfer from one party to another, from one set of policies and preferences to another, and often from one section of the country to another.

The same political miracle that occurred Friday happened a few weeks earlier in the House and Senate, when newly elected officials took office peacefully, with full powers. They do so routinely, even when majorities switch from Republican to Democrat.

Until the day before they leave office, government officials have full powers. The next day, they have none.

And yet throughout history, since people have walked upright, we have been ruled involuntarily by kings, cousins, or tyrants.

That we are not so ruled, that we vest vast powers in representatives we choose freely and that they relinquish that power peacefully when their terms end is a rare, historic achievement.

That achievement was hard won. That is why the letter from Civil War officer Sullivan Ballou, read at Donald Trump’s inauguration by Senate Minority Leader Charles Schumer, was so fitting, so moving. Major Ballou wrote to his wife in July 1861, on the eve of the first major battle of the Civil War:

"I have no misgivings about, or lack of confidence in, the cause in which I am engaged, and my courage does not halt or falter. I know how strongly American Civilization now leans upon the triumph of the Government, and how great a debt we owe to those who went before us through the blood and suffering of the Revolution. And I am willing – perfectly willing – to lay down all my joys in this life, to help maintain this Government, and to pay that debt."

Union Major Ballou died a week later at the first Battle of Bull Run.

Destabilizing the Peaceful Transfer of Power

In our constitutional democracy, the transfer of power will only remain peaceful if it is considered legitimate by nearly all our people and their representatives.

Our shared sense of legitimacy has been imperiled in our last three elections.

George W. Bush came into office only after a Supreme Court ruling, deciding a Florida election so close that the outcome could not be determined otherwise.
Barack Obama came into office with overwhelming goodwill (and an overwhelming sense of legitimacy), but there were a vocal few who never believed he could legally take office because he allegedly was not born in America. The most vocal was Donald J. Trump.
Trump's own legitimacy as the duly elected president was famously questioned by civil-rights hero John Lewis, whose refusal to attend the inauguration was followed by several dozen colleagues.

Rep. John Lewis’ Mistake

However sincere the Georgia congressman was, however repulsed he was by Trump's comments as a candidate, he made a fundamental mistake. His boycott, buttressed by his moral stature, encouraged others to follow and, sadly, prompted the president-elect’s sharp response.

Lewis’s boycott, like Harry Reid's change of Senate voting rules (from supermajorities to simple majorities on most appointee confirmations), is likely to be only the opening salvo, not the final one. In four or eight or 16 years, another president's political foes will find it easier to respond in kind.

Remember the near-universal condemnation of a Republican representative who interrupted President Obama’s 2009 State of the Union by shouting “You lie”? Why the condemnation? Because it was the wrong time and place for openly voiced partisan rancor. So, too, is boycotting the new president’s oath of office.

Renewing the Peaceful Transfer

What should Rep. Lewis have done? He should have drawn a crucial distinction between two aspects of Inauguration Day. One is the stately function of transferring power, which bring us together as nation. All elected representatives should participate in that swearing-in ceremony, and so should all citizens. Hillary Clinton deserves enormous praise for doing so; it must have been excruciating. But she did it.

The other aspect is a festive celebration of the person and party taking office. There is no obligation to join these celebrations or rejoice in them. If you do not approve the person or staunchly oppose the party’s policies, then boycott the parade, sit out the dances, and proudly march in peaceful protests the next day, as long as they oppose the person or the party elected, not the legitimacy of the election itself.

Too many Democrats, aided (apparently) by the U.S. intelligence community, have questioned the legitimacy of the election outcome. They have rightly noted that the Russian government did something unprecedented in our elections. Russians not only acquired secret information, they released it to affect American voters. That interference should be investigated thoroughly and sanctioned. But without any evidence the Russians changed the outcome, it is reckless to use their hacking and disinformation campaigns to undermine the legitimacy of a new president, however much you dislike him.

Other Democrats, aided by liberal media, have repeatedly stressed Trump's loss of the popular vote. As a political observation, that point is perfectly fine. It underscores a reality: The new president will lead a divided nation and lacks a popular mandate, just as President Bill Clinton did when he was elected with only a plurality of the popular vote.

But, again, partisans have gone too far, using the popular vote to argue the president is illegitimate. That goes beyond partisan bickering to attack our Constitutional arrangements for electing presidents. Challenging those arrangements is fine in their own right. Challenging them in the context of Trump's Electoral College victory, however, shakes the foundations of our peaceful transfer of power. Too many Democrats have done exactly that.

There is time enough, going forward, to reflect on the blunt populism of President Trump's inaugural address, with its pointed challenge to Washington insiders and its bold revision of America's global role.

But those reflections and vigorous debate about them will come in a polity that welcomes dissent within "an ordered liberty." That ordered liberty is a rare, historic achievement, won over generations. It needs to be remembered, nourished, and supported, not undermined.
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Carbonization Furnaces Turn Waste Rules Into Demand

Updated Category News Views 84

Smoke has become an expensive habit for farmers, mills, and municipalities. That is the real commercial backdrop for carbonization furnaces, not some glossy green-tech slogan. MarketsandMarkets estimates this small global equipment market at $310 million in 2026 and projects $510 million by 2031, a 10.2% compound annual growth rate. For a capital-equipment niche, that is...

Continue Reading
BreakBio's New CSO Adds Vaccine Trial Credibility in Cancer

Updated Category News Views 104

Personalized cancer vaccines have no shortage of grand promises; seasoned clinical operators are the rarer commodity. That is why BreakBio's appointment of Dr. Greg Lizée as chief scientific officer deserves a closer look, even if nobody should confuse an executive hire with clinical validation. BreakBio is private, its lead program remains in development, and cancer...

