'As American as Apple Pie': Harvard Professor Defends

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
PoemStone smackles #17617
'As American as Apple Pie': Harvard Professor Defends Trump's 'Extreme Vetting'

In his major foreign policy speech earlier this week, Donald Trump explained how he would expand the “ideological” vetting of immigrants who want to come to the United States.

“The time is overdue to develop a new screening test for the threats we face today,” he said. “I call it extreme vetting.” In particular, Trump proposed, “We must also screen out any who have hostile attitudes towards our country or its principles—or who believe that Sharia law should supplant American law. Those who do not believe in our Constitution, or who support bigotry and hatred, will not be admitted for immigration into the country.”

As with practically all of Trump’s policy statements, the over-the-top commentary came swiftly. Over at the Washington Post an opinionator opined (and I’m only slightly paraphrasing) that Trump’s ideas were crazier than crazy. I knew it wouldn’t take long before somebody called them un-American, and MSNBC nicely obliged; a commentator commented that “this is the single most un-American thing I have ever heard in my life.”

If all those pundits had bothered to do just a couple of minutes of googling before reacting, they would have discovered that immigrant vetting, and even extreme immigrant vetting, has a very long tradition in American history. Since before the founding even, U.S. policies about whom the country chooses to welcome and reject have changed in response to changing conditions. As early as 1645, the Massachusetts Bay Colony prohibited the entry of poor or indigent persons. By the early 20th century, the country was filtering out people who had “undesirable” traits, such as epileptics, alcoholics and polygamists. Today, the naturalization oath demands that immigrants renounce allegiance to any foreign state. Even our Favorite Founding Father du jour, Alexander Hamilton (himself an immigrant), thought it was important to scrutinize whoever came to the United States. He wrote:

To admit foreigners indiscriminately to the rights of citizens, the moment they put foot in our country … would be nothing less, than to admit the Grecian Horse into the Citadel of our Liberty and Sovereignty. … The United States have already felt the evils of incorporating a large number of foreigners into their national mass. … In times of great public danger there is always a numerous body of men, of whom there may be just grounds of distrust; the suspicion alone weakens the strength of the nation, but their force may be actually employed in assisting an invader.

In other words, immigration vetting is as American as apple pie.

In the colonial era, governments were particularly concerned with the entry of “public charges” who could impart substantial costs on the indigenous population. In 1691, the Province of New York must have hired a professional economist to design a bonding system that would discourage the entry of people who would be a drag on public resources:

All Persons that shall come to inhabit within this Province ... and hath not a visible Estate, or hath not a manual occupation, shall, before he be admitted an Inhabitant, give sufficient surety, That he shall not be a burden or Charge to the respective places, he shall come to Inhabit. Which Security shall continue for two years.

And in 1740, Delaware enacted legislation to “Prevent Poor and Impotent Persons being Imported." Many of these colonial-era restrictions remained in place until 1875, when the Supreme Court invalidated state-imposed head taxes on immigrants to fund the financial burden of caring for poor entrants, and made immigration the sole purview of the federal government. But that wasn’t the end of immigrant filters. Congress responded by creating the vetting system that—although modified many times—remains in place today. In 1875, Congress prohibited the entry of prostitutes and convicts. In 1882, Congress suspended the immigration of Chinese laborers, and added idiots, lunatics and persons likely to become public charges to the list for good measure.

