Research on Error-Related Hospital Deaths Is Flawed,

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
News Desk 2018
Research on Error-Related Hospital Deaths Is Flawed, According to the Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons

TUCSON, Ariz., Dec. 21, 2016 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- The American news media is telling the public that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in America, based on a misleading article in the BMJ (formerly the British Medical Journal ), states AAPS. But the article has such serious flaws that it should never have been published, according to an article by Gerard Gianoli, M.D., and John Dale Dunn, M.D., J.D., in the winter issue of the Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons .

Dr. Gianoli is a neuro-otologist practicing at the Ear and Balance Institute in Covington, La., and Dr. Dunn is an emergency physician in Texas.

The 251,454 “preventable medical deaths” per year that Makary and Daniel “found” for their BMJ article sound frightening, but they are actually just calculated or extrapolated from a mere fourteen (14) cases reported in the papers they cited. As the errors “may have”—or may not have—caused the deaths, there may actually have been zero deaths caused by errors, Gianoli and Dunn point out.

Gianoli and Dunn also note that Makary and Daniels did not do any new research but simply reviewed four studies published between 2000 and 2008. They disregarded other studies that would not have supported their hypothesis. And they used an expansive definition of error that includes an act that “did not achieve its desired outcome.”

The widely publicized studies relied on by the Institute of Medicine as well as Makary and Daniel screened charts for adverse outcomes, a method that encourages outcome bias. Gianoli and Dunn contrast these with the far more robust studies done for the Texas Medical Foundation, which actually reviewed 318,000 medical records. The TMF studies showed a positive patient safety picture, with a low rate of negligence events causing injury or death, stable for three decades. TMF studied high-risk Medicare patients, Gianoli and Dunn added.

“Death due to medical errors is an important and serious topic,” Gianoli and Dunn state. “It deserves careful consideration. However, exaggerating the severity of the problem of in-hospital medical errors supposedly leading to death does no service to the cause of improving patient safety.”

Exaggerating the problem has the political effect of denigrating the medical profession, and supporting the agenda of greater government control, with formerly independent professionals becoming servants of the system, they conclude.

The Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons is published by the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS) , a national organization representing physicians in all specialties since 1943.

Contact: John Dale Dunn, M.D., J.D., (325) 642 5073, jddmdjd@web-access.net; Gerard Gianoli, M.D, (985) 809-1111, ggianoli@gmail.com; or Jane M. Orient, M.D., (520) 323-3110, janeorientmd@gmail.com

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Utility Global’s India Steel Move Needs Hard Numbers

Updated Category News Views 56

Steel decarbonization announcements can sound enormous before a single bolt gets tightened. Utility Global says it plans to deploy its first industrial H2Gen project in India with Tata Steel, and that is plainly worth watching. Tata Steel is a serious industrial name, India is a consequential steel market, and any technology that can credibly lower emissions from heavy...

Continue Reading
Linux Foundation Unveils the Global Fraud Alliance

Updated Category News Views 82

Who would have thought the tech wizards at the Linux Foundation would step up to tackle fraud on a global scale? That's what we've got with their latest play: the Open Financial Trust Alliance (OFTA). Launched at the Singapore FinTech Festival, they've got their sights on connecting the world's disconnected fraud fight. Think of it as a translator for the tangled mess of...

Continue Reading
ELEGOO's Formnext Push Tests a Broader 3D Ambition

Updated Category News Views 89

Frankfurt’s show floor is where product promises meet some very unforgiving eyeballs. ELEGOO arrived at Formnext 2026 with more than a refreshed machine or two: it is laying out a wider bet across resin printing, FDM printing, and 3D scanning. That matters because the company is no longer presenting itself as merely a supplier of affordable creator hardware. It wants to...

Continue Reading
MobileX's $10 Plan Puts Holiday Pressure on Wireless

Updated Category News Views 157

A sixty-dollar commitment is a small bet, but in wireless it can become a loud little nuisance for every carrier charging far more. MobileX has rolled out a Black Friday offer giving new customers 10GB of high-speed data, unlimited talk and text, and six months of service for $60 upfront. That pencils out to $10 a month, before taxes and government surcharges, and it runs...

Continue Reading
ISDN Holdings: Leading APAC Automation with Innovation

Updated Category News Views 81

Pioneering Automation Intelligence in APAC Not every day you hear a company quietly revolutionizing an entire industry's landscape—but ISDN Holdings Limited is one of those rare players. Recognized by Frost & Sullivan for its top-tier customer value leadership, ISDN is making waves across the Asia-Pacific's industrial scene with its integrated industrial automation...

