I've actually read the transcripts as well as several

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
Bhawks dbergh #17001
I've actually read the transcripts as well as several critiques.

You can listen to Trump with that unquestioning mind of yours if you choose, but the math of what he proposes does not add up.

At least it doesn't if you want to 'make America great again' AND reduce debt and deficits.

Trump proposes a massive infrastructure Bill and an increase in Defense spending. You can't get one or the other, much less both, with the tax cuts he proposes and without massive debt.

I look forward to your math to make that work. Meanwhile:

Quote:
Donald Trump's “new" tax plan: a giveaway to the rich that he pretends helps the middle class

Updated by Dylan Matthews on August 9, 2016, 2:20 p.m. ET @dylanmatt dylan@vox.com

Donald Trump wants you to believe that his tax plan is maturing; that it’s moving away from its original form, in which it would more than double the national debt and give the top 0.1 percent $1.3 million apiece; that it’s more responsible and in particular more targeted toward people at the bottom.

He told the Detroit Economic Club on Monday that the plan was designed to "Make American Great Again for everyone, and especially those who have the very least," and promised that "for many American workers, their tax rate will be zero."

And superficially, he is making changes in that direction. His first tax plan had three brackets: 10, 15, and 25 percent. Now he’s bumped the rates up to 12, 25, and 33 percent, the same ones proposed by House Speaker Paul Ryan. He’s also added a new tax benefit: a deduction for child care costs borne by families.

The problem is that the changes do little to nothing to solve the main problems with Trump’s tax plan. The plan would still cost an enormous amount of money, adding many trillions of dollars to the national debt.

Despite Trump’s promise to close the carried interest loophole for hedge fund managers, the plan would actually expand it. And even after the changes, the plan is still heavily tilted toward helping the rich.

Trump’s tax plan is still exorbitantly expensive

It’s helpful to take a look back at the Tax Policy Center’s initial analysis of the Trump tax plan, back in December, which broke down the plan’s cost by its component parts. As you see, the rate cuts are the most expensive part of the package. But they only account for about 41 percent of the plan’s overall cost:

trump_breakdown.jpg

Tax Policy Center estimates of the cost of Trump's tax plan
Tax Policy Center

TPC’s initial analysis of Trump’s plan.

In the first 10 years, the new income tax rates would cost $3.95 trillion. But Trump’s massive expansion of the standard deduction to $25,000 for singles and $50,000 for couples, a near quadrupling of the current deduction (which is $6,300 for singles and $12,600 for couples), would cost $3.29 trillion.

What’s more, that provision is only going to get more expensive under the new rates. Higher tax rates make deductions more valuable (because you’re avoiding more tax through them), and thus more costly.

Then there’s Trump’s massive decrease in the corporate tax rate, from 35 percent to 15 percent. That’s another $2.4 trillion, plus another $1 trillion on top of that because he applies the new low rate to "pass-through entities," businesses that are currently taxed at individual income tax rates.

The combined $3.4 trillion cost here is also an underestimate, given the latest changes to Trump’s plan. When corporate tax rates are lower than individual ones, that creates an incentive to reclassify individual income as corporate income to pay the lower rates.

And that incentive is bigger when the gap is between a 33 percent top individual rate and a 15 percent corporate rate than when it’s between a 25 percent top individual rate and a 15 percent corporate rate. So Trump hiking the individual rates without hiking the corporate rate leads to some additional lost revenue.

Imagine for a second that Trump didn’t cut individual rates at all but kept every other piece of his plan the same. And forget for a second that this would make the plan itself more expensive, for the reasons explained above. The plan would still cost $5.57 trillion and, excluding interest payments, would increase the national debt by 19.5 percent of GDP.

By contrast, George W. Bush’s famously massive tax increases only boosted the national debt by 11.4 percent. Take into account the rate cuts, the increased cost of other provisions, and interest payments, and Trump’s plan would cost much, much more and even more dramatically dwarf Bush’s.

The Bush tax cuts have rightly gained a reputation as one of the more fiscally irresponsible, least economically necessary policies pursued by any administration in recent memory. Trump promises to increase the national debt by far, far more for an even bigger giveaway to the rich.

And that increased debt eventually has to be paid for somehow. Maybe it gets paid for by future tax increases on the rich, in which case this is all somewhat pointless. If the cuts are to be made permanent, that leaves spending cuts to plug the gap.


Even if you were to cut defense spending as well, there’s just no way to raise that much money without cutting programs for the poor and social insurance programs like Medicare and Social Security. Once you take those cuts into account, the plan becomes extremely regressive for all but upper-income taxpayers.