One of my favorite examples of the extreme vetting is the 1917 Immigration Act, which, in addition to effectively barring immigration from Asia, listed the many traits that would make potential immigrants inadmissible. The following quote is very long, but it shows the excruciating detail with which Americans have historically resorted to extreme vetting:

All idiots, imbeciles, feeble-minded persons, epileptics, insane persons; persons who have had one or more attacks of insanity at any time previously; persons of constitutional psychopathic inferiority; persons with chronic alcoholism; paupers; professional beggars; vagrants; persons afflicted with tuberculosis in any form or with a loathsome or dangerous contagious disease; persons not comprehended within any of the foregoing excluded classes who are found to be and are certified by the examining surgeon as being mentally or physically defective, such physical defect being of a nature which may affect the ability of such alien to earn a living; persons who have been convicted of or admit having committed a felony or other crime or misdemeanor involving moral turpitude; polygamists, or persons who practice polygamy or believe in or advocate the practice of polygamy; anarchists, or persons who believe in or advocate the overthrow by force or violence of the Government of the United States, or of all forms of law, or who disbelieve in or are opposed to organized government, or who advocate the assassination of public officials, or who advocate or teach the unlawful destruction of property; persons who are members of or affiliated with any organization entertaining and teaching disbelief in or opposition to organized government, or who advocate or teach the duty, necessity, or propriety of the unlawful assaulting or killing of any officer or officers ... of the Government of the United States or of any other organized government.

In other words, even a century ago we had put in place ideological filters against anarchists, persons who advocate the destruction of property, and persons who believe in overthrowing the government of the United States.

Of course, some of these filters, such as those restricting the entry of epileptics or Asians, have long since been rolled back—and for good reason. But many of them—especially those pertaining to criminals, and people who are likely to work against U.S. interests—remain in current law, with additions that reflect the changing security landscape. Hijacking and drug trafficking, for example, became major concerns only in the past few decades, and the law changed accordingly to ensure that it became more difficult for hijackers and drug traffickers to enter the country.

Here is the application filled out by green card applicants today (Form I-485). Among the many questions are:

Have you EVER, in or outside the United States:

a. Knowingly committed any crime of moral turpitude or a drug-related offense for which you have not been arrested?

Have you EVER:

a. Within the past 10 years been a prostitute or procured anyone for prostitution, or intend to engage in such activities in the future?

b. Engaged in any unlawful commercialized vice, including, but not limited to, illegal gambling

c. Knowingly encouraged, induced, assisted, abetted or aided any alien to try to enter the U.S. illegally?

d. Illicitly trafficked in any controlled substance, or knowingly assisted, abetted, or colluded in the illicit trafficking of any controlled substance?

Have you EVER engaged in, conspired to engage in, or do you intend to engage in, or have you ever solicited membership or funds for, or have you through any means ever assisted or provided any type of material support to any person or organization that has ever engaged or conspired to engage in sabotage, kidnapping, political assassination, hijacking, or any other form of terrorist activity?

Do you intend to engage in the United States in:

a. Espionage?

b. Any activity a purpose of which is opposition to, or the control or overthrow of, the Government of the United States, by force, violence, or other unlawful means?

Have you EVER been a member of, or in any way affiliated with, the Communist Party or any other totalitarian party?

Did you, during the period from March 23, 1933 to May 8, 1945, in association with either the Nazi Government of Germany or any organization or government associated or allied with the Nazi Government of Germany, ever order, incite, assist, or otherwise participate in the persecution of any person because of race, religion, national origin, or political opinion?

And, finally, here’s part of the oath that immigrants who wish to become citizens of the United States must recite at the naturalization ceremony:

I hereby declare, on oath, that I absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereignty; … that I will support and defend the Constitution and laws of the United States of America against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I will bear arms on behalf of the United States when required by the law.

In view of this almost 400-year track record, is it really that big a stretch to add questions, as Trump proposes, that would expand the filtering to reflect political conditions and national security concerns today? In particular, is it really that big a departure from what we have done in the past if we also asked green card applicants: “Do you believe that religious law should supplant the Constitution of the United States?” Or if we asked: “Do you believe that the law should treat people differentially based on their gender, their race, or their sexual orientation?” And would it really be that unreasonable if we had second thoughts about admitting persons who answered those questions in the affirmative? Are there really that many Americans who would disagree with the notion that a reasonable immigration policy should, in Trump’s words, keep out “those who do not believe in our Constitution, or who support bigotry and hatred”?