Continue Reading
Finzly Welcomes Paul Finch to Drive BankOS Growth

Updated Category News Views 42

Finzly's Strategic Move to Boost Innovation Alright, folks, it seems Finzly means business. They just roped in Paul Finch, the brains who gave us Zelle during his stint as CEO over at Early Warning Services. This guy's been around the block with a couple of the biggest names in banking, and if his past headlines are any indicator, he's got the knack for shaking things up...

Continue Reading
PSEG Declares $0.67 Fourth-Quarter 2026 Cash Dividend

Updated Category News Views 112

A 67-cent utility dividend rarely sets the tape on fire, and that is precisely the point. Public Service Enterprise Group declared a regular fourth-quarter 2026 common-stock dividend of $0.67 per share, payable on or before December 31 to shareholders of record on December 10. For owners of NYSE:PEG, this is the sort of announcement that belongs in the “steady as she...

Continue Reading
Unishippers Climbs 18 Slots on 32.4% Sales Growth Run

Updated Category News Views 127

Thirty new franchise units can move the needle fast Unishippers did not inch its way up the Franchise Times Top 400; it put up a number that deserves a hard look. Sales rose 32.4% in 2025, the company added 30 franchise units, and the result was an 18-place jump to No. 81 on the 2026 ranking. In the shipping category, it was named the sales-growth leader. For a business...

Continue Reading
AI Echo Study Sharpens a Difficult HFpEF Diagnosis

Updated Category News Views 71

A single echo clip may be doing more useful work than plenty of flashy healthcare AI demos. The November 2026 Journal of Cardiac Failure focus issue puts a hard number on that possibility: pairing an AI read of a routine echocardiogram clip with the H?FPEF clinical score identified 78% of patients with hemodynamically confirmed HFpEF, versus 48% with the score alone. That...

Continue Reading
Auria, LSAS Team Up: Japan Space Frontier Beckons

Updated Category News Views 105

Pioneering Ventures in Japan's Space Race Watch out, folks—Auria and LSAS Tec have something cooking. One's a titan in space technology, and the other's a maestro in mission analysis. They're joining forces to tango in Japan's booming space market. If you're into the street-smart equity dance, this partnership ain't just chatter over coffee; it's a leap toward new...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Gold's Surge and Euro's Stagnation Amid Economic Shifts

Updated Category News Views 261

Gold Gains Ground Amid Geopolitical Tensions Gold prices have recently shown an impressive rise, climbing 1.9% and breaking through the resistance level of $2,600. This rally followed a significant weekly decline in prices and reflects the market's reaction to ongoing geopolitical uncertainties. The surge in gold can be traced back to several influencing factors. One of...

Continue Reading
Teachable's Innovative Rebrand and Future Learning Vision

Updated Category News Views 209

Teachable's Innovative Rebrand and Future Learning Vision Teachable, a leader in online education, proudly announces a new visual identity and a striking product vision that redefines the learning experience for everyone. As the platform continues to evolve, the changes reflect a deep commitment to meeting the needs of today’s learners and educators. A New Identity for...

Continue Reading
Functionize Elevates Software Testing with Advanced AI Solutions

Updated Category News Views 169

Functionize Enhances Automation for Software Testing Automation Innovations Reshape Testing Using Natural Language Inputs to Create Reliable Tests and Streamline Complex Processes Across Enterprises Functionize, an innovative platform leveraging AI for software test case creation, has unveiled significant enhancements to its intelligent testing solutions. The recent...

Continue Reading
Anterix Inc. Delivers Strong Fiscal Performance This Quarter

Updated Category News Views 199

Anterix Inc. Highlights Its Fiscal Progress Anterix Inc. (NASDAQ: ATEX), based in Woodlang Park, has recently revealed impressive results for its second quarter of fiscal 2026. The company has filed its Form 10-Q, reflecting the financial performance for the three and six months leading to september 30, 2025. During this quarter, Anterix provided an update on its...

Continue Reading
10X Genomics Futures Brighten with New Single Cell Products

Updated Category News Views 80

10X Genomics Holds Steady with New Innovations 10X Genomics (NASDAQ: TXG) has received a reiterated Hold rating from TD Cowen, with a price target set at $20.00. This decision follows the company's announcement of plans to launch new Single Cell (SC) products during an industry event. The innovative products aim to provide cost-effective solutions focused on reducing...

Continue Reading