WSJournal. The Power of Negative Thinking Both ancient

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone

WSJournal. The Power of Negative Thinking

Both ancient philosophy and modern psychology suggest that darker thoughts can make us happier

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324705104578147333270637790.html?mod=WSJ_MostPopular_US

The holiday season poses a psychological conundrum. Its defining sentiment, of course, is joy—yet the strenuous effort to be joyous seems to make many of us miserable. It's hard to be happy in overcrowded airport lounges or while you're trying to stay civil for days on end with relatives who stretch your patience.

So to cope with the holidays, magazines and others are advising us to "think positive"—the same advice, in other words, that Norman Vincent Peale, author of "The Power of Positive Thinking," was dispensing six decades ago. (During holidays, Peale once suggested, you should make "a deliberate effort to speak hopefully about everything.") The result all too often mirrors the famously annoying parlor game about trying not to think of a white bear: The harder you try, the more you think about one.

image

Variations of Peale's positive philosophy run deep in American culture, not just in how we handle holidays and other social situations but in business, politics and beyond. Yet studies suggest that peppy affirmations designed to lift the user's mood through repetition and visualizing future success often achieve the opposite of their intended effect.

Fortunately, both ancient philosophy and contemporary psychology point to an alternative: a counterintuitive approach that might be termed "the negative path to happiness." This approach helps to explain some puzzles, such as the fact that citizens of more economically insecure countries often report greater happiness than citizens of wealthier ones. Or that many successful businesspeople reject the idea of setting firm goals.

One pioneer of the "negative path" was the New York psychotherapist Albert Ellis, who died in 2007. He rediscovered a key insight of the Stoic philosophers of ancient Greece and Rome: that sometimes the best way to address an uncertain future is to focus not on the best-case scenario but on the worst.

Seneca the Stoic was a radical on this matter. If you feared losing your wealth, he once advised, "set aside a certain number of days, during which you shall be content with the scantiest and cheapest fare, with coarse and rough dress, saying to yourself the while: 'Is this the condition that I feared?' "

To overcome a fear of embarrassment, Ellis told me, he advised his clients to travel on the New York subway, speaking the names of stations out loud as they passed. I'm an easily embarrassed person, so in the interest of journalistic research, I took his advice, on the Central Line of the London Underground. It was agonizing. But my overblown fears were cut down to size: I wasn't verbally harangued or physically attacked. A few people looked at me strangely.

Just thinking in sober detail about worst-case scenarios—a technique the Stoics called "the premeditation of evils"—can help to sap the future of its anxiety-producing power. The psychologist Julie Norem estimates that about one-third of Americans instinctively use this strategy, which she terms "defensive pessimism." Positive thinking, by contrast, is the effort to convince yourself that things will turn out fine, which can reinforce the belief that it would be absolutely terrible if they didn't.

In American corporations, perhaps the most widely accepted doctrine of the "cult of positivity" is the importance of setting big, audacious goals for an organization, while employees are encouraged (or compelled) to set goals that are "SMART"—"Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant and Timely." (It is thought that the term was first used in a 1981 article by George T. Doran.)

But the pro-goal consensus is starting to crumble. For one thing, rigid goals may encourage employees to cut ethical corners. In a study conducted by the management scholar Lisa Ordóñez and her colleagues, participants had to make words from a set of random letters, as in Scrabble. The experiment let them report their progress anonymously—and those given a specific target to reach lied far more frequently than those instructed merely to "do your best."

Goals may even lead to underachievement. Many New York taxi drivers, one team of economists concluded, make less money in rainy weather than they could because they finish work as soon as they reach their mental target for what constitute a good day's earnings.

Focusing on one goal at the expense of all other factors also can distort a corporate mission or an individual life, says Christopher Kayes, an associate professor of management at George Washington University in Washington, D.C. Prof. Kayes, who has studied the "overpursuit" of goals, recalls a conversation with one executive who "told me his goal had been to become a millionaire by the age of 40…and he'd done it. [But] he was also divorced, and had health problems, and his kids didn't talk to him anymore." Behind our fixation on goals, Prof. Kayes's work suggests, is a deep unease with feelings of uncertainty.

