An opposing position from a conservative economist, and a

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
Bhawks OMO #20462
An opposing position from a conservative economist, and a dead Scotsman.

Quote:
Listen to Adam Smith: inheritance tax is good

Inheritance tax is one levy that makes good economic sense


269796-1.jpg

Irwin Stelzer

17 October 2007

http://www.spectator.co.uk/2007/10/listen-to-...x-is-good/

Politics trumps economics. That’s the best summary of the Tory and Labour competition to pander to those who until now have been threatened with paying to the Treasury a portion of the money they receive for just ‘being there’.

Let’s de-emotionalise this issue. An inheritance tax is not a death duty. The slogan ‘No taxation without respiration’ is too clever by half. Even a Chancellor of the Exchequer as powerful as the previous occupant of the office could not get a corpse to sign a cheque. It is a tax paid by the recipient of this income, the inheritor, the lucky winner in the sperm lottery.

Nor, finally, is it a tax on a lifetime of thrift. In most cases the wealth being taxed results from a rise in the value of houses — not something brought about by the acumen and hard work of the owner, but by a decade of low interest rates and economic growth, or the good fortune of having a public amenity plunked down in the neighbourhood.

That out of the way, let’s consider why the rush to appease a few voters in a few marginals is bad economic policy.

Barry Bracewell-Milnes, a student and an opponent of these taxes, concedes that ‘Inheritance without taxation weakens the beneficiary’s incentive to work.’ Surveys by the Economic and Social Research Council show that only a very small minority of people say they work for ‘enjoyment’; most work for what ESRC researchers call ‘mainly instrumental reasons’ — to keep a roof over their head and food on the table.

Studies by the Policy Studies Institute and the London School of Economics support this conclusion: 70 per cent of the men and half the women questioned say the main reason they work is to ‘earn money for necessities’.

So it should come as no surprise that researchers at America’s Syracuse University find (with appropriate caveats), ‘An inheritance received by a family reduces the probability that both spouses will continue to work, and increases the probability that both will retire.’

In short, Andrew Carnegie, the great Scottish philanthropist and a special Gordon Brown hero, had it right — ‘The parent who leaves his son enormous wealth generally deadens the talents and energies of the son and tempts him to lead a less useful and less worthy life than he otherwise would.’

Leave inheritances untaxed, and many of the young inheritors will exit the productive workforce, not a good thing for an economy needing to encourage hard work in an increasingly competitive world.

We know, too, that inheritance taxes encourage parents to spend money enhancing their children’s educational and social skills. Unable to leave a tax-free financial package, parents are more likely to pour some of their wealth into what University of Chicago economist Casey Mulligan calls ‘educational and health expenditures, financial gifts, or time spent teaching or nurturing them [their children]’.

It is a social misfortune that such an inheritance is not more widely available — but that’s a policy discussion for another day. What is important here is that inheritance taxes encourage parents to invest in skills during their children’s formative years.

Then there is the practical question: where will the money come from to replace the revenues lost when the take from inheritance taxes is reduced?

Since the Tories have promised, cross their hearts and hope to die, that they will spend as much as the Labour wastrels, it won’t come from reductions in government spending.

No, it will come from pensioners, whose incomes will now be capped sooner than originally planned; employees who have invested in Save As You Earn (SAYE) schemes; higher taxes on farmers selling their farms; the military, which forfeits any prospect of a real increase in the funds available to defend the realm; small businessmen who had been encouraged by the last Chancellor to risk their meagre capital and ample sweat equity in the hope of selling out and paying only a 10 per cent capital gains tax; non-doms (of which I am one) who will pay £30,000 per year in addition to the taxes on the money they earn and spend in Britain; and hedge-fund operators who have been pretending that their ordinary incomes are capital gains, but who will still be allowed that pretence, their tax raised to 18 per cent from 10 per cent, but not to the 40 per cent that others pay on such incomes.

The non-doms and the hedge-fund operators are reasonable targets, if equity is all there is to consider. But these financial types are the most mobile of the assets located in Britain. Not all will flee, but some will, and others eyeing Britain as a site for new businesses will now know it is less worthwhile than it once was to brave the mean streets of London by taking up residence in a town with one of the highest costs of doing business in the world.

But if it is equity that the Labour taxmen are after, why penalise pensioners (again) and small businessmen (again), and employee-savers, and all the other innocent bystanders? All to benefit a handful of taxpayers who happen to be concentrated in key marginals.