Of course, it is sensible to wonder whether such filters are effective. I doubt that the 9/11 terrorists admitted in their applications for foreign student visas that they planned to use their flight training to fly planes into the World Trade Center. But the fact that such filtering is far from perfect does not imply that we should not have any filters whatsoever. If nothing else, the perjury in the visa application gives the government an easy way for detaining and deporting dangerous immigrants living in our midst, even after they become American citizens. The falsification or concealment of relevant facts during the application process provides grounds for the removal of a green card, for the revoking of naturalization, and for eventual deportation.

The many filters that have been used throughout American history to determine who will and will not get an entry visa have an obvious purpose. Yes, some of them, in the hindsight of history, seemed to have had no constructive purpose. But for the most part, they helped to strengthen the social and political fabric of our country and they helped to define the common set of values that distinguishes us as Americans. Or to quote Alexander Hamilton again: “The safety of a republic depends essentially on the energy of a common National sentiment; on a uniformity of principles and habits.”

So, regardless of what you think about the Trump candidacy, the next time you hear that Trump’s proposal for immigrant vetting is un-American, the correct response is that it is American to its core. And the next time you hear that Trump’s proposal is crazier than crazy, the correct response is that—given the mess the world is in—it is the notion that we should not vet immigrants more carefully that is certifiably insane.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Branch's Fast 500 Rank Signals Payroll Platform Reach

Updated Category News Views 118

Six straight appearances on Deloitte's Fast 500 is not random confetti; it says Branch has kept finding customers while plenty of fintech outfits were busy shrinking their ambitions. The Tampa-based workforce-payments company landed at No. 146 in the 2026 ranking, which measures fiscal-year revenue growth from 2022 through 2025. That is a respectable showing in a list...

Continue Reading
Northgate’s Stanton Opening Puts Community Work First

Updated Category News Views 100

A 55,721-square-foot grocery opening can look like ordinary retail churn until you notice where the money and attention are landing. Northgate González Market’s new Stanton location arrives ahead of Thanksgiving, yes, but the more telling detail is the company’s decision to pair a major store launch with 375 jobs and more than $30,000 directed toward families,...

Continue Reading
Sprocket’s GigaOm Leap Puts PTaaS Claims Under Scrutiny

Updated Category News Views 44

Security vendors love a shiny quadrant, but this one deserves more than the usual polite golf clap. Sprocket Security moved from Challenger and Outperformer in GigaOm’s 2025 Penetration Testing as a Service assessment to a Leader in the version 5 report released in 2026. That is a meaningful jump in a category where buyers are tired of annual testing reports that go...

Continue Reading
Travel Disruptions Reveal the Value of Human Support

Updated Category News Views 95

Air travel’s ugly little secret surfaced again during the recent ground stop: a reservation is easy, but rescuing a trip is labor-intensive, fast-moving work. Internova Travel Group says its people across Travel Leaders Network, Global Travel Collection and ALTOUR moved quickly as cancellations piled up and travelers were left staring at busted itineraries. That is not...

Continue Reading
Why Brief Chiropractic Visits Still Need Clear Expectations

Updated Category News Views 76

A few minutes on the table can sound almost suspiciously brisk when somebody is dealing with a stiff neck, sore back, or nagging joint discomfort. Yet that is the central point in Dr. Craig Peterson's explanation for HelloNation: the adjustment itself may be brief, while the value of a chiropractor visit depends on a focused assessment, appropriate technique, and whether...

Continue Reading
Franklin County Trees Raise Funds and Honor Veterans

Updated Category News Views 66

Holiday charity works best when it gives people something tangible to gather around, and Franklin County has found a pretty sturdy version of that formula. Its eighth annual Festival of Trees opens at 4 p.m. Saturday, November 21, at the Franklin County 11/30 Visitors Center in downtown Chambersburg, carrying the theme A Salute To Veterans. More than 80 decorated trees...

