Opinion: Is A Codec War in Our Future? While the Alliance

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
tinytoes51 tinytoes51 #66296
Opinion: Is A Codec War in Our Future?
While the Alliance for Open Media's AV1 shows promise for OTT, MPEG's system approach promises greater interoperability as it also addresses the broadcast market
Today, the industry is abuzz with articles, claims, and counterclaims about codecs. As someone who has been immersed in MPEG since the days of its inception, I want to explain the history of codecs in order to give you a better understanding of where the market is headed.

Until now, video standards have been necessary to create an interoperable world for the distribution of media, initially for broadcast given the constraints of hardware decoders and later on for unicast as the industry evolved toward software-based decoding. The first bump on the MPEG road came in the early 2000s when Microsoft developed its own codec, VC9, later known as VC-1 by SMPTE.

Does anyone wonder what happened to VC-1? This codec had the same performance as MPEG-4 AVC/H.264 and roughly the same licensing terms, so the industry response was “Thanks, but no thanks.” The second bump in the road came in 2010 when Google bought On2 to gain access to the A/V codec technology. They launched VP8, limited to YouTube, and are now transitioning to VP9. Thus far, VP8/9 has had very limited success outside YouTube, and it is not supported widely on mobile devices. Companies like Google, Microsoft, Cisco, and Mozilla do not like the MPEG licensing model for HEVC, since it is unclear, so they created the Alliance for Open Media (AOM) to offer an open source, royalty-free codec that performs twice as efficiently as HEVC. It’s compelling, right?

Now let’s do some math. The pay-TV market is worth approximately $350 billion, and the OTT market is valued at about $35 billion. Even if a new codec was able to address the OTT market, which has yet to be proven, it still has to succeed in a market that is 10 times larger. As a matter of fact, AV1, the AOM new codec, is only targeting OTT delivery and will not be able to solve the codec problems for the broadcast market.

Let’s take a look at the big challenges on the broadcast side. If service providers want to increase the resolution of their channels from SD to HD in emerging countries and HD to UHD in developed regions, especially for delivery over bandwidth-limited networks such as DTT, mobile, or OTT (DSL), then a new codec will be required after 2020.

This brings us to the dynamics of an open source codec. The nature of an open source codec is that it will be updated on a regular basis. As a reference, a new version of the Reference Design Kit (RDK), the open source cable middleware, is released every month. There will be multiple versions of AV1 operated by different OTT services that will have to interoperate with billions of AOM-capable devices. Who is going to be the traffic cop? It’s likely that AOM will define interoperability profiles, but based on what we have seen with DASH, it may be several years until there is a good level of interoperability for live services.

OTT operators pushing for AOM (i.e., Netflix, Amazon) will have to impose strict device rules and duplicate streams on their servers, incurring additional encoding and storage costs. This scenario could work for VOD where the library size is limited, but what about live applications? This would require using unicast to stream multiple versions to address each different client. If the operator has a managed network where multicast is used for live, there is not enough network capacity to simulcast.

This begs the question: Is AOM a real solution for live OTT? Well, if you liked the fragmentation of Android, you are going to love AOM. The open source codec can work in a software client environment, such as web browser on a PC, but does not work on TVs, IP STBs, HDMI dongles, smartphones, or game stations. Essentially, it is not compatible with the lion’s share of OTT clients with a dedicated hardware decoder for achieving a very high performance target (i.e., games and video in Ultra HD), a low cost (IP STB) or power efficiency (i.e., mobile devices).

MPEG-4 AVC/H.264 has been an international standard since 2002. And while MPEG-4 encoders have been deployed for at least 10 years all over the world, some TVs today have a hard time decoding a standard stream that is ratified for 14 years. Since most of those TVs are not connected, only an over-the-air update can be done. This costs money and is not always possible in all countries. Imagine if the codec was changing every month. Do you think this would work?

Now let’s circle back to the AV1 codec from AOM. Before it can be successful, performance claims have to be substantiated. MPEG is working with engineers to reach a factor two compression at the codec level by 2020 as an international standard, meaning its capabilities will be demonstrated in 2019.

On the royalty free aspect of AV1, MPEG has developed a lot of essential patents for block-based compression. Unless AOM comes up with a brand new technique, it will have to pay MPEG patent holders, who are not making much money with HEVC these days and will be eager to monetize on AV1.