Which brings us to the final objection to this forgiveness of taxes on inheritance, which in the end is no different from any other income the beneficiary might receive — except that it is not earned by the sweat of his brow or the whirring of his brain. The tax cuts could have been better concentrated on lowering the marginal tax rate faced by all earners.

Reduce taxes on the pay for that extra work, and you will get more of it; reduce taxes on the profits from risk-taking, and entrepreneurs will take more chances and create more jobs. Reduce the taxes on recipients of inheritances, on the other hand, and they will work less and be less likely to start up new businesses. Worse still, and perhaps most important, to abandon the laudable goal of trying to make opportunity more equal for all in order to favour the beneficiaries of perhaps the 6 per cent of estates that pay inheritance taxes is a terrible policy trade-off.

At least to an economist, whose policy role should be to tell politicians the cost of their decisions, and then leave it to them to decide whether a policy is worth its cost. Inheritance taxes make good economic sense, but against the economic advantages must be set the limitation they impose on the freedom of people to dispose of their lawfully earned wealth as they see fit.

In my view, that reduction in freedom — the cost of retaining inheritance taxes — is outweighed by the benefits: the economic advantages, especially when compared with other taxes, and their contribution to the drive for greater equality of opportunity. Which makes it too bad that politics trumped economics, since the result is neither greater overall fairness, nor the increased stimulus to economic growth that alternative tax cuts would provide.

Messrs Darling and Osborne would do all of us a favour if they would whip out their undoubtedly dog-eared copies of The Wealth of Nations. To meet the criteria of ‘evident justice and utility’, Adam Smith supported a tax on wealth inherited by children ‘who have got families of their own, and are supported by funds separate and independent of their father’.

Which is why the Economist classifies Smith as one of the political economists ‘broadly in favour’ of the estate tax. Pity that two Scots, both hailing from Kirkcaldy, differ on this policy question.


Irwin Stelzer is director of economic policy studies at the Hudson Institute and a columnist for the Sunday Times.

Irwin M. Stelzer is an American economist who is the U.S. economic and business columnist for The Sunday Times in the United Kingdom and The Courier-Mail in Australia. In the United States, he has been a contributing editor at The Weekly Standard. Wikipedia

Born: May 22, 1932 (age 84)

Education: Cornell University
Books: Lectures on Regulatory and Competition Policy, From Grave to Cradle: Building a Meritocracy
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

YONDELIS: Thai Approval Opens New Sarcoma Treatment Path

Updated Category News Views 210

New Hope for Thai Sarcoma Patients Alright, we’ve got some good news coming out of Thailand, folks. The Thai FDA just greenlit YONDELIS® (trabectedin) for those grappling with advanced soft tissue sarcoma (STS). Now, this isn’t your everyday drug release—it’s a clinical chess move packing potential for patients who’ve run out of other options. December 1st,...

Continue Reading
CureGene's CG-0416: Promising Weight Loss Breakthrough

Updated Category News Views 49

Game-Changer in Weight Management? Oh, the obesity world is buzzing, folks! There's some big noise coming from CureGene, and it's catching the attention of every lab-coat smarty in town. They just tossed out some preclinical data on CG-0416 at Obesity Week 2026 that could shake up how we tackle weight loss. Anyone still clinging to their old diet books might want to take...

Continue Reading
Championing Change: USTA Mid-Atlantic Gala's Impact

Updated Category News Views 360

A Night to Remember: USTA Mid-Atlantic's Gala Who would've thought tennis could wield such transformative power? This ain't your average sport gala. Last Saturday, a crowd of over 300 gathered at the Ritz-Carlton Tysons Corner for the USTA Mid-Atlantic Foundation's 2026 Tennis Creates Gala. Hosted by the formidable Malika Andrews, this event wasn't just a fancy...

Continue Reading
Kayla Harrison Dominates UFC 334, Earns Big Win

Updated Category News Views 64

Kicking off UFC 334 with a bang, Kayla Harrison didn't just step into the Octagon—she bulldozed her way through Amanda Nunes to retain her Women's Bantamweight Championship. This showdown didn't just electrify New York's Madison Square Garden, it shook the entire MMA landscape. Harrison, the face of Monster Energy's athlete roster, wasn't content with just defending her...

Continue Reading
HONOR Leads in China, Eyes Middle East Market

Updated Category News Views 0

A Force to be Reckoned With Talk about making waves—HONOR's got the bragging rights now. Sitting pretty at the top among Android smartphone brands in China ain't no small feat. We're looking at a snazzy 12.04% market share for October 2026, all thanks to selling a cool 2.573 million units. The kicker? This ain't even their full potential. They're hustling hard in the...

