What is a Free Trade Treaty? With the upcoming April 13,

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
PoemStone OMO #20666
What is a Free Trade Treaty?

With the upcoming April 13, 2015 vote on The Trans-Pacific Partnership Treaty (TPP), it may be important to know what a Free Trade treaty is (which the TPP is). This article is devoted to the non-economist in all of us. But, in order to define “Free Trade”, we must first know what “Import Tax” is, because “Free Trade” basically eliminates import taxes. As I am writing this article for an American audience and will use references specifically to the USA. For the bullet points, skip to the Economics for Dummies points.

Import Tax History in the USA

Import tax is a tax on materials that comes from other countries. It has two functions: 1) to protect businesses in the United States from foreign competition; and 2) to raise money for the government, so as to finance standing armies and other functions. Our forefathers knew that American businesses needed protection from foreign competition. In the original “Constitution” called the Articles of Confederation (1776-1783), which was a loosely based agreement of governance by the individual states, there was no import tax and American businesses suffered greatly from all the numerous British imports. After the Articles of Confederation was thrown out, the U.S. Constitution was written and ratified to establish a strong central government. Alexander Hamilton, founding father and first Secretary of the Treasury, established (or re-established like in colonial times) import taxes and protected American businesses from having to survive practices such as “dumping” – where a foreign country produces so much of the same product that it artificially drops the price of that object giving the foreign nation an unfair trading position. Economics For Dummies Point: Import Tax and “Protectionism” had been an unqualified success in the United States for over two centuries.

Inventing a New Way of Thinking – Free Trade

The “New Way of Thinking” actually came from very old thinking of Adam Smith (1723-1770) and his disciple David Ricardo (1772-1823) who wrote about the theory of comparative advantage in his 1817 book On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation, it makes a case for free trade based not on absolute advantage in production of a good, but on the relative “opportunity costs” of production. A country should specialize in whatever good it can produce at the lowest cost, trading this good to buy other goods it requires for consumption. This allows for countries to benefit from trade even when they do not have an absolute advantage in any area of production. Criticism Of Ricardo’s theory: The theory was written in 1817, before there was Industrialization or mass production; before there was dependable transportation like steamships, freeways, semi-trucks, airplanes or goliath cargo ships; and well before globalization where you communicate instantly between countries and before countries could “change their specialties” in a couple of years. None of Ricardo’s mathematical formulas even came close to addressing this. And overall, very few countries practiced Free Trade Treaties and, therefore, it was put on the shelf for many years. It does seem that this 1817 theory would have absolutely no relevance to the late 20th or 21st Century, but we would be wrong. Economics For Dummies Point: Free Trade eliminates import taxes which makes cheap crap from China even cheaper.

The Return of Free Trade

So, why would this outmoded 1817 theory that was never truly tested have a comeback? Let us look at few of the factors. America’s hubris was at its highest, in the late 1970’s. America was definitely the number one economy in the world and the world’s largest manufacturer. There wasn’t even a close second. The U.S. ruled the entire world, installing puppet governments and paying other countries to be our friends (we still pay countries to be our friends). America could do no wrong.

Then, there was the new school of economists, now called Libertarian Economists (in classic economic terms it was called Liberal Economics but it became very confusing and so it is rarely called that) lead by Milton Friedman, (financial adviser to President Ronald Reagan) and later Alan Greenspan (chairman of the Federal Reserve) who had bold “new”plans like “Trickledown” economics, an obsolete policy that did not work in the 1920’s, where it proposed that if you gave more money (decreased taxes) to the richest people, this money would gradually trickle down to the masses (which it never did), and “De-regulation” where control is done only by the businesses themselves -like in the 1700s (As well as the aforementioned revival of Free Trade).