Last but not the least, it’s important to note that AV1 is only looking at the codec level, while MPEG focuses on the system level. Harmonic believes (and recently made a contribution to MPEG) that if we work at the system level, we could reach a factor four compared with the HEVC approach of using new techniques such as elastic encoding, OTT content based rate control, tiling for VR, scalable coding for 8K, pre-post processing pairing, machine learning, etc. Of course, if all factors are considered, then the chances to reach a factor four are higher as opposed to the simple broadcast of HD. Those techniques will bring major differences compared with the pure codec rat race. In addition, they will solve system problems such a picture quality and latency that could derail applications delivered over the internet if performance levels are not met.

In short, MPEG has the potential to leapfrog AOM with a system approach, coming only two years after AV1 was deployed on web browsers for wired applications. What’s more, it’s a platform that also addresses the broadcast market.

You can argue AOM has rallied chip companies such as Intel, ARM, AMD and NVDIA, all of which develop silicon technologies for PCs and mobile devices. But on mobile devices, the A/V decoding function is always done in the hardware for cost and power reasons. The logic used to do AV1 decoding will have to be reprogrammable, probably using similar techniques to FPGA. (See the recent acquisition of Altera by Intel.) This has not been deployed yet, and of course what works today for HD might not work for Ultra HD, especially when all the goodies like WCG, HDR, HFR and NGA are added in 2017!

So what does AOM really bring to the market? It offers a clear alternative for the web world that does not want to pay an "MPEG tax," a potential plan B if HEVC licensing does not get resolved and possibly new algorithm innovation that is less controlled than MPEG.

Will the content providers and consumers win at the end of this codec war? MPEG isn’t finished yet. It is going to innovate or will become irrelevant, especially if the licensing terms are becoming less and less accepted. Will MPEG learn a lesson from HEVC? Trust me, there is a lot of frustration in the MPEG community, and they won’t repeat past mistakes.
http://www.streamingmedia.com/Articles/Editor...12919.aspx

Nanotech Entertainment Inc. (NTEK) Stock Research Links

NTEK Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Global-E Faces Fresh Scrutiny After Muted Quarterly Outlook

Updated Category News Views 28

A guidance bump that barely clears the curb can still wreck a stock. That is the unpleasant read-through from Global-E Online's third-quarter 2026 report: revenue guidance went higher, but not high enough to persuade investors that the business was pulling away from expectations. Shares fell after the release, and a securities-law investigation announced November 19 has...

Continue Reading
Baker Tilly Breach Raises Hard Questions on Vendor Risk

Updated Category News Views 57

A Quiet Vendor Failure Can Become a Loud Problem Tax files are not ordinary customer records, and that is why this reported Baker Tilly Advisory Group breach deserves more than the usual shrug people give cyber incidents. Names and addresses are bad enough; the potential exposure of Social Security numbers and other sensitive information turns a systems failure into a...

Continue Reading
Jeff Stern Turns Travel Photography Into a Sensory Memoir

Updated Category News Views 68

Frost in a mountain tent, fermented mare’s milk in a yurt, and coffee in Vietnamese rice paddies are doing more work here than a thousand polished sunset captions ever could. Jeff Stern’s A Change of Scenery, released by Palmetto Publishing on November 17, 2026, comes from a man who spent more than 25 years building brands and then decided the usual labels around...

Continue Reading
Wenge AI Removes a Small Friction Point for ScienceOra

Updated Category News Views 77

Scientific software rarely loses users because the underlying model is too clever; it loses them because getting through the front door is a nuisance. Wenge AI has addressed that unglamorous problem by adding Google and Apple sign-in options to the international version of ScienceOra, its AI-powered research and decision-support platform. This is not the sort of...

Continue Reading
Scientific Games Takes Big Buck Hunter to Lotteries

Updated Category News Views 84

A mounted arcade cabinet is an odd place to find lottery growth, yet Scientific Games may be onto something with its exclusive Big Buck Hunter licensing deal. Announced November 19, 2026, the arrangement lets the company carry a 26-year-old arcade franchise into U.S. and Canadian instant scratch games, Fast Play, draw games, digital products and second-chance promotions....