Continue Reading
E-Rate Risk and Data Center Rules Demand Attention

Updated Category News Views 71

America’s digital plumbing is getting squeezed at both ends: the public connections nobody notices until they fail, and the industrial-scale computing boom everybody suddenly wants built yesterday. Connected Nation’s two bonus podcast episodes from the Broadband Nation Expo in New Orleans put those pressures side by side, and it is a more useful pairing than it may...

Continue Reading
WaterField’s Nova Case Bets on Better Handheld Carry

Updated Category News Views 89

Tiny handhelds have spawned a surprisingly fussy luggage problem: protection without the clown-show aesthetic. WaterField Designs is taking a clean swing at that with a custom case for the Retroid Pocket Nova, a sleeve-like carrier built around the device rather than some generic pouch that leaves everything rattling around inside. This is not a market-moving corporate...

Continue Reading
Straub's Court Win Raises Cost of Seven-Year Fight

Updated Category News Views 87

Seven years of courtroom smoke over an under-$80,000 lien is the sort of mess that makes any business owner grind his teeth. Palm Beach Polo says its president, Glenn Straub, has again prevailed against Jessica Nicodemo in Palm Beach County, following an earlier Broward County dismissal of related claims. The company also says Vice President Sal Spano received a directed...

Continue Reading
YPTC’s Florida Office Bets on Nonprofit Finance Needs

Updated Category News Views 50

A Local Flag Planted After Years of Work Florida nonprofits do not need another consultant waving a glossy slide deck around; they need clean books, grant compliance, and somebody who can tell them where the cash is going before the lights start blinking red. That is the practical opening YPTC is chasing with a Jacksonville-based Florida office, its sixteenth office...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Discover the Luxury of the Mercedes-Benz EQS: Test Drive Today

Updated Category News Views 200

Experience the Mercedes-Benz EQS Test Drive at Arrowhead Drivers have a wonderful opportunity to immerse themselves in the world of electric luxury with the EQS at Mercedes-Benz of Arrowhead. This dealership is dedicated to providing an exceptional test drive experience, allowing potential buyers to see why this vehicle stands out in its class. With the surge in interest...

Continue Reading
Upcoming Financial Results and Conference Call for PROREIT

Updated Category News Views 103

Important Announcement from PROREIT PRO Real Estate Investment Trust, commonly known as PROREIT, is gearing up to share its financial performance for the 2024 fiscal year as well as the results for the fourth quarter. Scheduled for post-market release, this wave of data promises valuable insights for investors and stakeholders alike. The release will take place on an...

Continue Reading
Hearthside Food Solutions Seeks Bankruptcy Protection Amid Debt Issues

Updated Category News Views 293

Hearthside Food Solutions Files for Bankruptcy Hearthside Food Solutions has taken a significant step by filing for bankruptcy protection amidst deep financial strains. This decision comes as the company aims to reduce its staggering $1.9 billion debt and undertake a much-needed restructuring of its operations. The move follows troubling investigations into allegations of...

Continue Reading
New Affordable Housing Community Launched in San Antonio

Updated Category News Views 149

New Affordable Housing Community Opens in San Antonio The NRP Group, a leading developer known for its quality multifamily housing, has partnered with the City of San Antonio to celebrate the opening of a new affordable housing community called Los Arcos at Vida. This significant development, featuring 324 rental units, represents a crucial step forward in the ongoing...

Continue Reading
Insights on Dollar Tree's Stock Activity and Market Trends

Updated Category News Views 131

Understanding Dollar Tree's Investment Climate In the recent environment of stock trading, Dollar Tree (NASDAQ: DLTR) has caught the attention of many investors. A noticeable trend has emerged among deep-pocketed investors adopting a bearish stance towards the company. This change in sentiment is worth noting for those keeping tabs on the market. Market Activity Insights...

Continue Reading