This Recovery Really Is Different So next time someone

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board

Jul 3, 2016 at 12:56 PM

Quote:

This Recovery Really Is Different

So next time someone says this is the worst recovery since World War II, remind them that the economy is recovering from a full-blown financial crisis -- not just a typical recession.

https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2015-...the-others

Aug 3, 2015 9:53 AM EDT

By Barry Ritholtz

Calling this the “worst economic expansion since World War II” is like saying the ebola virus is the worst cold you ever had. At some level you might be technically correct, but you end up communicating confusing, even misleading, information.

This keeps coming up, despite a wealth of evidence that provides more appropriate context about the crash and subsequent recovery. A column in Real Time Economics is typical of the genre:

Since the recession ended in June 2009, the economy has advanced at a 2.2% annual pace through the end of last year. That’s more than a half-percentage point worse than the next-weakest expansion of the past 70 years, the one from 2001 through 2007. While there have been highs and lows in individual quarters, overall the economy has failed to break out of its roughly 2% pattern for six years.

The key that something is wrong is in the outlier status of the data. “More than a half-percentage point worse than the next-weakest expansion” is an enormous, Bob Beamon-like smashing of the earlier record. To better understand this data requires some context, which today’s column will provide.

First, the specifics: By just about every economic metric, this has been a mediocre, subpar recovery. For the first few years following the end of the recession in June 2009, employment increased slowly. Wages to this day have been little changed. Retail sales have been inconsistent; housing has seen soft sales numbers, while price increases have been a function of a lack of inventory caused by limited amounts of home equity and immobility as a consumer try to reduce debt. Gross domestic product growth has been weak and lacking in consistency.

The context is simple: When we discuss expansions, we typically are referring to the later half of a typical economic contraction-expansion cycle. That is what is typically referred to as a post-recession recovery.

However, that huge outlier is a clue that we are using the wrong data set. The post-World War II recession recoveries are the wrong frame of reference; the proper one is the much more severe set of credit-crisis collapses and recoveries.

Economists Carmen M. Reinhart and Kenneth S. Rogoff figured this out before the scale of the crisis even was apparent. In January 2008 they published a paper titled "Is the 2007 U.S. Sub-Prime Financial Crisis So Different? An International Historical Comparison." They warned that the U.S. subprime mortgage issue was turning into a full-blown credit crisis, not just a typical recession. I discussed this extensively in February 2008.

The economic researchers were astute enough to not use other recession-recovery cycles as their comparison when discussing the pace of growth in the U.S. economy after what they said would be a collapse caused by subprime mortgages. Instead, they suggested looking at five previous financial crises -- Japan (1992), Finland (1991), Sweden (1991), Norway (1987) and Spain (1977).

These earlier financial and credit crises had several consistent elements: A prolonged and deep decline in asset prices, including equity (average of 55 percent) and housing prices (average of 35 percent). They also noted that banking crises are followed by “profound declines in employment.”

The average increase in the unemployment rate was seven percentage points during the four years after the collapse. This is in line with the rise in the U.S. unemployment, rate, which increased from about 4 percent to 10 percent.

Other elements they saw as consistent with credit crises were an explosion of government debt, and costly “ambitious countercyclical fiscal policies aimed at mitigating the downturn.”

Let me remind you that Reinhart and Rogoff published their paper in early 2008 --before Bear Stearns collapsed, and well before Lehman Brothers, American International Group, the banks and government-sponsored entities Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac either failed or needed bailouts.

I give them enormous credit for not only understanding how subprime mortgages were a threat to the economy, but seeing exactly how that threat would manifest itself, and how the So next time someone says this is the worst recovery since World War II, remind them that the economy is recovering from a full-blown financial crisis -- not just a typical recession.subsequent recovery would take form.

The key point here is that credit bubbles are very different from ordinary recession recoveries. Bank crises and the long, slow painful recoveries are simply not comparable to other business cycles.

After the collapse, Reinhart and Rogoff turned their research into a book, “This Time Is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly.” Anyone who wants to understand the present economic cycle should give it a read.

