Federal EB-5
DECEMBER 07, 2016
We will see what comes of
Federal EB-5
DECEMBER 07, 2016
We will see what comes of this:
We’re hearing a lot these days about “draining the swamp” of Washington corruption but as every serious student of crime and punishment knows, the swamp is not one, but many.
The swamp contains multitudes. It is Washington. It is New York. It is San Bernardino County. It is the “high places before Jerusalem”—meaning the worship of idols, meaning corruption is not a place but a practice, the lesser angels of our nature brought low by vanity and ambition, greed and delusion. Today, we look at one corner of that vast ecosystem: the federal EB-5 program.
Congress will give EB-5 a new lease on life this week by slipping renewal of the controversial program into a continuing resolution. Administered by the Department of Homeland Security, it is formally known as the Employment-Based Fifth Preference Immigrant Investor Program. In plain language, it’s a green card fire sale for rich foreigners.
Under EB-5, a foreigner pays $500,000 and is granted a green card, placing the purchaser and immediate family on a road to permanent residency in the United States. Silken middlemen on two continents speed the process. The stated purpose of the EB-5 program is job creation. Each $500,000 fee is supposed to be directed to projects in economically distressed “targeted employment areas” in the U.S. to create ten full-time jobs.
Estimates of the funds generated by EB-5 in the last decade range from $15 billion to $21 billion. The cheap financing has attracted big time commercial developers and an industry to support them. But rather than flowing to hard-hit economic zones (Detroit, anyone?) EB-5 dollars have mostly gone to support glitzy projects in places such as Beverly Hills, Las Vegas, Miami, Manhattan, Atlantic Yards in Brooklyn and Nassau Coliseum on Long Island.
As the New York Times recently noted, EB-5 “is increasingly supporting large luxury real estate projects, not the development in the rural and downtrodden districts that some say were the original targets of the program.”
According to a report by the Government Accountability Office, the program has created “unique fraud and national security risks.” Hustlers around the world are hawking the precious U.S. visas. Sales have tripled in recent years. The GAO says funding for the visas could come through the “drug trade, human trafficking, or other criminal activities.” Those claims of ten-jobs-per-green-card seem sketchy as well. The reporting on the economic benefits of the program, the GAO warned, “is not valid or reliable.” Money flowing in from China is one of the main drivers of the program.
EB-5 is a hit because the easy money benefits so many movers and shakers here in the U.S. That includes some prominent members of the incoming presidential team. Mr. Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, raised $50 million in EB-5 funds for a 50-storey luxury tower in New Jersey, Trump Bay Street. The tower adjoins another hi-rise condo, Trump Plaza Residence. Mr. Trump licensed his name to both towers but was not involved in the construction funding. Another Trump-branded project, a 33-storey luxury hotel and condo, is seeking $40 million in EB-5 funds, the Wall Street Journal reported.
Democrats are closely tied to EB-5 as well. Senator Chuck Schumer is a fierce defender of EB-5 funds for major real-estate developers. At a recent Judiciary Committee hearing on improving EB-5, Mr. Schumer mocked the testimony of a witness who spoke about putting “the projects in only poor people areas.” Mr. Schumer added, “It won’t happen—it’s not how cities are structured.”
Mr. Schumer is a longtime ally of the powerful developer and Democratic Party heavyweight Bruce Ratner, who built the Barclays Center sports arena and Atlantic Yards development in Brooklyn with more than $500 million in EB-5 funds. Mr. Ratner is also in the EB-5 business on Long Island, where he has teamed up with a Russian mogul, Mikhail Prokhorov, to seek $90 million in EB-5 funds for the renovation of Nassau Coliseum.
According to a Judicial Watch investigation, after leveraging more than $1 billion in taxpayer assistance and EB-5 funds to develop Barclays Center and Atlantic Yards, Mr. Ratner walked away from the project. He sold his stake in Barclays to Mr. Prokhorov for more than $500 million and transferred ownership of Atlantic Yards to a business controlled by the Chinese government for $208 million.
In a little noticed twist, most EB-5 money appears to end up in New York City. No wonder Chuck Schumer loves it! Recent data, cited by David North of the Center for Immigration Studies here and here, suggests that about 56% of EB-5 funds—more than $10 billion—went to the city, mainly Manhattan. Mr. North drilled down into a study by two New York University scholars, Jeanne Calderon and Gary Friedland, who painstakingly compiled data from 52 large EB-5 projects nationwide.
Mr. North’s conclusion? The Obama administration is hiding a “huge tilt” of EB-5 funds to New York. The “Obama administration,” writes Mr. North, “…has refused to produce statistics on the distribution of EB-5 moneys geographically…. Whether the administration did this deliberately or not, the result has been to mask the enormous tilt of these funds—originally designed to serve depressed areas—to prosperous areas such as Park Avenue and Wall Street.”
All this is perfectly legal, bringing us back to the question of our lesser angels, to the dilemma of corruption as ethical misconduct, not law-breaking. Some swamps are harder to drain—or even to map—than others. But over at ecosystem EB-5, the solutions seem pretty easy for a new president pledged to combat corruption. The system should be tightened to get rid of the grift. Investments should be directed toward truly needy areas in the United States. Mr. Trump should order his agencies to ensure full transparency on EB-5 statistics. And both the president-elect and his son-in-law should set an example of high ethics by getting out of the EB-5 business.