The plan is still a big giveaway to the rich


Trump’s claim that the plan now offers more to "those who have the very least" also fails to hold up to any scrutiny. For one thing, as the Tax Policy Center’s Elaine Maag explains, the plan to make child care deductible is regressive: It only benefits the middle- and upper-income Americans with a positive income tax liability.

There are some indications that the deduction might apply against payroll taxes, which would help things a bit, but barring that, as Maag concludes, "Trump has identified a real challenge affecting working families, but his proposal would do little or nothing to help them."

The increased individual tax rates also don’t change the essentially regressive nature of Trump’s plan. Going from the current top individual tax rate of 39.6 percent to 33 percent is still a significant cut for high-income individuals, even if it’s a slightly smaller one than he initially proposed.

The corporate tax is overwhelmingly paid by rich corporate shareholders, not workers, meaning the 20-point drop in the corporate rate Trump is proposing would predominantly help the rich.

Same goes for his plan to abolish the estate tax, which is paid by a tiny number of rich families.

Then there’s Trump’s plan to let businesses currently paying individual rates pay the new 15 percent rate. As the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities’ Chye-Ching Huang, Chuck Marr, and Joel Friedman explain, this would create a massive incentive for individuals to reclassify personal wage income as income from business.

In particular, the plan would make it easy for hedge fund managers currently benefiting from the "carried interest" loophole, which lets them pay lower investment tax rates on their earnings, to pay even less than they do now. Given that Trump has explicitly called for an end to the carried interest loophole, that’s galling.

Currently, long-term capital gains are taxed at a maximum rate of 23.8 percent — significantly lower than the top rate on wages, 39.6 percent. So many hedge fund managers arrange their compensation to pay the former, not the latter.

Trump’s plan would make it easy for them to reclassify their compensation as business income, taxed at only 15 percent. Not only would that fail to close the loophole, it would also open a massive new one and save hedge funder still more money.

Then there’s the fact that taxing pass-through income at a lower rate is regressive, even if it didn’t encourage people to reclassify income. About 69 percent of pass-through income goes to the top 1 percent of earners.

And despite the common perception that pass-through businesses are small enterprises, most pass-through income comes from pretty large companies, just ones that have relatively few shareholders.

As CBPP explains, the mere 0.4 percent of all pass-through companies that earn more than $50 million in revenue account for 40 percent of all pass-through corporation income.

Long story short: This is big money, going from very successful businesses to their wealthy shareholders, that Trump is proposing to tax at a much lower rate.

Fundamentally, Trump is still offering voters the same approach to taxes he’s been offering all campaign: massive cuts for corporations of all kinds, big rate cuts for top earners, and benefits supposedly aimed at the middle class that offer less than they initially appear to.


Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Epic Blue Puts $50,000 of Marketing Work to Use Locally

Updated Category News Views 136

A $50,000 pile of donated know-how can look soft on a spreadsheet, until you remember how often a small nonprofit or early-stage outfit gets ignored because it cannot afford someone to sharpen its message. Epic Blue Marketing, a women-owned firm based in Jackson, Michigan, says it provided that amount in donated and reduced-rate marketing, communications and public...

Continue Reading
Persistent Dry Eye Symptoms Call for a Closer Look

Updated Category News Views 92

Eyes can turn into a stubborn little nuisance long before people realize something more complicated is going on. A bottle of artificial tears is easy to grab, cheap enough, and often perfectly sensible for a rough day of screens, wind, reading, or air conditioning. But Dr. Harlan Snyder’s point is the one worth sitting with: when dryness keeps barging back despite...

Continue Reading
Employer Ghosting Is a Quiet Talent-Cost Problem Today

Updated Category News Views 155

Silence is cheap right up until a company needs talent again. Then the unanswered email, abandoned interview loop, or vanished promise of next steps comes back with a price tag—maybe not neatly labeled in a quarterly filing, but real all the same. LiveCareer’s April 14, 2026 survey of 1,008 employed U.S. adults lands on an uncomfortable point: candidates remember...

Continue Reading
QuidelOrtho Faces Fresh Scrutiny Over Savanna Claims

Updated Category News Views 178

A diagnostic launch can turn into a corporate migraine with frightening speed, and QuidelOrtho is staring at exactly that sort of mess. Kahn Swick & Foti said on November 20, 2026, that it has begun investigating whether QuidelOrtho officers or directors breached fiduciary duties or otherwise violated state or federal law. This is not a finding of wrongdoing. It is an...

