The Triumph of Falsehood Steve Chapman Posted: Dec

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board

Dec 8, 2016 at 6:16 PM

Quote:

The Triumph of Falsehood

Steve Chapman

Posted: Dec 08, 2016 2:26 PM

In 1644, the English poet John Milton made an eloquent case against censorship. Freedom of thought and inquiry was not only a God-given prerogative but also the best protection against error: "Let her and Falsehood grapple; who ever knew Truth put to the worse, in a free and open encounter?"

Milton was fortunate enough to live before the internet. It has shown that among many people, truth doesn't have a chance in an encounter with manufactured falsehoods aimed at not only smearing enemies but obliterating the idea of objective reality.

There is now a bustling industry of websites and Twitter accounts whose chief product is fiction masquerading as fact. Their success was both cause and effect of the rise of Donald Trump, who went beyond any previous major presidential candidate in saying things that were utterly baseless and easily refutable.

He didn't have to wait to reach the White House to fulfill his promise to create new jobs. His campaign generated a new demand for fact-checkers, who found that trying to expose his lies was like trying to stay dry in a hurricane. The torrent was too big, fierce and persistent to overcome.

Trump peddled bogus information and profited from that spread by others. Of the 20 most read phony election-related stories circulated on Facebook during the campaign, 17 made him look good or Hillary Clinton look bad. The top two: the pope's endorsement of Trump and Clinton's selling arms to the Islamic State, neither of which contained a particle of truth.


Trump voters are not the only ones with a penchant for believing things purely because they are convenient. The website Vox reported that most of Bernie Sanders' followers want universal health care and free public college tuition but aren't willing to pay anything close to what they would cost in higher taxes. Most Americans can't name their member of Congress or the three branches of government.

It's no accident that so many Americans choose to be uninformed or misinformed. Educating yourself about candidates and their platforms by getting reliable information has little payoff. Your vote, wise or foolish, rarely makes a difference in the policies that affect you.

Being wrong about candidates generally costs you nothing, unlike being deluded about more practical matters. If you think you can fly, you will get a painful lesson when you leap off your roof. But if you believe that Barack Obama is a Muslim -- as more than half of Republican primary voters did -- you suffer no injury from indulging that fantasy.

In fact, you gain something: a powerful sense of connection with others who share your outlook. For most people who have great interest in politics, argued George Mason University economist Bryan Caplan in his 2007 book, "The Myth of the Rational Voter," ideology is a form of religion, and its disciples act more on faith than on evidence.

"Human beings want their religion's answers to be true," he wrote, and stick to them in the face of contradictory information. We have little reason to behave differently on Election Day. "Why control your knee-jerk emotional and ideological reactions if you can't change the outcome?" asked Caplan.

Conventional politicians shade and embellish the truth, but within established bounds. They have enough respect for voters to ration their deceptions.

What made Trump different was his conviction that most people are happy to be fed nonsense as long as it is palatable. He lied without reservation or limit, about topics big and small, and he got away with it. Among his followers, some believed he was telling the truth and some didn't care.

"Fake news" sources exploit the same cynical strategy, confident that many readers will seek out anything that confirms their prejudices and reject anything that doesn't. The news media have discovered that while there is a demand for accurate information, there is also a market, possibly bigger, for malignant myths. No lie is too big or absurd to find a gullible audience.

Not only that, fake news sites have a competitive advantage. Honest press outlets often present information their readers find unwelcome. Dishonest ones offer their customers the promise that their illusions will be preserved no matter what.

Our system of government rests on the assumption that in the long run, the truth will prevail over falsehoods. We have yet to consider what to do if our faith in the truth turns out to be false.

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Eyepic 2-in-1 Camera Innovates at IFA 2026

Call me a sucker for new tech but what Hohem just unveiled might flip content creation on its head. Welcome the Eyepic—a 2-in-1 pocket gimbal camera stirring things up at IFA 2026 in Berlin. Now, maybe your eyeballs are glazing over with all the camera announcements flooding the market. I get it. Yet, this gadget isn’t just another add-on; it's a sneaky move by Hohem...

USF Law Innovators: Leading AI Integration in Academics

Revolutionizing Legal Academia with AI If there's one thing that's caught my eye in the realm of education, it's how some folks over at the University of San Francisco School of Law are shaking things up. These legal eagles aren't messing around with the usual, archaic ways of teaching the law. Nope, they've dove headfirst into the future by hooking their curriculum to...

Curve Memberships: A New Path for Dental Practices

Revolutionizing Dental Practice Management Ever met a dentist who says they love dealing with insurance bureaucracies? Yeah, me neither. Curve Dental's latest gambit into membership plans is aiming to slice right through that mess. They've launched a shiny new component aptly named Curve Memberships. This isn't just some fly-by-night addon; it's about deep...

APX Bridges Crypto & Traditional Finance With New Credit Line

The Future of Financial Bridging Now here's a scenario that might perk your ears up if you've ever toyed with digital assets: APX Lending is stepping up its game, bringing a regulated five-year revolving line of credit backed by Bitcoin and Ethereum to the world stage. It's like blending your grandma's tried-and-true savings approach with the whiz-bang allure of crypto. A...

California American Water’s $8.6M Project: Big Move Upfront

California's Lincoln Oaks neighborhood is gearing up for some necessary upheaval, thanks to California American Water’s new $8.6 million infrastructure overhaul. For decades, those folks in Sylvan Park have been juggling with the roulette of aging water mains in their backyards. Now, imagine that: backyard pipes begging to turn traitors. It's about time someone decided...

Hello Group Posts Q2 Earnings with Mixed Signals

Q2 Revenue Slump Amid Profit Recovery No sugarcoating it, revenue numbers for Hello Group Inc. (NASDAQ:MOMO) are less than stellar for the second quarter of 2026. Net revenues fell 5.1% year-over-year to RMB2,486.0 million (about $366.4 million). Not exactly what you want to see in a growth-oriented tech company. However, what’s really worth your attention is the net...

Innovation Drives New Asia-Pacific Opportunities

A Glimpse Into The Future: Asia-Pacific's Tech Landscape There's a unique transformation bubbling across the Asia-Pacific scene, with young minds pushing the envelope on technology and innovation. Take Nathapol's team from Thailand, for example. They're merging bionic tech with drones for disaster relief—bold, ambitious, and nearly clinching glory at the Lancang-Mekong...

Doug Larson Takes Helm at Integra Pool Covers

A Seasoned Pro Joins Integra Pool Covers Change is afoot over at Explore Industries. They just tapped Doug Larson to be the General Manager for their Integra Pool Covers division. Now, I've seen plenty of hiring announcements in my day, but this has got an interesting ring to it. With Doug on this ship, it's like bringing a wolf back to the wild. Larson's no stranger to...

Curaleaf Eyes Growth: Conference Signals Opportunities

Curaleaf's Strategic Move: Getting in Front of Investors Here comes Curaleaf Holdings, stepping into the spotlight with their eye on increasing investor engagement. Announcing their participation in the ATB Cormark Capital Markets 2026 Fall Institutional Investor Conference, the folks at Curaleaf aren't just talking—they're putting their top brass under the lights. You...

Smithfield's Foreign Lobbying Interests Unveiled Amid Uproar

A Behind-the-Scenes Drama Over Lobbying Disclosure Something's fishy beneath the surface of Smithfield Foods' recent lobbying debacle. The Center for Responsible Food Business (CRFB) has turned the spotlight on some shady practices, and folks, it ain't pretty. Smithfield's lobbyists had been ducking disclosure rules apparently meant to keep track of foreign influence. Who...