Research by Saras Sarasvathy, an associate professor of business administration at the University of Virginia, suggests that learning to accommodate feelings of uncertainty is not just the key to a more balanced life but often leads to prosperity as well. For one project, she interviewed 45 successful entrepreneurs, all of whom had taken at least one business public. Almost none embraced the idea of writing comprehensive business plans or conducting extensive market research.

They practiced instead what Prof. Sarasvathy calls "effectuation." Rather than choosing a goal and then making a plan to achieve it, they took stock of the means and materials at their disposal, then imagined the possible ends. Effectuation also includes what she calls the "affordable loss principle." Instead of focusing on the possibility of spectacular rewards from a venture, ask how great the loss would be if it failed. If the potential loss seems tolerable, take the next step.

The ultimate value of the "negative path" may not be its role in facilitating upbeat emotions or even success. It is simply realism. The future really is uncertain, after all, and things really do go wrong as well as right. We are too often motivated by a craving to put an end to the inevitable surprises in our lives.

This is especially true of the biggest "negative" of all. Might we benefit from contemplating mortality more regularly than we do? As Steve Jobs famously declared, "Remembering that you are going to die is the best way that I know to avoid the trap of thinking you have something to lose."

However tempted we may be to agree with Woody Allen's position on death—"I'm strongly against it"—there's much to be said for confronting it rather than denying it. There are some facts that even the most powerful positive thinking can't alter.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

LG Channels UAE Push Tests the Free Streaming Model

Updated Category News Views 137

A television's idle screen is turning into contested real estate in the UAE. LG Channels is adding programming from Rakuten TV, Stingray and Red Bull TV to its free, ad-supported service, and that matters for more than somebody hunting a movie after dinner. This is a practical push to make webOS-powered screens more useful, more frequently used and, eventually, more...

Continue Reading
Condo Downsizing Demands More Than a Price Check Today

Updated Category News Views 58

A smaller front door can hide a surprisingly large stack of obligations. That is the useful point in the HelloNation guidance featuring Chevy Chase real estate expert Lise Howe: downsizing into a condo is not merely a square-footage trade. It is a decision about recurring costs, building stewardship, daily friction, and whether the place still works when life gets less...

Continue Reading
Housing's Value Equation Is Getting More Complicated

Updated Category News Views 58

A homeowner's insurance bill has become a louder market signal than a granite countertop. Green Builder Media's latest batch of research, publishing and events is aimed squarely at that uncomfortable truth: housing is no longer judged only by the price on the contract. Buyers, builders, lenders and insurers are being pushed to reckon with what a home costs to own, protect...

Continue Reading
Leqembi’s Real-World Data Gives BioArctic More Weight

Updated Category News Views 133

A Harder Look at Treatment Staying Power Alzheimer’s drug data rarely arrive without a thicket of caveats, and that is exactly why this Leqembi update deserves a calm read rather than a victory lap. BioArctic’s partner Eisai presented a three-year real-world analysis at CTAD 2026 covering 560 early Alzheimer’s patients across 13 U.S. sites. The headline is striking:...

Continue Reading
Yoodli's No. 9 Ranking Signals Enterprise AI Traction

Updated Category News Views 58

Ninth place can be easy to dismiss until you notice the company is sitting near the top of a 500-name growth list. Yoodli's No. 9 position on Deloitte's 2026 Technology Fast 500 is a meaningful signal that its AI-based coaching and workforce-skills pitch is getting traction inside large organizations. It is not a revenue disclosure, it is not a valuation marker, and...

Continue Reading
MetaOptics Tests a Real Path Into Secure Imaging Markets

Updated Category News Views 68

Fingerprint scanners have never impressed me much; fooling one is exactly the sort of nuisance that keeps security buyers spending. MetaOptics’ new collaboration with Hong Kong’s ASTRI goes after that uncomfortable problem with a compact nano-optics imaging system built for biometric security and smart sensing. It is a sensible target. It is also, at this stage, a...

