Quote:If You Want Bigger Government, Vote Republican
02/09/2016•Ryan McMaken
One of the nice things about Bernie Sanders is that he seems to be honestly saying flat-out that he plans to massively increase the size of government.
The other candidates are probably lying either to themselves or to us — or to both — about what they likely will do in office.
Of course, it's been so long since any president oversaw a federal government that actually cut spending, we'd have to go back to the immediate post-war years to remember any of that.
But, for decades, we've been told that a vote for the GOP is a vote for "smaller government." This is repeated both by Republicans, who say it like it's a good thing, and by Democrats who still seem to think that the GOP is committed to cutting grandma's safety net.
If we look at federal spending, though, it's easy to see that the myth of the budget-cutting Republican president is just that: a myth.
First, let's look at federal outlays overall. To make our analysis more simple, I have adjusted this for inflation, using the CPI, for lack of anything better. All dollar amounts here are in millions of 2015
dollars:
![]()
Just from eyeballing the graph, we can see a few things. Spending during the 1980s and 2000s was more robust than it was during the 1990s. And, we can see that after an initial huge jump in 2009, federal spending has been somewhat flat — albeit at a huge level of spending.
We also find that — given the timing of fiscal years and the politics of the budget process — the huge increase in 2009 was initially engineered not by the Obama administration, but by the Bush administration.
If we break out spending by each presidential administration, we can see how much spending increased during each one's tenure:
![]()
Because of the way that federal fiscal years work, we begin counting spending for a president in the fiscal year that begins after he's sworn in. For example, the periods we count for George H. W. Bush, are the fiscal years of 1990, 1991, 1992, and 1993.
This is because fiscal years end on September 30 meaning that when Bush was elected in 1988, the 1988 fiscal year had already ended more than a month earlier. And, the 1989 fiscal year would end just eight months after Bush was sworn in, having already been debated and planned under Reagan during late 1988.
Thus, it only makes sense to "blame" the 1989 fiscal year budget on Reagan, and the 1990 year on Bush.
Reagan and G.W. Bush Are the Worst Offenders
So, using this analysis, we do find that Bush I was the least-bad offender with federal spending increasing only 2 percent from 1990 through 1993. That's one in favor of the GOP claims for being against big government.
On the other hand, the top three worst offenders here are Republicans. As hard as it is to believe, there are still some people who think that Reagan cut the size of government, although Reagan was a big spender and laid the groundwork for the immense national debt we live with today.
During Reagan's tenure, counting FY 1982 to FY 1989, federal spending increased 19 percent. And worst of all, George W. Bush oversaw an increase in federal spending of 46 percent during his tenure.
We can compare this to an increase of 7 percent under Clinton and 4 percent under Obama, although, we'll likely have to assign the blame for 2016 and 2017 budgets to Obama.
However, even with all the coming increases in federal health care spending that we'll be able to thank Obama for, it's unlikely he'll be able to match the spending levels signed into law by Bush II.
I know that some people will complain and say that the 2009 spending increases — which included the massive bailouts in the wake of the 2008 crisis — should be blamed on Obama.
But, that would require us to forget that Bush II was a supporter of TARP, the auto bailouts, and immense amounts of fiscal "stimulus" in general that came in 2009.
Even the most rudimentary Google search shows that Bush was very much in favor of the massive spending increases that came in 2009.
Obama (and also surely McCain, had he won) would have done the same, but that doesn't change the fact that when given an opportunity to spend, the GOP grabs on to the opportunity with all its might.
Moreover, even if we changed our analysis to blame FY 2009 on Obama, and included FYs 2009-2015 in such a way as to assign 2009 to Obama's tenure, we'd still only find an increase of 17.7 percent in federal spending during Obama's time, so far. This compares to an increase of 32 percent for Bush, which would then include FYs 2001-2008.
We can fiddle with the measurements further, and including both election year and outgoing year for both. This means we'd be counting the increase from FY 2008 to FY 2009 and assigning that increase to Obama.
Of course, we also then carry the same method to all other administrations. We find, though, that no single year upends our analysis, although by this other count, we do find the two parties are a bit more equal:
https://mises.org/blog/if-you-want-bigger-gov...republican
If You Want Bigger Government, Vote Republican
Top 10 Most Recent News Articles
PinnacleQM Makes Its Enterprise Case More Visible
Six pages were never going to carry the weight of a complicated enterprise pitch. PinnacleQM has rebuilt its public face from a basic brochure into a library of more than 50 pages, putting its quality engineering, testing, automation and AI assurance work in clearer view for Australian technology and business buyers. This is not the sort of announcement that changes a...
Continue Reading
AI Forces Learning Teams to Redefine Their Core Job
Training Departments Are Not Sitting Still Corporate learning has spent years being treated like the office instruction manual, and AI is making that old arrangement look awfully flimsy. RedThread Research's November 19, 2026 study lands on a point that ought to make senior management pay attention: learning and development leaders are not merely waiting around to be...
Continue Reading
Hard Rock Tampa Bets $30 Million on Smoke-Free Play
Cigarette smoke is getting treated like a revenue problem in Tampa, and that is a far more interesting signal than another ribbon-cutting photo. Seminole Hard Rock Hotel & Casino Tampa opened The Breeze: A Smoke-Free Experience by Hard Rock on Nov. 19, 2026, following a $30 million transformation aimed at guests who want clean-air casino time from arrival through...
