Why ‘moral outrage’ over the Electoral College outrages

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone
Why ‘moral outrage’ over the Electoral College outrages me




Kate Upton is feeling a bit like a Hillary Clinton supporter: morally outraged that her man, Detroit’s Justin Verlander, lost the Cy Young award even though he got the most first-place votes.


The damn rules, which also give some credit for second- through fifth-place votes, made Boston’s Rick Porcello the winner. You can see why Kate’s upset.

But the Clinton fans’ “moral outrage” gives me “moral ulcers” — because it’s so profoundly wrong.

To start, it’s based on an illusion: Clinton “won” an election we didn’t have: Neither side was focused on a national-popular-vote win, because both knew the rules.

And if the rules were different, the whole campaign would’ve differed, too.

Just for starters, a lot more Republicans would’ve voted in California. They had no reason to turn out when everyone knew Clinton would carry the state — and the US Senate race was between two Democrats.

It’s also just plain easier to vote in Democrat-dominated states; Oregon is entirely vote-by-mail. That runs up Dems’ national total, too.

You couldn’t move to a “fair” national-vote system without having the feds take total control of voter registration, polling hours and locations and even printing ballots. And yes, that surely strikes the “morally outraged” as an excellent idea — as long as they also get to choose all those rules.

Even then, you can’t control the weather. Suppose Sandy or Katrina struck near Election Day in a tight race: Does the whole country do a do-over vote at a later date?

Mind you, the Electoral College isn’t even remotely the most “anti-democratic” feature of our government: You could make a better case for that being the US Senate, the Supreme Court or even the states. Not to mention the Bill of Rights . . .

Heck, even the House of Representatives — the most “popular” part of the federal setup — is anti-democratic in key ways: The party that wins the most votes in House races nationwide often winds up scoring the minority of actual house seats.

The thing is, every one of these features is vital to securing our great democracy, which is actually, in the famous 1787 words of Benjamin Franklin, “a Republic — if you can keep it.”

And the whole anti-democratic package is what has allowed us to keep it these 200-plus years.

Let’s go back to “republic”: Democracy is all about majority rule; the word actually means “rule of the people.” A republic is about the self-rule of a nation of free people.

The two words yield a lot of insight into the different thinking of Democrats and Republicans — why, one side loves early voting, vote-by-mail and such schemes, for example, while the other is more eager to honor the profound ritual of going out and casting the ballot on Election Day.

This is much of why the “moral outrage” crowd outrages me: Because they generally don’t even recognize the existence of a different way of thinking, let alone understand it.

Or, God forbid, grant it a shred of legitimacy — even though it’s the actual basis of our entire system.

Look: The Founders were deeply worried about the perils of democracy — its historic instability, its record of oppressing the minority and other potential disasters.

It’s not right to let the majority have its way on everything: Hence the Bill of Rights protections for free speech, a free press and so on.

And full-on democracy — every citizen voting on every law, for example — just doesn’t work at large scale, or last long even on a small level. So we elect representatives to do the law-making, and break the country into states so that local decisions largely get made by locals.

More, the Founders focused on creating a republic that would be stable (not static) and strong: They’d actually gathered for the Constitutional Convention because the government set up after the Revolution was neither.

Yet not too strong: Small states didn’t want larger ones to call all the shots, so we got the Senate (where New York is equal to New Hampshire, etc.) to even the playing field.

And the Electoral College protects a similar value — pushing candidates to fight it out state by state, rather than relying on what today would be some godawful national advertising war. (One that, incidentally, would make money even more central to our politics.)

But here’s the biggest thing for the “morally outraged” to ponder: The whole system is set up to ensure that no single election decides all that much — particularly a “fluke” election like the one we’ve just had.

Trump didn’t win a revolution: He won the chance to try to shift the country. He can (eventually) undo a lot of President Obama’s “pen and phone” ploys, but passing anything drastic could leave him fighting Democrats and Republicans.

March and protest to express your outrage if you must — but thank the Founders for guaranteeing that, once you’re ready to do something about it, you can.
Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

IT Tech Packaging's Going-Concern Warning Lands Hard

Updated Category News Views 55

A paper maker can survive plenty of ugly quarters; it cannot casually shrug off an auditor questioning whether it can keep operating. That is the cold part of IT Tech Packaging's Nov. 19 disclosure. Its newly filed Form 10-K for the year ended Dec. 31, 2025 carries a “Material Uncertainty Related to Going Concern” paragraph from Audit Alliance LLP. Nobody should dress...

Continue Reading
MemorialCare Adds AI Guardrails for Hidden Aneurysms

Updated Category News Views 73

A brain scan ordered for one reason can suddenly expose a risk nobody knew was sitting there. That is the sober promise behind MemorialCare Neuroscience Institute's rollout of Rapid Aneurysm, an artificial-intelligence tool embedded in qualifying CTA and MRA brain scans across its inpatient and outpatient network. MemorialCare says it is the first health system in Los...

Continue Reading
ATRenew's Q3 Profit Jump Meets a Cash Balance Test

Updated Category News Views 105

Used phones do not make for glamorous investing, but this quarter has some real muscle behind it. ATRenew turned a 25.3% revenue gain into a 57.9% jump in operating income for the three months ended September 30, and that is the sort of operating leverage I want to see before getting carried away with a circular-economy story. Margins Finally Move in the Right Direction...