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP
Scroll down for more posts ▼
Top 10 Most Recent News Articles
Profitability Arrived With a Few Splinters A shrinking top line wearing a profit badge is never an easy thing to applaud. Youdao delivered RMB1.4 billion in third-quarter 2026 revenue, or US$213.1 million, down 12.3% from a year earlier. Yet income from operations climbed 19.2% to RMB33.7 million, making this the company’s ninth consecutive quarter of operating...
Continue Reading
Most infrastructure only earns a thought when it breaks, and that is precisely the nerve these films are trying to touch. Nicely Done Productions has released the final five installments of its ten-part Threads of Connectivity documentary series, hosted on National Geographic's global digital platform. The subjects are illycaffè, Cargill, Honeywell Aerospace, Western...
Continue Reading
Private-market chatter has been leaking past the velvet rope for years, and advisors are sick of learning about it after a client already has a pitch deck in hand. FLX Networks is responding to that irritation by letting its eligible advisor and wealth-management members review select pre-IPO opportunities shared by other members. Announced November 19, 2026, the move is...
Continue Reading
Two million lights are doing more than brightening up a few winter evenings in Wichita. Illuminations at Botanica returns from November 23, 2026, through January 2, 2027, and the pleasant part of this story is that the spectacle has a practical backbone: it is Botanica’s largest fundraiser. For a garden nonprofit, that matters a whole lot more than another shiny...
Continue Reading
Three smart professionals can still hand a client a mess when nobody owns the handoff. That unglamorous reality sits behind the Professional Collaboration Institute, or PCI, which Sarano and Brooke Kelley plan to launch in a virtual briefing on December 2. The outfit wants to turn cross-profession coordination into a teachable, measurable discipline rather than leave it...
Continue Reading
A Small Slot With a Big Audience A calendar entry can still matter when the man holding the microphone runs AT&T. John Stankey, AT&T chairman and chief executive, is scheduled for a fireside chat at the UBS Global Media and Communications Conference on Tuesday, Dec. 8, beginning at 8:15 a.m. Eastern time. The company says the event will be webcast live through its...
Continue Reading
A missed rebate form can sting harder than most people expect, especially when a household has already spent the year watching property taxes, rent, groceries, and every other stubborn bill chew through fixed income. Pennsylvania’s Property Tax/Rent Rebate Program is not glamorous, and it is certainly not an investing story. It is, however, the kind of direct household...
Continue Reading
Ownership was the uncomfortable word hanging over Cape Town on day two of Africa Tech Festival 2026, and frankly it should make investors sit up. Africa’s digital economy has no shortage of big promises, shiny AI demos or overseas executives talking about opportunity. The harder question is who funds the pipes, owns the data, makes the rules and actually keeps the...
Continue Reading
A Calendar Entry With Real Weight December 9 is not earnings day, but it is the sort of date shareholders ought to circle anyway. Lowe's plans to hold its 2026 Analyst and Investor Conference at 8 a.m. Eastern time in New York City, with a live webcast available for those not sitting in the room. For owners of NYSE:LOW, these gatherings can be more useful than the usual...
Continue Reading
Five Australian business centres are one thing; getting a stalled crane or earthmover moving again is the whole ballgame. Zoomlion’s Nov. 4 customer gathering in Sydney matters because Chairman and CEO Zhan Chunxin kept the discussion on the unglamorous stuff: product quality, technical support, parts availability and local training. That is exactly where an equipment...
Continue Reading
Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles
Harnessing Digital Opportunities for the Excluded Population In an era where digital connectivity is vital for success, a significant portion of the global population remains disconnected. This is not just a statistic but a call to action as we face the reality that over 627 million people worldwide are still excluded from essential digital services. This number surpasses...
Continue Reading
Revolutionary Investment in Cancer Treatment First Ascent Biomedical, celebrated for its advanced approach to personalized cancer therapy, has recently secured an impressive $6 million investment from Vidal Duart Enterprises, Inc. This funding marks a significant stride for the company as it aims to reshape the landscape of medical oncology. Accompanying this investment,...
Continue Reading
Ameris Bancorp Set to Reveal Third Quarter Earnings Ameris Bancorp, a notable financial institution with a significant presence in the Southeast, has announced its plans to release third quarter 2024 earnings. The company will share its financial results via a press release following the market close on a Thursday, in late October. This strategic timing aligns with the...
Continue Reading
Amerant Bank Welcomes Jeffrey K. Tischler Amerant Bank, known for its strong reputation in the banking sector, has announced a significant addition to its executive team. Jeffrey K. Tischler has been appointed as the Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Credit Officer. This crucial role involves overseeing the bank's Credit Services, Portfolio Management, and Credit...
Continue Reading
Modera South Shore: A New Era of Living Modera South Shore is set to transform contemporary living with the addition of 270 stylish homes to a friendly community. Nestled in a charming seaside setting, this modern garden-style community is positioned ideally for those seeking a balanced lifestyle. With a thoughtful design aimed at both comfort and elegance, it promises to...
Continue Reading