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Sun Home Goes Big with Black Friday Sauna Extravaganza

Sun Home's Black Friday Warm-Up If ever there was a time to crank up the heat on a deal, it’s right now. Sun Home Saunas, a San Diego stalwart in the home wellness space, launched their Black Friday blitz today, offering savings that's hotter than a summer day in Death Valley. Between November 6 and December 7, they're slashing prices left and right, tossing in free...

EPG's New Malaysian Factory: A US$120M Commitment

In the hustle and bustle of manufacturing, EPG Modular Data Center has hit a landmark moment. They're not just slapping up another building—they're carving out a piece of future tech infrastructure with their fresh Malaysia FIZ Factory. Investing in Regional Strength When you pump US$120 million into a project, you're doing more than sinking cash into concrete—you're...

South Park Exhibition: A Sneak Peek Behind the Scenes

An Unconventional Legacy: South Park’s Journey There's a new kind of 'heritage' on display at the Colorado History Museum that's bound to shake a few eyebrows in December 2026. More than just cutouts and characters, South Park: Handmade in Colorado delves into the crazy, outrageous journey of Trey Parker and Matt Stone's brainchild from its humble beginnings to a...

Deep Principle's Hydrogen-1.0: A Leap in AI-Driven Chemistry

Leaving Old Lab Notebooks in the Dust Deep Principle just shook up the science lab with their latest brainchild, Hydrogen-1.0. We're talking about an AI-driven marvel designed to tackle chemistry and materials research like no traditional lab rat ever could. On November 4, they rolled out this bad boy—an open-weight model fine-tuned to turn vague scientific hunches into...

Radiation Oncology Text Earns Doody's 2026 Nod

Recognition in Radiation Oncology In the rapidly advancing arena of radiation oncology, staying current is no small feat. But here's a feather in the cap of one publication doing just that: Fundamentals of Radiation Oncology: Physical, Biological, and Clinical Aspects, 4th Edition. This resource has made quite the splash by snagging a spot on the 2026 Doody's Core Titles...

Vaudit Welcomes Industry Veteran David Coleman

David Coleman: Vaudit's New Ad Chief David Coleman stepping into Vaudit's spotlight as President of Advertising Industry is a twist worth watching. Vaudit, for those not up to speed, is an AI-driven powerhouse that keeps vendors in line with what they're charging. And let me tell you, Coleman's kind of heavy-hitter leadership doesn't come cheap, nor does it play nice with...

Workday: Dominating Cloud ERP with AI Prowess in 2026

Workday: A Force in the Cloud ERP Arena Right on! Workday's making waves again in the world of Cloud ERP. In a move that seems to defy the competition, they've locked down their spot as a Leader in the 2026 Gartner Magic Quadrant for Cloud ERP for Service-Centric Enterprises for the fifth year running. Consistency isn’t a coincidence here, folks—this is pure strategy!...

UP Fintech Faces 25% Stock Drop Amid Fraud Suit

Stock Market Whiplash: UP Fintech's Rough Ride You know, just when you think you've seen it all in this bonkers stock market world, something like a 25% drop in UP Fintech’s stock reminds you that surprises never end. Now, UP Fintech’s facing a class action lawsuit, alleging it didn’t exactly play fair, sparking this latest rollercoaster ride. Yeah, buckle up folks,...

BSA Unveils 2027 Board: Steering Architecture's Future

Fresh Faces Navigate a Storied Institution In this unpredictable dance of leadership, the Boston Society of Architects (BSA) just laid its cards on the table for 2027. The latest board of directors and governance committees were announced with the kind of precision that shows how serious these folks are about preparing for a future that's anything but predictable. Handing...

Ondo Finance Tops Tokenization with $4B Milestone

Ondo Finance Claims Tokenization Throne Damn, if you thought tokenization was just a sideshow in the fintech carnival, think again. Ondo Finance has waltzed its way to the front of the line, claiming the heavyweight title with over $4 billion in tokenized real-world assets. That's right, folks—$4 billion in the bag, handily surpassing 202 other platforms with its...