This Recovery Really Is Different So next time someone

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board

Jul 3, 2016 at 12:56 PM

Quote:

This Recovery Really Is Different

So next time someone says this is the worst recovery since World War II, remind them that the economy is recovering from a full-blown financial crisis -- not just a typical recession.

https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2015-...the-others

Aug 3, 2015 9:53 AM EDT

By Barry Ritholtz

Calling this the “worst economic expansion since World War II” is like saying the ebola virus is the worst cold you ever had. At some level you might be technically correct, but you end up communicating confusing, even misleading, information.

This keeps coming up, despite a wealth of evidence that provides more appropriate context about the crash and subsequent recovery. A column in Real Time Economics is typical of the genre:

Since the recession ended in June 2009, the economy has advanced at a 2.2% annual pace through the end of last year. That’s more than a half-percentage point worse than the next-weakest expansion of the past 70 years, the one from 2001 through 2007. While there have been highs and lows in individual quarters, overall the economy has failed to break out of its roughly 2% pattern for six years.

The key that something is wrong is in the outlier status of the data. “More than a half-percentage point worse than the next-weakest expansion” is an enormous, Bob Beamon-like smashing of the earlier record. To better understand this data requires some context, which today’s column will provide.

First, the specifics: By just about every economic metric, this has been a mediocre, subpar recovery. For the first few years following the end of the recession in June 2009, employment increased slowly. Wages to this day have been little changed. Retail sales have been inconsistent; housing has seen soft sales numbers, while price increases have been a function of a lack of inventory caused by limited amounts of home equity and immobility as a consumer try to reduce debt. Gross domestic product growth has been weak and lacking in consistency.

The context is simple: When we discuss expansions, we typically are referring to the later half of a typical economic contraction-expansion cycle. That is what is typically referred to as a post-recession recovery.

However, that huge outlier is a clue that we are using the wrong data set. The post-World War II recession recoveries are the wrong frame of reference; the proper one is the much more severe set of credit-crisis collapses and recoveries.

Economists Carmen M. Reinhart and Kenneth S. Rogoff figured this out before the scale of the crisis even was apparent. In January 2008 they published a paper titled "Is the 2007 U.S. Sub-Prime Financial Crisis So Different? An International Historical Comparison." They warned that the U.S. subprime mortgage issue was turning into a full-blown credit crisis, not just a typical recession. I discussed this extensively in February 2008.

The economic researchers were astute enough to not use other recession-recovery cycles as their comparison when discussing the pace of growth in the U.S. economy after what they said would be a collapse caused by subprime mortgages. Instead, they suggested looking at five previous financial crises -- Japan (1992), Finland (1991), Sweden (1991), Norway (1987) and Spain (1977).

These earlier financial and credit crises had several consistent elements: A prolonged and deep decline in asset prices, including equity (average of 55 percent) and housing prices (average of 35 percent). They also noted that banking crises are followed by “profound declines in employment.”

The average increase in the unemployment rate was seven percentage points during the four years after the collapse. This is in line with the rise in the U.S. unemployment, rate, which increased from about 4 percent to 10 percent.

Other elements they saw as consistent with credit crises were an explosion of government debt, and costly “ambitious countercyclical fiscal policies aimed at mitigating the downturn.”

Let me remind you that Reinhart and Rogoff published their paper in early 2008 --before Bear Stearns collapsed, and well before Lehman Brothers, American International Group, the banks and government-sponsored entities Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac either failed or needed bailouts.

I give them enormous credit for not only understanding how subprime mortgages were a threat to the economy, but seeing exactly how that threat would manifest itself, and how the So next time someone says this is the worst recovery since World War II, remind them that the economy is recovering from a full-blown financial crisis -- not just a typical recession.subsequent recovery would take form.

The key point here is that credit bubbles are very different from ordinary recession recoveries. Bank crises and the long, slow painful recoveries are simply not comparable to other business cycles.

After the collapse, Reinhart and Rogoff turned their research into a book, “This Time Is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly.” Anyone who wants to understand the present economic cycle should give it a read.

