More fake gay science:
The headlines were unsparing and
More fake gay science:
The headlines were unsparing and unambiguous. “Anti-gay Stigma Shortens Lives,” wrote US News & World Report.
“Anti-Gay Communities Linked to Shorter Lives,” said Reuters. “LGB Individuals Living in Anti-Gay Communities Die Early,” according to Science Daily.
Two years ago, these stories were hard to ignore when Columbia professor Mark Hatzenbuehler found that gays and lesbians who faced prejudice in their communities had a life expectancy 12 years shorter than those who lived in more accepting areas. Just so we’re clear, that’s bigger than the lifespan gap between regular smokers and nonsmokers.
We always knew prejudice was bad, but an Ivy League researcher had found that there were significant effects on the physical health of those experiencing it.
But where, one might wonder, were the headlines when another researcher tried to replicate Hatzenbuehler’s effects and came up empty?
Last month, Mark Regnerus, a professor at UT Austin, published an article in the journal Social Science and Medicine that concluded that “ten different approaches to multiple imputation of missing data yielded none in which the effect of structural stigma on the mortality of sexual minorities was statistically significant.”
In other words, Regnerus tried seven — er, 10 — ways from Sunday to try to get the same results as Hatzenbuehler using the exact same data, but failed. Which means, he concluded, that “the original study’s . . . variable (and hence its key result) is so sensitive to subjective measurement decisions as to be rendered unreliable.”
Oops. In case you missed it, there has been a “crisis of replication” in the social sciences recently. Or at least it was discovered recently. In 2015, a large initiative called The Reproducibility Project, led by Brian Nosek at the University of Virginia, repeated 100 published psychological experiments and replicated the results of only a third of them.
Anyone familiar with the way academic publication works could have seen this coming. A former editor of the British Medical Journal explained the process of peer review, which determines whether academic research is published: “The editor looks at the title of the paper and sends it to two friends who the editor thinks know something about the subject. If both advise publication, the editor sends it to the printers. If both advise against publication, the editor rejects the paper. If the reviewers disagree, the editor sends it to a third reviewer and does whatever he or she advises.”
Indeed, in the case of Hatzenbuehler, the author of the study was also the editor of the special issue of the journal in which the study appeared.
While no academic or media outlet has made a peep about Hatzenbuehler in the weeks since Regnerus’ article was published, Regnerus was subject to immediate public excoriation for his findings in a 2012 paper on the effects of same-sex parenting on children, which ran contrary to accepted academic opinion on the subject. Despite calls for his firing, the University of Texas found no wrongdoing. Critics disagreed with his methodology, but there was no mystery about how he arrived at his conclusions.
The difference between Regnerus and Hatzenbuehler is obvious. Certain conclusions are simply more acceptable than others.
Take, for instance, the fraudulent 2014 study in which UCLA’s Michael LaCour was found to have made up out of whole cloth segments of his data on shifting attitudes toward same-sex marriage. LaCour suggested that if someone knocking on doors and asking people about their attitudes toward gay marriage revealed that he himself was gay, that would dramatically change the answers of the respondent.
For years, LaCour’s research was cited by major media and used in political campaigns, but it turned out to be what New York magazine’s Jesse Singal called “one of the biggest scientific frauds in recent memory.”
In the end, neither LaCour nor Hatzenbuehler actually did the work to prove their theses — because there would be no real consequences if they were caught, and anyway academia writ large didn’t want to “catch” them at all. Facts be damned. Academics care only about the “narrative.”
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP
Scroll down for more posts ▼
Top 10 Most Recent News Articles
A corporate-law handoff rarely sets pulses racing, but this one deserves a proper look. Chemours is replacing its long-serving general counsel while keeping the departing executive in the building for four additional months. That is not flashy, and thank goodness for that. In a global chemicals company, legal leadership touches regulation, compliance, governance,...
Continue Reading
Silicon Valley's favorite growth machine has stumbled into the sort of fog investors hate most: regulatory questions, leadership upheaval, and a stock-price reaction with no clean answer attached. Reports cited in the lawsuit update say the Securities and Exchange Commission has opened a civil probe into NVIDIA's investor disclosures following former CEO Jensen Huang's...
