Some Elites Think We Should Get Rid of States
Here’s Why
Some Elites Think We Should Get Rid of States
Here’s Why They’re Wrong.
Hillary Clinton won the popular vote, but lost the Electoral College—and it’s driving progressives nuts.
The renewed calls to abandon the “antiquated” and “undemocratic” Electoral College were to be expected. But in a column for The Washington Post’s “In Theory” blog, author Lawrence R. Samuel goes even further, suggesting we get rid of states altogether.
In the 18th century, he admits, “the coming together of 13 disparate colonies was itself a historic achievement,” but since then, “regional differences have drastically dissipated … turning the once radical proposition of the ‘United States’ into an anachronism that now has little real value.” In his view, dispensing with states “offers a cleaner, more sensible, and much more affordable system.”
Insofar as Americans—no matter their state of residence—can shop at the same stores, eat at the same chain restaurants, and watch the same sitcoms, the nation is arguably more homogeneous than at the time of the founding.
But Samuel’s argument relies on the deeper claim that “we share the same basic principles and core values grounded in the unalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.”
A national consensus on principles and values may exist at the most abstract level, but not when it comes down to the stuff of everyday living.
Do Arkansans and New Yorkers agree on what a “right to life” entails? Do Californians and Texans agree on how far individual liberty should extend regarding the purchase and carry of firearms? Do Utahans and Coloradans agree on what substances a person should be free to smoke in their pursuit of happiness? Of course not.
The constitutional principle of federalism allows citizens who disagree about these questions to coexist by granting the states fairly wide latitude to enact a broad range of policies. It allows Vermont to be Vermont, Texas to be Texas, and all Americans to vote with their feet by moving to states that best reflect their policy preferences.
The ability to relocate to another state with relative ease serves as a safety valve to lower the temperature when political conflict reaches the boiling point. A bad state policy or governor can be escaped, but a bad federal law or president must be suffered.
By getting rid of states, we would be doubling down on the current divisive model in which the federal government imposes one-size-fits-all policies on the states.
Unfortunately, Washington, D.C., has, in effect, been following Samuel’s suggestion that we rid ourselves of states for the better part of the last century. Whereas the Constitution envisages the states to be sovereign in their spheres of authority, they have gradually been transformed into administrative sub-units of the federal government, tasked with implementing federal policies.
The states, of course, have been complicit in the erosion of federalism. By becoming reliant on federal grant money, they have become easy to buy off. So while the federal government has no constitutional authority to set a national drinking age, it was able to do so by threatening to cut the federal highway apportionments of any state that maintained a drinking age below 21.
Far from being antiquated and outmoded, our federal system may be more useful than ever before. While it would have been very difficult at the time of the founding for people to relocate across the country, now it is relatively simple. Highways and U-Hauls allow people to move wherever they please while high-speed internet connections allow them to do so without abandoning loved ones back home.
We are also a far more diverse nation than ever before. Greater ethnic and cultural diversity has spawned a wider range of views on basic social questions regarding the role of religion, the definition of marriage, and how basic distinctions like man and woman should be understood.
Because almost every consequential policy matter is determined at the national level, it is becoming difficult for contrasting beliefs and distinct subcultures to coexist. Because one view must ultimately govern the nation, each faction represents a clear threat to the others.
One way to turn down the temperature of national politics may be to turn up the temperature of state politics. By allowing the states to play their constitutional role—devising their own policies on issues both controversial and mundane—Americans would have the choice of 50 different regimes instead of only one.
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP
Scroll down for more posts ▼
Top 10 Most Recent News Articles
A single rifle can carry a staggering amount of meaning when the names on it belong to all five living U.S. Navy SEAL Medal of Honor recipients. Rock Island Auction Company plans to offer that one-of-a-kind custom precision rifle during its December 4–6, 2026 Premier Firearms Auction, and the financial arrangement is unusually clean: 100% of proceeds are slated for the...
Continue Reading
A cancelled photography conference in March 2020 sent Jeff Stern toward the American Southwest, and that detour eventually became A Change of Scenery. Frankly, that origin has more grit than the usual polished creative-origin tale. While much of the world had stopped moving, Stern went alone, stood at White Pocket beneath a cobalt sky, and began reconsidering what he...