Then, there was also the “Mega” business movement. Within this movement (economists forgot 200 years of banking tradition), it proposed to make banks not only interstate, but also international. This created too big too fail banks who possessed more assets than most countries. With this “Mega Movement” regular companies jumped in and laws were allowed to let them become mega-companies. These Mega-companies by their sheer volume were able to artificially bringing prices down and therefore eliminated most small business and middle size companies. Thus, the “Big Box Store” boom was created and the importance of small businesses became a thing of the past. Economics for Dummies Point: Factors that allowed Free Trade to prosper was unimpeded greed.

The Passage of Free Trade Treaties

The first Free Trade Agreement was negotiated by the Reagan administration and signed into law by President Ronald Reagan. This treaty was between the United States and Canada. The next free trade trade was spearheaded under the George H.W. Bush administration in 1990 which was to be called the North American Free Trade Treaty (NAFTA) – an agreement between Mexico, the USA and Canada. NAFTA became famous as it was debated in the public forum (unlike all other Free Trade Treaties). In the Presidential Debates of 1992 between incumbent President Bush (R), Bill Clinton (D) and third party candidate Ross Perot, Mr. Perot correctly predicted if the U.S. passed NAFTA “we would hearing “a giant sucking sound” coming from the south, which was his colorful phrase for the future term called offshoring. Bill Clinton won the 1992 election and NAFTA passed in 1994. Within 8 years, 700,000 American jobs were sent to Mexico. Here is a classic example of NAFTA: Hershey’s Chocolates no longer make any chocolate in the United States, it is all made in Mexico. As Hershey’s offshored all of its US jobs to Mexico it has created numerous manufacturing ghost towns of cities like Oakdale, CA, Robinson, IL, Hazelton, PA, Stuart’s Draft, VA Naugatuck, CT and, Hershey’s PA.

Then, came the mother of all Free Trade agreements, with the formation on January 1, 1995 of the World Trade Organization. Talks had started in earnest under The Ronald Reagan administration in 1986 to replace the previous world agreement called The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) – the most successful world agreement in history running from 1/1/48 to 1/1/95 (although it had been reality been phased out in 1986). With the GATT agreement, there were many agreements with favored countries to lower import tax rates. But with the WTO – this became an agreement with 161 countries with China joining in 2001. The WTO had really forced down import tax rate on products shipped to America.

Historically, in the 1800’s the average rate on import tax was anywhere from 15% up to 50%. From 1960-1970, the import tax rate was between 6.0 – 7.3%. In 2015, the import tax rate into the United States on average is 1.5% which is one of the lowest if not the lowest in the world. And with extremely low rate, it has allowed countries like China to overproduce and drive out U.S. businesses or even worse caused U.S. companies to pack up and join the enemy – offshoring of U.S. jobs. Economics for Dummies Point: Free Trade Agreements have virtually eliminated import taxes allowing companies to offshore U.S. jobs

The Effect of the WTO



Below are two graphs. One is the loss of manufacturing jobs in the U.S. due to Free Trade and the second graph is the actual Gross Domestic Product (GDP) figures (a way to characterize economic growth) of the U.S and China. Note in 1999, China was preparing to join the WTO (which it did in 2001) by revving up its factories as it knew that this was exactly the time that the United States was eliminating quotas (The quota laws called the Multi Fibre Acts were passed in 1974 to protect U.S. companies from “dumping”). And then China continuously dumped their untaxed products onto the United States. Did David Ricardo predict this? Did Milton Friedman predict this? No, only Ross Perot did.

Besides NAFTA and the World Trade Organization which affects 160 other countries, the United States also has 13 other smaller Free Trade agreements. Really too small to even mention individually. Economics For Dummies Point: Free Trade Agreements are devastating to the U.S. economy especially the World Trade Organization.

Other Criticisms of Free Trade



There are many arguments besides economic against Free trade policies. First, Free Trade heavily favors large corporations destroying infant industries as well as the small and medium sized companies. It undermines long-run economic development – it is difficult to revive manufacturing ghost towns, and difficult to plan for growth when American jobs can be offshored at any time. Free Trade has definitely caused income inequality, and environmental degradation.

