Shoddy Science in a Safe Space: Psychologist Slams Research

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone cashclan #16484
308
Shoddy Science in a Safe Space: Psychologist Slams Research on Microaggressions

388336.jpg

In 1970, Harvard psychiatrist Chester Pierce coined the term "microaggression" to describe seemingly minor but hurtful put-downs and dismissals inflicted upon African Americans by their non-black peers. For forty years, the term was mostly confined to the esoteric world of academia, but it has recently entered its heyday.

Just under a decade ago, in a paper published to the journal American Psychologist, Columbia University Professor of Counseling Psychology Derald Wing Sue and his collaborators introduced the modern definition of "microaggression":

"brief and commonplace daily verbal, behavioral, or environmental indignities, whether intentional or unintentional, that communicate hostile, derogatory, or negative racial slights and insults toward people of color."

According to Sue, examples of microaggressions include saying "America is a melting pot," as it implies that minorities should assimilate to the dominant culture; announcing "I believe the most qualified person should get the job," which sends the message that people of color are given extra unfair benefits because of their race; asking somebody "Where are you from?" which implies that they are not American; and complimenting a person of color by saying "You are so articulate," as it implies that such quality is rare amongst minorities.

Any connected individual is undoubtedly aware that popular media, public forums, and college campuses have grown rife with discussions about trigger warnings, safe spaces, and microaggressions, inciting ire and disagreement. Such disagreement is almost entirely absent from the nascent but growing body of research on microaggressions, however. Generally, most psychologists studying the topic seem to uncritically assume that microaggressions are mentally damaging, universally interpreted as demeaning, and reflect implicit prejudice and aggression in the people who say them.

This one-sided view of microaggressions surprised Emory University Professor of Psychology Scott O. Lilienfeld, who sees a lot of problems with the term "microaggression" as well as the associated scientific work being conducted. He outlined a number of his concerns in a blistering review just published to the journal Perspectives on Psychological Science.

Publically, Lilienfeld is best known for dispelling misconceptions about psychology in his book 50 Great Myths of Popular Psychology. He's a vocal advocate for evidence-based treatments and methods in his field, and has frequently policed his peers, encouraging them to pursue quality research practices. It was with that noble aim in mind that he turned his attention to microaggression research.

On the whole, Lilienfeld found the sub-field to be plagued with bias and sloppy methods. He also determined the definition of "microaggression" itself to be vague, allowing "a vast number of potential behaviors, many of which hinge on highly subjective retrospective judgments." He further noted that "there is no evidence that microaggressions are statistically associated with aggression or prejudice in deliverers." Lilienfeld also discovered that studies generally featured subjects strongly predisposed to believe in microaggressions and almost exclusively relied on subjective, self-reported data.

In light of the field's sorry state, Lilienfeld suggested that a moratorium be placed on practical applications of the research. The most notable of these applications are microaggression training programs instituted across college campuses, in which incoming freshmen are taught to recognize and guard themselves against the verbal transgressions. Lilienfeld also argued that microaggressions should be relabeled as “inadvertent racial slights."

To be clear, Lilienfeld is not opposed to research on microaggressions, he simply thinks that the sub-field needs to become far more empirical. To reach that goal, Lilienfeld provided 18 recommendations, among them, recruiting subjects from various ideological groups, coming up with better ways to measure the effects of microaggressions, and examining the people inclined to deliver microaggressions. He also suggested that researchers seek scrutiny from colleagues who might not share their political views. That could be a tall task, since the social sciences suffer from an extreme liberal bias. For every social scientist who is conservative, there are eight who are liberal.

Lilienfeld hopes his colleagues will consider his advice, as he believes their research as it's currently carried out could further tarnish psychology's stained reputation.

"One likely reason for the less than stellar impression of psychology as a science among many laypersons has been our field’s troubling propensity to advance premature assertions in the absence of adequate evidence," he writes.

As Lilienfeld notes, his "tough love" review could probably be considered a microaggression.
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Five SEAL Medal of Honor Signatures, One Charity Lot

Updated Category News Views 35

A single rifle can carry a staggering amount of meaning when the names on it belong to all five living U.S. Navy SEAL Medal of Honor recipients. Rock Island Auction Company plans to offer that one-of-a-kind custom precision rifle during its December 4–6, 2026 Premier Firearms Auction, and the financial arrangement is unusually clean: 100% of proceeds are slated for the...

Continue Reading
Jeff Stern Turns Travel Photography Into Full Attention

Updated Category News Views 57

A cancelled photography conference in March 2020 sent Jeff Stern toward the American Southwest, and that detour eventually became A Change of Scenery. Frankly, that origin has more grit than the usual polished creative-origin tale. While much of the world had stopped moving, Stern went alone, stood at White Pocket beneath a cobalt sky, and began reconsidering what he...

Continue Reading
TDH's First-Half Revenue Grew, but Margins Vanished

Updated Category News Views 91

A rental business can add tenants and still march backward, and TDH Holdings just demonstrated the ugly math. For the six months ended June 30, 2026, revenue from continuing operations rose 26.45% to $0.74 million. That is the pleasant number, and it deserves exactly one polite nod. Everything beneath it looks far less comfortable: costs climbed faster than revenue, gross...