Continue Reading
A rental business can add tenants and still march backward, and TDH Holdings just demonstrated the ugly math. For the six months ended June 30, 2026, revenue from continuing operations rose 26.45% to $0.74 million. That is the pleasant number, and it deserves exactly one polite nod. Everything beneath it looks far less comfortable: costs climbed faster than revenue, gross...
Continue Reading
A shiny AI license is not a productivity strategy, and Adecco's latest workforce survey puts some hard numbers behind that irritation. The company surveyed 40,500 workers in 36 countries for its seventh Global Workforce of the Future report, released November 19, 2026. Its central finding is disarmingly sensible: AI produces more when companies rebuild the work around it...
Continue Reading
July’s twin punches to Alphabet shares were not the sort of wobble investors can casually shrug off. First came a report on July 16 that Google was months behind on Gemini 3.5 Pro, its flagship AI model, after disappointing results from updated training data. Then came the harder financial reality a week later: a much larger 2026 capital-spending plan, negative...
Continue Reading
A Building Is Not a Balance Sheet Charlotte got a fresh First Horizon sign at 110 East Boulevard on Nov. 19, 2026, and that is a sensible move, not a magic trick. The bank has officially opened a corporate office in the city’s South End neighborhood, positioning the team to develop client relationships across the Charlotte area and broaden its regional footprint. That...
Continue Reading
Aluminum chips are where desktop-machine marketing stops bluffing, and Makera is leaning right into that test with the A1S. The company opened global pre-orders on November 18 for a machine aimed squarely at the awkward middle ground: users who have outgrown entry-level hobby gear but do not have room, budget, or patience for a full industrial setup. That is a real market...
Continue Reading
A missing present under a tree is not a statistic anybody ought to glide past. PenFed Credit Union has opened its annual Toys for Tots collection across Washington-region branches, taking new, unwrapped toys through December 8 at 1:00 p.m. ET. The useful detail, and frankly the one worth remembering when people default to buying the easiest shiny thing on a shelf, is...
Continue Reading
Three smart professionals can still hand a client a mess when nobody owns the handoff. That unglamorous reality sits behind the Professional Collaboration Institute, or PCI, which Sarano and Brooke Kelley plan to launch in a virtual briefing on December 2. The outfit wants to turn cross-profession coordination into a teachable, measurable discipline rather than leave it...
Continue Reading
A $3.03 gap is staring investors right in the face. As of October 31, 2026, Royce Global Trust carried a net asset value of $17.51 per share while the market price sat at $14.48. That works out to roughly a 17.3% discount to NAV, and with a closed-end fund, that discount is not some footnote shoved under the table. It is a major part of the return story, good or bad. The...
Continue Reading
Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles
Light AI Announces Successful Closure of Over-Allotment Option Light AI Inc. (formerly known as Mojave Brands Inc.) (CBOE CA: ALGO) is thrilled to share recent developments regarding its over-allotment option, which saw a successful full exercise by the Agents. This step resulted in the purchase of an additional 2,757,000 units, amounting to an impressive gross proceeds...
Continue Reading
U.S. Stock Market Futures Show Caution Ahead of Economic Reports Recently, U.S. stock index futures have taken a downward turn as traders adopt a cautious stance. With a series of economic data reports set to be released this week, the financial markets are bracing for potential impacts on the Federal Reserve's monetary policy in the near future. Market Performance in...
Continue Reading
RUSH's 2026 Tour: A Celebration of Music and Legacy Geddy Lee and Alex Lifeson are set to celebrate over 50 years of RUSH's musical journey as they announce a special headline tour for 2026, named the Fifty Something Tour. This tour not only commemorates the incredible music and legacy of RUSH, but also pays tribute to their late drummer and lyricist Neil Peart, whose...
Continue Reading
Star Hats & Embroidery Takes Center Stage on National Television Star Hats & Embroidery is proud to announce its recent television features that highlight the innovative products and services they offer. Following an exciting showcase on CBS's Las Vegas Now Lifestyle TV Show, the brand has appeared in numerous segments across the nation, captivating audiences everywhere....
Continue Reading
Celebrate the Return of the Lowrider Phenomena The excitement is building as the Lowrider Phenomena Show rolls back into Ohkay Hotel Casino, promising an unforgettable day filled with stunning custom rides, electrifying live entertainment, and family-friendly activities. This eagerly anticipated event is free and welcomes everyone to partake in the festivities. A Vibrant...
Continue Reading