Continue Reading
First Horizon Opens Its Charlotte Office in South End

Updated Category News Views 79

A Building Is Not a Balance Sheet Charlotte got a fresh First Horizon sign at 110 East Boulevard on Nov. 19, 2026, and that is a sensible move, not a magic trick. The bank has officially opened a corporate office in the city’s South End neighborhood, positioning the team to develop client relationships across the Charlotte area and broaden its regional footprint. That...

Continue Reading
PepsiCo Locks In Hyatt's 700-Property U.S. Supply Deal

Updated Category News Views 76

A hotel minibar is a lousy place to hunt for glamour, but it is a terrific place to spot durable distribution. PepsiCo has renewed its U.S. food and beverage relationship with Hyatt for 10 years, covering more than 700 properties. Nobody should pretend a hotel contract transforms a company with nearly $94 billion in 2025 revenue. Still, this is the sort of unflashy...

Continue Reading
PostalAnnex Adds Roseville Store as Owners Reach Three

Updated Category News Views 97

A third storefront from the same operators says more than a ribbon-cutting ever will. Aarondeep Hira and Manraj Sangha have opened a PostalAnnex in Roseville, California, their third Sacramento-area location after earlier operations in Sacramento and Antelope. For a franchise system, repeat ownership is the part worth noticing. It is not a guarantee of booming sales, and...

Continue Reading
Genome-Written XDP Mice Could Sharpen Drug Research

Updated Category News Views 60

Seventy-eight thousand DNA letters changed the pace of a cruel little-known disease story. NYU Langone researchers inserted a human disease-linked stretch of genetic material into mice and produced an accelerated model of X-linked dystonia-parkinsonism, or XDP. That is a serious laboratory accomplishment, not a cure announcement, and it deserves to be read with both...

Continue Reading
Makers Nutrition Backs Families Through Friends of Karen

Updated Category News Views 60

A thousand dollars in gift cards can look modest beside the noise of holiday marketing, but it lands differently when a family is carrying the weight of a child’s life-threatening illness. Makers Nutrition, a Hauppauge, New York-based private-label and custom supplement manufacturer, has donated $1,000 in gift cards to Friends of Karen for the nonprofit’s annual...

Continue Reading
Dario's WebMD Deal Opens a Vast, Unproven Channel Path

Updated Category News Views 122

One partnership can look like a gold mine from across the valley; getting the ore out is another matter entirely. DarioHealth has struck a strategic partnership with WebMD Health Services that could put its multi-condition care platform in front of an enormous commercial ecosystem: more than 3,500 employers and 65 million covered lives. That is a meaningful distribution...

Continue Reading
JDEnergy's RE+ Push Meets a Grid Hungry for Storage

Updated Category News Views 64

Certification Is Useful, Not a Victory Lap A battery box earning a safety certificate is not usually thrilling stuff, but the timing matters here. On Nov. 19, 2026, JDEnergy laid out its North American storage pitch at RE+ in Las Vegas while electricity demand is getting shoved higher by industrial buildout and AI data centers. Add more variable renewable generation to an...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Itaú Unibanco Financial Results and Upcoming Session Insights

Updated Category News Views 342

Itaú Unibanco's Q3 Financial Performance Overview Itaú Unibanco Holding S.A. has made a significant announcement regarding its financial performance for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2025. The condensed financial statements and management discussion analysis for the third quarter are now accessible for shareholders and the market, showcasing transparency and...

Continue Reading
XPLR Infrastructure Faces Class Action Lawsuit Amid Concerns

Updated Category News Views 186

Understanding the Class Action Against XPLR Infrastructure, LP Levi & Korsinsky, LLP has recently alerted investors of a pending class action lawsuit concerning XPLR Infrastructure, LP, formerly known as Nextera Energy Partners, LP. This significant legal action raises various concerns for investors affected by alleged securities fraud. Details of the Lawsuit The class...

Continue Reading
Elizabeth Warren Takes Stand on Sesame Street Funding Cuts

Updated Category News Views 213

Elizabeth Warren Takes a Stand Against Funding Cuts Recently, Senator Elizabeth Warren expressed deep concerns regarding a Republican initiative aimed at significantly cutting federal funding designated for public broadcasting. Her focus is primarily on programs cherished across America, such as Sesame Street and National Public Radio. Understanding the Proposal The...

Continue Reading
Generative AI: Paving the Future of Work in America

Updated Category News Views 195

The Impact of Generative AI on U.S. Workforce Management Enterprises in the United States are viewing the future of work with cautious optimism, largely influenced by the potential of generative AI (GenAI). A recent research report has shed light on how AI is transforming workplace strategies in the wake of ongoing economic fluctuations. Understanding Hybrid Work...

Continue Reading
Exploring Changes in Epilepsy Treatment Response Over Time

Updated Category News Views 145

Understanding Focal Epilepsy and Treatment Challenges Focal epilepsy is a prevalent form of epilepsy, where specific areas of the brain become excessively active, leading to a range of emotional and behavioral disturbances. Surprisingly, about one-third of patients diagnosed with this condition struggle with conventional treatment methods, often showing limited responses...

Continue Reading