Continue Reading
Newegg’s GIGABYTE Event Is Brand Work, Not a Catalyst

Updated Category News Views 205

A 2,300-square-foot room can tell a retailer plenty about its tribe. On November 21, Newegg is turning its Diamond Bar Gamer Zone into the home base for GIGABYTE’s AORUS VS40 celebration, a free five-hour event marking the hardware maker’s 40th anniversary. There will be 1v1 VALORANT and League of Legends contests, demo stations, raffles, anniversary merchandise, food...

Continue Reading
Isar’s Nova Scotia Pad Build Gives MAXQ a Real Test

Updated Category News Views 121

Concrete work is where space ambition stops being a brochure. Isar Aerospace has taken operational responsibility for its dedicated launch infrastructure at Spaceport Nova Scotia, and construction is beginning on the Canadian launch pad it will use. For Maritime Launch Services, this is the sort of update that deserves more than the usual starry-eyed applause. A Site...

Continue Reading
UAE Trust Model Faces Its Hardest Test During Crisis

Updated Category News Views 76

A country’s reputation is usually invisible right up until the machinery rattles. Then people, investors, trading partners and residents stop listening to polished slogans and start watching whether airports function, services hold up, information arrives, and business can keep moving. That was the useful core of Saeed Al Eter’s remarks at Ajman Media Forum 2026: soft...

Continue Reading
Anthropic's Leveraged ETFs Arrive After Wild Debut

Updated Category News Views 239

Nothing says a feverish new listing quite like leveraged products lining up before the opening-week confetti has settled. Anthropic priced its IPO at $83 on November 18, raised roughly $81.3 billion, then opened Nasdaq trading at $111.50 on November 19. That is an enormous gap between IPO price and first trade, and it tells investors the obvious thing: plenty of appetite...

Continue Reading
Human Frontier Mission Puts AI Research on Display

Updated Category News Views 95

A laboratory notebook is about to become the real product in this AI experiment. Human Frontier Mission, or HFM, says it will launch globally on Nov. 24, opening a research program where domain specialists frame scientific and engineering problems while autonomous AI agents develop and test possible answers. The unusual bit is not merely handing models difficult work. It...

Continue Reading
Alibaba Lawsuit Deadline Puts Disclosure Risk in Focus

Updated Category News Views 180

A calendar deadline is doing more work than any earnings headline for Alibaba shareholders this week. A securities class action notice says investors who bought or acquired Alibaba Group Holding Limited securities between May 23, 2024 and November 11, 2026 may seek appointment as lead plaintiff by January 19, 2027. That is a procedural milestone, not a verdict, and...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Vivid Seats Simplifies Market Structure and Tax Obligations

Updated Category News Views 221

Vivid Seats Streamlines Corporate Structure Vivid Seats Inc. (NASDAQ: SEAT), a leading online ticket marketplace, has embarked on a transformative journey to simplify its organizational framework. In a strategic move, the company has announced its Corporate Simplification Agreement, aimed at redefining how it operates while enhancing its tax efficiency and overall...

Continue Reading
NLS Pharmaceuticals Soars After Major Merger Announcement

Updated Category News Views 330

NLS Pharmaceuticals Sees Positive Stock Movement NLS Pharmaceuticals Ltd. (NASDAQ: NLSP) is experiencing significant upward momentum in its stock prices following a crucial announcement regarding a proposed merger. The company has filed a Form F-4 registration statement with the Securities and Exchange Commission, signaling an essential step toward completing this merger....

Continue Reading
Orchestra BioMed Achieves Key Financial and Operational Progress

Updated Category News Views 84

Orchestra BioMed Reports on Financial Performance and Business Updates Orchestra BioMed Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ: OBIO), a pioneering biomedical innovation company, recently presented its robust financial results for Q3 2024, reflecting both significant fiscal health and promising advancements in medical technology. The company is focused on elevating patient care through...

Continue Reading
Nutex Health Inc. Investors Urged to Join Securities Class Action

Updated Category News Views 130

Investors of Nutex Health Inc. Face Opportunities Amid Allegations Investors holding shares in Nutex Health Inc. are currently presented with a remarkable opportunity in light of claims surrounding securities fraud involving the Company. Founded as a notable player in the healthcare sector, Nutex Health has recently come under scrutiny due to alleged misleading statements...

Continue Reading
Empowering Resilience in Education: Embracing Failure with LetMeFail

Updated Category News Views 182

Transforming Education: LetMeFail's Innovative Approach LetMeFail is an exciting new educational initiative aimed at transforming how students perceive and deal with failure. In today's culture, where perfection is often idolized, this program makes it clear that setbacks can serve as important stepping stones toward personal growth and resilience. Unpacking the Goals of...

Continue Reading