Did members of Congress exempt themselves from complying

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
Bhawks HOT #29725
159
Did members of Congress exempt themselves from complying with the health care reform laws?

tom-pantsonfire.gif

Quote:
Members of Congress "specifically exempted themselves from many of the laws they have passed, such as being exempt from any fear of prosecution for sexual harassment" ... (and) from the healthcare reform."

— Chain email on Sunday, January 6th, 2013 in a chain email message

Did members of Congress exempt themselves from complying with the health care reform laws?

http://www.politifact.com/ohio/statements/201...mplying-h/

By Tom Feran on Wednesday, January 16th, 2013 at 6:00 a.m.

A new poll released this month by the firm Public Policy Polling showed Congress to be less popular than colonoscopies, root canals or cockroaches.

To get a lower favorability rating than Congress, the Washington newspaper The Hill reported, they had to be compared to lobbyists, playground bullies, telemarketers and the Kardashians.

Maybe that explains why people keep forwarding a viral email making damaging claims about Congress.

Our friends at Snopes.com, the urban legend checker, say the email has been circulating in various forms since at least 2000. But it’s still circulating. A reader who recently received a version of the email forwarded it to PolitiFact Ohio asking about its accuracy.

It asserts that relatives of members of Congress and Congressional staffers "are exempt from having to pay back student loans" -- a ridiculously false claim that Snopes.com and our colleagues at FactCheck.org debunked and that we rated Pants on Fire.

We also rated as Pants on Fire its claim that members of Congress can "retire with the same pay after only one term."

But readers also asked about another claim in the email: that members of Congress "specifically exempted themselves from many of the laws they have passed, such as being exempt from any fear of prosecution for sexual harassment, while ordinary citizens must live under those laws. The latest is to exempt themselves from the healthcare reform, in all of its forms."

PolitiFact first examined the claim that members of Congress are exempt from the provisions of the Affordable Care Act in 2009, when the legislation was still under consideration in Congress.

We rated it False. That claim was based on the assumption that the health care reform plan would have sent everyone -- except Congress -- into a new "public option" federal insurance plan. It would not have.


In fact, the law as passed did not even include a public option -- and Section 1213 of it requires members of Congress and congressional staff, starting in 2014, to buy health plans created by the health care act or offered through the state exchanges the act establishes.

Political scientist Norman Ornstein, a long-time observer of Congress and a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, debunked the claim of congressional exemption in a piece he wrote for the Washington newspaper Roll Call.

"On the assertion that Members of Congress are exempt from the provisions of the Affordable Care Act: also false," he wrote.

"Members of Congress are subject under the health care reform law to the same mandate that others are to purchase insurance, and their plans must have the same minimum standards of benefits that other insurance plans will have to meet.


Members of Congress currently have not a gold-plated free plan but the same insurance options that most other federal employees have, and they do not have it provided for free.

They have a generous subsidy for their premiums, but no more generous (and compared to many businesses or professions less generous) than standard employer-provided subsidies throughout the country."

FactCheck.org examined the broader claim that members of Congress "specifically exempted themselves from many of the laws they have passed (such as being exempt from any fear of prosecution for sexual harassment)," and found it "15 years out of date" in 2010.

The reason: Passage of the Congressional Accountability Act of 1995. It specifically made sure a variety of laws dealing with civil rights, labor and workplace safety regulations applied to the legislative branch of government. The independent Office of Compliance was set up to enforce the laws in Congress.

The act specifically prohibits harassment based on sex, race, color, religion, national origin, age and disability.

Ornstein, who has been sharply critical of Congress (and only last month co-authored a piece for Foreign Policy magazine titled "Yes, Congress Is That Bad" said it is "not surprising that, in tough times, Americans would be inclined to believe the absolute worst about their elected officials.

"But at least," he added, "let the criticism be fair and based on facts instead of persistent urban legends."

PolitiFact Ohio would agree.

At best, the chain email's statement about Congressional exemptions is ridiculously out of date. At worst, it is cynically inaccurate.

On the Truth-O-Meter, it rates Pants on Fire!
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

AMD Faces Fresh Scrutiny Over China Supply Exposure

Updated Category News Views 72

One nasty report can turn a chip giant’s supply chain into a flashing red light, and that is precisely the mess confronting Advanced Micro Devices investors this week. Shares fell more than 7.7% on November 19 after Hunterbrook Media published allegations involving China-linked sales, firmware and manufacturing relationships. Then, on November 20, shareholder-rights...

Continue Reading
MTI Adds Aviation Veterans as Acorn Builds MRO Plan

Updated Category News Views 117

Two old hands entering a boardroom can matter more than another glossy growth slogan, especially in aircraft maintenance, where a delayed part can ground an airplane and turn a customer relationship sour in a hurry. MTI Aviation has added Tony DiSimone Sr. and Aviv Tzur to its board, a move announced November 20, 2026, after Acorn Capital Management took a majority...

Continue Reading
ECW Puts $52 Million Behind Learning Through Crisis

Updated Category News Views 66

A reserve fund for a classroom is not glamorous, but it may be the smartest detail in this whole $52 million commitment. Education Cannot Wait has announced support for more than 300,000 children in Lebanon, Myanmar and South Sudan, where war, flooding and displacement have ripped ordinary schooling apart. The money is meant to restore learning, provide catch-up classes...