Free Trade is supportive of countries sticking to their native practices which often means supporting child labor and working in sweatshops where workers get no benefits in often poorly ventilated and dangerous work environments.

Free Trade has definitely caused the race to the bottom, wage slavery, accentuating poverty in poor countries, harming national defense, and forcing cultural change. One additional criticism is that it allows large corporations to ignore local, state and governmental rules and laws: U.S. Appeals WTO Ruling on Meat Labeling Laws – where the American Meat Institute refused to label their meats as to where the originated. The Congress has successfully repealed the Country of origin labeling law this past winter. Instead of raising global standards, free trade tries to lower standards of countries that are more advanced. All of these inequities have been created so you can buy cheap crap from China at even lower prices. Economics for Dummies Point: If You Think Free Trade is Good, Then You Are a Sociopath.

What To Do About The Trans-Pacific Partnership Treaty?

Do we really need another free trade agreement, our import tax rate is already a record low at 1.5%. We already know the economic impact of previous Free Trade policies. It has been very devastating to the U.S. economy. If you want to stop the TPP from becoming a reality, you will need to write, or e-mail or tweet your Congressman. I have a link that will get you the address or email of your Senator: Listing of U.S. Senator addresses. Write today. the job you save may be your own or at least your neighbors. Stop the TPP!





Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Mason Adds Nonprofit Expertise to Institutional Bench

Updated Category News Views 110

Endowment committees rarely need more noise; they need somebody who has actually sat through the uncomfortable votes. Mason Investment Advisory Services has hired Rebecca “Becky” Farnsworth, CFA, as a senior investment consultant, and this looks like a practical addition rather than the usual chest-thumping personnel announcement. Her stated focus will be...

Continue Reading
CITGO Sign Return Caps Kenmore's Careful Rebuild Work

Updated Category News Views 88

Thirty feet upward and 120 feet eastward is not the sort of move that usually stops a city in its tracks, yet Boston’s CITGO Sign was never merely rooftop hardware. Its public relighting in Kenmore Square marks the final phase of the redevelopment at 660 Beacon Street, and the real accomplishment is less flashy than the lights: a beloved, federally landmarked object...

Continue Reading
Lara Kirchner's Surgical Leadership Earns Recognition

Updated Category News Views 83

Surgical care gets judged in the quiet moments nobody puts on a plaque: a sterile instrument ready when it must be, a handoff done cleanly, a team that does not let a rushed schedule turn into a bad outcome. That is why Lara L. Kirchner's recognition as a Pinnacle Professional of the Year deserves a more serious look than the usual congratulatory confetti. Kirchner is...

Continue Reading
CVRx Lawsuit Puts Barostim Sales Claims Under Hard Scrutiny

Updated Category News Views 121

August 7 turned a compliance disclosure into a wrecking ball for CVRx shareholders. After the company revealed a Department of Justice civil investigative demand and cut its outlook, the stock dropped $3.55, or 60%, to close at $2.39. That is not a routine bad quarter getting punished. It is the market abruptly questioning whether the sales engine, the revenue it...

Continue Reading
California Stone Ban Puts a Hidden Worker Toll in View

Updated Category News Views 42

Countertops are supposed to finish a kitchen, not quietly wreck the lungs of the people cutting them. Yet California's move toward prohibiting the fabrication and installation of artificial stone containing more than 1% crystalline silica puts an ugly, long-running occupational-health problem in plain sight. This is not a story that calls for chest-thumping market talk....

Continue Reading
California Initiative Puts Missed Diagnoses in Focus

Updated Category News Views 73

When Reassurance Turns Into a Risk A clean scan can become a dangerous lullaby when symptoms refuse to leave. That is the hard, unsettling territory behind Hodes Milman’s new Missed Diagnosis Project: California, launched November 20, 2026. The statewide effort focuses on breast cancer diagnostic failures: scans read as benign when more scrutiny was warranted, referrals...