Continue Reading
Thanksgiving Kitchen Safety Is No Place for Autopilot
Steam, chatter, and one forgotten burner can turn a holiday meal ugly in a hurry. The Consumer Product Safety Commission’s Nov. 19, 2026 reminder lands on a point that should not need repeating, yet plainly does: Thanksgiving kitchens demand attention, not casual optimism. This is not about ruining anybody’s celebration with a lecture. It is about recognizing that a...
Continue Reading
Triller Lawsuit Puts Merger Disclosures Under a Harsh Light
A $0.32 closing price has a way of stripping the paint off a corporate story. The proposed securities class action involving Triller Group, Inc. puts a hard spotlight on a familiar, ugly market sequence: a splashy merger, glowing talk around acquired assets, delayed financial filings, Nasdaq trouble, and then a collapse severe enough to leave shareholders wondering what...
Continue Reading
Tigo's Guidance Gap Draws Lawsuit and Investor Scrutiny
A Revenue Promise Hit the Wall Solar investing can turn ugly in a hurry when a supposedly near-term catalyst gets shoved down the calendar. That is the central bruise behind the securities class action involving Tigo Energy, not some arcane accounting footnote that only lawyers can love. The complaint alleges Tigo overstated the revenue contribution it expected from its...
Continue Reading
SQM Investigation Puts Chile Approval Claims on Trial
A Regulatory Promise Meets a Rough Earnings Reaction A 5.52% haircut after disappointing quarterly numbers is the sort of thing that makes shareholders stop pretending every loose management comment is harmless. Sociedad Química y Minera de Chile, NYSE:SQM, is facing an investigation by Levi & Korsinsky into public statements concerning regulatory matters, particularly...
Continue Reading
Cirrus CEO Takes SIA Chair as Chip Policy Heats Up
A trade-group gavel rarely moves a stock by itself, but this one lands in a noisy part of the chip cycle. On November 19, 2026, the Semiconductor Industry Association elected Cirrus Logic President and CEO John Forsyth as chair of its board. That is not a revenue announcement, not a factory groundbreaking, and certainly not a reason to start flinging confetti at...
Continue Reading
Software-Defined Cars Put $310 Billion in Play by 2035
Cars are becoming rolling computers, and that changes who gets paid. Market Growth Reports projects the software-defined vehicle market will rise from $56.94 billion to $310.46 billion by 2035, a 20.74% compound annual growth rate. That is a loud number, no question. Still, investors ought to treat any long-range market forecast like a map, not a mortgage deed. The...
Continue Reading
TCL CSOT's Oxide Leap Gives LCD a Sharper Fight Ahead
Fifty-one point six is the number that makes this announcement worth chewing on. TCL CSOT says it has moved ultrahigh-mobility oxide technology into mass production on an 8.6-generation line, clearing the 50 cm² V?¹ s?¹ threshold that has largely belonged to lab-talk and presentation slides. For display people, that is not decorative science. It could change the old...
Continue ReadingTop 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles
Saratoga Investment Corp. Set to Reveal Q1 Results with Insights
Saratoga Investment Corp. Set to Announce Fiscal Q1 Results As the business world remains keenly focused on financial performances, Saratoga Investment Corp. (NYSE:SAR), a dedicated business development firm, is preparing to unveil its financial results for the quarter that concluded on May 31, 2025. This significant announcement is set to occur on a Tuesday, marking an...
Continue Reading
Great Circle Group Enhances Marine Services in Cape Cod Area
Great Circle Group Expands Marine Services Great Circle Group has made a significant move by embracing a strategic alliance with three top marinas in Cape Cod and the Islands: MacDougalls', Falmouth Marine, and Vineyard Haven Marina. This collaboration positions Great Circle's Navtronics division as the key marine technology partner for these respected establishments,...
Continue Reading
Verizon Executive to Present at Citi 2024 Global TMT Conference
Executive Insights at the Citi 2024 Global TMT Conference Verizon is excited to announce that Joe Russo, the Executive Vice President and President of Global Networks and Technology, will be representing the company at the Citi 2024 Global TMT Conference. This much-anticipated event is set for Thursday, September 5, at 9:10 a.m. ET. Attendees can expect engaging...
Continue Reading
ANI Pharmaceuticals’ Upcoming Participation in BioConnect Event
ANI Pharmaceuticals to Present at BioConnect Conference ANI Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Nasdaq: ANIP), located in Princeton, New Jersey, has exciting news for investors and stakeholders. The company is gearing up to participate in the H.C. Wainwright 3rd Annual BioConnect Investor Conference, an event that showcases innovative companies in the biopharmaceutical sector. Nikhil...
Continue Reading
Exciting Titanium Discoveries by NioBay Metals in Foothills
NioBay Metals Reports Impressive Titanium Intercepts MONTRÉAL -- NioBay Metals Inc. (TSX-V: NBY) (OTCQB: NBYCF) is thrilled to share recent findings from its drilling operations at Zone 1 of the Foothills Property, highlighting significant titanium (TiO?) mineralization. This development brings the company one step closer to unlocking the potential of this resource-rich...
Continue Reading