A graduated income tax could put Illinois in the

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board

Aug 15, 2016 at 1:04 PM

Quote:

A graduated income tax could put Illinois in the clear

By Curtis Black | April 21, 2016

SPRINGFIELD, ILLINOIS, USA - SEPTEMBER 1; Ornate dome inside state capital building/Shutterstock

Instituting a progressive income tax in Illinois would destroy the economy and drive people to flee the state, according to Gov. Bruce Rauner and his supporters.

After the economic refugees got over the border, however, they’d have to keep running. That’s because income tax rates are higher in every bordering state, according to a recent study by the Illinois Economic Policy Institute.

Illinois currently has a flat 3.75 percent individual income tax. Indiana is the only neighboring state with a flat rate – it’s 3.3 percent. But Indiana permits counties to levy income taxes, and the average county rate is 1.5 percent.

The other states have progressive rates; the lowest is Missouri’s, which rises in steps from 1.5 percent to 6 percent – that’s for people earning less than $1,000 a year and those earning over $9,000 a year, respectively. Wisconsin’s top rate, which is for individuals earning over $69,000 a year, is 7.65 percent; Iowa’s is 8.9 percent for people earning over $60,000.

Looking at the combination of state and local taxes, all the states have regressive tax structures, with poor people paying a higher proportion of their income than the wealthy.

But Illinois is the worst. Here the bottom fifth of earners pay 13 percent of their income in state and local taxes, while the top 1 percent pays 4.6 percent, or about a third of what poor people pay.

Compare that to Wisconsin, where the bottom fifth pays about 9 percent of its income, and the top 1 percent pays a little over 6 percent.

Progressive taxation is fairer, since the people who pay more are those who can afford to, and it’s also more efficient and stable because it taxes the sector that has benefited from economic growth for the past several decades.

But perhaps the most interesting statistic – particularly with our accumulated budget deficit topping $9 billion and growing – is how the neighboring states bring in much more revenue than Illinois. That’s not just from a smarter income tax; it’s because unlike Illinois, they’ve all extended their sales taxes to cover services, and they all tax some retirement income.

Adopting Indiana’s tax structure would give Illinois $4.6 billion more each year. Using Iowa’s structure would bring in $7.3 billion more, and Wisconsin’s would yield $8.3 billion more.

That would put Illinois in the clear.

House Democrats have introduced a constitutional amendment to permit a progressive income tax; and if that’s passed, they will introduce legislation that would provide a tax cut to all but the wealthiest taxpayers in the state and raise an additional $1.9 billion a year.

Under that plan, introduced by Rep. Lou Lang, D-Skokie, the tax rate on incomes up to $100,000 (twice that for couples) would be reduced to 3.5 percent. It would rise to the current rate of 3.75 for income up to $500,000, to 8.75 for the next $500,000, and to 9.75 for income over $1 million ($1.5 million for couples).

According to Voices for Illinois Children, that means a couple earning $1 million would pay an additional $11,785 in income taxes.

That’s probably not enough to cover their costs of relocating -- especially when they’d end up paying higher taxes if they moved next door.

Lang’s proposal doesn’t put Illinois’ budget in the black, but it goes part of the way. According to the Center for Tax and Budget Accountability, the state could raise an additional $2 billion by extending the sales tax and another $1 billion by taxing retirement income over $50,000. And there are huge corporate tax loopholes that are ripe for the closing.

For decades, Springfield Democrats have shied away from these kinds of reforms, putting their political fortunes ahead of fiscal responsibility. Now Rauner has brought the state to the brink of disaster; maybe the legislature will muster the courage to act.

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

S?LACE Boats Unveils First Catamaran, the 41CT

Setting a New Course with the 41CT Picture this: a company known for pushing the envelope does it again, but this time, they aren't just elbowing their way into the catamaran market—they're redefining it. S?LACE Boats has unveiled their all-new 41CT center console catamaran. Not just another addition, it's practically a game-changer for anyone passionate about offshore...

Beta Bionics Hit with Lawsuit Over Misleading Claims

Unpacking Beta Bionics' Legal Storm Investors in Beta Bionics, Inc. —ticker BBNX—are probably feeling like they're caught in a whirlwind right now, and who can blame them? The company's facing a class action lawsuit, and the accusations aren't anything to sniff at. They're talking about violations of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, along with some shady...

FirstService Ups the Ante with Stylish Jacksonville Office

A New Chapter for FirstService Residential Picture this: a property management powerhouse dialing up their Jacksonville operations with a shiny new office move. FirstService Residential, North America's big shot in property management, has swapped location to a swish setup on Southpoint Drive South in Jacksonville, Florida, aiming to supercharge collaboration and give a...

3D Concrete Printing Set to Transform Construction by 2035

Concrete Revolution: The 3D Printing Surge Times are changing in construction, and this ain’t your grandfather’s cinder block. We're talking about 3D concrete printing here—an industry poised to swell from just a pipedream sort of $293.4 million in 2025 to a staggering $1.87 billion by 2035. Driven by housing demands and resilient defense contracts, the sector is...

Decoding New Loyalty Strategies with TrueLoyal In this cutthroat market, loyalty's the name of the game, and TrueLoyal just rolled out a sharp new tool that's got me raising an eyebrow. Their Advanced Analytics is shaking up the way brands look at their loyalty programs. This ain't your granddad's analytics tool—it promises to cut the fat and put your spending where it...

b.well and MyDirectives Streamline Access to Care Plans

Pioneering Access to Critical Care Documents Ever thought about where all those critical healthcare documents are stashed? Trust me, it’s often a mess—file cabinets, bookshelves, or stuck in some forgotten safety deposit box. Well, b.well Connected Health and MyDirectives are rolling up their sleeves to change that. They've teamed up to make advance care planning...

New Blood Joins Board: A Power Move for Bank of America

A Fresh Breeze in the Boardroom Bank of America isn't sitting still. They're shaking things up by bringing in Jim Fitterling and Bill Thomas. Now, why’s that a big deal for those watching NYSE:BAC? Well, these guys pack heavy resumes, and their experience could steer the ship with precision across turbulent financial waters. The Minds Behind the Names Let's chew the fat...

Labcorp Scoops Up BioReference Health For $722M+

Picture this: You’re a big fish like Labcorp ready to feast on smaller catches. That’s exactly what’s rolling out as OPKO Health cuts a deal to offload a chunk of its BioReference Health assets to Labcorp for a tidy $722 million in cash. Assets on the Move OPKO’s BioReference Health has long been a player in the clinical testing world, with a focus on services...

EverSmith Rolls Out Training Hub to Propel Franchise Growth

Big Ambitions Nestled in Milford, Ohio Beneath the glow of fluorescent lights in a fresh-to-the-world 12,000-square-foot box of opportunity, EverSmith Brands is betting on big returns. EverHUB has opened its doors, aiming to be the cradle that hatches their aggressive franchise dreams into reality. It's not just brick and mortar—it’s the manifestation of their grand...

Baltimore's New Pact for Family Financial Stability

An Ambitious Proposal for Baltimore's Future Folks, of all places, Baltimore is making waves in the realm of direct financial support again. Being a city that's no stranger to economic challenges, it’s doubling down on an approach that’s shown actual promise. Enter the new partnership between the CASH Campaign of Maryland and Baltimore City. They’re set to shape...