Continue Reading
FFR Adds Academic and Commercial Muscle to Its Board

Updated Category News Views 50

Robotics boards can get crowded with lofty nouns fast, and FFR just added another one with some real-world connective tissue behind it. Carolyn Kissane, associate dean at NYU's Center for Global Affairs, has joined as an independent director. The appointment is not a product launch, a contract, or revenue. It is a governance move. Still, in a business trying to weld...

Continue Reading
Yiwu Squishies Turn Viral Demand Into Factory Backlogs Worldwide

Updated Category News Views 87

A pizza-shaped stress toy booking more than one million units is the sort of detail that makes a jaded market watcher sit up before rolling his eyes at the word “viral.” Yiwu’s squishy-toy surge appears to have moved beyond a few social-media impulses and into actual factory scheduling, repeat purchase orders and supermarket procurement. That is meaningful. It is...

Continue Reading
Goosehead Restatement Puts Accounting Trust on Trial

Updated Category News Views 133

A filing delay can be irritating; a multi-year no-rely warning is something uglier. Goosehead Insurance told investors on November 9, 2026, that it would not timely file its quarterly report for the period ended September 30 and that prior financial statements must be restated. That is not a garden-variety paperwork hiccup. It reaches back across fiscal 2023, 2024 and...

Continue Reading
AIC Hotel Group's 11 Awards Test Resort Market Reach

Updated Category News Views 89

Eleven Trophies, Four Properties, One Useful Signal Hospitality awards can be a lot of polished brass and very little cash flow, but this batch is substantial enough to deserve a hard look. AIC Hotel Group collected 11 honors spanning Condé Nast Traveler's 2026 Readers' Choice Awards, Travel Weekly's 2026 Magellan Awards, and Good Housekeeping's 2027 Travel Awards. The...

Continue Reading
Thanksgiving Kitchen Safety Is No Place for Autopilot

Updated Category News Views 107

Steam, chatter, and one forgotten burner can turn a holiday meal ugly in a hurry. The Consumer Product Safety Commission’s Nov. 19, 2026 reminder lands on a point that should not need repeating, yet plainly does: Thanksgiving kitchens demand attention, not casual optimism. This is not about ruining anybody’s celebration with a lecture. It is about recognizing that a...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Rob Shields Steps Up as Chief Growth Officer at Greenlane

Updated Category News Views 533

Greenlane Welcomes Rob Shields as Chief Growth Officer Greenlane Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ: GNLN), a distributor of premium cannabis accessories and vaporization products, has recently appointed Rob Shields as Chief Growth Officer. This transition comes at a pivotal time for the company, as it aims to enhance its market presence and address ongoing challenges in the...

Continue Reading
HealthBird Revolutionizes Healthcare in Ecuador with Collaboration

Updated Category News Views 436

HealthBird Partners with Ecuador to Innovate Healthcare HealthBird, a leading health technology provider, is making waves as it spearheads an innovative healthcare initiative in Ecuador. The company, associated with OneNest, aims to support the nation in transforming its healthcare system into a modern, efficient, and sustainable framework. With a commitment to investing...

Continue Reading
Exciting New Travelzoo Offers for Enthusiasts Awaiting You

Updated Category News Views 579

Exciting Travel Offers for Members Travelzoo® (NASDAQ: TZOO), a renowned name for travel enthusiasts, has recently unveiled new Club Offers designed specifically for its members. These unique deals have been meticulously vetted and negotiated to ensure travelers can enjoy exceptional experiences at remarkable prices. Explore Enchanting Destinations Among the latest...

Continue Reading
Join Tiptree for Insights on Q3 2024 Performance

Updated Category News Views 180

Join Tiptree for Insights on Q3 2024 Performance Tiptree Inc. (NASDAQ:TIPT) is gearing up for an engaging conference call and live webcast to delve into the details of its Q3 2024 results. Scheduled for Thursday, October 31, 2024, at 10:30 AM ET, this event promises to be an informative session for all stakeholders. How to Access the Conference Call Participants wishing...

Continue Reading
WOW! Expands Services in Florida with New Fiber Customers

Updated Category News Views 236

WOW! Expands Its Fiber Network in Florida Residents and businesses can now eagerly sign up for WOW!'s all-fiber services that come with simplified pricing, marking a significant milestone in the company's expansion efforts within the state. Enhanced Connectivity for Communities WOW! Internet, TV & Phone (NYSE: WOW), renowned for its reliable broadband services, has...

Continue Reading