Continue Reading
Adecco Finds AI Value Depends on Better Work Redesign

Updated Category News Views 74

A shiny AI license is not a productivity strategy, and Adecco's latest workforce survey puts some hard numbers behind that irritation. The company surveyed 40,500 workers in 36 countries for its seventh Global Workforce of the Future report, released November 19, 2026. Its central finding is disarmingly sensible: AI produces more when companies rebuild the work around it...

Continue Reading
Alphabet Lawsuit Puts Gemini Delays Under a Microscope

Updated Category News Views 151

July’s twin punches to Alphabet shares were not the sort of wobble investors can casually shrug off. First came a report on July 16 that Google was months behind on Gemini 3.5 Pro, its flagship AI model, after disappointing results from updated training data. Then came the harder financial reality a week later: a much larger 2026 capital-spending plan, negative...

Continue Reading
First Horizon Opens Its Charlotte Office in South End

Updated Category News Views 14

A Building Is Not a Balance Sheet Charlotte got a fresh First Horizon sign at 110 East Boulevard on Nov. 19, 2026, and that is a sensible move, not a magic trick. The bank has officially opened a corporate office in the city’s South End neighborhood, positioning the team to develop client relationships across the Charlotte area and broaden its regional footprint. That...

Continue Reading
Makera A1S Tests the Desktop CNC Metal-Cutting Promise

Updated Category News Views 84

Aluminum chips are where desktop-machine marketing stops bluffing, and Makera is leaning right into that test with the A1S. The company opened global pre-orders on November 18 for a machine aimed squarely at the awkward middle ground: users who have outgrown entry-level hobby gear but do not have room, budget, or patience for a full industrial setup. That is a real market...

Continue Reading
PenFed’s Toys for Tots Drive Targets Holiday Gift Gaps

Updated Category News Views 69

A missing present under a tree is not a statistic anybody ought to glide past. PenFed Credit Union has opened its annual Toys for Tots collection across Washington-region branches, taking new, unwrapped toys through December 8 at 1:00 p.m. ET. The useful detail, and frankly the one worth remembering when people default to buying the easiest shiny thing on a shelf, is...

Continue Reading
Why Professional Collaboration May Matter More in AI

Updated Category News Views 43

Three smart professionals can still hand a client a mess when nobody owns the handoff. That unglamorous reality sits behind the Professional Collaboration Institute, or PCI, which Sarano and Brooke Kelley plan to launch in a virtual briefing on December 2. The outfit wants to turn cross-profession coordination into a teachable, measurable discipline rather than leave it...

Continue Reading
Royce Global Trust's Discount Is Still the Whole Debate

Updated Category News Views 90

A $3.03 gap is staring investors right in the face. As of October 31, 2026, Royce Global Trust carried a net asset value of $17.51 per share while the market price sat at $14.48. That works out to roughly a 17.3% discount to NAV, and with a closed-end fund, that discount is not some footnote shoved under the table. It is a major part of the return story, good or bad. The...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Light AI Secures Major Over-Allotment and Begins Trading on Cboe

Updated Category News Views 160

Light AI Announces Successful Closure of Over-Allotment Option Light AI Inc. (formerly known as Mojave Brands Inc.) (CBOE CA: ALGO) is thrilled to share recent developments regarding its over-allotment option, which saw a successful full exercise by the Agents. This step resulted in the purchase of an additional 2,757,000 units, amounting to an impressive gross proceeds...

Continue Reading
U.S. Stock Market Futures Decline Ahead of Key Economic Data

Updated Category News Views 290

U.S. Stock Market Futures Show Caution Ahead of Economic Reports Recently, U.S. stock index futures have taken a downward turn as traders adopt a cautious stance. With a series of economic data reports set to be released this week, the financial markets are bracing for potential impacts on the Federal Reserve's monetary policy in the near future. Market Performance in...

Continue Reading
RUSH's 2026 Tour: Celebrating Legacy and New Beginnings

Updated Category News Views 329

RUSH's 2026 Tour: A Celebration of Music and Legacy Geddy Lee and Alex Lifeson are set to celebrate over 50 years of RUSH's musical journey as they announce a special headline tour for 2026, named the Fifty Something Tour. This tour not only commemorates the incredible music and legacy of RUSH, but also pays tribute to their late drummer and lyricist Neil Peart, whose...

Continue Reading
Star Hats & Embroidery Shines on CBS National Network

Updated Category News Views 126

Star Hats & Embroidery Takes Center Stage on National Television Star Hats & Embroidery is proud to announce its recent television features that highlight the innovative products and services they offer. Following an exciting showcase on CBS's Las Vegas Now Lifestyle TV Show, the brand has appeared in numerous segments across the nation, captivating audiences everywhere....

Continue Reading
Celebrate Culture and Community at Ohkay Hotel's Lowrider Show

Updated Category News Views 350

Celebrate the Return of the Lowrider Phenomena The excitement is building as the Lowrider Phenomena Show rolls back into Ohkay Hotel Casino, promising an unforgettable day filled with stunning custom rides, electrifying live entertainment, and family-friendly activities. This eagerly anticipated event is free and welcomes everyone to partake in the festivities. A Vibrant...

Continue Reading