Continue Reading
TGHL Eyes U.S. Battery Shift Through EnChem Merger

Updated Category News Views 159

A Policy Squeeze Is Rewriting the Battery Map Battery supply chains are getting shoved through a narrower gate, and that is exactly why this proposed deal deserves a hard look. The GrowHub Limited wants to acquire EnChem America, a Georgia-based lithium-ion battery electrolyte producer, and the timing is plainly built around Washington's push to reduce reliance on...

Continue Reading
Clarivate's 2026 Research List Carries a Trust Test

Updated Category News Views 254

Seven thousand ninety awards can look like a victory lap until you remember how easily raw citation counts can be gamed. Clarivate’s 2026 Highly Cited Researchers list is more interesting for its insistence on screening than for the familiar names at the top. In a research world where publication volume, self-citation and paper mills have made plenty of people...

Continue Reading
Mar-Jac's Safety Milestone Carries Real Operational Weight

Updated Category News Views 62

Four million worked hours without a lost-time accident is the sort of number that ought to make people pause, especially in poultry processing. Mar-Jac Poultry’s Gainesville facility earned Workplace Safety recognition from the Greater Hall Chamber of Commerce after reaching that mark, and this is one corporate achievement that deserves a little less eye-rolling than...

Continue Reading
Tim Hortons Bets on ELF Cheer for U.S. Holiday Visits

Updated Category News Views 35

Nothing says holiday restaurant marketing quite like putting spaghetti-shaped whipped topping on hot chocolate and trusting a 2003 movie to do the selling. Tim Hortons is rolling out an ELF-inspired menu at participating U.S. locations starting November 18, 2026, pairing the chain with Warner Bros. Consumer Products and mining Buddy the Elf's sugar-fueled world for a...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

T&T Supermarkets Expands Presence with New Store Opening

Updated Category News Views 466

T&T Supermarkets Unveils Plans for a Major New Store T&T Supermarket Inc., Canada's largest Asian grocery retailer, is excited to share plans for their newest store in California, which will be located at Crossroads Marketplace in Chino Hills. This store will span an impressive 61,000 square feet, providing ample space for a wide variety of products and services to meet...

Continue Reading
Autohome Inc. Unveils its Comprehensive 2024 ESG Report

Updated Category News Views 268

Autohome Inc. Releases 2024 ESG Report Autohome Inc. (NYSE: ATHM) has shared its 2024 Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) report. This document emphasizes the firm's commitment to sustainable practices and highlights their ongoing journey towards eco-friendly solutions within the automobile sector. Insights from the ESG Report The report details the extensive ESG...

Continue Reading
Nintendo and The Pokemon Company Pursue Legal Action Against Palworld

Updated Category News Views 87

Nintendo and The Pokemon Company Take Legal Action Nintendo and The Pokemon Company have officially initiated a patent infringement lawsuit against the creators of the popular survival adventure game, "Palworld." This development has caught the attention of both gamers and industry experts alike. Details of the Lawsuit Reports indicate that the lawsuit was filed on...

Continue Reading
NYCM Insurance Achieves Elite Winner Status for Wellness

Updated Category News Views 118

NYCM Insurance Celebrated for Wellness Excellence NYCM Insurance proudly announces its recognition as an "Elite Winner" among the Nation's Best and Brightest in Wellness. This marks an outstanding milestone for the company, achieving the accolade for the twelfth consecutive year, a testament to their dedication to enhancing employee wellness. Commitment to Employee...

Continue Reading
Antonio Filosa Leads Stellantis with Newly Formed Team

Updated Category News Views 284

New Leadership Structure at Stellantis Under Antonio Filosa Today marks a significant milestone for Stellantis N.V. as Antonio Filosa steps into the role of Chief Executive Officer. Alongside this transition, he has unveiled an exciting new leadership team, showcasing a strong lineup of industry veterans and decision-makers from across Stellantis’ diverse operations...

Continue Reading