Continue Reading
ASU's International Enrollment Lead Carries Real Weight

Updated Category News Views 108

Twenty thousand nine hundred twenty-six international students is not a campus footnote; it is a serious operating force moving through Arizona State University and the state around it. ASU has held the No. 1 spot among U.S. public universities hosting international students for six straight years, and the 2026 Open Doors report puts it No. 2 across public and private...

Continue Reading
Fervo IPO Lawsuit Puts 71% Share Collapse in Focus

Updated Category News Views 61

Fervo’s $27 debut has turned into the sort of wreckage IPO buyers dread: shares were alleged to have closed as low as $7.79 when the complaint was filed. That is more than a 71% fall from the May 13, 2026 offering price, and it puts a hard, ugly number beside the new securities class action against the geothermal power developer. More Than a Bad Quarter Is Being Alleged...

Continue Reading
Classic Chevrolet Gives $1.145M to 13 Local Groups

Updated Category News Views 90

A Thanksgiving Check With Some Real Weight More than a million dollars changing hands before lunch is not the usual holiday fluff, and Classic Chevrolet's planned $1,145,040 donation deserves more than a quick nod. On Tuesday, November 24, at 11 a.m. CST, the Grapevine dealership says it will distribute that sum among 13 nonprofit organizations and charitable programs...

Continue Reading
Jalisco’s Culinary Push Puts Tourism Strategy in Focus

Updated Category News Views 50

A destination sells itself twice: first with a memorable meal, then with a reason to come back. Jalisco’s stated effort to connect the world’s cuisines through The 50 Best Gastronomic Experiences belongs in that second category. It is not merely restaurant chatter. It reads as part of a broader attempt to make the state’s tourism offering feel deeper, more varied...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Global Microinsurance Market Expected to Surpass $11 Billion by 2034

Updated Category News Views 137

Growth Trajectory of the Global Microinsurance Market The microinsurance market is witnessing remarkable transformation as consumer demands shift towards financial inclusion, coupled with increasing awareness of the myriad advantages insurance provides. This positive trend is fueled by government initiatives aimed at regulation and expansion of microinsurance offerings,...

Continue Reading
Ormat Technologies Launches Secondary Stock Offering

Updated Category News Views 188

Ormat Technologies Launches Secondary Stock Offering Ormat Technologies, Inc. (NYSE: ORA), renowned for its innovative geothermal and renewable energy solutions, recently announced an exciting development in the investment realm—the initiation of an underwritten secondary offering. This offering encompasses a total of 3,700,000 shares of common stock on behalf of ORIX...

Continue Reading
MongoDB Executive Share Transactions Highlight Growth Potential

Updated Category News Views 132

Insights from MongoDB Executive Share Transactions Cochran Hope F, a director at MongoDB, Inc. (NASDAQ: MDB), recently made notable moves with the company's Class A Common Stock, and these transactions were disclosed in the latest SEC filings. This activity has attracted attention from investors. In September, the director sold 1,174 shares at $224.38 each, which brought...

Continue Reading
Essential Guidance for Navigating Hurricane Travel Risks

Updated Category News Views 69

Essential Guidance for Navigating Hurricane Travel Risks Hurricane season brings with it the potential for severe weather that can disrupt travel plans and lead to significant financial losses. As storms like Hurricane Helene have shown, the impact can be widespread, devastating homes and infrastructure, particularly in the southeastern regions. During these turbulent...

Continue Reading
Ascend Performance Materials Launches High-Purity Production

Updated Category News Views 279

Ascend Performance Materials Starts High-Purity Acrylonitrile Production Ascend Performance Materials has recently announced an exciting new phase in its production capabilities. The company is now producing high-purity acrylonitrile at its Chocolate Bayou facility. This advancement comes after the successful installation and commissioning of state-of-the-art purification...

Continue Reading