Continue Reading
KINGRVER Boosts RV Comfort with New Water Heater Lineup

Updated Category News Views 349

An Upgrade for the Open Road In the land of RV living, comfort is king—or in this case, KINGRVER. Dropping affordable upgrades for water heaters into the world of RVs, KINGRVER's CT6 lineup is like a warm hug on a chilly campsite morning. Whether you've pulled up to a wooded retreat or parked under the vast desert sky, having dependable hot water shouldn't be a gamble....

Continue Reading
Pony.ai & Toyota Launch 1,000 Gen-7 Robotaxis in China

Updated Category News Views 98

Revving Up the Autonomous Ride Revolution Not every day you see two giants, Pony.ai and Toyota, join forces to shake up the way folks get from A to B. But here we are — they’ve fired up their engines in Guangzhou, unleashing their Gen-7 bZ4X Robotaxis for commercial use. And let me tell you, this is no shot in the dark. With plans to dot about 1,000 of these...

Continue Reading
DoGo Power Revamps Energy for Remote Indonesian Isle

Updated Category News Views 16

Bringing Light to Pagerungan Kecil Island These days, if you wander into the fishing communities of Pagerungan Kecil Island, the buzz isn't just from the daily catch. Residents are talking about power, and not the kind you get from a generator spluttering along—I'm talking about a brand-new energy storage system that’s turning the lights on in ways these folks have...

Continue Reading
Guangdong's APEC Trade: Deep Ties, Big Stakes

Updated Category News Views 138

A New Chapter in Guangdong's Economic Story Swing by the bustling streets of Shenzhen, and you'll catch more than a whiff of change in the air. With China gearing up to host the APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting for the third time, Guangdong is under the magnifying glass. But it's not just the international attention landing on the province that’s worth the chatter —...

Continue Reading
InstaHeat 35K: FOGATTI Offers Upgraded RV Furnace Control

Updated Category News Views 548

Winter RV Trips Just Got Cozier There's nothing quite like hitting the open road in an RV during the winter months. But let's face it, nobody wants to return to a cabin that's as frigid as the great outdoors. Here's where FOGATTI steps up its game with the InstaHeat Ultra 35K RV Furnace. They’ve tinkered with the thermostat to iron out more precise control, just in time...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Key Insights on Paragon 28, Inc. Class Action Lawsuit

Updated Category News Views 106

Understanding the Paragon 28 Class Action Lawsuit Recently, investors in Paragon 28, Inc. have been alerted about a significant class action lawsuit involving the company's financial disclosures. The litigation revolves around potential inaccuracies in previously issued financial statements. Investors must be aware that the upcoming deadline to file a lead plaintiff...

Continue Reading
Newtopia Partners with Payvider for Enhanced Health Benefits

Updated Category News Views 278

Newtopia Partners with Payvider for Enhanced Health Benefits Newtopia Inc. (NEWU; NEWUF), a leader in tech-enabled habit change solutions, is thrilled to announce its new partnership with a supplemental insurance payvider. This exciting collaboration aims to provide Newtopia's successful habit change platform as a fully-covered benefit for thousands of workers in the...

Continue Reading
A4A Celebrates 250 Years of American Independence through Aviation

Updated Category News Views 94

A4A Launches Campaign for America's 250th Anniversary Airlines for America (A4A) is excited to unveil a memorable campaign, "Red, Flight & Blue—Celebrating America 250," which aims to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the United States. This significant campaign will utilize a variety of platforms, including social media, blog posts, and videos, to highlight the...

Continue Reading
Alexander’s Secures $400M Loan for New York Office Refinancing

Updated Category News Views 238

ALEXANDER’S, INC. concluded a hefty refinancing deal worth $400 million for its office condominium at 731 Lexington Avenue back in 2024. This isn’t just any property; it’s where Bloomberg LP hangs its hat—a landmark in the bustling New York City real estate scene. Traders were glued to this one because it wasn’t just about refinancing but about what it signals...

Continue Reading
IDV Secures Major Contract for Military Logistics Vehicles

Updated Category News Views 239

IDV Secures a Major Tender from the Dutch Armed Forces In a significant development for military logistics, IDV, part of the renowned Iveco Group (EXM: IVG), has successfully secured a contract with the Dutch Ministry of Defence. This contract entails supplying an impressive fleet of 785 military logistics vehicles, which includes three distinct versions: semitrailer...

Continue Reading