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

ABC Honors 2026 Spirit of the Heart Leaders

Celebrating Champions of Cardiovascular Health In a world where accolades often feel as cold as the stock market after a crash, it’s heartening to see genuine recognition for those who are making actual, lasting impact. On October 3, 2026, the Association of Black Cardiologists (ABC) will hold its annual Spirit of the Heart Awards at none other than Cipriani Wall...

IDX Expands, Enhances Team Amid 56% H1 Growth

IDX's Aggressive Global Expansion Here's a tip from a trader who’s seen cycles rise and fall: watch the movers who're playing the long game, putting down roots worldwide while making headway in the data game. IDX has clearly mapped out this trajectory as evidenced by its recent grab in the global strategic communications ring. IDX's bustling around like a squirrel...

RevSystems Joins Elite OpenAI Partner Network

RevSystems Inks Deal with OpenAI Partner Network In the latest shuffle of the AI advisory deck, RevSystems just found itself elbowing into the exclusive OpenAI Partner Network. Based out of New York, RevSystems has carved a niche by spinning tech wizardry into tangible business results. Their new status as an OpenAI Select Partner puts them on a playing field where AI...

From Kitchen Experiment to U.S. Debut Here's a story that barely fits the tight mold of your typical business textbook. Hair Syrup, born from the brain of a university student tinkering at her kitchen table, is about to make waves across the pond. Lucie Macleod did what many dream of—she took a DIY hair oil project and spun it into a multimillion-dollar brand, now set...

LeoLabs and SciTec Partner for $93.7M Space Force Deal

LeoLabs and SciTec Join Forces for Space Dominance The space race ain't just about rockets blasting off anymore. It's about making sure we've got eyes everywhere, even on the back of our heads, so to speak. Enter LeoLabs teaming up with SciTec to help the U.S. Space Force upgrade their radar systems to something out of a sci-fi flick, armed with a $93.7 million contract...

South Florida Donor Network Honors 52 Heroic Donors

A Heartfelt Tribute to Lifesavers You ever been to a gathering that reminds you how deeply human connections run? That's what happened at The Diplomat Beach Resort in Hollywood. South Florida Donor Network (SFDN) pulled together a ceremony honoring 52 donor heroes whose legacies beat strong through the recipients living thanks to their gifts. An Event Worth Attending...

Hanover Unveils Skinny Veg® for GLP-1 Dieters

Seems like Hanover Foods is turning heads with their move into the ever-demanding health-conscious market. This family's stepping into the limelight with their new Skinny Veg® line, clearly targeting folks riding the GLP-1 wave. You see, it's not every day that a company that's been around the block since 1924 shakes things up like this. Simplicity is the Name of the...

CUBEX Lights Up Veterinary Care with Mini Essential

Inventory Woes? Meet Mini Essential If you’ve ever worked in or around veterinary hospitals, you know the old-school headaches of managing controlled substances. Picture this: piles of paper logs, end-of-shift recounting, and inevitable discrepancies that rear their ugly heads long after closing time. Enter CUBEX, shaking things up with their latest launch, Mini...

Strategic Hire: Whisenhunt Joins FlexScreen & RiteScreen

Shaking Up the Window Screens Biz If you've been grinding in the window and door game, you know it's not an industry with a lot of buzz, but here comes a shot of caffeine. FlexScreen and RiteScreen just snagged David Whisenhunt to rev up their sales machine. Who's David Whisenhunt? Well, he's no rookie. With over two decades deep in the fenestration field, Whisenhunt...

Mandeville Pests: Health Dangers Lurking at Home

Pest Trouble Brewing in Mandeville: A Health Alert There’s a storm brewing in Mandeville, Louisiana, and it's not the kind you can see rolling in on the horizon. We're talking about those sneaky pests going unnoticed in our homes. Folks, these pests aren't just a nuisance; they're ticking time bombs for public health. Take it from J&J Exterminating, who know a thing or...