Continue Reading
Mindstream’s Jordan AI Campus Faces Its First Real Test

Updated Category News Views 31

Jordan’s AI ambitions just got attached to a very large gas meter. Mindstream Energy has unveiled a plan for an AI-ready data-center campus at Al-Risha in Mafraq Governorate, built around dedicated natural-gas generation rather than a conventional dependence on the utility grid. The headline number is 400 megawatts of eventual capacity. The number that matters first is...

Continue Reading
ACOLT Bets on Gold, Craft, and a Sci-Fi Story World

Updated Category News Views 74

A gold pendant moonlighting as a plot device is not the usual luxury pitch, and thank goodness for that. ACOLT, the Denver-based men's fine jewelry house founded by Colton Hindle, plans an international December 2026 launch of its Gold Collection alongside CHRYSON Volume 1: The Arrival, an original science-fiction comic. The actual hand-forged pieces are meant to show up...

Continue Reading
Receipts Turns Vegas Party Shirts Into AR Keepsakes

Updated Category News Views 123

A shirt that coughs up a Vegas weekend when scanned is either a smart little keepsake trick or a privacy headache wearing sequins. Receipts™, introduced by Las Vegas-based Naked City Couture and the AR Trading Card Company, is betting it can be the former. The concept is simple enough: friends wear the apparel, capture photos and videos during a trip, upload those...

Continue Reading
Software-Defined Cars Put $310 Billion in Play by 2035

Updated Category News Views 71

Cars are becoming rolling computers, and that changes who gets paid. Market Growth Reports projects the software-defined vehicle market will rise from $56.94 billion to $310.46 billion by 2035, a 20.74% compound annual growth rate. That is a loud number, no question. Still, investors ought to treat any long-range market forecast like a map, not a mortgage deed. The...

Continue Reading
Stanford Forum Puts Industrial AI in the Real World

Updated Category News Views 144

Factory Data Is Not a Free Lunch A factory dataset is worth precisely nothing if its owner cannot control it. That was the hard-nosed thread running through the ASI City Forum at Stanford on November 17: industrial AI is not just about smarter models or splashy chip announcements. It is about whether manufacturers will trust a system with proprietary operating data,...

Continue Reading
Hyster-Yale’s $135 Million Convert Carries Real Cost

Updated Category News Views 143

Forklift makers do not usually get to hide a 7.50% borrowing cost behind glossy financing jargon. Hyster-Yale has priced $135 million of convertible senior notes due in 2031, lifting the deal from the originally announced $125 million. There is also an option for initial purchasers to take another $20 million. For NYSE:HY shareholders, this is not a simple debt cleanup....

Continue Reading
Tigerlily Takes Its Advocacy Model to Ovarian Cancer

Updated Category News Views 166

Ovarian cancer has a nasty habit of hiding behind symptoms people are taught to shrug off. Persistent bloating or pelvic pain can look like any number of ordinary problems, and that ambiguity is exactly why practical, trusted education matters. Tigerlily Foundation's new ovarian cancer initiative is not a flashy breakthrough claim. It is a grounded attempt to help women...

Continue Reading
Makera A1S Tests the Desktop CNC Metal-Cutting Promise

Updated Category News Views 61

Aluminum chips are where desktop-machine marketing stops bluffing, and Makera is leaning right into that test with the A1S. The company opened global pre-orders on November 18 for a machine aimed squarely at the awkward middle ground: users who have outgrown entry-level hobby gear but do not have room, budget, or patience for a full industrial setup. That is a real market...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Future Growth of the Premium Chocolate Sector: Insights and Trends

Updated Category News Views 85

An Insight into the Premium Chocolate Market The global premium chocolate market is experiencing remarkable growth, with projections indicating an increase of USD 20.8 billion between 2024 and 2028. This growth is expected to occur at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 9.48%. Key drivers for this rise encompass new product launches and evolving consumer preferences....

Continue Reading
Lovesac's Commitment to Sustainability: The 2024 ESG Report

Updated Category News Views 260

Understanding Lovesac's 2024 ESG Report The Lovesac Company (NASDAQ: LOVE) has recently published its Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Report for the fiscal year ending February 4, 2024. This comprehensive report showcases the company’s unwavering commitment to sustainability and responsible business practices, emphasizing their innovative product offerings...

Continue Reading
How High-Net-Worth Investors Can Save Millions in Taxes

Updated Category News Views 171

Strategies for High-Net-Worth Investors to Manage Tax Implications In a world where technology and artificial intelligence are reshaping the investment landscape, the CEO of Wealthstone, Zak Gardezy, offers new insights for high-net-worth individuals. His recent publication, Secrets of a Wealth Advisor: How To Diversify Concentrated Stock Tax Efficiently, focuses on...

Continue Reading
Major Leadership Change at Camping World Holdings Inc. Revealed

Updated Category News Views 251

Marcus Lemonis Steps Down from Camping World Holdings Inc. Marcus Lemonis, a prominent entrepreneur and television personality famed for his roles in popular shows, has announced his departure as CEO of Camping World Holdings Inc. (NYSE: CWH). This announcement marks a significant change for the company Lemonis co-founded, which has grown into a leading name in the...

Continue Reading
Market Outlook Update: Novozymes' Stock Rating Downgrade

Updated Category News Views 131

Recent Downgrade of Novozymes Stock by Citi Novozymes A/S (OTC: NVZMY) recently faced a significant shift in its market perception as Citi has downgraded the company’s stock rating from Neutral to Sell. Even with this downgrade, the price target has seen a slight improvement—from DKK390.00 to DKK400.00. This change arrives despite the company showcasing a remarkable...

Continue Reading