Continue Reading
Holiday panic is a thief's favorite crowbar, and Long Island households are plainly in the crosshairs. PSEG Long Island used Utility Scam Awareness Day on Nov. 18 to warn customers about impersonators demanding immediate payment under threat of a power shutoff. The central message, “Think Before You Scan,” is not flashy corporate wallpaper. It is practical advice for...
Continue Reading
A six-month recommendation has a nasty habit of disappearing beneath today’s emergencies. That is the unglamorous, important problem AbbaDox is trying to solve in outpatient radiology: not reading the scan, but making sure a future scan recommendation actually gets reviewed, ordered, and scheduled. For investors watching healthcare operations software, this is the sort...
Continue Reading
A finance chief moving continents is not decorative corporate wallpaper. Teciem’s decision to appoint Jesús Rueda Molins as chief financial officer says the company wants its next growth chapter run with more than product ambition and executive slogans. It wants somebody holding the purse strings who already knows the machinery, the customers and the people making the...
Continue Reading
An imaging order does not mean much if nobody is available to read it, and that plain operational fact sits at the center of Medicus Healthcare Solutions' 2026 report on the radiologist shortage. The report's projected gap of 2,450 full-time-equivalent radiologists in 2027 is troubling enough. Its estimate of a 4,130 FTE shortfall by 2032 is the part that should make...
Continue Reading
A Memory Market Win Can Turn Sour Fast Nothing rattles a chip story quite like the word collusion showing up beside a judge’s ruling. SK hynix had been riding a powerful memory-market narrative, but investors got a blunt reminder on November 15, 2026: a proposed U.S. class action accusing SK hynix, Samsung Electronics, and Micron of restricting DRAM supply to raise...
Continue Reading
Fresh snow does not make a boardroom dispute disappear. Vail Resorts has put out an investor presentation ahead of its December 14, 2026 annual meeting, asking shareholders to support all nine of management’s director nominees on its white proxy card. That is the formal message. The real message is plainer: NYSE:MTN knows this election has become a test of whether...
Continue Reading
A December filing turned into a mid-2027 wait, and Candel shareholders absorbed the damage in one ugly trading session. On November 13, shares of Candel Therapeutics fell 26% after the company disclosed that its biologics license application, or BLA, for aglatimagene in prostate cancer was no longer expected in December 2026. The revised plan is to submit in the middle of...
Continue Reading
A dark storefront can apparently erase goodwill faster than plenty of owners want to admit. The Hanover Insurance Group's 2026 Small Business Pulse Report found that 60% of surveyed consumers would temporarily buy from a competitor if their preferred small business shut unexpectedly. More than half would start looking elsewhere within a week. That is not a cute...
Continue Reading
Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles
TCL's Commitment to Innovation and Sustainability At IFA 2024, TCL, a prominent global technology brand, showcased its unwavering dedication to innovation and sustainability. This year marks TCL's 14th consecutive appearance at the event, where the company highlighted two key initiatives: TCLGreen and TCLArt. These initiatives have attracted considerable attention as they...
Continue Reading
Western Metallica's Successful Private Placement Financing Western Metallica Resources Corp. (TSXV: WMS) has successfully completed its non-brokered private placement financing. This strategic decision allowed the company to issue a significant number of units at an appealing price point. By offering 10,833,345 units at $0.03 each, Western Metallica raised gross proceeds...
Continue Reading
Astrion Unveils Dynamic Executive Leadership Team Astrion, a leader in providing advanced engineering services and mission support to government sectors, has recently announced an exciting new executive leadership team. This strategic move aligns with their ongoing mission to deliver innovative solutions following the acquisition of Axient. With industry veteran Dave...
Continue Reading
Keyera Corp. Schedules 2024 Q3 Results Conference Call Keyera Corp. has announced its timeline for the release of third-quarter results. Investors and interested parties are encouraged to take note of the important dates surrounding this announcement. When to Expect the Financial Results The financial results are set to be released before the market opens on November 14,...
Continue Reading
Netflix and WWE Join Forces for a Live Streaming Revolution In an exciting new venture, Netflix has entered the world of live programming by teaming up with World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) to stream its flagship show, "Raw." This collaboration marks a significant shift in how wrestling fans will experience their favorite matches, bringing the thrill of live...
Continue Reading