Continue Reading
Northgate’s Stanton Opening Puts Community Work First

Updated Category News Views 86

A 55,721-square-foot grocery opening can look like ordinary retail churn until you notice where the money and attention are landing. Northgate González Market’s new Stanton location arrives ahead of Thanksgiving, yes, but the more telling detail is the company’s decision to pair a major store launch with 375 jobs and more than $30,000 directed toward families,...

Continue Reading
Travel Disruptions Reveal the Value of Human Support

Updated Category News Views 61

Air travel’s ugly little secret surfaced again during the recent ground stop: a reservation is easy, but rescuing a trip is labor-intensive, fast-moving work. Internova Travel Group says its people across Travel Leaders Network, Global Travel Collection and ALTOUR moved quickly as cancellations piled up and travelers were left staring at busted itineraries. That is not...

Continue Reading
Great Rail Journeys Bets Bigger on Luxury Rail in 2027

Updated Category News Views 99

A $19,995 vacation is not selling a seat on a train; it is selling relief from planning, crowds and compromise. Great Rail Journeys is leaning hard into that proposition for 2027 with two additions to its premium Landmark Collection: a Europe-heavy Orient Express and Rhône cruise pairing, plus a South Africa itinerary built around safari, Victoria Falls and rail-flavored...

Continue Reading
Sprocket’s GigaOm Leap Puts PTaaS Claims Under Scrutiny

Updated Category News Views 44

Security vendors love a shiny quadrant, but this one deserves more than the usual polite golf clap. Sprocket Security moved from Challenger and Outperformer in GigaOm’s 2025 Penetration Testing as a Service assessment to a Leader in the version 5 report released in 2026. That is a meaningful jump in a category where buyers are tired of annual testing reports that go...

Continue Reading
Fraud0-FouAnalytics Takes Aim at Legacy Ad Verification

Updated Category News Views 25

Digital ad measurement has spent years grading its own homework, and that little arrangement may finally be getting some daylight. fraud0 and FouAnalytics say their expanded partnership will give advertisers impression-level visibility into where ads actually rendered, whether apparent humans engaged with them, and where wasted Google Ads spend might be recoverable. The...

Continue Reading
Duetti, CesiumAstro, and a Busy NYSE Capital Morning

Updated Category News Views 78

Three very different piles of money are jamming up the November 20 NYSE slate, and that contrast is the whole point. Private music catalogs, space-and-defense communications, and a new stock-and-bond ETF do not belong in the same bucket. Yet all three are competing for investor attention before the opening bell, alongside Danaos Corporation's 20th listing anniversary....

Continue Reading
Why Insurance Must Change as Family Assets Keep Growing

Updated Category News Views 32

A policy bought in the starter-home years can turn stale quietly while everything around it gets bigger, pricier and more complicated. That is the uncomfortable little truth behind Daniel C. DiCocco's discussion in HelloNation: families often treat insurance as a box checked long ago, even as they add property, savings, debt, children and fresh responsibilities. Static...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Infrastructure Dividend Split Corp. Exciting Class A Updates

Updated Category News Views 208

Infrastructure Dividend Split Corp. Class A Distributions Overview Infrastructure Dividend Split Corp. (TSX:IS) is making headlines with its recent announcement regarding the June 2025 distributions for Class A shareholders. This initiative is a significant opportunity for investors who hold shares in the Fund, and it emphasizes the ongoing commitment to providing value...

Continue Reading
Navigating Market Opportunities with Domino's Pizza Insights

Updated Category News Views 239

Understanding Market Sensitivity and Its Impact In today's financial markets, there’s a heightened sensitivity to news, especially when stock valuations are at all-time highs. With major indices like the S&P 500 reaching unprecedented levels, stocks have become reactive to various news headlines, often regardless of their actual implications on the business. This...

Continue Reading
Noble Corporation plc Reports Strong FY 2024 Financial Results

Updated Category News Views 475

Noble Corporation plc Reports Strong FY 2024 Financial Results Noble Corporation plc (NYSE: NE) has recently reported its outstanding results for the fourth quarter and the entire fiscal year of 2024. The company's financials highlight a remarkable return of over $575 million via dividends and share buybacks, marking a significant milestone in its operational success and...

Continue Reading
Revolutionizing Home Financing: Hard Money Lenders Arizona

Updated Category News Views 171

Revolutionizing Home Financing with Innovative Loans Hard Money Lenders Arizona, a renowned name in alternative lending solutions, has reshaped the landscape of bridge loans, making them more accessible to homebuyers. Under the expert guidance of CEO Michael Iuculano, the firm leverages over 23 years of industry expertise, enabling thousands of clients to successfully...

Continue Reading
Triumph Financial Shifts Stock Listing to NYSE for Growth

Updated Category News Views 105

Triumph Financial Moves to New York Stock Exchange Triumph Financial, Inc. (NASDAQ: TFIN) has made a significant decision to enhance its market presence by transferring the listing and trading of its common and preferred stock to the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE). This strategic move is not just about a change of scenery; it's a calculated step towards unlocking greater...

Continue Reading